• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Rega Planet, advice needed

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
My Planet recently began skipping and so I thought I'd give the tracks and lenses a clean. One of the wires to the lid sensor was frayed and so I took the sensor off and desoldered the wires from the board to make fixing it easier. Things were left in that state till after work the following day, now I cannot find the sensor anywhere. Its part number, written on it (luckily I took note) is A41e 710.
Does anyone know exactly what this is or where I could get another ? Its approx 5 mm square and has 5v, ground and signal terminals, on the board its referred to as the lid switch.


Thanks for any help.
 

companyja

Active Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
151
Likes
172
The first step would always be to contact Rega and ask whether there are replacements available to purchase anywhere. For such old products, it can be nigh impossible to find original replacements, though.
 

restorer-john

Grand Contributor
Joined
Mar 1, 2018
Messages
12,579
Likes
38,274
Location
Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia
Step one, contact Rega and ask nicely- they'll have one most likely. If they say they don't have any, ask them what it was specifically.

If no luck, get back to us here. I have heaps of lid/mech/limit switches, so don't be too worried.

If it has three wires/connections, it is either a two state (NC/NO) switch or it could be an optical (photo interrupter). Did it have visible leaf contacts or was it enclosed? Was there a lever or button/gap or how was it activated? Was it silent in operation or did it click like a microswitch?
 

restorer-john

Grand Contributor
Joined
Mar 1, 2018
Messages
12,579
Likes
38,274
Location
Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia
Could it be a hall effect sensor?

Absolutely. The only schematic I can find shows it as a hall sensor.
1613949770271.png


A3141EU.

Mystery solved. :)
 
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
It was a solid state unit that was held in place on the underside of the top casing by a strap. This makes me think it may be a magnetic proximity type ( Didnt know they were known as hall effect sensors).
The 3 connections (wires) were connected to a small pcb with contactors to holes where the wires from the board were soldered. Its operation was silent. I've emailed Rega for info as to what it was specifically .. hopefully it will be good news from them. Thanks for the replies.
I'll remember this site you'r a right helpfull bunch :).
 

restorer-john

Grand Contributor
Joined
Mar 1, 2018
Messages
12,579
Likes
38,274
Location
Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia
I'll remember this site you'r a right helpfull bunch :).

Remember to come back and post your solution to this thread. Take a few pictures of the fix. It may help someone else down the track.
 
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1


I used CD-Player-DAC-Transport List (narod.ru) to find a donor for the cd transport mech KSS240A, a Sony CDP M12 cost £30 off ebay .. luckily in perfect working order .. plays all the CD's the planet skipped on no problems. Just waiting for some solder, 4 replacement diodes for the power section and the Hall sensor and all should be sorted again.

As I only use it as a cd transport (plugged into an MDAC) I'm not sure if I should bother with replacing the electrolytic capacitors on the board?
 

Count Arthur

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
2,192
Likes
4,880
I used CD-Player-DAC-Transport List (narod.ru) to find a donor for the cd transport mech KSS240A, a Sony CDP M12 cost £30 off ebay .. luckily in perfect working order .. plays all the CD's the planet skipped on no problems. Just waiting for some solder, 4 replacement diodes for the power section and the Hall sensor and all should be sorted again.

As I only use it as a cd transport (plugged into an MDAC) I'm not sure if I should bother with replacing the electrolytic capacitors on the board?

I kind of got the wrong end of the stick when I read your original post, I saw "lenses" and "sensor" and thought you were talking about the laser mechanism. :)

Regarding the capacitors, these can last a very long time. They don't last as long when they are used at or over their temperature specifications in things like hot power amps; especially if you leave things powered up all the time. If you switch things off when they are not used it can take many years to rack up 2 or 3,000 hours of running time, and in low power stuff, like CD players, things shouldn't get anywhere near 85 degrees C, so they should last significantly longer.

You can have a good look at the capacitors, they sometimes bulge when there are problems, but not always: https://www.capacitorlab.com/visible-failures/
 

DSJR

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 27, 2020
Messages
3,312
Likes
4,425
Location
Suffolk Coastal, UK
The Planet was a very popular £500 - £600 player (clamshell case type?) and I sold many of them. Rega are good gys when it comes to service and as I understand it, they can supply parts still BUT ALWAYS BEST TO ASK THEM!!!!! Hopefully you can get what you want. You may need to go through a Rega dealer though - in the UK, your contract is via the dealer and even a twenty year old player should be addressed via a dealer first. Hopefully said dealer won't be so up themselves that they can't or won't help you (takes one to know one and I've been there, done it much to my shame in decades past :( - but hopefully learned many life-lessons along the way).

