• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

PaperBoat

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
219
Likes
36
Hi all! Merry Christmas Eve! I've paired my JBL 305p MKII Monitors with an IFI Zen Air DAC... I toggled boundary EQ to -3dB and now trying to tighten up the low end using DSP... My IFI DAC has an XBass+ switch which is an ASP circuitry. I know the XBass (XBass+ has better components) feature is not a gentle boost and is actually meant for Headphones... But when I see the frequency response graph of the XBass and IFI TRUEBASS (meant for Headphones and Speakers) it clearly shows that the TRUEBASS is a more aggressive boost than XBass and/or XBass+! I've contacted IFI support and they told me that XBass+ could be used in my scenario but at medium volume... Now I'm trying to set up some tweaks using Fabfilter Pro MB and Fabfilter Pro Q3 in my JRiver DSP chain to use the XBass feature safely... I wonder if there is a better way to control the low end and then boost it (like the"Pultec punch") again using XBass to get a punchier kick (but not a sub rumble)? Any help?
https://ifi-audio.com/faqs/cant-hear-the-effects-of-xbass/
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20221221_233908.jpg
    IMG_20221221_233908.jpg
    161.9 KB · Views: 61
  • IMG_20221224_123518.jpg
    IMG_20221224_123518.jpg
    127.7 KB · Views: 60
  • 1671867205149.jpg
    1671867205149.jpg
    111.5 KB · Views: 53
  • Screenshot_2022-12-24-13-08-23-58.png
    Screenshot_2022-12-24-13-08-23-58.png
    170.6 KB · Views: 55
  • 1671867471498.jpg
    1671867471498.jpg
    8.6 KB · Views: 61
  • XBass_TotallyAddictedToBass.pdf
    205 KB · Views: 47

ppataki

Major Contributor
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
1,216
Likes
1,355
Location
Budapest
For the Pultec punch I would recommend using the PuigTech plugin from Waves
It is modeling the Pultec hardware and adds some punch even if you don't adjust the lows
Tip: try boosting and cutting the lows at the same time, will sound awesome

Another alternative is Fabfilter Saturn 2
Use Warm Tape, Drive = 0
If you want even more punch just start increasing the Drive (note that it will then start applying some dynamic range compression though)
I warn you that these plugins are addictive! :)
Have fun! & Merry Christmas!
 
Last edited:
OP
PaperBoat

PaperBoat

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
219
Likes
36
For the Pultec punch I would recommend using the PuigTech plugin from Waves
I don't have Pultec but I would like to know will Pultec eqp-1a cause phase shift?

Another alternative is Fabfilter Saturn 2
Use Warm Tape, Drive = 0
If you want even more punch just start increasing the Drive (note that it will then start applying some dynamic range compression though)
Oh boy! I love FF plugins bundle... I have Saturn 2 but never used it and will definitely try...
 

ppataki

Major Contributor
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
1,216
Likes
1,355
Location
Budapest
Every non-linear phase EQ causes phase shift, so yes, it will
If you have the Saturn 2 already then start with that, maybe you wouldn't even need to try the PuigTech plugin
 
OP
PaperBoat

PaperBoat

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
219
Likes
36
Every non-linear phase EQ causes phase shift, so yes, it will
If you have the Saturn 2 already then start with that, maybe you wouldn't even need to try the PuigTech plugin
My goal is to reduce sub-rumble but get punchier kick... To achieve that I'm currently using FF Pro MB to control/ attenuate low end and switching on the XBass+... It's good/ fantastic for classicals but not for modern music...
My FF Pro MB setup:

Band 1: Compression Frequency is 42.426Hz
low crossover at 30Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
high crossover at 60Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
Gain: 0dB
Range: -12dB
Threshold: -90 dB
Attack: 100%
Release: 0%
Stereo link: Mid-only
Lookahead: 20ms
Knee: Hard
Ratio: ∞


Band 2: Compression Frequency is 84.853Hz
low crossover at 60Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
high crossover at 120Hz, Slope: 48 dB/oct
Gain: 0dB
Range: -6dB
Threshold: -30 dB
Attack: 100%
Release: 0%
Stereo link: Mid-only
Lookahead: 20ms
Knee: Hard
Ratio: ∞

Am I doing right?
 
