• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Palmer Orbit 11 Monitor Review

Rate this monitor speaker:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 8 2.8%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 50 17.6%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 150 52.8%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 76 26.8%

  • Total voters
    284
1784334870185.png
If 86 is enough - let be so.
At 96 it's not hifi)))
 
I find the price a little too high, it's possible ?!
It's certainly possible. But price "is a little too high" is not the same thing as "for the price it's not very well made."

If you have other speakers in mind that you feel are a better value, and if you can point to specific manufacturing flaws or weaknesses that you feel make it not very well made, please do.
 
The Iron Law of Josef Anton Hofmann is not broken here.

I am among those who consider that distortion below 30 Hz is not particularly significant.

Directivity issues are also not supposed to exist with studio monitors. These speakers are designed to be mounted on adjustable stands, and a 10° deviation at a distance of one meter is simply inconceivable - except in cases of disability.

While Amir's work is remarkable, I do not find it entirely appropriate to apply the same measurement procedure to studio monitors designed for listening at a distance of 1 meter and Hi-Fi speakers designed for listening at 3 to 5 meters or more. A speaker is a speaker, but they are not required to be optimized for the same type of use. That is the only minor criticism I would level at the testing procedure, which is otherwise rigorous.

The conclusion is that these speakers offer excellent value for money for achieving 75 dB at 1 meter—the standard listening level for a studio monitor.
 
Last edited:
The Iron Law of Josef Anton Hofmann is not broken here.

I am among those who consider that distortion below 30 Hz is not particularly significant.

Directivity issues are also not supposed to exist with studio monitors. These speakers are designed to be mounted on adjustable stands, and a 10° deviation at a distance of one meter is simply inconceivable - except in cases of disability.

While Amir's work is remarkable, I do not find it entirely appropriate to apply the same measurement procedure to studio monitors designed for listening at a distance of 1 meter and Hi-Fi speakers designed for listening at 3 to 5 meters or more. A speaker is a speaker, but they are not required to be optimized for the same type of use. That is the only minor criticism I would level at the testing procedure, which is otherwise rigorous.

The conclusion is that these speakers offer excellent value for money for achieving 75 dB at 1 meter—the standard listening level for a studio monitor.

That's a fair take. There are other things like that. For instance He won't use any vendor supplied DSP but will add his own.

At least he does it consistently. He killed all the small Genelec monitors for the same reason but obviously people love those
 
I do not find it entirely appropriate to apply the same measurement procedure to studio monitors designed for listening at a distance of 1 meter and Hi-Fi speakers designed for listening at 3 to 5 meters or more.
The procedure seems quite satisfactory (provided the speakers aren't too huge). How to interpret and apply the data obtained in any given case is another matter.
Let’s just listen to a cute pretty lovely track by Bob Katz. Small bass-reflex speakers with big motors drivers and powerful amplification w\o HPF are highly recommended:
 
Hi! I'm thinking about buying these monitors. I've had my JBL 305 Mk1s for about 10 years now, and I love them, but I'm looking to upgrade to something that will last me another 10 years. I don't want to buy a separate subwoofer, maybe because I'm just used to listening to music, producing and mixing without one. That's why this all-in-one solution caught my attention.

My question is whether these monitors would be overkill for an apartment and a small room. My current bedroom is fairly big and has acoustic treatment, but I'm going to move at some point, and I'm wondering whether they'd work well in a 10 m² room without making my neighbours want to kill me. My listening distance is about 80 cm, and I don't listen to music very loud, so the volume concerns discussed in this thread aren't really an issue for me. Maybe a pair of monitors that performs well at low volumes is exactly what I need...

thanks
 
Hi! I'm thinking about buying these monitors. I've had my JBL 305 Mk1s for about 10 years now, and I love them, but I'm looking to upgrade to something that will last me another 10 years. I don't want to buy a separate subwoofer, maybe because I'm just used to listening to music, producing and mixing without one. That's why this all-in-one solution caught my attention.

