• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Neumann KH120 II Monitor Review

Rate this monitor speaker:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 5 0.9%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 6 1.1%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 47 8.5%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 498 89.6%

  • Total voters
    556
I've uploaded a short video recording made with my phone with the microphone placed right next to the tweeter (the first half is the left speaker, the second half the right one). I've boosted the audio by 12 dB to make the crackling easier to hear:
KH120 II Left vs Right

Would you recommend contacting Thomann, Neumann directly, or both?
Absolutely yes. Start with Thomann.
 
KH120 II & KH150 noise issue: For those experiencing this noise, was it always there, slowly increase, suddenly increase, start after pushing the speaker hard, or did it exhibit some other manifestation pattern?
 
In my case, it just started happening yesterday during normal use. It wasn't present before.
 
KH120 II & KH150 noise issue: For those experiencing this noise, was it always there, slowly increase, suddenly increase, start after pushing the speaker hard, or did it exhibit some other manifestation pattern?
For some units, it was right away, for others it took a day or so. I've gone through maybe 7 or so units at this point, mix of 120ii's and 150's.

On my current 150's, sometimes the issue is barely audible, before randomly becoming louder. It doesn't seem to be triggered by playback, at least not for me. Although sometimes the issue flares up right after I stop playing something, so it seems that way.
 
For some units, it was right away, for others it took a day or so. I've gone through maybe 7 or so units at this point, mix of 120ii's and 150's.

On my current 150's, sometimes the issue is barely audible, before randomly becoming louder. It doesn't seem to be triggered by playback, at least not for me. Although sometimes the issue flares up right after I stop playing something, so it seems that way.
As regards the earlier point about Neumann communicating which serial numbers could be affected by the issue, I have doubts they will do that. I base that on the fact that many issues have been reported numerous times (across the 120II/150 threads) since 2023 approx, ranging for problems with auto-standby, to amp and other problems. In that time, Neumann reps here have been invited to comment and not a single acknowledgement has been made from them (afaict), even when loads of people were posting. If they officially acknowledge anything (let alone provide serial number info), I will be very pleasantly surprised, but don't hold your breath.
 
As regards the earlier point about Neumann communicating which serial numbers could be affected by the issue, I have doubts they will do that. I base that on the fact that many issues have been reported numerous times (across the 120II/150 threads) since 2023 approx, ranging for problems with auto-standby, to amp and other problems. In that time, Neumann reps here have been invited to comment and not a single acknowledgement has been made from them (afaict), even when loads of people were posting. If they officially acknowledge anything (let alone provide serial number info), I will be very pleasantly surprised, but don't hold your breath.
My experience has changed over two years of contact--initially the reps I was talking to helped me through standard troubleshooting, going through several replacement units, before finally offering me an extended warranty. When the issue flared up again and continued into this year, I got my ticket transferred to the US division of Neumann/Sennheiser, and it's only now that we've been able to get the EU engineering team to look at the issue. As a result they were able to identify an issue with manufacturing, at least that's what I've been told.

All of this is to say, with a steady stream of clear and objective communication, the way the company responded changed, so I have some hope that they'll be clear in issuing a PSA. At the very least, privately via Neumann accounts or retailer accounts.

Personally, I expect they will help anyone who reaches out, but not necessarily anyone who doesn't. After all, the speakers do work perfectly in all other regards, and the issue is genuinely a non-issue for some users, for various reasons.
 
So i wonder do i have the fixed version or just a new monitor. Thomann send me a monitor that the serial number is not even close the original. Its actually older than the one i purchased. I already told them a few months ago that there is an issue with other people and gave the post so they can send it to neumann. No one told me officially that there is a problem and i was left for more than one month without a monitor to work. I dont use them just to listen to music. So what happens now if i get this problem again in the future and im out warranty. Its working now, will it work next year and how bad it can get? The first monitors i got start with a serial of 64 and the one they send me starts with 60. If they could just send emails privately to the customers they think will get this problem based on the serial that would be great. My warranty of 2 years expires January and i got one extra year from thomann. Ive lost my trust in this company since i replaced this monitor twice since the day i got them.
 
