• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

New - miniDSP AMP8, 8 channel Class D Audio Amplifier

Also, Trinnov uses the same modules (or is it 400a2, I don't remember the thread, maybe the later) with lower gain though (17dB, normally is 29dB gain for 400a2):

trin.PNG
 
I'm considering buying one of these.
I also been considering the Marantz AMP 30. But this one seems better pricewise. Will use it to drive my surround channels.

Anything important missing on the cheaper Mindsp amp 8 compared to the more expensive Marantz?
 
Also, Trinnov uses the same modules (or is it 400a2, I don't remember the thread, maybe the later) with lower gain though (17dB, normally is 29dB gain for 400a2):

The Trinnov Amplitude 16 and the Marantz AMP10 & AMP20 use the 400A2.

The Storm Fusion 20 uses the 300A2.

Audioholics did an interesting test of the Amplitude. The measurements were a bit better than the AMP10 ( >100dB SINAD), and it's ridiculously load tolerant. I believe the Amplitude has a much bigger power supply(s).
 
I am considering this amp, to complement my NAD C298 which is currently a backup amp sitting in a box.
In total I will then have 10ch with a SINAD of around 100dB.

Not sure how loud the fan noise will be of the Amp-8, but I do have an acoustically treated home cinema and I don't need to play at volume.

Another reason is that I am considering to replace my Anthem AVM60 some day, which has the 1 kHz distraction when the main fader is set very loud (loud like the max what is legally allowed in Belgium, in actual real cinema's). The amp will then visually match with the Tide16,
 
AMP-8 arrives Today.

Will test with our second pair of Amphion Krypton3, since that exposes a 4 Ohm load, to see when the fan noise starts to become problematic.
Curious how the sound compares to the C298, since SINAD and power wise, these are similar amps.

In the home cinema, this will not generate that load for all effects channels combined, since they don't have to reproduce bass.
 
I really like the sound of the AMP-8, and I did compare the amp directly to the NAD C298. But there are some issues with the fan noise, even in idle, when the chassis reaches a certain temperature. I do hope that miniDSP can fix it.

This is my feedback:

The sound quality is on par with the NAD C298—if not slightly better or more refined. Getting 8 channels for 2,900 EUROS instead of 2 channels for 2,500 EUROS is a great deal. Its strengths include excellent control over the low frequencies and the ability to drive flagship 4-ohm speakers—such as the Amphion Krypton3X—at any volume level.

However, this setup was used solely to evaluate the amplifier's performance; it is not the final configuration, which is intended to become our home cinema system.

However, we have encountered a design issue where the amplifier's fan does nothing at all upon startup, leaving the amp completely silent. Yet, as soon as the top panel reaches a temperature of around 33–34°C, the fan starts blowing intermittently for a few seconds—a behavior that persists even when no music is playing. This does not happen immediately; it occurs after about an hour during the day, or after roughly two hours in the evening when the living room has cooled down slightly.

This occurs in a setup where the amplifier is completely unobstructed, with no nearby heat sources.

In a quiet home cinema environment, this quickly becomes annoying.

So these are the specific questions for miniDSP:

Are there ways to make the fan run more slowly? Whether the fan cools a second faster or a few seconds slower shouldn't significantly impact its lifespan; we have much more expensive Class A amplifiers here—with chassis that run much hotter than this one—that have been in use for a decade.
 
I did use the amp-8 to test some field recordings made Yesterday in a local church, of an organ played by upcoming local talent + Gregorian choir :


So yes the amp-8 is very good and resolving.

My only issue with the amp-8 until Today was the fan noise. Received firmware from miniDSP:

"Based from the way the unit operates, the fan will indeed switch on when temperature is 60deg. It's doing a big push to clear the air inside and that's most likely what's
going on here. i.e. the AMP turning on to clear the air inside the unit. You could try the attached firmware instead to see if that solves the issue as we're basically increasing the starting temp (70deg) and also change the fan speed."

Flashed a new firmware via the USB-C port, and now the top panel is somewhere around 35 degrees after half a day with one channel playing in the home cinema, and loud enough so I can hear it in another room. The fans no longer turn on until the internal temperature is at 70 degrees, but it never reaches that.

The funny thing is that the power button now turns pink when the amp is on, as if this is a pig being slowly cooked. I pinged Hifi Pig about it ;)
 
In the past i used an NAD M25 (former NAD Master dealer) until it was destroyed beyond cost-effective repair, since I bought the wrong standby board from an ebay seller, which was intended for USA / Canada. I donated the NAD to a local audio club. As a temp solution, I hooked up a bunch of 15 Watt Tripath amps to a linear PSU (and later several TPA3116 based amps), and that already sounded much better than the NAD. I compared our Atmos setup with these "improvised" amps, to the IPEM 64ch array In Ghent, so I know where I stand, with regards to Atmos panning and clarity, compared to extreme research projects, with much more speakers.

I also listened to my own 24/96 field recording of a local church concent, upmixed with DTS Neural:X and this recreates my experience - and that was already with the cheap improvised amps.

The amp-8 cleans up this improvised setup, by having all effect channels in one nice chassis. I also rearranged the equipment now on solidsteel racks, on wheels with locking mechanism, so I can easily access the 8x XLR and speaker cables. In the new home the good old solid steel racks do not visually fit with the living room, but perfect for the home cinema.

The amp-8 is here to stay. When applying the fan mod firmware, we never could spot the fan so that means the internal temp is in between 60 and 70 degrees all the time.

The next challenge is to buy identical XLR runs, since I used a mix of whatever spare XLR I had, a mix of mogami's, DIY and some cheap entry level for the height channels, just to confirm the cable routing and channel mapping works.

So next challenge is to find 8x short XLR. The Anthem AVM60 is directly on top of the amp-8. Yup that Anthem with the 1 kHz issue, which only distracts when played very loud, and the content is so silent that it competes with that 1 kHz issue. But it's rare enough I am postponing the search for a new surround processor.
 
The firmware which allows the internal temperature to reach 70 degrees before the fan starts, still makes the fan spin when there's a device on top of the amp8, even with several cm's of additional spacing. I put additional ice hockey pucks in between the amp8 and anthem. But that triggers after longer home cinema use.

A workaround:

I am currently running 2 small 12V server chassis fans which are rated 0.15 Amps to get rid of the hot air.

This array is external to the right side of the amp8, and when supplying 5V from a USB power bank as a test, there's subtle air movement but it is completely inaudible, which was not the case with the internal fan.

It is keeping the top panel of the amp around 31 ~ 32 degrees Celcius, just below the point where the stock firmware would try to get rid of the hot air, so it's never triggering.

It would have been better if the internal chassis fan could be operated at a very low RPM so that it does not distract, instead of heating/cooling waves as with the stock firmware.
 
Back
Top Bottom