• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Pragmatic Audio PEQ - System Wide IOS PEQ

Jeromeof

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Forum Donor
Joined
Jul 25, 2021
Messages
934
Likes
1,930
Location
Ireland
Introduction
I have always been frustrated by the lack of system wide PEQ in IOS but that is hopefully about to change.

I have developed a small App (called 'Pragmatic Audio PEQ' ) that hooks into a new IOS 27 API ( so no older devices can be supported).

Note: I got this idea from playing with a new App called Effect Deck https://apps.apple.com/us/app/effectdeck/id6812467517 - but since that App is very general purpose audio filter, I thought I would use the same techniques to build a new IOS app that is more dedicated to just PEQ ( though I might add Crossfeed and a few other effects in later versions).

Available on AppStore now:

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pragmatic-audio-peq/id6818329288

I believe this is the first dedicated system wide PEQ application for iPhones (and iPads) but because of the way I developed this application is it also available on Android, MacOS and Windows. The Android PlayStore version is being reviewed but I have an APK available on this location:


How it works:

So how it works, after you install it - optionally you should see a new 'audio playback device' - called "Pragmatic EQ" - I had it originally called "System PEQ" and you can still rename it in the App if you like that name (or 'System Wide PEQ' maybe):

IMG_6905.jpg


Without any PEQ loaded this App will 'pass through the audio' so whatever audio device you were playing music previously will continue when you switch to this Audio output but it will be passed through this 'System PEQ' ( So, I can't make it the 'default' - but this is relatively easy switch and should stay selected until the next reboot, even if you switch around different music apps on your iPhone, but it will go back to the default after a reboot or obviously you can always switch back using the same 'Control Panel' on your iPhone).

The App itself is roughly split into 4 parts:

IMG_6906.PNG


The 'Load' is how you load PEQ into it - I have added a few typical online measurement DB e.g. Squig.link and @crinacle's graph.hangout.audio and you can add more via the Settings:
IMG_6907.PNG

Then once you click the Load PEQ:
1790961031013.png

It will launch that website and the idea is you pick your headphone and goto the 'Equaliser' tab and design your PEQ (or using autoEQ) and then look for the 'Export' button e.g. on Squig.link:
IMG_6908.PNG

The App captures the exported PEQ 'filters' and imports them automatically.

You can then review and edit them - you can double click on a numbered filter and edit the values and you can even 'drag' a number around to alter its FR and Volume - unlike the Effect Desk I am automatically applying a Preamp adjustment based on the PEQ filter:
IMG_6909.PNG

And this should be 'live' so you can hear the PEQ when playing any music in any app on your iPhone.

To make evaluating the PEQ easier I added an A/B testing with 'manual' volume matching so you can hopefully evaluate the PEQ against the 'no PEQ':
IMG_6910.PNG

And finally you can view the music playing with a Graphics Equaliser and some 'nerdy' statistics:
IMG_6911.PNG


Not sure if I will fully publish an App yet - but looking for some feedback from users of iPhones (with IOS 27 installed) and some knowledge of configuring PEQ.

Thanks
All comments welcome !!
 
Last edited:
OK - I released an updated version - with more PEQ measurements (optionally from OPRA so various other PEQ like Oratory1990's ), Cross Feed and more visualisations.

You can also customised the "Audio Channel Name" ( so you can rename it to "SystemWide PEQ" if you want ).
 
@Jeromeof Holy crap!! Where have you been all my iOS life, this is awesome! Just started playing around with it and seems fantastic, no need for dongles or anything

Many thanks for this
 
Am i correct to think that this will break dolby atmos playback?

Also did you build a mechanism for people to quickly do a level matched seamless A/B testing?

I feel like a lot of people are obsessed with targets (of which for IEMs all are shit or at best unsubstantiated) and forget to listen.
 
Am i correct to think that this will break dolby atmos playback?

Also did you build a mechanism for people to quickly do a level matched seamless A/B testing?

I feel like a lot of people are obsessed with targets (of which for IEMs all are shit or at best unsubstantiated) and forget to listen.
At the moment, I believe the audio will get resampled to 2 channel - so yes dolby atmos playback won't work - on IOS I also found that Apple will not send audio associated with video content ( maybe they will change this ) but it basically means watching a movie or even 'Canvas' within Spotify won't work with this app.