It's a specialist niche device outside of a Rega system (we sold it with Remote, Couple interconnect (Klotz AC110 with Neutrik Pro plugs) and into a 'clamshell' Mira amp) and the 'sound' was always very good for fifteen hundred quid with Jura speakers, the first version of which I loved with a port tweak and spesaker cables which didn't upset the sparkly highs too much.

Since the thing is now so old, if you can get it working properly again and feel an update is possible, have a look here - http://www.acoustica.org.uk/ and scroll to the Rega Planet page ;)
 

Berwhale

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Aug 29, 2019
Messages
3,933
Likes
4,922
Location
UK
Jura speakers, the first version of which I loved with a port tweak and spesaker cables which didn't upset the sparkly highs too much.

Out of interest, is that the mod to put the port at the front of the Jura?

My Jura's were orginally paired with a Marantz CD-63 and Onix OA21s amplifier (modified and upgraded by a friend who worked for Onix at the time :)). I loved that setup.
 

DSJR

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 27, 2020
Messages
3,312
Likes
4,425
Location
Suffolk Coastal, UK
The first Jura had two issues - boom and tizz. Inside the box as I recall, there was a slatted partition above the port tube, so the thing had been thought through to a large extent. All I did was to buy a 50p basic bath sponge, cut it in half and put it in sideways in the port, minimising the air-flow. Easily removed but on the mk1 Jura, it fixed it for us, the bass remaining fairly extended but still 'tuneful' and quite articulate (in audiophool terms). The last gen Ela in comparison (which became a slim tower over the wedge shaped little floor-stander) totally lacked bass and tonal 'substance' for me. Why anyone would bodge the port further I've no idea when the bodge above worked so well and for pennies...

the Jura tweeter was a Tonagen thing I believe and a bit 'lively' (without seeing measurements). At the time, Cable talk did some good speaker cables with no perceived hf 'hash' (I'd love to do an a-b again of their identical looking 3.1 and 4.1 dumbbell types) and with the Planet linked to the Mira as described in my earlier post and with 4.1 speaker cables, a very satisfying little system of the times for UK size rooms (long before the days of cheap Chinese made speakers although Quad did well with the popular 11L if anyone wants to look that one up).

Sorry for the thread crap here. Rega revised the Jura into a mk2 model with the drivers pushed closer and further to the top of the box as I remember (I can't remember which version has the black band around the 'base') and these lost all the bass I remember and all but screamed at you! Remember Rega are primarily 'vinyl people,' their main dealers tend to live in a kind of 'splendid isolation bubble' away from the stuff being reviewed and recommended here and their own MM cartridges have quite a severe hf suckout right where the Jura and others in their family could project too much. useless for neutral sources though, even the Planet unless they were jammed into corners.

All good fun for me and it's disappearing fast into ancient history. Current similar size RX3 speakers are double the price and much more 'solid' than the Ela or Jura ever were and rather more 'tamed and benign' in tonal balance, but still 'communicate' well. As I've moaned before, absolutely no idea how they'd (say, Brio R driven) begin to compare with some of these smaller active 'prosumer' models today for a couple of grand the pair or less..
 
Last edited:
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
As asked previously, up there somewhere, I thought I'd post some pics and a description of what I've done.
I only had an old cheap n nasty iron, so I bought a soldering station (little more expensive, but worth it)
I found a version of the A3141 (the KY-003) mounted on a mini PCB with an led attached (useful for troubleshooting)
PIC1 (2).JPG

I bought a Nikko version of the KSS240A, dead easy to fit, simply remove the player mechanism from the top case (4 screws and a ribbon cable), remove the pin (push down on 'L' shaped plastic clip and push the pin), It may be my ears, but cymbals etc sound clearer.
P1000538.JPG


I replaced all the capacitors in the power supply side of the board with Panasonic FC or FM caps (depending on what was available). the 4 Diodes were replaced with 1N4004 Diodes.
P1000521 (2).JPG



The caps at C9 were replaced with Nichicon UFG FG "Fine Gold" MUSE, which look nice, if nothing else.
P1000523.JPG


