• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

New Genelec 8380 main monitors

YT is Erin’s Audio Corner. Patreon is likely the same, and in any event a Patreon link will be available on his YT channel page and/or in the descriptions of his videos.
I was’t asking about Erin’s.
 

There a subjective review here, they have a bit of fun with the speakers they test :)
Thank you Erin for your reviews always illuminating.
 
I honestly can't follow their reviews, they release 3-4 videos for a single product and it's all structured weirdly.
 
I honestly can't follow their reviews, they release 3-4 videos for a single product and it's all structured weirdly.

I appreciate his reviews. It's not my style and TBH I rarely watch due to lack of time but he absolutely puts in a lot of effort to provide his audience with tons of information and I like that - despite it being all subjective - he has different people come in and demo the speakers and provide their own feedback. It's entertaining. If you're into the subjective only side of things.

That said, I agree with you here. I haven't thought about it before but reading your comment I thought to myself "right?!". I personally think more structure - even something simple as "Part 1", "Part 2", etc with a standard format - would help his channel immensely.
 
I appreciated the time you put into GLM. I know it's hard to review and takes up valuable time.
 
I appreciate his reviews. It's not my style and TBH I rarely watch due to lack of time but he absolutely puts in a lot of effort to provide his audience with tons of information and I like that - despite it being all subjective - he has different people come in and demo the speakers and provide their own feedback. It's entertaining. If you're into the subjective only side of things.

That said, I agree with you here. I haven't thought about it before but reading your comment I thought to myself "right?!". I personally think more structure - even something simple as "Part 1", "Part 2", etc with a standard format - would help his channel immensely.

Well, I do appreciate that your reviews are properly chaptered, even if I usually watch everything in one go.

That said, I did miss the higher level of enthusiasm you showed in some of your previous reviews. In my humble opinion, pleasing a few detractors doesn't necessarily increase overall engagement or viewership. People who watch your audio product reviews are there just as much for the storytelling and your genuine reactions as they are for the measurements. Otherwise, simply reading the measurements on your website would be just as informative, but it lacks the personal impressions and reviewer reactions that make the videos compelling.

Speaking of measurements, I'm sorry to hear about people scraping your data. If it's any consolation, I haven't stumbled upon any of those sites myself. Is that why you've stopped sharing the full dataset with spinorama.org (like with the 8380a)?
 
You're right about the sweep, here's the conditions:





Talking about music though, wouldn't it make better sense to measure it with something like PN or M-noise across the spectrum as it is additive?
(my previous post at another thread was about that too)
Pink noise is among the worst signals you can find for measuring maximum SPL of a loudspeaker, even worse than the typical sine sweeps. Spectrum which is nothing like typical music material and only 6 to 12 dB crest factor (depending on source) which is much too little especially above the bass range. M-Noise (AES75) is a good initiative, but it also has its issues and the procedure is painful and slow to use. We are not using either one internally.
 
Last edited:
In a logarithmic 2.7 s sweep from 20 Hz to 20 kHz (ca. 10 Octaves) the range from 10.000 Hz to 20.000 Hz (the last Octave) is only forced pretty much exactly 270 ms
Perhaps it should have done better in this testing.

Here the KEF Blade 2 Meta as an example:
The tweeter sees the signal already from about 2 kHz and upwards where the crossover is. That is where the heat starts building up because of the sweep direction. A 2.7 second sweep spends about 0.9 seconds from 2 kHz to 20 kHz which is an eternity from the tweeter's viewpoint which is designed to produce high SPL peaks of a much shorter time. Anything longer than a few tens of milliseconds will trigger the protection circuit at that kind of SPL.

Blade 2 and 8380A are two completely different loudspeakers for two completely different applications. Other is a domestic hi-fi loudpeaker, other is a professional monitor. They don't have the same design requirements for example when it comes to keeping the speaker alive and operational no matter what kind of signal (and level) is being fed to it. This kind of additional protection layer will be typically visible in measurements which are not designed to mimic the typical source signal (music). It does not make the product to perform any worse in real life use. Depending on the LF room gain, GLM calibration, possible additional spectrum shaping settings and of course the actual source signal, it is much more likely to reach the maximum SPL of a loudspeaker below 100 Hz than it is above 10 kHz.
 