So i wonder do i have the fixed version or just a new monitor. Thomann send me a monitor that the serial number is not even close the original. Its actually older than the one i purchased. I already told them a few months ago that there is an issue with other people and gave the post so they can send it to neumann. No one told me officially that there is a problem and i was left for more than one month without a monitor to work. I dont use them just to listen to music. So what happens now if i get this problem again in the future and im out warranty. Its working now, will it work next year and how bad it can get? The first monitors i got start with a serial of 64 and the one they send me starts with 60. If they could just send emails privately to the customers they think will get this problem based on the serial that would be great. My warranty of 2 years expires January and i got one extra year from thomann. Ive lost my trust in this company since i replaced this monitor twice since the day i got them.
Sorry, but I don't think anyone has any answers right now--the only thing I can say for certain is that there's no 'fixed' version; some units suffer the issue, and some don't. We were just guessing that a certain serial range was affected, but that isn't a confirmed fact.

File a warranty claim with Neumann, since you've already done so with Thomann. Explain your situation, and maybe even link this thread. The idea is that whenever a 'fixed' version arrives, you will be a priority for speaker replacement, and as long has you have established the issue under Neumann's warranty with them directly, you'll be able to keep communicating with the manufacturer directly (Thomann can't do anything other than keep replacing with similar defective units). Not a guarantee of course.

If the work is urgent, and the crackling impedes it, I would get different speakers for now.
 
I've uploaded a short video recording made with my phone with the microphone placed right next to the tweeter (the first half is the left speaker, the second half the right one). I've boosted the audio by 12 dB to make the crackling easier to hear:
KH120 II Left vs Right

Would you recommend contacting Thomann, Neumann directly, or both?

Can you hear that noise from your listening position? From 1 meter?
 
So i wonder do i have the fixed version or just a new monitor. Thomann send me a monitor that the serial number is not even close the original. Its actually older than the one i purchased. I already told them a few months ago that there is an issue with other people and gave the post so they can send it to neumann. No one told me officially that there is a problem and i was left for more than one month without a monitor to work. I dont use them just to listen to music. So what happens now if i get this problem again in the future and im out warranty. Its working now, will it work next year and how bad it can get? The first monitors i got start with a serial of 64 and the one they send me starts with 60. If they could just send emails privately to the customers they think will get this problem based on the serial that would be great. My warranty of 2 years expires January and i got one extra year from thomann. Ive lost my trust in this company since i replaced this monitor twice since the day i got them.
If you are located in the European Union, in addition to the commercial guarantee, the statutory/legal guarantee also applies. Typically, using a legal warranty is a more advantageous solution for the consumer.

The warranty period varies slightly depending on the country, but is usually extended by the time needed to process the complaint. If the seller decides to replace the device with a new one instead of repairing it, the warranty period starts again.

If, after repair or replacement, the product fails in the same way a second time, you can also request a full refund from the seller.
 
Yes, I can definitely hear it from my listening position, even with my PC running and its fans producing some background noise.
I could hear it also in my room especially when it was quiet, nighttime. It became a little louder though after a few days.
 
There is no fixed version yet--but if you can tolerate a mild, sometimes random crackling, then by all means. In all other aspects, the speakers work phenomenally.
Sorry, but who could ever "tolerate a mild, sometimes random crackling" on a monitor that claims to be for professional purposes? I have permanently lost all trust in Neumann and I'm glad I have sold my Neumanns a couple of years ago and use Genelecs now. It would drive me insane if I listened to music and would permanently wait for the crackle to start.
 
At least in my case, no speaker currently matches Neumann's neutral sound for the same form factor, so I'd rather stick with them while I still have warranty. And besides, the crackle isn't audible for like 80% of my listening and working.

But yes, I don't tolerate it outright; I'm sticking with them under the impression that Neumann is actively working to fix the situation.
 
At least in my case, no speaker currently matches Neumann's neutral sound for the same form factor, so I'd rather stick with them while I still have warranty. And besides, the crackle isn't audible for like 80% of my listening and working.

But yes, I don't tolerate it outright; I'm sticking with them under the impression that Neumann is actively working to fix the situation.
Is it audible when playing music?
 
Is it audible when playing music?
If it's something like an old Telarc classical recording, then yes it can show up. For anything else, no. Zero impact on the linearity and response of sound, on the 150's. However on the 120ii's, the subbass would distort softly, at least in my experience (I sent clips of that to Neumann as well).
 
If it's something like an old Telarc classical recording, then yes it can show up. For anything else, no. Zero impact on the linearity and response of sound, on the 150's. However on the 120ii's, the subbass would distort softly, at least in my experience (I sent clips of that to Neumann as well).
sorry--should clarify: anything with silence will let the issue be heard. I mention classical music because the dynamic range frequently goes to near-silent.
 
Back
Top Bottom