• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Never damaged a speaker...

WillBrink

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 16, 2021
Messages
1,294
Likes
1,094
I regularly see blown speakers on forums and FB groups, and realized in my 40 years + of audio, never damaged a speaker. You? I have had the volume up to ear splitting levels countless times, well above what would be recommend for hearing damage as a dumb 20 something and all, never blew a speaker. Had parties where loud music played all night, etc, not blown a driver. What are people doing to damage their speakers ? I know distortion is what causes damage most of the time.
 
Speakers over 10 years old, you should try measuring the left against the right to see if their drivers are still performing identical to each other.
 
I, too, wonder. In my 60+ years in audio, I have had one speaker blown and that was due to a power amp that was defective out of the box! Nothing before or since, even when I let others use the system.
 
I regularly see blown speakers on forums and FB groups, and realized in my 40 years + of audio, never damaged a speaker. You? I have had the volume up to ear splitting levels countless times, well above what would be recommend for hearing damage as a dumb 20 something and all, never blew a speaker. Had parties where loud music played all night, etc, not blown a driver. What are people doing to damage their speakers ? I know distortion is what causes damage most of the time.
I've blown the amp in a DENON AVR receiver once: when the speaker wires under the carpet wore through each other and connected together to have a short. By the time I found the issue, the smoke had come out of the wires & the magic had gone away.
No blown speakers since I started my audio journey in 1971 (with some cruddy gear as a young teen).
I have seen some & wondered at the time "How did you manage to do that?"
Of course (at the time): they never admitted that they had done something stupid.
 
I fried the tweeters in my car once (aftermarket setup).

Usually speakers get blown at parties when a teenager or drunk has access to the volume control. Or maybe someone "testing" to see how loud it can go.

A 100W speaker is designed to handle regular program material from a 100W amplifier that's not clipping. It can't handle constant 100W test tones, and the tweeter can't handle as much power as the woofer. Or, if you push the amplifier into clipping the peak is clipped-limited to 100W but the average power goes up and you can burn-out the woofer. There's a myth that an overdriven lower power amp is worse than a higher-power amp but you can blow a speaker either way.

You can also burn-out a speaker with high-power test tones that are too high or too-low for the speaker to reproduce, or too high for you to hear. With low frequencies you'd usually hear some noise or distortion but with high frequencies the tweeter might be "silent"
 
I fried two tweeters of Epos bij playing them very loudly. the first one went and a few weeks later the other one.
Replaced them and a few years later i bought the R3 and that sound was a revelation to me. So different from the Epos.
But i cant play them hard because the sound will distort for wich i blame the CXA 81.
 
I had a damaged cone that I made worse once by then playing at high volume is the closest I've gotten that I can think of. A friend of mine wasted my ribbons on some Carver Amazing Speakers by turning the volume to 11.....but I wasn't there. I'm more of the school of it sounds bad, turn it down....but sometimes alcohol at parties can sidestep that quickly enough :)
 
I can't recall blowing up speakers unintentionally. Have almost lost a couple due to faulty amps without DC protection; one was a test driver specifically to test bad amps.
Had a cheap woofer voice coil move up the former when soldering a terminal on the speaker while the amp was on.

I've blown up plenty of cheapo drivers on purpose too :)
 
Never damaged one by playing music, and regularly used to listen just below the level where the drivers would hit the end stops, and there is only one simple way of working out where that is.
Have taken out 2 tweeters simultaneously by wiring a Naim pre amp and one of it's multiple external power supplies wrongly, huge howling noise followed by panic at switch on, fortunately cheap to replace. The cables and plugs are designed to prevent this happening, I found a combination they hadn't thought of.
 
A brother damaged the woofers of a pair of then 23YO JBL Decade L36 loudspeakers while playing a Compact Disc of Telarc's recording of Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture. The woofers were replaced and last year the JBL's were succeeded by a pair of Revel F206 loudspeakers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EJ3
I fried the tweeters in my car once (aftermarket setup).

Usually speakers get blown at parties when a teenager or drunk has access to the volume control. Or maybe someone "testing" to see how loud it can go.

