• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

New Gustard R30 Flagship DAC/Streamer

Observation IS empirical evidence, it just requires leaning into the field of statistics.

For example, if you're investigating "too hot" in the context of McDonald's coffee:
  • If 1 person says its "too hot," a single sample size is too small to make a conclusion.
  • If 8 of the first 10 people surveyed say it "too hot," you can only conclude "possibly too hot, with low certainty."
  • If 980 people out of the 1000 people surveyed say the coffee is too hot, then you can objectively say "the coffee is too hot, with a statistical correlation close to +1."
This means very little, some people like cold coffee just like some people like distortion. Make one measurement with a thermometer.
 
Sokel, with respect, a good portion of the thread are comments from non-owners who believe they know more about the R30 than actual owners. There are assertions about "all DACs sound the same," which itself is objectively not true, otherwise Amir wouldn't be spending so much time measuring SNR and distortion, and posting comparison results.

Even as someone with an engineering background, the entire conversation is fatiguing and probably a waste of my time, it make me question if if its worth contributing here. There are those here who believe they're the arbiters of what constitutes science, and then press others with their self anointed purity tests. The snake-oil flung around at head-fi is a lot less fatiguing, if I'm going to be honest.

I've had a lot of enjoyment discussing various topics with others in the hobby throughout the years, and this is a low point.
It seems like a low point to me.
 
Some light moderation has been applied and see indication in the other thread of mediation so am reopening.
 
Last edited:
I need to apologize for posting in a manner that is counter to the ASR culture, which is: objective analysis based on data and measurements only, and subjective discussion (which does not apply to DACs at ASR) does not belong here, and is better suited for other forums.

I would not be opposed to more heavier moderation for some of the more "bickering" posts between myself, @voodooless and @Svend P over the past 2 days, both here and in the other R30 thread. I'll start a thread with the 3 of us and @RickS .

There is opportunity for contributors to educate new contributors in the science-focused purpose of this forum, and there is opportunity for people like myself to disengage sooner, and be more mature and respectful towards others as they curate the conversation towards a more science-based focus. I will treat this as a learning opportunity, albeit in part at the expense of others, to which I again apologize.
 
I'm sure you compared level matched, controlled and blind.

No?

then your observations are meaningless - as you probably already know.
Well I did level match everything and compared them blindly. The differences are obvious. 2 dacs connected to the same pre-amp playing the same track at the same time with the same hdmi cable (i2s) both connected via a su-6 ddc so switching is made on the fly
 
If your ears can't tell the difference between an MP3 listened to while jogging with your smartphone and headphones and a FLAC listened to in an auditorium with a coherent system, you're right, all DACs sound the same.

Mmmmmmm no, this is not the point. And of course anybody that says "all DACs sound the same" — On the contrary, I could swear that I heard an AudioGD DAC with a very different sound from my Topping D90, but the first one was a model with a (very well known) very high distortion, but that was a sighted test.

But if you're able to put yourself in favorable listening conditions and hear nuances, then you'll discover music in all its nuances and you'll hear differences between different systems. Some you'll like, others less, but that's a matter of taste, not nuance.

You shouldn't say:
"All DACs sound the same."
You should say:
"I've never heard any difference between a €200 DAC and a €3,000 DAC."
It would be more honest for the readers.

Wrong. One should not say "All DACs sound the same," but rather "all competently designed DACs sound the same when used in the same conditions." The latter is the actual message one gets from ASR — "All DACs sound the same" is an oversimplification. Also, "competently designed" does not mean that they have one good measurement, nor that they have to cost 50.000 EUR because of "carefully selected" audiophile components — it means that the sound quality can be proven by scores of measured parameters (Amir's tests offer, the very least, a quite close to complete series of tests). Controlled listening tests are less reliable. I do not even consider sighted ones.
 
Last edited:
Well I did level match everything and compared them blindly. The differences are obvious. 2 dacs connected to the same pre-amp playing the same track at the same time with the same hdmi cable (i2s) both connected via a su-6 ddc so switching is made on the fly
Well, you should publish. No DAC manufacturers ever publicize a test like that. Ever wonder why?

