• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Pink Floyd – 8-Tracks – A benchmark to follow for future Pink Floyd vinyl releases? – Review (CD vs Vinyl record vs Streaming high resolution)

Jean.Francois

Active Member
Joined
May 31, 2022
Messages
273
Likes
1,012
Hello,

8-Track is a new compilation dedicated to Pink Floyd, focusing on their most iconic era.
Curated with care by Steven Wilson, it offers a concise selection of the band s essential tracks.
The album stands out for its smooth sequencing, designed to create a coherent listening experience.
Pink Floyd - 8-Tracks - small.jpg


It notably includes the full version of Pigs on the Wing (previously available on the 1977 Animals 8-track cartridge release.), a rare and highly appreciated addition for fans.
This compilation highlights timeless classics in a refreshed and thoughtfully assembled presentation.

This album exemplifies what every release should strive for: outstanding dynamics across all tested formats, from CD and vinyl to high-resolution streaming.
Dynamic range has been fully preserved, with no signs of loudness-driven compression.
waveform_8-Tracks - Tidal MAX - 2026MVD -- small.jpg


The graph below compares the spectrum of the Blue Vinyl Record – 2026 (white curve) with the spectrum of the vinyl of Dark Side Of The Moon released in 2023 for the anniversary (blue curve). The spectrum of the 8-Tracks vinyl largely overlaps with that of the 2023 anniversary edition of Dark Side of the Moon up to approximately 10 kHz. However, in the red-highlighted region, clear spectral anomalies can be observed, with a rise of around 10 dB at 14 kHz followed by a drop of nearly 30 dB extending to 17 kHz.
These irregularities are characteristic of a cutting issue that is sometimes encountered vinyls cuts produced at Bernie Grundman. By contrast, the 8-Tracks vinyl edition exhibits the spectral behavior expected from a properly executed cut.
Pink Floyd - spectrum -  8-Tracks - Vinyl record - 2026 (white) vs  Dark Side Of The Moon - 20...jpg

When listening, these anomalies can result in less natural extreme high frequencies and a harsher, more aggressive presentation of certain instruments, such as guitars. In this respect, the 8-Tracks edition should serve as a benchmark for future Pink Floyd anniversary vinyl releases.

We hope that future anniversary editions, such as The Wall, will maintain this same level of quality.

You can also find the full analysis (all graphs and measurements) HERE (link).

Enjoy listening,
Jean-François
 
I purchased this in 24-bit/192-kHz FLAC on ProStudioMasters.com. A good way to get it.
 
How does "The Dark Side of The Moon" on this new Floyd Lp compare to the original? Which do you prefer ? I have the original Lp.
 
Back
Top Bottom