A 100W speaker is designed to handle regular program material from a 100W amplifier that's not clipping. It can't handle constant 100W test tones, and the tweeter can't handle as much power as the woofer. Or, if you push the amplifier into clipping the peak is clipped-limited to 100W but the average power goes up and you can burn-out the woofer. There's a myth that an overdriven lower power amp is worse than a higher-power amp but you can blow a speaker either way.
In my teens the guys running the local rock disco regularly blew the tweeters of their Canton stand mount speakers due to playing too loud and clipping the amps. Since the speakers were new they got the replacements for free.
You can also burn-out a speaker with high-power test tones that are too high or too-low for the speaker to reproduce, or too high for you to hear. With low frequencies you'd usually hear some noise or distortion but with high frequencies the tweeter might be "silent"
The tweeters in my small PA speakers (FBT Jolly 8a) were blown during a live concert. A possible cause could be a feedback loop with a frequency so high I no longer hear it. I'd expected to see burned voice coils but both looked as new despite somewhere being broken (no resistance). The service guy in the pro shop who sold the replacements was also baffled, although he had seen something similar before. No clue what killed the voice coils.
 
Anyone wants to fix this tweeter? ;)
1000104381.jpg
 
I've blown midranges in Vega 3-ways with 15's.
Unheard of.......

Cross them at 100hz to 2 pair of 18's, play "juke box hero" as loud as the ab international 600a and altec 9440a will go.......

I've blown woofers and tweeter also......
 
Not damage, but failure of both tweeters happened to me (B&W CDM7, 20 years old, stuck due to "dried out" ferrofluid).
I was lucky and got the (allegedly) last replacement pair of matching Sig7 tweeters from B&W.
 
I've blown midranges in Vega 3-ways with 15's.
Unheard of.......

Cross them at 100hz to 2 pair of 18's, play "juke box hero" as loud as the ab international 600a and altec 9440a will go.......

I've blown woofers and tweeter also......
A history of the speaker company Frazier (since they were mostly a regional company and are relatively unknown):

Jack Frazier began manufacturing commercial loudspeakers around 1952 in Dallas, Texas. This was a small audio contractor, run by Jack Frazier, that was building public address systems and renting them out across the state for small fairs and public gatherings. Frazier also did a number of sound installations in the Dallas Ft. Worth area. One in Dallas was the Hotel Adolphus that incorporated a very early form of room equalization developed by Dr. C.P. Boner. The system was called 'ring mode equalization' where system gain was increased to feedback threshold and a notch filter tuned to this frequency was inserted in the signal path. Not many filters were used, but the results were impressive. Then Ed May (later of JBL fame) joined Frazier.
Ed and Jack got along well enough that they decided to become partners and formed the Frazier-May loudspeaker company. Frazier-May continued the development of professional sound equipment consisting mainly of bass and high frequency horns that were not dissimilar to the Altec Voice of the Theatre systems. They also made a successful effort to capture a portion of the burgeoning hi-fi market with home speakers such as the Dixielander.
During this time, Frazier May used OEM drivers, with Quam Nichols as their main supplier. Ed was always on the look out for better performing drivers and was very impressed with the JBL D208. He was developing a system that used a horn-loaded 8" driver and this JBL performed better than any previous transducer. Nonetheless, a fair amount of technical work was undertaken by Ed in getting optimum performance out of the D208. He worked closely with JBL in doing this optimization.
dixielander.jpg

The Frazier-May Dixielander
In turn, JBL took note of Ed May's high level of technical ability. In 1956, JBL called with an offer for Ed to join the company.
Ed accepted and moved to California to work at JBL's new Casitas headquarters. He immediately became involved in all aspects loudspeaker engineering. Within three years, he would become JBL's primary transducer and systems engineer. He initially worked closely with Richard Ranger to develop the Paragon, Metregon and Minigon. He also worked closely with Bart Locanthi, who as a consultant, had been the primary technical resource at JBL since 1950. In 1960, Bart joined JBL full time as Corporate Vice President of Engineering. Ed became a Director, reporting to Bart, responsible for all new product development. In these capacities, Bart and Ed would work as a team for the next decade. Bart was the acknowledged theoretician while Ed was the practitioner that could take basic concepts and develop them into fully detailed products.​
During the 1960s and 70s, the company offered consumer hi-fi loudspeakers in addition to its line of commercial products. The company operated under Jack's leadership until his death in 1983.
Jack Frazier did not document much for files. They had build sheets that they gave to the assemblers, most of the designs stayed in Jack's head.
Frazier Speakers were hand built in Dallas and were some great speakers. The best cabinets I have ever seen, with double sided Walnut Veneer and killer construction. Jack Frazier and Paul Klipsch were acquaintances, and legend has it that Klipsch had a pair of Frazier Mk IV’s in his office and they are what influenced him to make the Heresy speaker.

