• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Pure Electric Vehicles

It is also a good idea to see what the manufacturer considered a 'failed' battery. If you start with a 250 mile range and the battery loses 30-40% of its capacity and is considered fine by the company that may not be fine for the owner.

Granted gas engines can have problems in the same time range that would be out of warranty so it all comes down to how common losing that much capacity over time is.
Neither range nor durability is considered an general issue with EV batteries, nor is fire hazard or cold weather range (which of course is shorter). From a purely technical perspective they are hunky dory. But of course, if you are a ristaker, I'm pretty convinced you can have really bad experiences. Like with any car or device if you are a happy go lucky shopper.
 
If you keep your car for 20 years and use less than 5,000 miles a year are you better off with gas or electric? My only concern with electric is the battery life. If it's like my notebook or phone the first 5 years are the best, after that its hard to keep a healthy charge. Battery replacement is so expensive I'm tempted to trash the device.
I can only speak to Tesla from personal experience. I also drive around 5,000 miles/year. After 16,000 miles my battery is a good as it was when I first got the car, 100% capacity, and I live in a hot climate, which is (in theory) not good for the battery. It costs me very little to charge the car, I use about 67 kWh of electric/month. I charge the car once every week or two. The Wall Street Journal published an article on the subject, locked behind a paywall, but news reports on the article indicate that EV battery life is far exceeding what was originally thought. I don't believe that you need to be concerned about battery life with any of the mainstream manufacturers, and certainly have no concern with the Tesla battery. My battery was made at the Panasonic/Tesla facility in Texas, but I'm sure that they are all good.

I also plan to keep the car for 20 years, assuming that I last 20 years.
 
If you keep your car for 20 years and use less than 5,000 miles a year are you better off with gas or electric? My only concern with electric is the battery life. If it's like my notebook or phone the first 5 years are the best, after that its hard to keep a healthy charge. Battery replacement is so expensive I'm tempted to trash the device.

Mine has had basically *no* deterioration in 5 years. It still charges fully, maybe a 1% loss. I think the battery will outlive the car.
 
If you keep your car for 20 years and use less than 5,000 miles a year are you better off with gas or electric? My only concern with electric is the battery life. If it's like my notebook or phone the first 5 years are the best, after that its hard to keep a healthy charge. Battery replacement is so expensive I'm tempted to trash the device.
The hybrid I bought in 2005 is still on its original traction battery. It has needed multiple 12V lead-acid batteries during that time.
 
Mine has had basically *no* deterioration in 5 years. It still charges fully, maybe a 1% loss. I think the battery will outlive the car.
Sometimes a device (or car) have more battery capacity fitted than reported. Just an example:

A car never reports more than 100 kwh, but actually has 106.5 kwh fitted. It can loose 6.5 kwh before you spot any degredation by readouts or performance. One could always argue the additional weight or not being able to access the full 106.5 kwh as a drawback, I don't think so.

I believe Tesla sold cars packed with battery cells where owners only got parts of it available and had to purchase access to the rest.....
 
Sometimes a device (or car) have more battery capacity fitted than reported. Just an example:

A car never reports more than 100 kwh, but actually has 106.5 kwh fitted. It can loose 6.5 kwh before you spot any degredation by readouts or performance. One could always argue the additional weight or not being able to access the full 106.5 kwh as a drawback, I don't think so.

I believe Tesla sold cars packed with battery cells where owners only got parts of it available and had to purchase access to the rest.....

That's the case with mine. It's known to have a bigger battery than advertised, but it's so it stays within the "healthier charge levels", because it seems the bad thing for car batteries is leaving them for a long time at either 0 or 100% charge extremes. Hence they keep a safe margin - I'd think mine is not the only one.
 
I believe Tesla sold cars packed with battery cells where owners only got parts of it available and had to purchase access to the rest.....
I think this is an urban myth rumor. I have never had or heard of an offer to purchase access to more battery capacity. The only thing they offer me is a software controlled acceleration boost, which is entirely meaningless for normal driving.

My car is specified with a 330 mile range, and that is what you get for sure at 55-65 mph under average conditions, and you can get more or less depending on how the car is driven. Consumer's Union (in the US) drove it at 70 mph and got the same range, about 337 miles. The battery is either 78 kWh or 82.1 kWh, I'm not sure which, I'd have to find the old paperwork that came with. Tesla recommends charging to up to 80% for everyday use, up to 95 or 100% if starting a long drive. There are obsessives who post all kinds of strategies that will supposedly increase battery life, but I think that those folks are a little neurotic on the topic. I just follow Tesla's recommendation, leave at that, and don't give it any thought.

The Tesla Y (and other EVs I am certain) are designed to be easy to own, without any fuss or maintenance, and that has been my experience.
 
I think this is an urban myth rumor. I have never had or heard of an offer to purchase access to more battery capacity. The only thing they offer me is a software controlled acceleration boost, which is entirely meaningless for normal driving.

My car is specified with a 330 mile range, and that is what you get for sure at 55-65 mph under average conditions, and you can get more or less depending on how the car is driven. Consumer's Union (in the US) drove it at 70 mph and got the same range, about 337 miles. The battery is either 78 kWh or 82.1 kWh, I'm not sure which, I'd have to find the old paperwork that came with. Tesla recommends charging to up to 80% for everyday use, up to 95 or 100% if starting a long drive. There are obsessives who post all kinds of strategies that will supposedly increase battery life, but I think that those folks are a little neurotic on the topic. I just follow Tesla's recommendation, leave at that, and don't give it any thought.

