• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Really Expensive Speakers: Overrated For Mixing And Mastering

Audio is significantly more complicated than video in that regard. Our eyes don't integrate reflections of the screen off the wall behind you into what you see. And light doesn't change its behavior in the room with frequency.

Anyway to OP's point, "really expensive" ≠ good. PMC 10s are $47,000 a pair, they're between "not great" and "straight up bad".

But NS10s are a terrible speaker to rely on. They're wildly inaccurate - bass shy with a -3dB point around 85hz w/r/t 200-500hz, super pushed upper mids with a hump centered around 1500hz at +8dB w/r/t 200-500hz, etc - and their "time domain" isn't anything special. Any sealed box will do that.

I mean, shit, Bob Clearmountain only picked them up because they were cheap and available to bring with him into various rooms. It wasn't because they were like God's Gift to Mixers or anything, Bob is just a very capable mixer.
With all due respect, I'm twice your age - and so is Bob - and I was around, when the NS-10 started to show up in the Studios we (never met Bob...) were working in.
Personally - I never liked them, but tape was time was money was rolling - and so, we figured out how to use 'em. So, unless you met Bob Clearmountain and he told you so...
I still have Auratones - from that period... Dire Straits comes to mind.

https://www.mixonline.com/recording...ic-tracks-dire-straits-money-nothing-372507-2

Excerpt:

...Dorfsman and the band worked on the album in Montserrat from early November until Christmas of ’84, then came back to the island for another month after the holidays before moving briefly to Power Station for some final overdubs, followed by mixing on an SSL G Series console at AIR in London.

“I mixed that album in six days on Auratones,” he says. “The thing that saved me was knowing the tracks so well. When I record I always work with an eye toward mixing; I’m always EQ’ing. [In this case he’d used the Neve EQs on the 8078.] I rarely cut things flat, so when it came time to mix, it was mainly a matter of balancing and it was relatively easy.”

Cheers
 
So, unless you met Bob Clearmountain and he told you so...

This article seems pretty exhaustive and it tells the Clearmountain/NS10 origin story, which does indeed revolve at least partly around his need for portable monitors he could bring from studio to studio in a changing era when mix engineers were suddenly freelancers and thus did a lot of traveling for work.
 
In a perfect world more money will give you more bass extension and SPL.
The D3V I have on my desk right now is really driving that point home.

Unit to unit variance is one of the reasons Genelec and Neumann speakers are more expensive, they try to account for it as best they can, although I do not know which process Genelec currently uses.

You get what you pay for in that case so no, I would not call them overrated.
However you can spend a lot of money and get bad speakers.

If anyone would rather fly blind then trust 60 years of research, go right ahead, but thanks to what I know I can fix the tonality of a speaker with decent directivity during a coffee break. After that the bass has to be corrected in room and I use shelf filtering when listening to recordings as they are also not perfect.

In this case I ended up with one shelf filter at 5Khz while listening and I can see what I did:
I pulled down the on axis to flat, slightly sloped down listening window and a slightly better PIR slope above 5Khz,
On the sample measured ON, LW and PIR are all within+/- 1dB, but again, unit to unit variation is a thing, at this point I trust my ears and room correction is always needed. :)

1791952471733.jpeg


Currently testing a few cheap speakers to see which sound good to me after correction.
T5V got through all the testing, you can find what I did to it in the review thread, one of the last posts.

The D3V I only got yesterday, so at this point I simply put on my desk, loaded in the correction and threw a bass and treble shelf filter at.
It's a good example of what one can do one once has the measurements and a basic understanding of how to interpret them.
 
Last edited:
Lots of great recordings have been made by engineers on heroin or cocaine as well, but that I'd still recommend avoiding that if you can.

Of course if you can't avoid it, make the best of it.
Don't tell me what to do! :p
Thanks for the laugh mate, these threads can really use some humor.
 