Btw, level-matching has to be done with a voltmeter and be very precise to avoid 1db+ audible differences.

I’d bet on a flaw in your test. Just on Bayesian grounds.
 
Well, you should publish. No DAC manufacturers ever publicize a test like that. Ever wonder why?

Btw, level-matching has to be done with a voltmeter and be very precise to avoid 1db+ audible differences.

I’d bet on a flaw in your test. Just on Bayesian grounds.
Even on these web pages, one can detect the strong urge to deny the fact that just like there are differences between amplifiers, same goes for DACS (as they all have an amplifying stage which contributes to their sound)
Continue living in denial and believe that you listen to music at its best and let others who have experienced the clear differences, enjoy their music a bit more
 
Even on these web pages, one can detect the strong urge to deny the fact that just like there are differences between amplifiers, same goes for DACS (as they all have an amplifying stage which contributes to their sound)
Continue living in denial and believe that you listen to music at its best and let others who have experienced the clear differences, enjoy their music a bit more

Amplifiers can sound different, but usually only when they’re pushed outside their linear range (high distortion, low power, bad load matching, etc.). Well-designed solid-state amps, running within their limits, sound identical in blind tests. So the idea that “amps can sound different, therefore DACs must too” just doesn’t hold up.

Yes, DACs do have an “amplifying” or buffering stage, but in a properly designed unit that stage is meant to be linear and transparent. It’s not supposed to change the sound - that’s literally the whole point of a DAC: to convert digital to analog as accurately as possible, not to add its own flavor.

Modern DACs have distortion and noise way below what humans can hear. In properly controlled listening tests, transparent DACs are simply indistinguishable from one another under normal listening conditions.

There’s no need to get emotional about the facts or seek valiadation. Be happy with your DAC, enjoy music.
 
Even on these web pages, one can detect the strong urge to deny the fact that just like there are differences between amplifiers, same goes for DACS (as they all have an amplifying stage which contributes to their sound)
Continue living in denial and believe that you listen to music at its best and let others who have experienced the clear differences, enjoy their music a bit more

A DAC has one, and only one job, and that is to accurately convert the digital representation of music from the source into an analog representation of that music. Well measuring DACS do that with inaudible levels of noise and distortion, and with flat frequency response in the audible band. In other words the analogue output is (audibly) a perfect representation of the digitally encoded music. Any defects are below the level any human ear can detect.

If two DACS both achieve this (and well measuring DACS do - including from the analogue part) then the analog signal from both must be identical within audible limits. By definition, they must sound the same.

Yet on the other hand we know that our hearing is subject to perceptive bias (call it cognitive bias, or expectation bias if you like). What we hear is impacted by what we know, what we believe, how we feel, our life experiences, what we see etc etc. No-one is immune to this if they are human - it is how we are built. In fact we would be unable to function if our senses were not filtered by our subconscious brain. Everyone is subject to this, it happens at the subconscious level, and it is not possible to avoid it - even when we are aware it is happening.

So when we see someone state that they hear differences between DACs where the engineering, science and measurements all tell us that is impossible or vanishingly unlikely - do we just take the statement at face value - or do we attribute it to the fact that the listener is being fooled by his (humanities) very fallible auditory system?
 
Even on these web pages, one can detect the strong urge to deny the fact that just like there are differences between amplifiers, same goes for DACS (as they all have an amplifying stage which contributes to their sound)
Continue living in denial and believe that you listen to music at its best and let others who have experienced the clear differences, enjoy their music a bit more
Taking into account masses of evidence to the contrary of your assertion is not “an urge to deny” but a solid probabilistic inference. Perhaps you didn’t understand my Bayesian reference.

Neither you nor anyone else has yet to offer solid evidence of these claims. It appears to be you that is living in a fact-free state of delusion, my friend (or you are just trolling here for your own recreation). But remember, I don’t know you, you shouldn’t take it personally. You’re just someone with an anonymous handle making an extremely unlikely claim. It only makes sense to be skeptical.
 
