• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Question regarding 2.1 setup

tdesaules

New Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2020
Messages
3
Likes
0
Hi everyone ;)

I'm looking some advise regarding a 2.1 setup in a small room (~130 sq ft).

I have some constraint and some stuff :
  • My multiroom setup is based on raspbery pi
  • Need to be small
  • Need to be cool and fun to test thing
  • I already have some speaker and a subwoofer ( 2 Cambridge Audio Minx Min 22 and 1 Minx Min X201 )
  • I have 2 DAC (never used) a Topping D10 and a SMSL SU-8 ( both should be compatible with the raspberry )
  • I have a small preamp FX-Audio 6J1
Now I have a big question should I use the preamp or useless ? how to connect the subwoofer ? how to choose the amp ?

I was looking for those amp :
  • Topping PA3
  • SMSL DA-8s
Regarding my sub I understand ( from the manufacturer ) that it need a preamp signal. Don't exactly understand what that mean.
And It have an RCA in and another out.

Should I do something like those diagrams ( using some RCA splitter ) :
2.png


To resume :
  1. Any advice between both dac ? The Topping D10 or SMSL SU-8 ?
  2. Any advice between both amp ? The Topping PA3 or SMSL DA-8s ?
  3. Should I use preamp FX-Audio 6J1 or just useless ?
  4. Forget all of that and go only with a small SMSL Q5 or Topping MX3 that have 2.1 native support ?
Another question do you know something that should replace the Cambridge Audio Minx I have, something with the same ~ size ?
( I like it it's just to know if there is alternative )

Thank you guys !
 

Attachments

  • 1.png
    1.png
    4.1 KB · Views: 120
Same sort of size as the Min 22? That'll be a short list. iLoud Micro Monitors perhaps?

From the Installation Guide I'd say either of the first 2 options, assuming that you can do enough volume control with just the DAC. It would have been better if the x201 rca out was high pass filtered for the 3rd arrangement, but it seems that's not what they do. On paper the SU-8 is the better DAC, but I don't know how either behave with the Pi. I can't really comment on the amps. If the native 2.1 support means a high pass for the Min 22s it might be worthwhile.
 
Hi !

Thank you for the answer.

Regarding the two DAC, I will try both. SMSL look better and Topping look smaller :)
I think I will conclude on it after test both on the raspberry pi. Both should work XMOS chipset driver are present in the last kernel image. But will see about the hardware capabilities. Not sure regarding the volume control sometime it is a pain on PI.

If I can't control volume on the DAC I suppose I need a preamp. Or I can play with the sub and amp volume.
Any recommendation on a preamp option ? (around ~ 150$)

For the amp I'm still looking for some options. I start to look the nice graph from the forum.
If you have another options for this ? (around ~ 150$)

For the sub I will ask about the high pass filtered output directly to the manufacturer.
The only response I get from them is that the input signal must be pre-amplified. Don't know if that mean the signal from the DAC will be good to be directly send through the sub...
 
@tdesaules, IIUC, your SU-8 has remote-controlled voume already, right?

If that's the case, there's certainly no need for a preamp.

For optimal simplicity and performance, I would set your system up as follows:

Raspberry Pi --> SMSL SU-8 --> X201 --> Power amplifier (or integrated amp if that's all you have) --> Minx Min 22

Set the volume control and crossover frequency on the subwoofer when you first set up the system.

Then, do whole-system volume control with the SU-8.
 
Hi,

Well I'm still hesitating regarding the amp.
Right now I found the Topping PA3 and SMS DA-8s on my budget 200$ max and a small one.

But I'm open to any other suggestion, if someone know other board ?

Regarding the sub connection I will wait the manufacturer answer regarding the high pass filtered.

thank you
 
Back
Top Bottom