• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Pure Electric Vehicles

This old Dinosaur can still learn new tricks.

Firstly, a few months ago I dropped my four 150W tube monoblocks for two stereo Class D amps.

And now the wife and I run around in an EV... a Mini Aceman S named Marvin...so we are truly a 21st century couple.

In New Zealand, very few Japanese or European car makes have an extensive range of pure EV's (lots of hybrids)... unless of course you want to spaff stupid money on a Beemer, Audi, Merc, Polestar or Lexus. Some well known brands such as Renualt, Citroën or Puegout have no EV's for sale and little or no hybrids cause our market is too small.

Hybrids make no sense to me (at least for our use case) cause you now have two drive trains to maintain plus the additional weight of two drive trains to lug around.

Because we have no car industry to protect in NZ, there are a lot of Chinese brands (+++) with new ones literally appearing every month so you kinda feel you would be taking a chance on long term viablity (***). Thus aside from the quality brands of BYD (Chinese) and Hyundai/Kia (Korean) your non-Chinese EV options for reasonable money (say $50k - $75k) in NZ are limited.

We looked at a few other EV's and what struck us was how front and center all the "tech" was... huge screens with lots of buttons to press, lots of gloss black plastics, stupid shit like "keep your eyes on the road" warnings and steering interference when it thought it knew better (As I noted in another post a while back, when I need to get out of the way of a logging truck coming around a blind corner on my side of the road, I don't want some "intelligence" getting in the way)

The Mini's interior is very minimalist/funky and the driver assist treats you like an adult.

Battery regen appears very good (but I have no real comparison as this is my first EV). Range is stated at 400km but they recommend not letting it drop below 80km nor charging above 80%, so effective/recommended range is 240km.

That is fine for the wife and I as we are retired and as we are rural, most of the windy roads around us are 50km with some small sections at 80km (i.e. not doing motorway speeds or stop/start which can kill range)

Shopping area is 20km away with a big arsed steep and windy road between us and shopping so we will start to do one big shop a week (at least until we get a good read on the range)

Last week we traveled 332km (including three round trips down/up the Mountain) where the utilized range was 300km (i.e. we did 10% better than the utilized range). A trip up or down the Mountain takes 15mins, with the up hill leg having a steep gradient so that was very impressive.

Charged it yesterday from a standard 1800w outlet and it took 15 hours to charge from 80km to the recommended 320km. Used 27khw for the princely cost of $8. Won't bother installing some faster home charger and in fact Mini recommend that battery life is extended if you charge at 1800w/10amp's

The Mini's ride is firm and stable with sharp steering. Some of the other brands we looked at were a bit rolly and wooly in the steering especially on our windy, off camber roads... and given what we need to contend with, sharp handling is a life and death matter.

So far very happy.

Peter


*** Just in case I get mis-read, I am not dissing Chinese EV's.. the issue is in our market, aside from BYD, other Chinese brands have only been here a short time (1-2 years), sell in really small numbers (we are a small country) so maybe they withdraw in a few years, maybe support disappears etc etc.

+++ Below is a list of Chinese brands that aren't BYD that are available in NZ. A lot of brands competing for the same budget end of the business (i.e. they wont all survive) and it makes sifting through them time consuming.

Arcfox
Denza
Dongfeng
Farizon
Forthing
GAC
GWM
Geely
Jaecoo
Leapmotor
MG
Omoda
XPeng
Zeekr

View attachment 566594
Welcome to the Club :)
 
Hybrids make no sense to me (at least for our use case) cause you now have two drive trains to maintain plus the additional weight of two drive trains to lug around.
The BYD Atto 2 (BEV) weighs 1555 kg and the Atto 2 PHEV weighs 1510 kg. Interesting, hey?
 
The BYD Atto 2 (BEV) weighs 1555 kg and the Atto 2 PHEV weighs 1510 kg. Interesting, hey?

Indeed....in my defense (such as it is), I didn't do any deep market analysis but it could make sense as a "full fat" EV has a stack more batteries than the hybrid and maybe the batteries weigh more than an ICE engine.

I tried to get some idea about the typical weights of batteries, electric motors, regen tech of an EV a while ago but the ranges stated were too broad to conclude anything.

So I will retract that statement and scurry away with my tail between my legs while doffing my hat and bowing profusely in your direction.

Peter
 
Last edited:
Unless something goes wrong, these cars will a blessing to handicapped people. My daughter had seizures as a child and never got a drivers license.
And the elderly

And anyone who simply finds driving a chore they would rather not bother with.

And people who don't want to trust their lives to humans with a flesh bone and brain operating system
:)

Oh, and people with broken collar bones
:cool:
 
We have a GAC Aion V - a brand and model that is also sold in China as the Toyota BZ3X...

Claimed range of 510km (real seems more like 400km).... drives well, has excellent suspension, good isolation from road bumps and such, ample power - and it is the smallest SUV that could fit both my sons Cello or my mothers walker.

I would have preferred a "wagon" format rather than SUV....

It shows its SUV'ness on the twisty roads up in the hills. Work has taken my up into the hills quite frequently recently, and that difference between my previous 2012 Subaru Outback and the GAC Aion V is quite noticeable.

The Subaru was much more fun to drive, and lent itself to pushing through the tight mountain curves, the SUV doesn't lend itself to that kind of driving and I find myself being more conservative on the curvy bits.
The interior is incredibly spacious with loads of room for all occupants - I would have happily sacrificed some of that huge back seat legroom in exchange for a deeper trunk...

In use it is a very comfortable and somewhat luxurious, but unexciting car - white goods on wheels (which has always been an apt description for much of Toyota's products... and clearly Toyota had a major hand in the design of this car).

GAC claims that its styling was inspired by the T-Rex.... to be honest I don't see it, but as a result, the family has officially baptised her "Trixie".

 
The Subaru was much more fun to drive, and lent itself to pushing through the tight mountain curves, the SUV doesn't lend itself to that kind of driving
I am hearing some reports that the new Subaru BEV cars are keeping some of that fun factor that you mentioned…
 
The BYD Atto 2 (BEV) weighs 1555 kg and the Atto 2 PHEV weighs 1510 kg. Interesting, hey?

in markets where the chinese are available there's kinda two choices i would make...

a PHEV ie. plugin where they give you *some* EV only range... anywhere from 100-160km (say 60 to 100 miles)

my daily commute is under 60km and a LONG round journey across this city is something like 100km for me (ie. airport run)

and so a LARGE RAV4 sized PHEV is something like 1,750 - 2 ton (ie. 4 to 4,400lb)

that's fine

if you pick them little small PHEVs then yeah sub 1,500 kg is possible... as an ONLY car these are perfect... you get the choice of wall power OR gasoline

we chose the MG4 Urban as a 2nd commuter car... its something like 1,500kg say 3,300lb and it does 400km or 300 miles... so i can charge it maybe once a week

its $30k AUD or something like $20k USD for a large hatch to small SUV sized vehicle


its an entirely adequate vehicle

i have two petrol SUVs and i kind of dont need them any more.;.. i'm not likely to ever go regional... our state capital is 300km away and that place sucks so there's nowhere else to go

this $30,000 car is warranted for 10yrs so it'll be with us for.. a least a decade....
 
Back
Top Bottom