Interesting thread!
First of all, I’m blown away by how big the TVs are that many here own! Wow! It really is a new world.
I was an early adopter of plasma TV - I bought the third generation of Panasonic plasma TVs, the generation they finally solved being able to do good black levels back in 2001. Mine was a 42 inch “ED” resolution plasma. That was essentially the native resolution of DVDs at the time. Although they had just introduced HD resolution plasmas, the ED resolution plasma produced much smoother, more artefact-free images with the broadcast TV images at the time as well as DVD. It’s still the smoothest overall image I’ve ever seen on a display. With the exception that if you get too close, you can see the pixels.
That served as my first “ home theatre” in this house, to which I added, surround sound in our back family room.
I really got heavily into the whole thing, including trying to maximize image quality in every way possible. I was even the first and possibly only person I know who actually introduced “ black masking” for plasma TVs.
They still didn’t quite solid black levels, even my Panasonic , so I had these black masking straps. I could easily place at the top and bottom to mask the edges of a 2:35:1 black-barred image. It actually produced a shockingly better picture for such movies.
Then I began to experiment more with Whatever could affect perceived image quality.
I actually began to hang black velvet curtains behind the plasma to blackout the wall. Again that made the perception of the image depth and pop really jump out.
It took on a picture window viewing depth. In fact, guests who watched content on that plasma and who years later owned much better plasmas, would still tell me “ I’ve never seen a better picture than the one I saw at your house.”
If you’re not about picture quality , it really pays dividends to pay attention to aspects that you wouldn’t normally think affect picture quality.
Anyway, when Panasonic came up with a 65 inch HD model several years later I was completely blown away at how cinematic that size felt at that time. That to me was the obvious upgrade.
But it was too big for the back family room, and the only room I had was the front living room of the house which has served as my two channel listening room.
I tried some 65” mock ups with tape on the wall to get a general idea of the placement and size, but then I borrowed a friend’s ultra cheap business projector to throw a 65 inch 16:9 image on the wall to give me an idea of viewing angles and arranging my furniture.
That was helpful but after a bit of experimentation, I made the fateful decision “ I wonder what the image would look like zoomed out bigger on the wall?”
I happened to be watching the Jurassic Park DVD and I zoomed out the image big on the wall and he was like “holyyyy sheeeet!”
Totally changed the experience.
So immersive. So cinematic. And now I was looking at what seem to be real size dinosaurs towering over me just like I remember in the cinema.
Well, that was it. After watching a few more DVDs like that, I knew my new direction was a projector!
So early on I thought I was a flat panel or die guy. And then I went straight to projection and have paid only cursory attention to the development of flat panels.
That 42” ED Panasonic plasma is still our TV in the back family room!
And after 25 years, it’s still going strong , dimmed a little bit, so it’s not great for daytime viewing but we never watch in the day and it’s plenty bright at night. And no obvious signs of burn in! Pretty amazing given the amount of handwringing there was over how well that technology would last when it came out. It certainly lasted longer than any other TV my family, or I have owned in my life.
When I plunged into the projection I was still a black level fiend, so I’ve stuck JVC protectors over the years. At this point I’m still using my JVC RS00 projector that I bought in 2016, and whose contrast levels still haven’t been beaten by any other consumer projector (150,000:1 native contrast, with vastly higher dynamic contrast).
To maintain the very best image quality, my room was renovated to have a non-reflective ceiling with a bulkhead covered in brown felt, non-reflective carpet wall to wall, dark furniture, but light walls, so the room still looks cheery during the day.
However, for watching a movie, there are thin, very dark, black velvet curtains that I pull across every wall, turning it into a “Batcave/black box.” (in fact, I even have a canopy of black velvet over top of the image as well).
This allows the room to completely disappear from view when watching a movie so you just see a giant image floating in a sea of black.
And I use automated four-way masking panels to ensure that the active image area is always perfect perfectly surrounded in black, no matter what aspect ratio or image size. And I can play sort of any image size I want…100” 16:9 for some content, maybe 124 inch 16:9 for other content, and up to 118 inches wide for 2:35:1 scope AR.
Sometimes when I’m watching at 100” or even smaller down to 95” the pictures is so bright, dense, sharp and punchy it reminds me of a flatscreen.
Of course the Home theatre geek me is aware of the development in flatscreen TVs. I was continually in Best Buy over the years, watching them grow in size and capability.
I especially enjoyed when HDR and big OLEDs hit the scene.
I’m a black level fiend and also really dislike alterations of the image from different viewing angles so I would prefer OLED over any form of LCD.
So occasionally, the question comes into my mind “ could I go for a large flatscreen at this point instead of the projection?”
But then I zoomed out the image big , or even wide it out for cinema scope, and from my 10 foot viewing distance it’s just so incredibly cinematic and immersive. It’s just a totally different experience from a smaller screen. And then I’m like “ nope, no way, can’t give this up.”
And as I’ve said, I’ve maximized the image quality and contrast available from the projector, so in the dark I’m not really missing flatscreen quality.
I just recently purchased a Kaleidescape Strato E 4K player and I’ll be implementing a Lumagen radiance pro video processor to do dynamic to mapping for HDR to my projector, so I’m excited about that too!
It’s not going to match the contrast you can get with HDR on an OLED, but apparently it will still be a noticeable upgrade.
Anyway, just thought I’d share the journey of somebody who was all about flatscreen TVs to begin with and he went to projection, and still not ready to leap to a big screen TV.
But I’m sure they look fantastic .
And given the TV sizes you’re all talking about it’s no wonder. Movie attendance has been going down over the past 15 years or so.