• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Output stage : Wiim Amp vs (disappointing) Wiim Amp Ultra

I guess you don’t understand. The point is: it’s not just yours ears. They are just a conduit for sound to the brain. Your brain interprets this data, but also adds in a myriad of other sources you can neither control nor switch off at will. So you’re never just evaluating what you hear, but also what you see, what you read somewhere, how you feel at that point in time, and many, more things.

The fact of the matter is, you cannot trust your judgement without applying some basic controls. We’ve all been there, nobody is immune to is.
Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.
 
Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.
I think the context is that in a vacuum - without direct controlled testing - it is hard to tell what an amp sounds like since they are typically very neutral. The point many tried to make is that his casting of the WiiM amp as the cause of his dislike was out of alignment with what most experienced with that amp and his conclusions seemed illogical at times. It isn’t for me to say if you should love or hate a piece of gear - but making claims about what it is or isn’t capable of and how it behaves without objective measurement and subjective controlled testing is hard to sell to this crowd.

Saying I love the way x sounds in my system is sometimes just a simple opinion without much to comment on.
 
Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.

No, it is being used to inform him that he cannot tell if the amp is good or not, from uncontrolled subjective listening. It might be fine - or it might be appalling. Subjective listening doesn't give you real information one way or the other.

But the measurements tell us there is no significant difference between the Wiim amp, and the amp ultra. In fact if anything the Ultra has better measured performance, so switching from that to the former would be illogical.
 
The WAU puts out a higher clean power level.

If matching that aspect and ABX testing blindly

are the performance differences audible?
 
Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.
It isn't an argument designed for any goal of persuasion.

It is a fact, like gravity, the Earth is round, we landed on the moon.

It's fine for people to claim they can hear differences between quality electronics, but around here they need to include an acknowledgement that these are likely subjective perceptions, not due to anything real that should influence others.

Or of course presenting measurements and test conditions, IOW objective evidence even better! but that is difficult, requires skillz and expensive gear...
 
Hmmm. The OP said he used a new amp (Tangent Ampster) using Apple AAC via BT as the source. He never said what he was using as a source when he decided he didn't like the WAU. BT is a piss-poor way to provide a signal to compare an amp to a memory of a different amp. Comparing an amp to what you think you remember another amp sounded like is equally pissy.
 
BT is a piss-poor way to provide a signal
Not at the higher bit rates it isn't. You'll not be able to tell the difference between LDAC, and any lossless codec. Probably not even Apt X.


Comparing an amp to what you think you remember another amp sounded like is equally pissy.
This however, is true.
 
Were I a betting man, I'm not, I would put money on your settings being wonky or the source having issues. The Marantz CR610 on paper looks like a dogs breakfast. The amp ratings are pitiful and called out at 50Watts @ 6 Ohms and a THD of .7%. The Wiim Amp Ultra on the other hand is rated at 100Watts @ 8Ohms and a THD of .08%. At normal listening levels that THD drops to .005% It implements the power amp section using a pair of the TPA3255 Chips for stunning power delivery. The Wiim is superior in every way.
 
Were I a betting man, I'm not, I would put money on your settings being wonky or the source having issues.
That was my original thought too. I see the Marantz M-CR610 has a "Dynamic Bass Boost" button on the remote that could certainly cause speakers to sound less "depressed" at low volumes. But it just provides a 10-dB boost to certain lower frequencies so is not a sophisticated dynamic range expander.

Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.
I think you are correct. OP's 1st post suggested his Tannoy's "depression" was perhaps caused by PFFB anomalies. Later, he comments both on his own engineering background and that TI "killed" the amp market with a $5 chip. So, like virtually everyone who signs up to ASR, he is not a blank slate, and has biases that will impact his experience.

PFFB is interesting in that many here seem convinced that when correctly implemented it impacts their own listening experiences in a noticeably positive way. My own experience going from a non-PFFB TPA3255 amp to a 3e Audio A5, I heard it. Yet, objectively, nothing that PFFB was doing was likely in the audible range of my 72 y/o ears.

We like what we like. For engineering types with a love of gear and some knowledge of how it works, its much simpler to just select products that make you feel good (and you can afford). That's fine, though you should then not be disappointed if you visit ASR looking for confirmation of your biases and do not find it.