I don't remember exactly what has been said earlier in this thread, but in most cases, the audio engineer has chosen the speakers that he thinks sound correct to him with well-known reference materials, or that he has found certain qualities with the speakers that he thinks help him reach a reliable result. It doesn't matter if these speakers are objectively the best measuring speakers in the world, the only important thing is that he doesn't have to “fight” the speakers to reach that reliable result. Using good and well-known reference material and well-known speakers is in many cases the answer to reach continuous great mixing results, while the objectively best measuring speakers on their own will not necessarily be the thing that saves the day.
 
I don't remember exactly what has been said earlier in this thread, but in most cases, the audio engineer has chosen the speakers that he thinks sound correct to him with well-known reference materials, or that he has found certain qualities with the speakers that he thinks help him reach a reliable result. It doesn't matter if these speakers are objectively the best measuring speakers in the world, the only important thing is that he doesn't have to “fight” the speakers to reach that reliable result. Using good and well-known reference material and well-known speakers is in many cases the answer to reach continuous great mixing results, while the objectively best measuring speakers on their own will not necessarily be the thing that saves the day.
This is very idealistic and not consilient with the reality I have experienced.

Engineers often use a tool just because someone they were working for or studied under or were inspired by decided they were the right tools for the job (for whatever reason, almost always sighted and budget-aware). Path dependency is real and formidable: early-stage accidents or coin flips or coincidences or conveniences very frequently constrain future choices, often locking us into a specific outcome or standard even if better alternatives exist or become available.

A very small minority of engineers actually have the best tools for the job. The best ones make up for that with skill and intuition. The others have to rely on luck. Many recordings don't sound very good.
 
A very small minority of engineers actually have the best tools for the job. The best ones make up for that with skill and intuition. The others have to rely on luck. Many recordings don't sound very good.

The reason some/many audio productions don't sound as good as you want them is that it's F* hard to get everything right, and that is all the steps from the actual recording of the material to the finished product. Even the best in the business have productions they are less proud of, and that the stars must have aligned just right for their best works.

It's a good start to go with the speakers that sound just as expected to you when listening to well-known reference tracks, and regularly go back listening to those tracks to recalibrate your hearing while mixing new tracks, otherwise, you will pretty soon be acclimated to whatever balance the work in progress material happens to have at the unfinished state. That last thing will happen no matter how objectively good or bad your speakers are considered to be.

The right tools for you are the ones that work best for you, and that is a highly personal thing. Some people love Genelec speakers, while others can't work with them. Still, everyone knows that Genelec speakers are objectively good measuring speakers.
 
This is very idealistic and not consilient with the reality I have experienced.
Why not? It's common practice to refer to known records if there's an aesthetic you're targetting and I think that's the only way you can really get there.

Many recordings don't sound very good.
The better gear I get, the less I share this sentiment, but YMMV. Path dependency is one thing, but the correct process trumps hi-end.
 
I´m not a pro mixing engineer by any means, I mix sparingsly when my band needs it. With that in mind, I quite value what pro engineers tell me. I´m lucky enough to know a lot of guys who produce records (not in big studios, but pro studios anyway... some are small and some are medium and very well regarded in Spain). And that´s this:

- A looooot of years ago, the first pro enginner I met told me: those Yamaha NS are garbage. I´m sick of the idea of bad sounding monitors because of their supposed revealing qualities.

- A few years later, another pro engineer told me the Yamaha NS were very "hard sounding". I didn´t understand it at that time. Now I do, because I followed the advise of some mates here, studied measurements, took a read at Toole´s book and also at a lot of reviews and opinions here. Of course, I´ve also has been teached by some of these mates who mix for a living.

- Some years later, I started to mix a little. Asked 3 pro engineers who happened to be friends of mine. All of them told me, without a shadow of doubt: "get a pair of Genelecs. No question". When I asked... "how about the NSs?". They just told me "don´t do it, Genelecs are a in a different league".