Until recent times, I had no subs to cross over to...
But I did generate 112 DB in room several times.
I would then leave the room to do other things around the house, come back & turn the stereo down to a more normal 96 DB (I would still be doing other things in other rooms upstairs where the stereo was in my bedroom). The Speakers that I was doing this with were Frazier Super Monte Carlo's. Inside (with no crossover, using the natural tuning of the drivers) these speakers have a 8" woofers that uses a paper pleated surround and Piezo tweeters.
They are in the low 90's DB per watt @ 1 meter F10 @ 40 Hz-17 KHz (approx.)
1750596117117.png

I bought them around 1977, Jack Frazier died in 1983.
An interesting anecdote:
Ken Thomas
[email protected]
My first full time job was a repair technician in a high-fidelity audio shop in 1975. That is where I first witnessed Frazier speakers. I was very impressed with the sound quality. Truly taken and mesmerized by the realism. My interest in Frazier speakers continued to grow as many models passed through the shop showroom and witnessing them in theaters, auditoriums and, night-clubs. I started saving money to purchase a pair of Concertos.
I called the Frazier factory and asked if I could purchase and pick up the speakers in person at the factory. I was told that I would be very welcome. A time was setup – June 22, 1977 (my birthday!). When I arrived, I was introduced to Jack Frazier himself. He was older but got around well. He asked if I had time to tour the factory? I felt like Charlie Bucket at the Willy Wonka Chocolate Factory. I was mesmerized as Jack lead me through, showing each step of construction. Everything hand made, no automation.
He explained that a very prominent source of distortion was the speaker enclosure itself. When the enclosure flexes with the sound wave energy, it resonates, generating and radiating its own sound distorting the intended sound radiation. He showed me how the materials and construction, including complex corner cuts to lock the panels together, internal bracing, special non-resonant panel materials, no flush cuts for woofers among other unique techniques. He explained that the speaker enclosure was the speaker’s foundation. It was clear that Jack Frazier was deeply in love with his speaker designs and factory. He just beamed with delight showing me everything.
Then he took me to his office, which had many of the more popular Frazier speakers, plus a few in-work prototypes, all lined up on one end of the office. His desk was on the opposite end. Along with all the typical office desk items including a turntable. He said there was a very simple test to demonstrate speaker cabinet flexing. He pulled a nickel from his pocket and balanced it on edge on top of a large model home speaker – called the “Thing”. He then put a record on the turntable. I don’t remember what the music was, but it had some very heavy percussion and bass. He cranked it up. The base was nauseatingly powerful. The realism was unsettling. The drums and instruments were all right there, but not to be seen. The nickel remained on its edge with no movement. He turned it down then grabbed a few more nickels and placed them, on edge, on other objects in the room; desk, shelves, etc. He replayed the same piece. Immediately all the nickels throughout the room fell over, some jumping completely off the surface. The nickels on the speakers never moved – remained on edge. He then played a movie soundtrack that included a bomb explosion. It was shocking. It wasn’t just loud; I actually felt the bomb blast in my body. The nickel never moved.
I found this totally unbelievable, it had to be a trick. So, when I got back to work the next day, I decided to perform the same test in our showroom. Along with a pair of Frazier 7’s we also happened to have a pair of “Things” on the showroom floor, so I placed a nickel on its edge on both speakers. Just as in Jack’s office, all nickels in the room fell over except for the ones on the “Things” and 7’s.
It was clear from my visit with Jack Frazier that he was an artist in the truest sense. He sought to design and build the most faithful speakers he could. His interest was in the art, not the business. He hired people to run the business, leaving him to the art. This is also why Frazier inc, never became a mass market manufacture.
Jack understood Newton’s third law of motion: for every action there is an opposite and equal reaction. Jack understood the requirement of a solid ground (foundation). In a speaker, the cabinet is the speaker’s foundation, it’s the reference point, the anchor.
 
Anyone wants to fix this tweeter? ;)
Beryllium and ceramic diaphragms are brittle and subject to physical damage. I once reviewed a pair of speakers with ceramic diaphragms which played loud without complaint. Neither midrange driver survived subequent shipment.
The Frazier-May Dixielander
I remember those. The local dealer had them on demo for years but I always found that the polarity wiring between the two drivers was ambiguous to most listeners.
 
I remember those. The local dealer had them on demo for years but I always found that the polarity wiring between the two drivers was ambiguous to most listeners.
I've never personally seen a Dixielander, but I like many of the speakers that Frazier had in the 70's.
 
Nope, never damaged a speaker and every pair of the 4 speakers I’ve bought since my first purchase of Tannoy 607 in 1992 with my first months wages are still in use (3 still are, not by myself….obviously I’m using the 4th)
 
Back
Top Bottom