The Tesla Y (and other EVs I am certain) are designed to be easy to own, without any fuss or maintenance, and that has been my experience.

Also - a lot of EVs are eminenty programmable if you know what you're doing. I personally wouldn't mess with standard charging limits/setting much, but there's a ton of online info if you're into it. I did use programmability to improve some personal usability preferences. But you can make a lot more, and in the process learn quite a bit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BJL
If you keep your car for 20 years and use less than 5,000 miles a year are you better off with gas or electric? My only concern with electric is the battery life. If it's like my notebook or phone the first 5 years are the best, after that its hard to keep a healthy charge. Battery replacement is so expensive I'm tempted to trash the device.
So for the time until battery reliability will be performing more consistent (will take some 5 or 6 years), just lease, don't buy .
 
I'm on my 3rd leased one. Battery reliability is unknown. Interesting that both my Audi's kept wanting my to reduce charge threshold to no more than 80%
 
I'm on my 3rd leased one. Battery reliability is unknown. Interesting that both my Audi's kept wanting my to reduce charge threshold to no more than 80%
That gives the battery longer life. Every car company and charger manufacturer recommends 80-85%. Phone suppliers do the same for phones.
 
That gives the battery longer life. Every car company and charger manufacturer recommends 80-85%. Phone suppliers do the same for phones.

OTOH phone suppliers don't build cooling systems and such to protect the battery... :-) EV vendors take the issue a bit more seriously, otherwise the business model would collapse given regulatory frameworks protecting consumers...
 
That gives the battery longer life. Every car company and charger manufacturer recommends 80-85%. Phone suppliers do the same for phones.
One other thing is that chargers slow down the charging rate at 80% to reduce heat in the battery. That is why all the time to charge quotes are 10-80%.
 
That's the case with mine. It's known to have a bigger battery than advertised, but it's so it stays within the "healthier charge levels", because it seems the bad thing for car batteries is leaving them for a long time at either 0 or 100% charge extremes. Hence they keep a safe margin - I'd think mine is not the only one.
Yeah, that's 2 sides of the same coin and makes sense indeed.
That gives the battery longer life. Every car company and charger manufacturer recommends 80-85%. Phone suppliers do the same for phones.
Basicly the same for all kinds of devices with sophisticated batteries. This kind of protection is fairly new on MacBook Pros but has been around for a very long time on ThinkPads. I stick to 80-85% wherever I can whenever I can, for longer storage I aim for 60-80%.

For devices which doesn't have the option of stopping charge at 80-85%, like a battery driven shaver/beardtrimmer, I charge them just before I use them, and not just after.
 
I think every reviewer of the Ioniq 5N that I've read and watched said the fake shifts made the car more fun and engaging. Sure, it's slower but who drives around at 10/10 all the time?
I think every reviewer who said such a thing is an idiot. "This car is better because it's not as smooth with this setting on." Um, ok.

It's like the obsession with manual transmissions. Sure, it's fun to learn how they work and all, but if they're slower than the automatic, then why are you bothering? There is the amount of control one can get for drifting and such, but most people do not want that nor care.
 
I think every reviewer who said such a thing is an idiot.
So everyone who has an opinion that differs from your own is an idiot? These are car people, no appliance analysts. Porsche bought a 5N for evaluation and is implementing them in their upcoming revised Taycan. I haven't driven a 5N but I'll trust their opinions until I have a chance to make my own.
 
I think every reviewer who said such a thing is an idiot. "This car is better because it's not as smooth with this setting on." Um, ok.

It's like the obsession with manual transmissions. Sure, it's fun to learn how they work and all, but if they're slower than the automatic, then why are you bothering? There is the amount of control one can get for drifting and such, but most people do not want that nor care.
I saw a video review from a mainstream (US) auto magazine. The reviewer was test driving an EV that had synthetic sounds and synthetic gear shifts. I believe that it was a Hyundai, but I am not certain.

The reviewer seemed be suffering from arrested development. He sounded like a 16 year old from the 1980s who grew up watching car chases on Miami Vice, which if you have never seen it, was an entertaining cop show shot on location on Miami Beach, and filmed like a music video. Lots of rock and roll, muscle cars careening around and bad guys getting blown away by a Versace clad hero with perfect hair driving a Ferrari Daytona. Great fun.

I didn't think that the reviewer was an idiot necessarily, but he sure did sound like a dummy. Super excited about the things that EVs fix, noise, shift hesitation, pollution; but yeah, he got to drive the car out of control, just like we all want, right?
 
For what its worth, I did the driving of some cars for the photoshoots of some well known car magazines in the USA!
 
I think every reviewer who said such a thing is an idiot. "This car is better because it's not as smooth with this setting on." Um, ok.

It's like the obsession with manual transmissions. Sure, it's fun to learn how they work and all, but if they're slower than the automatic, then why are you bothering? There is the amount of control one can get for drifting and such, but most people do not want that nor care.
You are correct depending on your use. I prefer paddle shifted manuals, stupid fast shifts with better dynamics due to human control AND no more blown engines due to missed shifts.
 
Back
Top Bottom