My question is whether these monitors would be overkill for an apartment and a small room. My current bedroom is fairly big and has acoustic treatment, but I'm going to move at some point, and I'm wondering whether they'd work well in a 10 m² room without making my neighbours want to kill me. My listening distance is about 80 cm, and I don't listen to music very loud, so the volume concerns discussed in this thread aren't really an issue for me. Maybe a pair of monitors that performs well at low volumes is exactly what I need...

thanks

In my experience a subwoofer plus small monitors gives the best result for the least amount of money. ( I haven't heard a set of speakers under 8000 euros that could do without it. )

I can recommend Genelec G three or 8030C plus subwoofer of your choice. Or Neumann kh750 sub plus Neumann kh80 or kh120 monitors. Then for 1500- 2000 euros you're done and improvements upon that setup are small. I have the Genelec 8030C + F two sub myself. An 8.5 inch sub, very small, but perfect for a small room.

For your setup I would keep the Jbl 305's and add a subwoofer. Make sure you have a proper crossover and a way to add equalisation. (Wiim ultra can do that for consumer use. Maybe others can recommend a producing/mixing setup).
 
Last edited:

destroyers​

I think it would work well (in terms of distance and volume). However, it might be difficult without room correction—much like how it would also be necessary if you were using a subwoofer.
To be considerate of your neighbors, you can simply apply a high-pass filter—which is also a good option if you don’t (yet) have a DSP (with PEQ).
 
To be considerate of your neighbors, you can simply apply a high-pass filter—which is also a good option if you don’t (yet) have a DSP (with PEQ).

This is a very good idea.

Iirc you can set different smart profiles for eq in a Wiim. What that means for the OP is that you could set for example profile 1 with a high pass filter, ie without or with much reduced sub sounds. And for example profile 2 with sub.
 
Hi! I'm thinking about buying these monitors. I've had my JBL 305 Mk1s for about 10 years now, and I love them, but I'm looking to upgrade to something that will last me another 10 years. I don't want to buy a separate subwoofer, maybe because I'm just used to listening to music, producing and mixing without one. That's why this all-in-one solution caught my attention.

My question is whether these monitors would be overkill for an apartment and a small room. My current bedroom is fairly big and has acoustic treatment, but I'm going to move at some point, and I'm wondering whether they'd work well in a 10 m² room without making my neighbours want to kill me. My listening distance is about 80 cm, and I don't listen to music very loud, so the volume concerns discussed in this thread aren't really an issue for me. Maybe a pair of monitors that performs well at low volumes is exactly what I need...

thanks
You can lower bass, tune in highpass at 80 Hz, eq mids and highs on the menue on top of the speaker. Feel free to explore (my room has 13 m^2 and I don't attenuate or elevate anything).
 
Thanks for the comments! To be honest, I’ve been producing music more profesionnaly lately, and I feel a bit limited by my monitors. Not just in terms of sub-bass response (I have a good open headphone), but also transients, clarity, etc. These JBLs are extremely good for the price, but at the end of the day, they’re entry-level monitors from 10 years ago.

My initial idea was to get something a bit bigger (6"), but still compact enough for small spaces, suitable for placement close to a wall, and with a listening distance of around 1m. I don’t need much volume. So my first choice is the Adam A7V, which are cheaper than the other options I’m considering. I really like being able to tweak their response using the built-in DSP to suit my ears, and I can add room correction in the future. But I’ve read that they’re too bright, and I’m very sensitive to treble... They’re not highly recommended on this forum.

As for the Palmers, I like their compact size, which would be perfect for my current room and smaller rooms in the future. They’re a bit over my budget, but I don’t mind spending a bit more on something I’ll use every day for the next 10 years.
 
Thanks for the comments! To be honest, I’ve been producing music more profesionnaly lately, and I feel a bit limited by my monitors. Not just in terms of sub-bass response (I have a good open headphone), but also transients, clarity, etc. These JBLs are extremely good for the price, but at the end of the day, they’re entry-level monitors from 10 years ago.

My initial idea was to get something a bit bigger (6"), but still compact enough for small spaces, suitable for placement close to a wall, and with a listening distance of around 1m. I don’t need much volume. So my first choice is the Adam A7V, which are cheaper than the other options I’m considering. I really like being able to tweak their response using the built-in DSP to suit my ears, and I can add room correction in the future. But I’ve read that they’re too bright, and I’m very sensitive to treble... They’re not highly recommended on this forum.

As for the Palmers, I like their compact size, which would be perfect for my current room and smaller rooms in the future. They’re a bit over my budget, but I don’t mind spending a bit more on something I’ll use every day for the next 10 years.

Then ime Genelec 8030C plus sub or Neumann kh120 or kh80 plus kh750 sub, would be as close to perfect as possible. They have a small footprint too and are meant for listening at short distance.