- A few years ago, another pro engineer told me: monitors are not that important, as long as you learn how to listen to them and use reference tracks. Learn how to match your mixes to your favourite reference tracks, and any half decent monitor will serve you well.

And all of them seem to agree in this: monitors don´t have to sound hard, harsh, brittle or revealing, or bad, or whatever... you can perfectly enjoy good sounding monitors while mixing with them.

Just my humble add to the thread.
 
Last edited:
I´m not a pro mixing engineer by any means, I mix sparingsly when my band needs it. With that in mind, I quite value what pro engineers tell me. I´m lucky enough to know a lot of guys who produce records (not in big studios, but pro studios anyway... some are small and some are medium and very well regraded in Spain). And that´s this:

- A looooot of years ago, the first pro enginner I met told me: those Yamaha NS are garbage. I´m sick of the idea of bad sounding monitors because of their supposed revealing qualities.

- A few years later, another pro engineer told me the Yamaha NS were very "hard sounding". I didn´t understand it at that time. Now I do, because I followed the advise of some mates here, studied measurements, took a read at Toole´s book and also at a lot of reviews and opinions here. Of course, I´ve also has been teached by some of these mates who mix for a living.

- Some years later, I started to mix a little. Asked 3 pro engineers who happened to be friends of mine. All of them told me, without a shadow of doubt: "get a pair of Genelecs. No question". When I asked... "how about the NSs?". They just told me "don´t do it, Genelecs are a in a different league".

- A few years ago, another pro engineer told me: monitors are not that important, as long as you learn how to listen to them and use reference tracks. Learn how to match your mixes to your favourite reference tracks, and any half decent monitor will serve you well.

And all of them seem to agree in this: monitors don´t have to sound hard, harsh, brittle or revealing, or bad, or whatever... you can perfectly enjoy good sounding monitors while mixing with them.

Just my humble add to the thread.
The discussions, and opinions – on the Yamaha NS-10 are pretty much all coming from the wrong premise, in my opinion - and experience.
A lot of people in the industry accepted the NS-10, and produced mixes that translated pleasurably to an audience, larger in sheer numbers - by an nth degree,
than the people exchanging arguments, pro and con, about the speakers.

In the consumer segment, nobody really knew, or cared for - how these productions came about, and the consumer generated income, and fame - , unlike the rather small number of audio aficionados, where the seemingly endless debate about the merits, or lack of, the NS-10 regurgitates endlessly. Get what works for you,
again- in the industry, and much, much more so in the consumer market, nobody cares.

If anyone has a nice pair, and wants to sell them - I'd be interested. Just saying...

Cheers
 
Here's another "take" on "crap" versus "really expensive" speakers:

For the last 6 years or so I've worked almost exclusively from my home studio. I've gone through a few different kinds of speakers and have used the Kali IN-8 for the past 4 years or whatever. When I edit sound I use those speakers. I also use them as the mains when mixing (with LP-6 for surrounds).

However, to check that my mix has a good balance I've come to rely on a "crap" speaker off to the right in my room. It's technically a stereo speaker, but I don't really hear a stereo image from it. With some of the jobs I do it's literally all Kali, but with a large amount of other jobs it's about 80-90% this small speaker.

Now, I get that we can simply run the main mix output through an emulator or just EQ and other software in order to mimic "crap", but I think that in reality a lot of people just got used to the NS-10s and the Auratones. I got used to my Roland CS-10. I think I probably paid about $20 for it back in the 1990's. Literally.

So the point I'm getting at is really two-fold. First that we get used to whatever we get used to, it is what it is, and it's hard to argue against. Secondly, that using "crap" speakers (or emulated "crap") lowers the load on your brain when working. To me it's always as simple as "Is the music balanced well against dialog?" and I never have to second-guess that when listening to my Kali's (full range). With the latter it would be "Ah, just a bit louder than I feel like it should be on this track because the bass is so heavy).

Just my unnecessary 2-cent contribution.
 
Back
Top Bottom