Yes, I have a A/B testing feature with both A/B testing with 'NO PEQ' / 'PEQ Profile' but also recently I added the ability to pick a second 'local' PEQ profile against the active one ( you can download a profile - then "Save as Personalised" will save it locally so it can be used in these A/B testing against the current PEQ profile.

I included a Blind A/B test also with level matching ( will be interesting to see what people think of this feature).

And yes people are obsessed with Targets, but one thing I am trying to do with this is allow easy personalisation of a downloaded PEQ - so you can listen to music while you customise the PEQ and then save it as a personalisation profile. You can also Pinned that PEQ profile to a headphone/TWS ( where I can see the Bluetooth device name), so you can sort of 'fix' individual bluetooth headphones but still have no PEQ for other headphones.
 
Hey, just tried out the app :)

Good news: The app works very well for what it it aims to do, I managed to setup some filters, used the A/B feature successfully and the estimate level feature for the loudness difference between PEQ and no PEQ seems to work great (psychoacoustically at least).

"Bad" News: Now that we have PEQ directly on the AirPods PRO 3 to deal exactly with the pain points for many (recessed ear gain and high treble), for me personally the sound is excellent now and whatever improvements to be gained are not worth the trade offs (no HRTF adjustments, no spatial audio-ed stereo and no Atmos).

I unironically went 'what is this dull shit?' when I disabled Spatial Audio processing on stereo tracks lol

I wanted to test the 3rd filter here and see if it makes a difference (the first two filters are applied with the built in PEQ of the AirPods Pro 3):

1791458545575.png


As expected the Q was too high to be actually audible in music, I could hear it in pink noise though.

Sorry for the boomer rant, great app so far, some constructive feedback:

1) The A/B comparator needs to be at the same window as the window where you setup the filter, otherwise setting up the gain by ear for filters is a hassle.

2) consider making sliding up and down an option for setting up the gain of a filter, along side point number 1 it should enable users to adjust the sound to their ears the best.
 
Hey, just tried out the app :)

Good news: The app works very well for what it it aims to do, I managed to setup some filters, used the A/B feature successfully and the estimate level feature for the loudness difference between PEQ and no PEQ seems to work great (psychoacoustically at least).

"Bad" News: Now that we have PEQ directly on the AirPods PRO 3 to deal exactly with the pain points for many (recessed ear gain and high treble), for me personally the sound is excellent now and whatever improvements to be gained are not worth the trade offs (no HRTF adjustments, no spatial audio-ed stereo and no Atmos).

I unironically went 'what is this dull shit?' when I disabled Spatial Audio processing on stereo tracks lol

I wanted to test the 3rd filter here and see if it makes a difference (the first two filters are applied with the built in PEQ of the AirPods Pro 3):

View attachment 563267

As expected the Q was too high to be actually audible in music, I could hear it in pink noise though.

Sorry for the boomer rant, great app so far, some constructive feedback:

1) The A/B comparator needs to be at the same window as the window where you setup the filter, otherwise setting up the gain by ear for filters is a hassle.

2) consider making sliding up and down an option for setting up the gain of a filter, along side point number 1 it should enable users to adjust the sound to their ears the best.

Great thanks for the feedback.
 
Real ones know the pain of jailbreaking and giving up banking apps solely for EQE back in the day

ico.webp
 
Are you secretly trying to sell me some Airpods that I still do not own to this day? Been holding off for something exactly like this for over a decade. Functionally, the app seems to work fine, although I will echo the A/B function and editing/saving of presets needs to be conveniently accessible at all times.
 