Last edited:
Amplifiers can sound different, but usually only when they’re pushed outside their linear range (high distortion, low power, bad load matching, etc.). Well-designed solid-state amps, running within their limits, sound identical in blind tests. So the idea that “amps can sound different, therefore DACs must too” just doesn’t hold up.

Yes, DACs do have an “amplifying” or buffering stage, but in a properly designed unit that stage is meant to be linear and transparent. It’s not supposed to change the sound - that’s literally the whole point of a DAC: to convert digital to analog as accurately as possible, not to add its own flavor.

Modern DACs have distortion and noise way below what humans can hear. In properly controlled listening tests, transparent DACs are simply indistinguishable from one another under normal listening conditions.

There’s no need to get emotional about the facts or seek valiadation. Be happy with your DAC, enjoy music.
Sounds like McNamara fallacy thus making a decision based solely on quantitative observations (or metrics) and ignoring all others.
 
Sounds like McNamara fallacy thus making a decision based solely on quantitative observations (or metrics) and ignoring all others.
It worked when he was at Ford though. Wars tend to be a lot more complex than selling cars, that's where it falls over. Audio amplifiers are pretty simple by comparison to either.
 
Observation IS empirical evidence, it just requires leaning into the field of statistics.

For example, if you're investigating "too hot" in the context of McDonald's coffee:
  • If 1 person says its "too hot," a single sample size is too small to make a conclusion.
  • If 8 of the first 10 people surveyed say it "too hot," you can only conclude "possibly too hot, with low certainty."
  • If 980 people out of the 1000 people surveyed say the coffee is too hot, then you can objectively say "the coffee is too hot, with a statistical correlation close to +1."
A DAC is a man-made object. If engineers didn't understand how they work or how they would sound, they wouldn't be able to design them in the first place. Fortunately, engineers know exactly what they are doing, and they know exactly how to measure them to verify their 'intent'—measurements that are no different from what we do here at ASR.

Whether it's a Topping D50s or a Gustard R30, they are ultimately both DACs. If they sound different, that difference is a 'deliberate choice' by design. The fundamental role of a DAC is to reconstruct 10 out of 10, not to turn 10 into 20 or 30. That is the inherent limit of the device. Furthermore, R2R NOS designs often deliver an '8' instead of a '10' in terms of fidelity.

As consumers, we must remember these principles to avoid being swayed by external 'packaging'—price, size, or marketing fluff—that tries to make degraded sound seem premium. We shouldn't be spending $3,000 for something that a $200 device can do better. Those who think twice to avoid such foolish losses shouldn't be dismissed as 'poor people judging without experience.' Just as we don't need to jump off a cliff to know it will break our bones, we can use logic to deduce performance. The only reason this remains a debate in the audio world is a fundamental ignorance of these facts.

So what I am trying to say is that comparing auditory perception to a tactile sensation—like the temperature of coffee—is entirely unconvincing and lacks any logical merit. Furthermore, anyone old enough to read and write should at least have a basic grasp of the fundamental principles behind the devices they use. Lastly, we must all remember a simple truth: money is very easy to spend, but incredibly difficult to earn. We should be more prudent with our hard-earned cash.
 
Last edited:
So what I am trying to say is that comparing auditory perception to a tactile sensation—like the temperature of coffee—is entirely unconvincing and lacks any logical merit. Furthermore, anyone old enough to read and write should at least have a basic grasp of the fundamental principles behind the devices they use. Lastly, we must all remember a simple truth: money is very easy to spend, but incredibly difficult to earn. We should be more prudent with our hard-earned cash.
I agree, for the most part, with all of this. But if the user has set fidelity aside as a goal, then I suppose they can pursue whatever differences they like. There are really two different claims here:

1) No accounting for taste/subjective evaluation: This is when Fidelity is not the goal. What’s amazing to me is that a lot of the degraded fidelity some audiophiles pursue could easily be simulated for much, much less than the high end price tag.

2) “I can hear a difference”: Even more amazing - they more frequently pay orders of magnitude more for no audible difference at all. It’s really this second argument where our differences lie. They deny it, we insist. We have scientific evidence on our side, so they sneak arguments from the ‘not pursuing fidelity’ angle into the ‘no difference’ discussion.
 
Back
Top Bottom