If I were in your situation I would demo a genelec, neumann and/or Palmer. My take is you will instantly know which sounds right to you.
 
Then ime Genelec 8030C plus sub or Neumann kh120 or kh80 plus kh750 sub, would be as close to perfect as possible. They have a small footprint too and are meant for listening at short distance.

If I were in your situation I would demo a genelec, neumann and/or Palmer. My take is you will instantly know which sounds right to you.
Yeah, definitely! They’re on my list, and now they’re top priority thanks to your recommendation. I’m going to try to listen to them in a music store or somewhere to get an idea. I’ll post my impressions in case someone comes across this forum and finds them helpful. Thanks!
 
Then ime Genelec 8030C plus sub or Neumann kh120 or kh80 plus kh750 sub, would be as close to perfect as possible. They have a small footprint too and are meant for listening at short distance.

If I were in your situation I would demo a genelec, neumann and/or Palmer. My take is you will instantly know which sounds right to you.
Seconded. After a year of on-off searching I still haven’t found an upgrade from the 8030C’s with subs that’s not stupid money.
 
Hi, I went to a music store today. Although they didn't have the Palmers on the exposition, I realized that they would be overkill for my use and room.

I've listened to the Focal Shape 65, Neumann KH120 II, the new JBL mk3 and Kali IN-5. Just some minutes, there was noise, the acoustics, configuration... so my first impressions could be wrong.

I like the bass in the Focals, not about quantity but quality, I heard precision and good extension. But they sound so warm, and I missed better clarity in mids and treble. Maybe they are good for listening and producing but not for mixing...

The Kali IN-5s sound good, they have the body/bass that I missed in my JBLs but apart from that I'm not impressed. The new JBL version could be the best option in the market for its price.

And finally the KH120 II. I'm really impressed. I fell in love instantly. The clarity, precision and separation are above anything I've listened to. I mean, the feeling that the instruments are in front of you, not that the sound is coming from speakers. That was the moment when I realised that I'm looking for an upgrade in quality, not just more bass or volume.

I still need to listen to the Adam A7V before making the choice.
 
Hi, I went to a music store today. Although they didn't have the Palmers on the exposition, I realized that they would be overkill for my use and room.

I've listened to the Focal Shape 65, Neumann KH120 II, the new JBL mk3 and Kali IN-5. Just some minutes, there was noise, the acoustics, configuration... so my first impressions could be wrong.

I like the bass in the Focals, not about quantity but quality, I heard precision and good extension. But they sound so warm, and I missed better clarity in mids and treble. Maybe they are good for listening and producing but not for mixing...

The Kali IN-5s sound good, they have the body/bass that I missed in my JBLs but apart from that I'm not impressed. The new JBL version could be the best option in the market for its price.

And finally the KH120 II. I'm really impressed. I fell in love instantly. The clarity, precision and separation are above anything I've listened to. I mean, the feeling that the instruments are in front of you, not that the sound is coming from speakers. That was the moment when I realised that I'm looking for an upgrade in quality, not just more bass or volume.

I still need to listen to the Adam A7V before making the choice.
Exactly my impression when I first listened to the KH 150's that I now own. And I still get that impression every time I listen to them.
 
I like the bass in the Focals, not about quantity but quality, I heard precision and good extension. But they sound so warm, and I missed better clarity in mids and treble. Maybe they are good for listening and producing but not for mixing...

That's an interesting opinion. I've been using the Focals for 8 years, mainly for the final touch on mixes and for demo mastering, because I find them too unforgiving for production. I can pick up even the tiniest clicks and forgotten fades, something I've never been able to do on the Genelecs, Amphions or Auratones.

The point is, these kinds of generalizations based on a "quick listen" in a demo room (mostly workst case scenario acousticly..) don't help anyone and are often just unnecessary noise.
 
That's an interesting opinion. I've been using the Focals for 8 years, mainly for the final touch on mixes and for demo mastering, because I find them too unforgiving for production. I can pick up even the tiniest clicks and forgotten fades, something I've never been able to do on the Genelecs, Amphions or Auratones.

The point is, these kinds of generalizations based on a "quick listen" in a demo room (mostly workst case scenario acousticly..) don't help anyone and are often just unnecessary noise.
Same case with the krk e8b expose with beryllium tweeters I still have :)
 
Back
Top Bottom