"What-Hi-Fi" is much better at that sort of thing.
 
That was my original thought too. I see the Marantz M-CR610 has a "Dynamic Bass Boost" button on the remote that could certainly cause speakers to sound less "depressed" at low volumes. But it just provides a 10-dB boost to certain lower frequencies so is not a sophisticated dynamic range expander.


I think you are correct. OP's 1st post suggested his Tannoy's "depression" was perhaps caused by PFFB anomalies. Later, he comments both on his own engineering background and that TI "killed" the amp market with a $5 chip. So, like virtually everyone who signs up to ASR, he is not a blank slate, and has biases that will impact his experience.

PFFB is interesting in that many here seem convinced that when correctly implemented it impacts their own listening experiences in a noticeably positive way. My own experience going from a non-PFFB TPA3255 amp to a 3e Audio A5, I heard it. Yet, objectively, nothing that PFFB was doing was likely in the audible range of my 72 y/o ears.

We like what we like. For engineering types with a love of gear and some knowledge of how it works, its much simpler to just select products that make you feel good (and you can afford). That's fine, though you should then not be disappointed if you visit ASR looking for confirmation of your biases and do not find it.

"What-Hi-Fi" is much better at that sort of thing.
I looked up the speaker and it was a fairly complex load. The lack of pffb in the original source of comparison could make that amp have elevated highs which might increase perceived transient attack and the weaker grip could make the the mid-bass registers more wooly which might seem like paradoxically more bass even if it wasn’t. It’s really hard to know without direct comparison. It is suggestive that the replacement that the op liked lacked pffb.
 
Pretty much just about any AB amp has feedback. Feedback on Class D amps ia a newish thing but been around for a good time. I have a number of AB amps and Class D amps, some with and some without feedback. I have to say that to my ears they all are generally well behaved and sound pretty good. The TPA3255 with PFFB, to my ear, is a pretty hard package to beat. Especially at the price of entry for the performance. Between speakers limitations and the room they are in, any subtle differences in the resultant sound introduced by various amps is hardly noticeable to my ears. Either bad gear or incorrect setup is my bet.
 
Interesting. This argument is being used, I believe, to convince the now departed OP that his amp is fine and he should keep it. This same argument is used when someone buys an amp and they just like the way it sounds.
At the end of the day I'm not going to let random people tell me to keep an item that I believe sucks from my own experience. Just not going to happen. You'd have to be quite controlled by others to do such a weird thing.
 
Of course, giving up based on your belief is your prerogative.

But those who know it's a great product objectively are more inclined to increase their knowledge and skillz to fix whatever is actually causing the problem.

If it even is a real problem objectively as opposed to biased perception of some sort.

Or not just a faulty unit.

That's the zeitgeist of this community.
 
It is suggestive that the replacement that the op liked lacked pffb.
It is suggestive of nothing. The OP was based on sighted listening comparisons. Any perceptions he had are utterly meaningless as regards the actual performance of the device, or any technical design feature.
 
At the end of the day I'm not going to let random people tell me to keep an item that I believe sucks from my own experience. Just not going to happen. You'd have to be quite controlled by others to do such a weird thing.
Nobody is telling you what to keep or what to like. Giving someone advice isn’t the same as controlling their decisions.

By that logic, anyone who takes advice into consideration is being controlled by others. That’s a rather interesting definition of “independent thinking”.
 
Your ears will adjust over time to the cleaner amplification, meantime tweak with EQ.

Replacing the amp will do nothing real.

I would suggest adding a good variable Loudness Control that works automatically, linked to volume level.

You could attempt to create a static version in PEQ but only if you listen at a consistent level.
This maybe! Is the op @Emilio75 using the dynamic bass boost on the old Marantz?
 
Even if they were, they are happy with another different amp also class d also without pffb. They also suggest that they were happy with another different amp ab amp NAD 312.
Missed that before replying :eek: . I've certainly run into this where people forget that Loudness or some kind of dynamic bass boost was engaged on their familiar old unit, and the new unit doesn't have an equivalent. Then you get the "it sounds like crap" complaints after 'upgrading' or replacing a failed unit.

Anywhoo - glad careful amp selection was able to curb the OP's complaints. Not a usual solution for sure...
 
Back
Top Bottom