The cap at C33 was again replaced by a Nichicon FG.
I couldn't find any FG's of the size for C7 (above the mains voltage warning) so I used a Nichicon UKA KA instead.
P1000489.JPG

The last cap I replaced was the 1 uf below the lid switch connection. Here I used a VISHAY BC 045 (only match I could find).
P1000486.JPG


I did think of going onto the DAC and see what modding I could do there, but thought better of it as I don't mind the sound from it and I usually connect up to the MDAC anyway.
Finally, I thought I'd replace the Lamp stand power lead with something more suitable (OFC) and a nice big toroid to put it through.
P1000524.JPG


Then I crossed my fingers and switched it on
P1000539.JPG


:)

A few more pics
P1000485.JPG
P1000522.JPG
P1000520.JPG
P1000520 (2).JPG
P1000519.JPG
P1000492 (2).JPG
P1000488.JPG
 

Attachments

  • P1000486.JPG
    P1000486.JPG
    203.9 KB · Views: 121
  • P1000487.JPG
    P1000487.JPG
    186.8 KB · Views: 117
Last edited:
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
Whenever I've built or "modified" anything electrical, I always stand well back and switch it on from the mains plug socket. :)
Think I've got the bug now .. in the middle of upgrading my Rega ear mk1, looking for ideas about what to do with my Cyrus 2, PSX and probably the DAC too.
 

Count Arthur

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
2,192
Likes
4,880
Have you considered building something from scratch?

I couldn't design a circuit to save my life, but give me a PCB and a bag of components and I can solder them all in the right place and make something that works - "electronics by numbers".

I've built a few bits and bobs over the years, a couple of headphone amps, a Gainclone amp: https://liquidaudio.com.au/lm3886-chip-amp-project/ and later a pair of Hypex UCD based amps, and I was generally really pleased with the results.

Having said that, given how good and how innexpensive some of the products available now are, particularly the headphone amps, it's not likely to be as much of a value for money proposition as it once was. Even if you look at the Hypex and Purifi amps, you can buy them ready made for little more than you could build them yourself. It's still satisfying to cobble something together though.
 
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
Here is an update on how things went, despite early promise the replacement laser unit was not up to scratch, noticeable distortion on Alanis morrisset's former infatuation junkie, higher midrange sounding fuzzy and gravelly if that makes sense. The later tracks on longer CD's also skipped. I had bought a Sony cd player with the right laser as a donor failsafe, that's now in and the skipping has stopped.
The distortion has largely gone but I still get the fuzziness on busier tracks.
On soldering components (namely the last 1uf capacitor (which I fitted first)) I learned the hard way on how not to use solder suckers and removed the connecting ring off the track on the board (I now de-solder with copper mesh), I made a bridge to the track (which i exposed with wet n dry) with a capacitor leg offcut.
I've been using Oyaide SS-47 Audio Grade Silver Solder, the joints don't look shiny as with lead based but I read this is normal.
Before The upgrading and when the player operated normally I was not aware of any of this kind of distortion.
One possible reason could be the Nichicon fine gold, UKA KA and the Vishay which were sourced off ebay.

Any thoughts ?
 

Count Arthur

Major Contributor
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
2,192
Likes
4,880
I can't offer any advice on trouble shooting, but some observations.

1. De-soldering and re-working PCBs is much trickeier than working on a new PCB.
2. The quality of PCBs varies a lot and some of best I've worked on have been DIY stuff, with nice thick boards with thick traces and solder pads that go through the board. Whereas some of the boards in commercial products have been quite flimsy with pads that will lift if you look at them funny.

LM3886-Chip-Amp-Power-Supply-PCB.jpg


3. Do you have a multimeter that can check the values of capacitors? It might be worth checking those you bought on Ebay. It won't tell you if they're genuine, but at least if they are actually the value that's printed on them.
4. Don't buy components on Ebay, unless you're really sure of the seller. I'll happily buy cases, sockets, connectors, etc. on Ebay, but for passive and semiconductor components I'll go to RS, Farnell, Mouser, Digikey, Rapid, etc.

noticeable distortion on Alanis morrisset's former infatuation junkie

No great loss then. :p
 
OP
D

Desmo67

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2021
Messages
14
Likes
1
Count Arthur, I've been thinking about what you said earlier, about building things from scratch. Any suggestions as to reputably suppliers of decent (tho not too expensive) kits? Something like a headphone amp or preamp, maybe even a valve type - observing the costs involved though.
 
Top Bottom