Real ones know the pain of jailbreaking and giving up banking apps solely for EQE back in the day

View attachment 563275
So, many years ago I was building some custom Android ROM with ViPER4Android
Are you secretly trying to sell me some Airpods that I still do not own to this day? Been holding off for something exactly like this for over a decade. Functionally, the app seems to work fine, although I will echo the A/B function and editing/saving of presets needs to be conveniently accessible at all times.
Yes I will review how my A/B testing functionality is shown. The problem is I am trying to make the UI as simple as possible for newbies and A/B testing is super important so I have it on the main screen but after the options to Load a Headphone Profile or Create your own:

1791530740906.png

And in the Create your own - I added 4 options to 'gentle' let people get used to EQ:
1791530853890.png

And I made those 'Fixed band' as traditional as I could even though technically this 'fixed' bands are full PEQ filters so you can drag them around (or edit the FR and qValues) :
1791530907127.png

Then if you have at least 1 PEQ profile loaded I show it as the current profile where uses can Edit it:
1791531043989.png
1791531086980.png

But maybe I can add a link here to A/B testing the current profile - but the A/B testing section is hopefully straight forward.
So with only one profile downloaded or personalised - you can A/B test between it and the No PEQ with Live Music:
1791531231199.png
1791531288150.png

At this point the user can start level matching between No PEQ and the PEQ:
1791531350256.png

And then even start a blind testing process:
1791531389942.png

And if you have 2 different Profiles 'saved' locally you can to the A/B testing between them:
1791531510342.png

So, I have been playing with different ways of doing the layout to 'gentle' get users to understand and play with the features without bombarding them with more complicated things but maybe I can offer a toggle on live A/B within the current PEQ editor.

So thanks for the feedback and I will have a think over the weekend about how best to do this without 'scaring' away newbies.

FYI: I am almost ready with full MacOS, Windows and Android versions with effectively the same UI ( but obviously different audio engines underneath and different ways of hooking into the audio stream - developing a Windows APO DLL is a bit tricky :D but hopefully this evening).
 
You can also Pinned that PEQ profile to a headphone/TWS ( where I can see the Bluetooth device name), so you can sort of 'fix' individual bluetooth headphones but still have no PEQ for other headphones.
That's a nice feature, I use a similar one in PowerAmp on Android to implement PEQ for Bluetooth headphones and earbuds and also turn off PEQ for my bluetooth DAC/Amps which implement their own PEQ (Qudelix 5K and Fiio BTR13).
 
Apologies as maybe I've missed it- is there a way to adjust the applied pre-amp?
 
An UI suggestion...

IMG_3679.jpg

I can move the filter "Point" around, and the frequency & gain track the change...

Could you mimic the MS-Office freeform Bezier point editing feature in order to adjust the Q-Factor?
1791563617512.png

If I "long-press" the point, I trigger an overlay with these adjustable anchors, wider = lower Q, narrower = higher Q. This could expand into something much more complex where moving the L/R anchor independently would do "something" to the filter (don't know what could be the resulting EQ filter...).

On the other hand, discoverability of the UI feature could be an issue—it may not be a good idea in the end !!!
 
An UI suggestion...

View attachment 563445
I can move the filter "Point" around, and the frequency & gain track the change...

Could you mimic the MS-Office freeform Bezier point editing feature in order to adjust the Q-Factor?
View attachment 563446
If I "long-press" the point, I trigger an overlay with these adjustable anchors, wider = lower Q, narrower = higher Q. This could expand into something much more complex where moving the L/R anchor independently would do "something" to the filter (don't know what could be the resulting EQ filter...).

On the other hand, discoverability of the UI feature could be an issue—it may not be a good idea in the end !!!
I do have the + / - width/qValue just below so you move the point around where you want it to go and then -/+ just underneath the graph to adjust the qValues.

If the newest version I have a 'pretend' 5-band , 10-band and 15-band 'fixed' EQ and sliders ( to gentle get people used the idea of adjusting these filters but even on that view you can still move the points around to change the FR ( and for those brave enough there is qValue adjustments even on that screen).

So, I added the A/B testing to this editing screen also (and move the filter editing values section into a collapsable section underneath so only those really interested in the values need to look at each filter value, but then under that section there is now a A/B compared of just the current edits compared to what was previous setup for that filter:

1791566000158.png


And for those brave enough or curious enough, I also have beta's of the Android, Windows and MacOS versions of this app with mostly the same UI ( Android doesn't let me add Crossfeed or other effects or at least I haven't figured out how to do that yet).

Those builds are here:


Note: I will probably publish the Android version on the Playstore but for now you will need to "Allow Unknown Sources" etc and the Window Version similarly will give a warning that you will need to accept. Windows App signing seems to cost $10 a month which given this is a very niche App it probably isn't worth it for me to pay.

