• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Pink Floyd

I like the Wall, a lot.
But I always liked it as it is, a soundtrack of a great movie (even if it's the other way around) .

They really need to do a 4K UHD remaster of The Wall - The Movie. Not sure why it hasn’t happened yet? After all, they do seem to like making money with remasters, reissues, and special editions; and I don’t mind buying just about all of it
 
Two buddies and I borrowed my parents car, and drove up to Blossom Music Center and saw this show: https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/pink-floyd/1973/blossom-music-center-cuyahoga-falls-oh-43d72373.html I was 17. Getting near Blossom, we were stopped at a traffic light waiting to make a left turn, and a guy ran into us from behind. It was hard hit, and I remember searching for my glasses till I found them in the back seat. This was long before headrest were the norm.

The roads were a madhouse. Reminded me of the news coverage I saw of Woodstock (though obviously nowhere near that magnitude). The car was drivable, but we opted to park it and hitchhiked into the show. It took for-ev-errr to get there and involved hopping from one car to another for reasons I can't recall. As a result we were late for the show, and were just walking up to the crest of the hill to the amphitheater as the first pings of echos started. Something I will never forget. Had a seat, and were treated the entire DSOTM album. By that point I had swallowed the dark side kool aid, and it was glorious.

After the show, we hitchhiked back out. Same thing, jumping from car to car, and wandered around for about an hour before we found my parents car. It made it halfway home before it died, and I had to call my parents. They never gave me any grief about the accident. I woke up the next morning with a horrific stiff neck, went to the doctor to get checked out, and was deemed ok, but the other driver's insurance sent me a check big enough to buy my first real stereo. Marantz 1060, Epicure EPI 50's, and a Philips 212 turntable.
Great story. What a fantastic memory. Other than the car wreck, obviously, but that does add to the story!
 
Yes, but how are they important?

Their musical influence was pretty much over by the time Syd was defenestrated. And by the late 70s they were almost exclusively the main symbol of everything that was wrong with rock music as evidenced by Paul Cook's t-shirt further up the thread. I suppose that's a form of importance but I feel that's not what OP meant ...
Two words: LIVE QUAD (which inspired more than quad, live).
 
That needs some justification. In what way are PF important other than in Roger Waters' imagination?
It's always subjective and although they were not the only ones pushing the technical boundaries in recording and live performance they were certainly at the forfront. Also pushing the boundaries of integrating moving lighting fixtures, film, large PA systems and stage architecture and engineering. Read up on Mark Fisher (Stage Engineering) and Storm Thorgerson (Album Art), just to name a few. From my recollection they were one of the key drivers of the Album Oriented Rock (AOR) stations across the country. Again not the only ones, but certainly one of the major drivers. They and again along with others, also led the way in lyrics addressing topics of mental health, isolation, corporate greed, war and emotional pain, the pain and pleasure paradox, mostly to the credit of Roger Waters and written about Syd. Musically they just had a way of making space in the music that I'm not sure anyone else has ever accomplished to the same degree certainly debatable. I attribute most of this to Richard Wright and David Gilmore. Even David Gilmore's most recent recording work seems to still capture some of that kind of writing and arranging, but it's easy to hear the impact of Richard Wright's passing. The drummer Nick Mason wrote a book Inside Out that tells the story quite well and if you think about other things happen in the rock industry along the same timelines it will give you a pretty good perspective of where they fit in.
 
:rolleyes: Numbers from what?

And it's funny how those 'prog' albums are labelled....'Psychedelic/Space Rock'

Nothing funny about it whatsoever. Not all progressive rock are born equal. There are at least 20 progressive rock sub-genres. No one is forcing you (or anyone else) to agree, and like all efforts at genre classification there are bands/songs that straddle the fence and have elements of more than just one genre or sub-genre. But, it absolutely is the case that progressive rock can be and is sorted.

Dream Theater, Jethro Tull, PFM, Porcupine Tree, Camel, Grobschnitt, Magma, Gentle Giant and, yes, Pink Floyd, for example, all are progressive rock bands but each band's music is nothing like the others'. (Notable exception: PT's The Sky Moves Sideways might be the best Pink Floyd album that Pink Floyd did not produce.)

That website has a database with over 13,000 progressive bands/artists and over 85,000 progressive rock albums. There are over 2,000,000 reviews from over 70,000 progressive rock lovers. Again, the numbers speak volumes.
 
If anyone hasn't heard this and likes banjo and chainsaws - just trust me and check it out. A concept album around a concept album and with Pinks full blessing:

 
And then there's:

1781615998976.png


A tribute band that only does covers of Pink Floyd, Talking Heads, and Phish. Go figure...
 
