• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

My Kingdom For A Remote Volume Knob! can this be made?

MCH

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 10, 2021
Messages
2,581
Likes
2,197
If all you want is volume, wouldn’t the Surface Dial (or custom and Pi) work for controlling system volume? Are you using any solution now for controlling multiple app volumes?
I wish I could use the dial, but I don't know how. The farther I went was to pair it to a raspberry pi (but doing nothing), and also found this link where a guy explains how he found out what instructions the dial sends via bluetooth when actuated (link below). Beyond that is all dark as the darkest night for me. What do i use now? The remote of my topping dac in my main system and my phone in the rest. And I can't decide which one I despise more :-/

 

IPunchCholla

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
1,102
Likes
1,384
I wish I could use the dial, but I don't know how. The farther I went was to pair it to a raspberry pi (but doing nothing), and also found this link where a guy explains how he found out what instructions the dial sends via bluetooth when actuated (link below). Beyond that is all dark as the darkest night for me. What do i use now? The remote of my topping dac in my main system and my phone in the rest. And I can't decide which one I despise more :-/

The examples I posted ( I changed post #26 to link to a remote rather than a receiver) would get you there (technically, if not aesthetically, but use an Arduino rather than a Pi. Those tutorials show you how to look up (or capture) the Topping remote’s code and give examples of programming a dial encoder (plugged directly into the circuit. But I would use the code from post 24 (with the Topping’s values) myself as it is directly using the a knob as a button And is fairly elegant.

For Bluetooth/dial If you have linked the Dial to the Pi, you need to program the Pi to emit the Topping’s code for volume up and volume down. Your link tells you how to capture the input from the dial. It unfortunately assumes the reader knows what to make of that raw input, and how to translate that to code. I need to look at it more carefully to see if I can grasp it.

If you want to go the Dial->Pi->Topping route, your next step would be to figure out how to control a blinking LED. That is what will control the Topping. Link. Once you can control the topping with the Pi manually, you will need to program it to do it on receiving data from the dial.

Personally, I think I am going to look in to going the Arduino/Bluetooth route myself. As I am trying to control system volume rather than device volume.
 

MCH

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 10, 2021
Messages
2,581
Likes
2,197
The examples I posted ( I changed post #26 to link to a remote rather than a receiver) would get you there (technically, if not aesthetically, but use an Arduino rather than a Pi. Those tutorials show you how to look up (or capture) the Topping remote’s code and give examples of programming a dial encoder (plugged directly into the circuit. But I would use the code from post 24 (with the Topping’s values) myself as it is directly using the a knob as a button And is fairly elegant.

For Bluetooth/dial If you have linked the Dial to the Pi, you need to program the Pi to emit the Topping’s code for volume up and volume down. Your link tells you how to capture the input from the dial. It unfortunately assumes the reader knows what to make of that raw input, and how to translate that to code. I need to look at it more carefully to see if I can grasp it.

If you want to go the Dial->Pi->Topping route, your next step would be to figure out how to control a blinking LED. That is what will control the Topping. Link. Once you can control the topping with the Pi manually, you will need to program it to do it on receiving data from the dial.

Personally, I think I am going to look in to going the Arduino/Bluetooth route myself. As I am trying to control system volume rather than device volume.
Awesome, thanks, it even seems easy reading your post.
To be honest, for me either ir or Bluetooth would work, i see advantages and disadvantages in both: bluetooth - not directional. IR - could make it work with any device that has a ir receiver.
 

MadMaxx

Active Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2022
Messages
135
Likes
240
Location
Islamorada, FL Keys
Best volume knob ever was the long discontinued Emotiva Control Freak. Best one I've found since my CF passed away is the TC Electronic Level Pilot X.


tc x.png
 

Kundroc

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2018
Messages
26
Likes
28
I use a SPIN remote.

DSC08986.JPG


It's a programmable IR remote control. It recognizes if it's upright, upside down or if your holding it horizontally. It will send different IR codes in each position, allowing you to, e.g., change volume when upright and inputs if turned horizontally.
Unfortunately, its discontinued now and the app not available from the app stores anylonger (only on 3rd party repositories).
http://www.spinremote.com/index.html
 

Chromatischism

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jun 5, 2020
Messages
4,767
Likes
3,703
Thanks. Would you mind posting some examples? I would be specially interested in sending commands to LMS

I have not seen many ir volume knobs, the few I know are bluetooth like the ms dial, could you link to any you know too? Thanks a lot!
I can't see IR working well. It would have to blast every increment as you turn it, just like holding down the volume button on a traditional remote control. And if you turn it fast, there would be a lot of lag until it catches up.
 

iann

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
38
Likes
47
Location
UK
I've been looking on and off for a nice physical volume control as well and I think this might fit the bill...

The ortho remote from Teenage Engineering. Designed to control volume on their speakers, it seems that it should work as a Bluetooth volume controller for Android and iOS phones as well. Not cheap at £89, but someone was selling one for half that on ebay and I think it's worth a look.

teenage engineering - ortho remote
 

MaxBuck

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
May 22, 2021
Messages
1,515
Likes
2,118
Location
SoCal, Baby!
I was watching an old Darko video in which he discussed his appreciation for being able to control an audio system with a remote volume knob.

He gets to the "why" of this around 51 seconds in:


I was like: YES! Someone gets me!

I place a high value on the combination of ergonomics and aesthetics and the "feel" of equipment.

