• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Possible solution for DTS/Dolby/Atmos+eARC+HDCP to AES/EBU - via Dante? (for Okto DAC8PRO etc)

Nuprime have another product now with configured inputs. Okto like 8bchannel dac with ess 9038



But as before, it seems they are using the same boards as the H16 versions for AES and AoIP?

Edit: I stand corrected, the plugin cards don't HDMI decode, just provide inputs
 

That was an interesting article:

Traditional AV receivers and some multichannel processors, however, pack the DSP, DACs and analog outputs tightly into one circuit design to save cost and chassis space. If you want to push sound quality further and step into the world of the "high-end multichannel system," you have to deal with interference between channels, and between the digital, analog and power sections of the circuitry.

To borrow a line from U-Audio editor-in-chief Kuo Han-cheng, high-end comes down to one word: "separate." Decoding stays decoding, DRC room correction stays DRC, the clock comes from a more precise external clock, and of course the DAC gets its own box too. That turns the so-called surround preamp into a pure "digital processor": once decoding and DRC are done, an external DAC converts the signal to analog and hands it to the power amps that drive the speakers.

That's my way of thinking, except that I might go mad and add separate source selection and audio extraction, reconstruction filtering, and preamplification.

I do like the fact that he used a Mac Mini for DRC, whcih I think gets round some of the limitations of AVP Dirac processing.

It was interesting to hear a comparison of a Nuprime system vs a StormAudio system.
 
> multichannel AES/EBU DACs are almost impossible to find

The legacy Yamaha converter frames I mentioned above are an inexpensive way to go.



$400 can also get you MY16-AUD2 cards which do Dante or AES67 AoIP
 
> multichannel AES/EBU DACs are almost impossible to find
There are lots of good options (besides multiple stereo DACs, which might actually be a good solution).

One could also consider Behringer, Crestron, Dangerous Music, Ferrofish, Glennsound, Penta, Tascam, Yamaha

EDIT - see post below.
 
Last edited:
Wow where's the source of that chart?

And why those cells blacked out?
 
Wow where's the source of that chart?
And why those cells blacked out?

It's a subset of a subset of something I wrote. Here's a new version with light backgrounds added.

1791399083136.png
 
Thanks!

I'd be very interested in looking at the superset, if not the OG contextual text?

A gSheet allowing crowdsourced updates would be a great public resource...
 
Thanks!
I'd be very interested in looking at the superset, if not the OG contextual text?
A gSheet allowing crowdsourced updates would be a great public resource...
Here's the main spreadsheet, compiled over the last couple of years.
It's got a lot of other information besides.
It focusses on the layered audio architecture on the first tab.
Feel free to ask questions.
 

Attachments

I would add to that list Audient Oria 16 with dante extension card
 
I didn't use my Mac for a few days and when I got back to it my dolby atmos tracks won't launch. They would start playback and stop within a second. Couldn't figure out what was happening. No error logs or messages. Feels like a handshake issue.

However if I change my speaker configuration to 7.1.4 or 5.1.2 or 5.1 things worked, but could not get 5.1.4 to work. It seems apple music has some weird issue with being able to decode discreetly to a 5.1.4 configuration.

Apple tv movies seemed fine for the couple of movies I tried, but not apple music. So at this point I just had to stick my speaker config to 7.1.4 and use total mix to downmix the extra bed channels.
 
My complaint about Apple TV music is that it crossfades every song. I can't change it because the Music App on Apple TV doesn't have any settings. In the andrioid app for Apple Music I can turn off crossfade.

This is new by the way, just in the last few weeks.

I hate it.
 
I'm not sure which is the right forum for this, but this might be interesting. Audient have been on my radar for a while, both from several positive tests by Julian Krause, and the Oria being the first "Atmos ready" audio interface. Despite having an optional Dante input, the Oria only had AES3 outputs, which dented it's utility, and it's sonic performance wasn't brilliant.

Audient have been working hard, and recently launched their flagship Horizon interfaces, the 8P with mike preamps, and the line level 16 and 32. They're slim, 1U, interfaces with ADAT and Thunderbolt 3 inputs that run on MacOS and seem to be decent alternatives to the plethora of Universal, Antelope, Apogee, Merging, MOTU, RME, Avid, Direct Out, Lynx & Focusrite boxes.

1793207560568.png


What distinguishes them is in the spec sheet.
The analogue inputs are great, but the analogue outputs claim 122dB THDN and 132dB DR.
They also have high max output voltage and low output impedance. All that takes them straight to the top of the class.
Audient confidently claim they're genuine measurements (rather than DAC chip specs) and better than anyone else's.
There doesn't seem to be any room EQ, and there's no USB input, but otherwise these are very interesting, and moderately priced.

1793206537429.png
 
Last edited:
So after some Time at least i could Mesure my 7.1 alternative to an Trinov CI ;)

The Results you can find here:

https://www.diyaudio.com/community/...ound-digital-aktive-setup.440807/post-8411995

Sure it is only for LPCM use for now till i get an good ATMOS Processor with AES Outs but thats probably not before .03.2027 next year or so (Hyperion DPR-16 or NuprimeX HX-16AES, both not released for now).

All measurings done with COSMOS Stack (APU, SCALER and ADC DM).

There you can see that all Jitter from HDMI Extractor is gone while using Mutec MC-4 as an SRC for 7.1 AES into RME HDSPe AES Card!