Last edited:
Blade 2 and 8380A are two completely different loudspeakers for two completely different applications.
In previous years ago, perhaps. But sites like ASR and Erin have bridged a gap between Home and Studio speakers. Unless I'm mistaken, Erin has stated in this thread that he would enjoy owning either a KEF Blade or a Genelec 8380A in his home for purely Home use. His reviews are seemingly targeted primarily at Home use where he subjectively evaluates them. I think about owning either of these speakers for personal Home only use in the future. There are seemingly numerous ASR members who use Genelec speakers purely for Home use.

And, there is no reason a KEF Blade cannot be used in a Studio, granted it has no built in protection circuitry, but presumably that could be somewhat achieved manually via DSP. I can't see how a KEF Blade would be anything other than a well above average speaker for Studio use, from purely a performance point of view.
 
I heard it in a relatively large, moderately damped room not so long ago, with GLM enabled. It came across as pretty neutral (so not overly bright).
This is what I think, it is much easier to determine the tonality of a speaker if one can quickly A/B against a measured neutral on axis response. Otherwise, one is entirely dependent on what is neutral from (questionable) memory.
 
In previous years ago, perhaps. But sites like ASR and Erin have bridged a gap between Home and Studio speakers. Unless I'm mistaken, Erin has stated in this thread that he would enjoy owning either a KEF Blade or a Genelec 8380A in his home for purely Home use. His reviews are seemingly targeted primarily at Home use where he subjectively evaluates them. I think about owning either of these speakers for personal Home only use in the future. There are seemingly numerous ASR members who use Genelec speakers purely for Home use.

And, there is no reason a KEF Blade cannot be used in a Studio, granted it has no built in protection circuitry, but presumably that could be somewhat achieved manually via DSP. I can't see how a KEF Blade would be anything other than a well above average speaker for Studio use, from purely a performance point of view.

I don't necessarily disagree with what you've written here. But I do think there's an important difference between "designed for" and "can be used in," and I think @Ilkka Rissanen is primarily referring to the former while you're referring to the latter.
 
In previous years ago, perhaps. But sites like ASR and Erin have bridged a gap between Home and Studio speakers. Unless I'm mistaken, Erin has stated in this thread that he would enjoy owning either a KEF Blade or a Genelec 8380A in his home for purely Home use. His reviews are seemingly targeted primarily at Home use where he subjectively evaluates them. I think about owning either of these speakers for personal Home only use in the future. There are seemingly numerous ASR members who use Genelec speakers purely for Home use.

And, there is no reason a KEF Blade cannot be used in a Studio, granted it has no built in protection circuitry, but presumably that could be somewhat achieved manually via DSP. I can't see how a KEF Blade would be anything other than a well above average speaker for Studio use, from purely a performance point of view.
The Blade is a passive speaker which makes it irrelevant to probably 90% of the studios
Plus it doesn't have any room correction
So you're comparing apples to oranges
 
I think about owning either of these speakers for personal Home only use
Get both. It would be interesting to read a comparison.
 
The Blade is a passive speaker which makes it irrelevant to probably 90% of the studios
Plus it doesn't have any room correction
So you're comparing apples to oranges
From a performance point of view, a KEF Blade is seemingly a very acceptable speaker in a studio.
GLM is not the only form of room correction for Studio use.

I'm not comparing apples to oranges, I'm comparing a passive speaker to an active one.
I bet you could pick an apple from an orange in a blind test.
Do you think you could or could so easily pick a passive speaker to an active one in a blind test? ;)

I'm guilt free to compare passive and active speakers, I just see speaker versus speaker, with different implementations, performance and feature sets.
 
...So you're comparing apples to oranges
I think people complain about comparing apples and oranges too much.

Speakers: The Genelec and the KEF are both good. They could be used in a home audio setting or as studio monitors.
Fruit: Apples and Oranges are both good. They could be used in a fruit salad or a muffin.

:p
 
FWIW, the data for these may wind up not going on my website anytime soon. I’ve had a lot of issues with other websites using AI to scrape my website/data to generate “reviews“ and affiliate links. I’m considering a complete overhaul of my website or a second one to be more like a buyers guide mainly to disrupt the flow of traffic to these other sites. Quite frankly, I’m pissed off by it.
Yikes, hate that.
it is much more likely to reach the maximum SPL of a loudspeaker below 100 Hz than it is above 10 kHz.
Correct in one. Bass runs out much sooner than mid or treble.
 
Back
Top Bottom