When I'm streaming my digital music in my system I'm using my iPhone as the remote (or iPad), so that just feels like, well...using my damned iphone again. Like I do all day long. There isn't anything particularly "nice" about the feel of using my phone or ipad for this purpose. For volume I can use the iphone (using logitech server software) but I often prefer to leave the volume at 0 and adjust volume via my pre-amp remote (or universal remote control). Again...pretty much held hostage to the feel of the supplied remote, or my universal remote.
Eh.

What I'd REALLY LOVE is just what Darko describes in the video: a big ol' physical volume knob to control volume, right at my listening position. Ideally one that looks super high quality and lux, and feels that way. I could even imagine a nice wood knob as the dial.

I once had this when I used a Museatex Bidat DAC, which could be run directly in to my amps, the volume was a wired remote control - a dial on a little wood block like this:

View attachment 211845

Not exactly luxurious, but it's the general idea.

I did a fairly extensive search on the web and there doesn't seem to be a product like the one I'm describing. There is the occasional product with a knob remote control, but it's usually proprietary to the device in question. There are remote knobs that you can set up via blue tooth or wired to your computer, but that doesn't solve it either. (My Apogee Duet usb audio interface I use with my DAW has a nice volume knob, though doesn't do exactly what I'm asking).

I have both analog sources (turntable) and digital, running through my preamp in to my system.

So what I'd need is a remote volume knob that is also able to learn or download remote commands to control either my LA4 or Conrad Johnson preamps. Right now those are controlled with their own remotes (and an IR repeater system).

Lacking any finished product I wondered if such a learning volume knob could be built custom. But I have no idea if there are any sort of "computer module" parts that would constitute the "learning remote codes" part somehow in concert with some potentiometer section or whatever?

To be honest, this post is more curiosity about how difficult such a project would be more than any likelihood I'd engage in trying to build one. And among the vast experience on this site, perhaps someone has actually come across something like this, or used one before.
Matt, I understand this likely won't be useful for you, but it might be for others.

I use the active bezel on my Samsung Galaxy Watch Classic as a volume control dial when I'm controlling my Bluesound Node via my phone. It works great. I can certainly understand your desire for a remote with similar functionality.
 

kma100

Active Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 2, 2020
Messages
169
Likes
236
I've bought the ortho remote from eBay and will see next week how well it works.
This looks very cool. Do share your experiences (I want to see if it would work with a Bluesound Node). Was the eBay price significantly lower?
 

iann

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
38
Likes
47
Location
UK
This looks very cool. Do share your experiences (I want to see if it would work with a Bluesound Node). Was the eBay price significantly lower?
Was £42. Looks unused. Nice blue colour.

Will report back next week.
 

Zaireeka

Active Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2020
Messages
285
Likes
314
Location
fRAMCE
I've bought the ortho remote from eBay and will see next week how well it works.
Think I'm gonna buy one aswell for my future Raspberry 3 based streamer. Looks sturdy and well made.
 

MCH

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 10, 2021
Messages
2,581
Likes
2,197
Think I'm gonna buy one aswell for my future Raspberry 3 based streamer. Looks sturdy and well made.
What pi streamer is that? How are you planning to make it work? Thanks.
 

Zaireeka

Active Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2020
Messages
285
Likes
314
Location
fRAMCE
Don't know yet, probably Rune Audio. I'll find a way to make this thing work, I think Bluez is what I need for that project.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCH
OP
MattHooper

MattHooper

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Messages
7,196
Likes
11,811
Ok I'm becoming momentarily re-obsessed with this idea.

I even imagine taking something like the ortho remote and spiffing it up with some custom wood around the dial (not a skill I have, but I'd pay for someone to do it). The thing is, I'm still looking for one that can learn the IR codes used for my CJ and Benchmark Preamps. If I could just get that, I'd be golden.
 

MCH

Major Contributor
Joined
Apr 10, 2021
Messages
2,581
Likes
2,197
Ok I'm becoming momentarily re-obsessed with this idea.

I even imagine taking something like the ortho remote and spiffing it up with some custom wood around the dial (not a skill I have, but I'd pay for someone to do it). The thing is, I'm still looking for one that can learn the IR codes used for my CJ and Benchmark Preamps. If I could just get that, I'd be golden.
The closest thing I know that has chances to achieve that is the spin remote posted on #45. It seems to me that the ortho is only Bluetooth like the dial and others
 
OP
MattHooper

MattHooper

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Messages
7,196
Likes
11,811
I use a SPIN remote.

View attachment 213491

It's a programmable IR remote control. It recognizes if it's upright, upside down or if your holding it horizontally. It will send different IR codes in each position, allowing you to, e.g., change volume when upright and inputs if turned horizontally.
Unfortunately, its discontinued now and the app not available from the app stores anylonger (only on 3rd party repositories).
http://www.spinremote.com/index.html

I somehow missed this post!

Yeah I just checked it out; as you say, discontinued, like so many cool items.

Also, I thought it would spin on the base, but it looks like it uses all sorts of goofy gestures which I'm not in to.
 
OP
MattHooper

MattHooper

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Messages
7,196
Likes
11,811
I still don't understand why this would be so impossible to find. There are all sorts of home automation/AV system remote control systems using iphones/ipads, which incorporate IR codes and can learn codes.
 

mglobe

Senior Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
458
Likes
702
Location
Texas
I still don't understand why this would be so impossible to find. There are all sorts of home automation/AV system remote control systems using iphones/ipads, which incorporate IR codes and can learn codes.
Because only a handful of eccentric nerds like us (self most definitely included) want one.
 
Top Bottom