I believe DSOTM is one of the best albums ever made. Even today, young people listen to the ENTIRE album. This in a generation that grew up with music on digital tap, who only otherwise listen to single songs.
Check this out:
Screenshot_2026-06-16_152913.jpgScreenshot_2026-06-16_152841.jpgScreenshot_2026-06-16_152853.jpg
I could have taken more screenshots. These are just a few examples.
If those in the screenshots above otherwise only listen to single songs, I have no idea. They may be album enthusiasts for other artists, musicians than Pink Floyd.
 
I believe DSOTM is one of the best albums ever made. Even today, young people listen to the ENTIRE album. This in a generation that grew up with music on digital tap, who only otherwise listen to single songs.
Check this out:
View attachment 539270View attachment 539271View attachment 539273
I could have taken more screenshots. These are just a few examples.
If those in the screenshots above otherwise only listen to single songs, I have no idea. They may be album enthusiasts for other artists, musicians than Pink Floyd.
You raise a very good point. DSOTM flows from song to song as well as any album ever made. For me it’s impossible to hear the end of one song without hearing the beginning of the next one in my head. That was not uncommon in the days of vinyl, but few albums did it better.
 
I believe DSOTM is one of the best albums ever made. Even today, young people listen to the ENTIRE album. This in a generation that grew up with music on digital tap, who only otherwise listen to single songs.
Check this out:
View attachment 539270View attachment 539271View attachment 539273
I could have taken more screenshots. These are just a few examples.
If those in the screenshots above otherwise only listen to single songs, I have no idea. They may be album enthusiasts for other artists, musicians than Pink Floyd.
Reaction videos are almost always exaggerated with positivity & surprise. This is done for "clicks". This renders them mostly insincere and fake. Even if they do like what they're reacting to.
 
Reaction videos are almost always exaggerated with positivity & surprise. This is done for "clicks". This renders them mostly insincere and fake. Even if they do like what they're reacting to.
That may be the case, but how often are reaction videos made to entire albums? From what I've seen, it seems to be mostly single songs.Top hit songs to get more clicks, of course.
 
This is an aggregate list that seems to compile favorites of a certain age demographic. Those albums are all from the 1970's. There are surely more prog albums than "Thick As a Brick" & "Animals" (which I love btw, but no way is that a top 10 prog album). The only one I'd certainly agree with on that list is "Close to the Edge". That is the #1 prog album of all time.
 
Reaction videos are almost always exaggerated with positivity & surprise. This is done for "clicks". This renders them mostly insincere and fake. Even if they do like what they're reacting to.
I didn't even look at the videos. Don't really care about them. But I stand by my impression of the album wrt flow of the music.
 
This is an aggregate list that seems to compile favorites of a certain age demographic. Those albums are all from the 1970's. There are surely more prog albums than "Thick As a Brick" & "Animals" (which I love btw, but no way is that a top 10 prog album). The only one I'd certainly agree with on that list is "Close to the Edge". That is the #1 prog album of all time.

If you would like to form an informed opinion rather than offering an immediate gut reaction, I encourage you to spend some meaningful time visiting the site. IMO it is a superb resource for those interested in progressive rock. You will find that brand new progressive rock artists and albums are discussed and reviewed there daily. You will find, e.g., rankings for the top 10 progressive rock albums from 2026, 2025, and so on.

You are, of course, free to agree or disagree with the order of the top 10 or, for that matter, the inclusion of an album in the first place. Opinions are like ..., everyone has one. But, again, the numbers do not lie. Pink Floyd, this thread's subject band, has three albums that land in the top 10 progressive rock albums of all time based upon the votes and reviews of the membership.
 
If you would like to form an informed opinion rather than offering an immediate gut reaction, I encourage you to spend some meaningful time visiting the site. IMO it is a superb resource for those interested in progressive rock. You will find that brand new progressive rock artists and albums are discussed and reviewed there daily. You will find, e.g., rankings for the top 10 progressive rock albums from 2026, 2025, and so on.

You are, of course, free to agree or disagree with the order of the top 10 or, for that matter, the inclusion of an album in the first place. Opinions are like ..., everyone has one. But, again, the numbers do not lie. Pink Floyd, this thread's subject band, has three albums that land in the top 10 progressive rock albums of all time based upon the votes and reviews of the membership.
I was just stating an observation. I'm sure the website is a good resource, but that list is just an aggregate (for example: In no objective world is "Animals" more prog than Dream Theater's "Images & Words"). I only view CTTE as the #1 prog album of all time. After that, it doesn't matter to me. My favorite PF album is "The Division Bell".
 
I was lucky enough to meet Nick Mason, a friend of my late father, a couple of times in the 1980's. The one constant member of the band, he is also a very humble, kind and down-to-earth man.
He gave me this copy of The Final Cut, signed by Roger Waters (left panel), David Gilmour (centre), and himself (right).
 

Attachments

  • 20260615_205943.jpg
    20260615_205943.jpg
    578.3 KB · Views: 31
Back
Top Bottom