• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Normalize or Replay-Gain ?

In the case of albums spanning multiple CDs, all in my collection seen to have been originally recorded to the same "loudness", so when I have processed them with RG, they maintain their relative loudness differences. Every once in a while I have come across an album with a 'bonus' CD, often a live album that does have a different loudness from the main CD, and for me, when FB2K applies slightly different gain, that's exactly what I would want. For me, It's really about not having to touch the volume control too often.

Also, yes I saw that the Android version does give an option to add tags to the files, but not by default. Doesn't bother me as I prefer to add tags using a PC as it's 10x faster or more (I have a reasonably fast PC but only a cheap phone!).

Everyone has different needs and 'workflows' (hate the word BTW). In my case I buy and rip CDs (usually used) or buy FLACs. In both cases as soon as I have the fikes, I standardise file and folder naming conventions (using my preset in AdvancedRenamer), then standardise tags and cover art and cleanup (MP3tag), then test the files in FB2K, where I do the the RG. It sounds a lot but is the work of seconds (a bit more of a faff if you have to start from scratch with thousands of albums, but do-able). I then drop the finished album into the right folder place on my NAS, and in seconds it's automatically scanned by the DLNA media server and ready to play on any device. Oh yeah, I also generate MP3 copies for my cheap car which can't handle FLACs in its SD card, which get MP3gain added too (even more important in a car!)

My main thing is only to say it works well, and easy to do or undo.....

And I would avoid "normalisation" like the plague, except for films, where ffmpeg is a cracking tool and easy to use if you set up a few simple scripts (you only need a couple of lines in a batch file)
 
All disk can be in the same folder and cd, tracks can bee encoded in the tag metadata. I have checked in my collection, similar situation have given a single "replay gain album" for all albums in the folder (coded in tags and filename cd-track-name.ext )
Yes of course. Needs file renaming and proper disc tagging, then it's no issue anymore.
 
Re. normalization. I do that when recording and have a hi-res workfile in front of me. I would not do that to any "finished product", incl. flac of various qualities. Containers shall get tags, not content-reprocessing.

Just my opinion about where to do what.

RG is pretty perfect in my opinion. I do not have to use the remote at all once set up to listen to a selection.
 
Back
Top Bottom