• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

PC/MAC for Dirac Processor

EQ really is too broad a term when breaking things down, just like crossovers can be analog or DSP.

EQ based on "as anechoic as possible" of each speaker could be "baked in" unchanging as the room changes.

Crossovers as well, whether passive or active. If DSP-based, may implement ToA timing phase tuning again separate from DRC.

User ad-hoc PEQ / tone controls adjusted per source content, and systemic Loudness Contouring tied to volume level adjustments, those are EQ as well.

This thread is about using Dirac's tools, specifically using the version runs on PC/Mac. It seems likely many are using the basic Dirac Live for JUST Room Correction - does that even do crossovers?

If using it in conjunction with Bass Control or also with ART, would be different right? To take full advantage, the crossovers and DRC filtering get created and applied altogether, all rolled up in the same process.

In any case, any non-DSP crossovers are upstream – in place "set in stone as given" before bringing Dirac into the picture.

I'm thinking if using MSO to manage a group of freely placed trueSubs all fed the same <80Hz mono signal, that would also be done first, "set in stone as given" before bringing Dirac into the picture, presented to Dirac's filters creation as if a single Sub.
 
The point should be pretty obvious. If you change the system after EQ'ing it, then the all bets are off. Probably won't sound as good.

I love analogies. I've heard that super intelligent people like to communicate through analogies, especially when communicating with less intelligent people. I've also heard that analogies are done by weak minds because they can't state their ideas clearly. Not sure what side I'm on, but here goes:

Ferrari has hired the best engineers in the world to design the engine in your Ferrari F40. It performs amazing. Faster than hell. But, because you like to tinker, you move the turbos from the exhaust to the intake. What do you think will happen?
 
I've heard that super intelligent people like to communicate through analogies, especially when communicating with less intelligent people.

Indeed. When I am trying to train my dog to sit, I explain sitting via an analogy. I tell him something about an F40 getting tired of standing on its wheels and it badly wants to put its backside on the floor. The dog looks back at me smiling. I think he gets it.
 
If you change the system after EQ'ing it, then the all bets are off. Probably won't sound as good.

Again, do you mean all EQ functions?

Or are you talking about DRC specifically?

The "speaker building" domain

"as anechoic as possible" of each speaker

must come before designing crossovers

gets "set in stone" before DRC if using separate tools. Timing and phase tuning are to me part of that.

Once the DRC calibration workflow is done, are you saying "no further DSP"?

Volume control and auto-variable Loudness Contouring must be analog?

User ad-hoc tone controls adjusted per source content can be done in analog, are you saying that is "better" than using PEQ when there is DRC being used upstream?

ALL of these functions are "EQ"
 
Again, do you mean all EQ functions?

Or are you talking about DRC specifically?

The "speaker building" domain

"as anechoic as possible" of each speaker

must come before designing crossovers

gets "set in stone" before DRC if using separate tools. Timing and phase tuning are to me part of that.

Once the DRC calibration workflow is done, are you saying "no further DSP"?

Volume control and auto-variable Loudness Contouring must be analog?

User ad-hoc tone controls adjusted per source content can be done in analog, are you saying that is "better" than using PEQ when there is DRC being used upstream?

ALL of these functions are "EQ"

I'm referring to Dirac ART when I say EQ.

If, after creating a Dirac ART calibration, you somehow change the response of your system within the target frequency range of Dirac ART, then the Dirac calibration is not correct anymore. The system won't sound as good.

Of course you have to change the volume after a Dirac calibration, but I don't consider volume a form of EQ. Volume control multiplies the entire audio signal by the same factor. Every frequency is scaled equally. This is a pure homogeneous operation. On the other hand, EQ deliberately changes the relative levels (among other things) of different frequencies.

I do boost the frequencies above 2,500 Hz in my system by 3dB after I perform a Dirac calibration. But I configured Dirac ART to only correct up to 125 Hz. So the changes I made in the high frequency region shouldn't impact what Dirac is doing.
 
Thanks for clarifying. My point is, precision in our posts helps us communicate

Out of the universe of "EQ" a very general term DSP for Room Compensation is a tiny part.

And even in the context of this thread, ART is just one tool of the Dirac Suite, and EQ just one part of ART's functionality.

I would hate to use a Volume Level control that did not automatically scale loudness contour up and down.

That can be Analog, but most implementations are DSP based.

Tone controls same-same.

So are you saying, if using ART, or Dirac generally for DRC, the effect of doing those two EQ functions means one must choose EITHER one OR the other?

It is a bad idea combine them?

Even if the latter two are done in analog?
 
Thanks for clarifying. My point is, precision in our posts helps us communicate

Out of the universe of "EQ" a very general term DSP for Room Compensation is a tiny part.

And even in the context of this thread, ART is just one tool of the Dirac Suite, and EQ just one part of ART's functionality.

I would hate to use a Volume Level control that did not automatically scale loudness contour up and down.

That can be Analog, but most implementations are DSP based.

Tone controls same-same.

So are you saying, if using ART, or Dirac generally for DRC, the effect of doing those two EQ functions means one must choose EITHER one OR the other?

It is a bad idea combine them?

Even if the latter two are done in analog?
Adjusting the tone should be ok for higher frequencies that you aren't EQ'ing. In my case anything over 125 Hz is fair game. For tone controls in the bass region, I'd just try it to see if it sounds ok since the tone controls are already in your signal path. But I think it would be better to create several profiles with different target curves, say 2dB, 4dB, 6dB boosts in bass, and then select them at runtime. That way you aren't interfering with Dirac in the bass region.
 
No, auto-variable LC is a given.

Using Dirac or not, or tbh any DRC is still an open question.

My system must be adaptable to use outdoors, in different venues including off-grid cabins or tents, various van/trucks, even an occasional boat.

Smaller spaces, fewer speakers...

So the ability to save different profiles is critical, want to keep the DRC tuning separate from the underlying infrastructure-level stuff that is independent of the "room".

How high in frequency I go in that aspect of DSP is something I plan to test, but ofc the LC is affecting the low end more than the high.
 
Back
Top Bottom