The MacOS is reasonable well tested ( as I have been using it for the past week) but the Android and Windows were only testing on one Android DAP (for a few hours) and similar the Windows build was only tested on one Windows Laptop ( a pretty slow one that I happen to have 'for emergencies' :D ). So I would love some comments about these other builds if people have time to look at them.

I probably won't do any more features until I find out whether Apple will allow the iOS version on the AppStore ( still waiting for the review of the version from earlier in the week to be reviewed).
 
Is there a way to send the EQ'd music to Airplay or CarPlay? I purchased the iOS app just for this reason and it seems I can only use it with earphones?
 
Is there a way to send the EQ'd music to Airplay or CarPlay? I purchased the iOS app just for this reason and it seems I can only use it with earphones?
At the moment, I haven't figured out a way for CarPlay ( CarPlay as a protocol is a mixture of bluetooth and Airplay ) - since CarPlay is really needs custom REW done measurements in your car it doesn't seem a match for what I was trying to do with this App.

But, I do have a different App 'Pragmatic Audio Lossless' that is more designed around Airplay there is a Testflight sign up here => https://www.pragmaticaudio.com/apps/ - with this other App I rewrote the Airplay 1 and 2 Protocol so I could control the bitrate negotiation (as that is one of the main complaints as Apple can switch to AAC without telling the User) but with this app I control the 'end to end' protocol but if you wanted to capture the audio output of one app, route it into this lossless app and then 'send' it to a Airplay speaker (or possible CarPlay ) I don't think it will work as the Audio route is too complicated.

But because I wanted to control the route in this app, I mainly support your own music ( both lossless and lossy on Plex, cloud storage, network files, DLNA and local files on your phone) to be played to an Airplay (1 or 2) server but I do have a little bit of optional DSP ( mostly I feel the people into Lossless Audio do not want the 'bits' changed so the only aspect of my DSP engine, I have made available a "DSP corrections" for a given Airplay output:

1793609002364.png
1793609061118.png

So the idea is you could measure your 'room' (and possible car) and apply some PEQ within REW to both the L and R channels and then load those PEQ filters as DSP corrections.
 
So the short answer is no then. It might be helpful if you stated this more clearly in your app description as it currently states you can send corrected audio to headphones and speakers but no mention of BT exclusivity and presumably a HP out port. I did get it to work on some BT speakers.

I've installed TestFlight but in need an invitation from you it seems with a link to install PragmaticAudio Lossless beta. How do I get a link? the link on your webpage in step 2 View PragmaticAudio Lossless Beta "View in TestFlight" is broken.

I primarily use locally stored files so not an issue for streaming services. Measuring spaces with REW is trivial work, will the Lossless app accept individual PEQs or just a LR FIR filter as indicated in your screenshot. I've never understood anyones desire for bitperfect files in a car but everyone had there own priorities I guess.
 
So the short answer is no then. It might be helpful if you stated this more clearly in your app description as it currently states you can send corrected audio to headphones and speakers but no mention of BT exclusivity and presumably a HP out port. I did get it to work on some BT speakers.

I've installed TestFlight but in need an invitation from you it seems with a link to install PragmaticAudio Lossless beta. How do I get a link? the link on your webpage in step 2 View PragmaticAudio Lossless Beta "View in TestFlight" is broken.

I primarily use locally stored files so not an issue for streaming services. Measuring spaces with REW is trivial work, will the Lossless app accept individual PEQs or just a LR FIR filter as indicated in your screenshot. I've never understood anyones desire for bitperfect files in a car but everyone had there own priorities I guess.
Let me check - the TestFlight link should have resulted in a version inside TestFlight that you can install.

As for the PEQ I never promised carplay and that app is sort of built around PEQ correction of headphones but i think it could work soon but the new api I am using is very new MediaExtension ios27 so I guess for now it is not supported on CarPlay - Apple are very cautious about apps on CarPlay ( and as I mentioned I never tested with CarPlay ).
 
Ok I tried both apps to see what happens ( I have an old CarPlay setup ) - the PEQ does route to CarPlay as it doesn’t appear as an audio output I route too after I apply the PEQ.

The lossless app does get close but it’s like the pairing that works for AirPlay doesn’t work with CarPlay - see this image with an error

1793637642320.png
 
Back
Top Bottom