Last edited:

ppataki

Major Contributor
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
1,216
Likes
1,355
Location
Budapest
My goal is to reduce sub-rumble but get punchier kick... To achieve that I'm currently using FF Pro MB to control/ attenuate low end and switching on the XBass+... It's good/ fantastic for classicals but not for modern music...
My FF Pro MB setup:

Band 1: Compression Frequency is 42.426Hz
low crossover at 30Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
high crossover at 60Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
Gain: 0dB
Range: -9dB
Threshold: -90 dB
Attack: 100%
Release: 0%
Stereo link: Mid-only
Lookahead: 20ms
Knee: Hard
Ratio: ∞


Band 2: Compression Frequency is 84.853Hz
low crossover at 60Hz, Slope: 6 dB/oct
high crossover at 120Hz, Slope: 48 dB/oct
Gain: 0dB
Range: -6dB
Threshold: -90 dB
Attack: 100%
Release: 0%
Stereo link: Mid-only
Lookahead: 20ms
Knee: Hard
Ratio: ∞

Am I doing right?

Well, I think this is rather subjective and depends on one's taste (=there is no right or wrong I believe)
I personally never use dynamic EQ for boosting the lows, it sounds unnatural to me

What I usually do is either I apply a low shelf filter, let's say at 70Hz, 24dB/octave, Q=1, 3-4dB (again, this is totally up to taste) and then apply a high-pass filter to prevent over-excursion of the drivers (this is needed for higher SPL)
Or instead of the low shelf filter I just apply a simple bell (peaking) filter, let's say at 40-45Hz, 24dB/octave, Q = anywhere between 0.5 and 0.7, 3-4dB - in that case I don't necessarily need a high-pass filter since the bell won't boost all the way down

And after all of the above I apply Saturn 2 with the Warm Tape option, Drive = 0
 

Elitzur–Vaidman

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Jul 13, 2022
Messages
502
Likes
534
What's your source? I have a pair of JBL 306Ps for my computer/desk setup, and I use peace EQ to apply a few dB bass shelf around 65hz and a high pass filter around 35hz
 
OP
PaperBoat

PaperBoat

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
219
Likes
36
Well, I think this is rather subjective and depends on one's taste (=there is no right or wrong I believe)
I personally never use dynamic EQ for boosting the lows, it sounds unnatural to me

What I usually do is either I apply a low shelf filter, let's say at 70Hz, 24dB/octave, Q=1, 3-4dB (again, this is totally up to taste) and then apply a high-pass filter to prevent over-excursion of the drivers (this is needed for higher SPL)
Or instead of the low shelf filter I just apply a simple bell (peaking) filter, let's say at 40-45Hz, 24dB/octave, Q = anywhere between 0.5 and 0.7, 3-4dB - in that case I don't necessarily need a high-pass filter since the bell won't boost all the way down

And after all of the above I apply Saturn 2 with the Warm Tape option, Drive = 0
Sorry for the late reply... I was busy testing some A/B setups but was still not fully satisfied with them. Some modern music contains excessive 808, synth bass and sub-bass and I'm trying to separate kicks and bass out of it (more kick and less sub). I know my monitor has a flat response and my DAC has a warm sound signature. My room is small but the speaker placement is good. I've tried to learn Saturn 2 but it's too complex for me... Saturn adds harmonics... harmonics will add distortion... Don't know what else to do now... BTW Merry Christmas! ⛄
 
Last edited:
OP
PaperBoat

PaperBoat

Active Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2022
Messages
219
Likes
36
What's your source? I have a pair of JBL 306Ps for my computer/desk setup, and I use peace EQ to apply a few dB bass shelf around 65hz and a high pass filter around 35hz
Merry Christmas!

Source? FLAC, Hi-Res FLAC, Top quality AAC, and some High-quality MP3...

JBL 306 is quite different from JBL 305... 306 has a dip around 1.5k and has a superior bass response than 305 due to a bigger diaphragm and enclosure... I don't think any boost is still needed in the low end if you have 306... Is Peace EQ a dynamic EQ? Has auto threshold function like Fabfilter? Is it linear?
 
Last edited:

Elitzur–Vaidman

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Jul 13, 2022
Messages
502
Likes
534
Merry Christmas! Peace EQ is a PC based parametric EQ program. I use it to fill in the 1.5k dip enhance the low frequency extension of my 306Ps by a few Hz in exchange for some headroom.
 

ppataki

Major Contributor
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
1,216
Likes
1,355
Location
Budapest
I've tried to learn Saturn 2 but it's too complex for me... Saturn adds harmonics... harmonics will add distortion... Don't know what else to do now... BTW Merry Christmas! ⛄
Merry Christmas to you too!

All of these kind of plugins will add harmonics (distortion) - that is how they work
Pultec plugins will do the same too (the original Pultec hardware has a tube in it....)
I suggest trying it nevertheless - if you don't like the sound you can just ditch them and keep looking for other solutions

btw. setting up Saturn 2 is very easy, just observe the highlighted parts:

1671976895150.png


If you don't like Saturn 2 and PuigTec then you could try some transient-shaping plugins too such as Voxengo Peakbuster and various modules of Izotope Ozone 10 (like Impact, Stabilizer, Master Rebalance, Low End Focus)
 
Top Bottom