Still reaching THD+N better -121dB in that CHAIN on SU-2 DAC and i am fine with it!

I got the MUTEC MC-4 for 720€ as B-Ware but it has no scratches ot any visable defects!

Compersion: SU-2 DAC directly on Extractor:

HDMI to AES Extractor SU-2.jpg

SU-2 DAC after Extractor --> MUTEC --> RME Card:

HDMI to MUTEC no SRC to RME to SU-2 RME AES SYNC 48kHz .jpg
 
Last edited:
So after some Time at least i could Mesure my 7.1 alternative to an Trinov CI ;)
The Results you can find here:
https://www.diyaudio.com/community/...ound-digital-aktive-setup.440807/post-8411995
Sure it is only for LPCM use for now till i get an good ATMOS Processor with AES Outs but thats probably not before .03.2027 next year or so (Hyperion DPR-16 or NuprimeX HX-16AES, both not released for now).
All measurings done with COSMOS Stack (APU, SCALER and ADC DM).
There you can see that all Jitter from HDMI Extractor is gone while using Mutec MC-4 as an SRC for 7.1 AES into RME HDSPe AES Card!
Still reaching THD+N better -121dB in that CHAIN on SU-2 DAC and i am fine with it!
I got the MUTEC MC-4 for 720€ as B-Ware but it has no scratches ot any visable defects!

That's absolutely tremendous Frunse!
All the benefits and none of the compromises with HDMI.
It even measures better than the Tide16.
I hadn't read that DA thread before, but I'm going to read it all.
I also got an RME HDSPe AES to use in my PC for the same purposes, but I haven't used it in anger yet.
 
Last edited:
That's absolutely tremendous Frunse!
All the benefits and none of the compromises with HDMI.
It even measures better than the Tide16.
And still Cheeper LOOOL

1000 to 1100€ Extractor with Mutec
900€ 8 SU-2 DAC'S (now cheeper i guess)
850€ RME HDSPe AES
150€ 2x DB25 to AES Tascam stile (RME HDSPe)
100€ 1x DB25 to AES Yamaha Stile (MUTEC)
PC ??? Now all is more Expensive (RAM SSD and so on fxxk KI ;) )

3000 to 3100€ + PC

Tide 16 in Germany 4600€ and no FIR FIlter or not much Tab's for Steep FIR Filter at all and only 48kHz Samplerate:
https://www.soundimports.eu/de/mini...MIx43H2b_hlwMV7bCDBx3c-B1NEAAYASAAEgLqtfD_BwE

so still 1400€ left for PC in a HDCP Enclousure and a nice Enclousures to my Extractor LooL

Also possible to use an Second MUTEC MC-4 with ATMOS Processor for 16 Channels before RME Card if it has some Jitter left ;) !

And the best is, you could add up to 3 HDSPe Cards at once for crazy 48 Channel Out!!!

Next for me is also to build up an Relais Based Volumecontrol for each Channel before the HYPEX Amps so all Digital Stuff can work with maximal Headroom in use (no compromise there) Remotecontrolled probably with 433MHz Lora Arduino Network close at each Speacker for shortest Analoge Wiriring possible ;).

Digital Stuff -->AES Cable 10 to 15m --> SU-2 DAC--> XLR Cabel 0,5m --> Volumecontroll (Ballanced) --> XLR Cabel 0,5m --> HYPEX AMP each Speaker chassis!

If you wan't to use DANTE instead, thats also possible with RME HDSPE AoX-D PCI Card (1750€) but not sure if it work's on Linux for now but surely on Windows or MAC ;)

And you need to watch for other kind of DAC or Interfaces for Dante to analogue Out.

For 32 Channles 2x HDSPe AES (2x850€) still cheeper than one HDSPE AoX-D, but with 48 Channels it becomes more expensive ;) so you need to know before, where you wan't to go with the Setup!
 
Last edited:
I'm deeply impressed with this.
Just a couple of immediate questions:
  • What sample rates can you run at?
  • Wouldn't it make more sense to have the Mutec AFTER the RME, because the jitter going into the DAC is the crucial thing, and that seems to make a difference?
 
I'm deeply impressed with this.
Just a couple of immediate questions:
  • What sample rates can you run at?
  • Wouldn't it make more sense to have the Mutec AFTER the RME, because the jitter going into the DAC is the crucial thing, and that seems to make a difference?
You can use up to 192kHz on Extractor (LPCM), Mutec as well as RME Card (no Samplerate reduction at different Chanel counts like on DANTE or ADAT, main reason why i choosed AES instead of DANTE).

The RME Card on it's own has an Jitterreduction with Steadyclock FS engine.

So for me the most Jitter comes from HDMI Extractor and i wan't to clean it up as soon as possible also i need the SRC on MUTEC before CamillaDSP!

So i can play anything on HDMI without Bother about Samplerates and the MUTEC brings it up to 96kHz for CamillaDSP!

CamillaDSP can't watch for incomming Samplerate changes! Thats would only work with an USB interface used ;)

With an descent ATMOS Processor i could place it (2x MUTEC MC-4) after RME Card if needed, because the Processor has an SRC included i guess / Hope!

I will make an different Measuring with MUTEC behind RME Card, now i am interested as well how it measured that way ;)
And without MUTEC at all !
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom