• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

My Kingdom For A Remote Volume Knob! can this be made?


Thanks. It’s not you it’s me.

Per the criteria I outlined earlier in this thread for a remote, that particular remote is not enough interest to me to try and learn all that stuff.

But it’s outstanding that somebody is doing this for those interested in that type of remote.
 
There is also the MiniDSP KD-1 reviewed by Chris Connaker on Audiophile Style:

1791588813460.png


He was very disappointed with it. He wasn't happy with the build quality or the usability.
 
Anyone calling it a remote control knob is THE ENEMY. It is a SUPER KNOB.
 
There is also the MiniDSP KD-1 reviewed by Chris Connaker on Audiophile Style:

View attachment 563507

He was very disappointed with it. He wasn't happy with the build quality or the usability.

Oh man, just read the review and the description of the user experience as well as that depicted in the videos are such a hilarious fail.
 


Never have I wanted a knockoff, so much, "erect" indeed!

Must have the size & weight, that Swiss bearings feel. Yes willing to get a solid block of brass, and engage a local lathe artiste...
 

Never have I wanted a knockoff, so much, "erect" indeed!

Must have the size & weight, that Swiss bearings feel. Yes willing to get a solid block of brass, and engage a local lathe artiste...

If you can believe it, I almost had a knock off of that Steinway knob made!

The company that produced the custom volume control knob I wrote about in this thread said afterwards they could do a remote just like the Steinway if I wanted.
We started to talk about it, but then I said no need to spend more money on remote controls.
 

pricey, but not Steinway pricey!

VSN1...
 
I always enjoyed watching the volume knob on the JVC FS-7000 “executive” mini system rotate while pressing the volume buttons on the remote. IIRC, a light ring around the volume knob would illuminate as it moved. Very slick.
 

Never have I wanted a knockoff, so much, "erect" indeed!

Must have the size & weight, that Swiss bearings feel. Yes willing to get a solid block of brass, and engage a local lathe artiste...
It comes with a lot of other cool stuff...at a price!

https://holthill.com/collections/al...ns-lyngdorf-model-d-ultimate-audio-experience
 
https://github.com/scottbez1/smartknob could be pretty close if you got the 3d printing done in metal and picked the appropriate level of surface finish. Its main feature is the programmable haptic feedback so you can give it detents for stepped values, end stops, a centre notch for balance and so on. You would have to mod it if you want the physical buttons though.
 
good stuff!

I don't really care about replicating the whole device, just love the idea of HEAVY, nice haptics and classy brassy metal.

JDS Labs Element IV is my current frontrunner especially if their auto-variable Loudness Contour is up to scratch

Just drop a snug fitting "knob sleeve" top over that!

An OG machine shop using a plain lathe might be cheaper than 3D metal printing?
 
JDS Labs Element IV is my current frontrunner especially if their auto-variable Loudness Contour is up to scratch
That's a DAC/headphone amp, not a remote.
An OG machine shop using a plain lathe might be cheaper than 3D metal printing
IIRC as it was designed for 3D printing there are some features that are somewhat complicated with machining, but a bit of redesign would probably sort that. It's certainly what you'd do for production. For one-off or low volume projects you can't spread setup costs over a production run, so the 3D printing often works out cheaper. Places like JLC offer both machining and 3D printing so you can submit the models and compare pricing. If you know a machinist that'll charge mate's rates or work for beer it's another matter entirely.
 
That's a DAC/headphone amp, not a remote
I personally do not care about the device classification, so long as I get A Big Knob for level control at MLP tied to a quality implementation automatically variable Loudness Contour.

Of course it must also fit into the planning of my signal chain, but to get the above I am willing to make adjustments.

...

> IIRC as it was designed for 3D printing

sorry, what does "it" refer to there?

As for cost, maybe a heavy-walled cylindrical brass endcap can be repurposed

that happens to be just over the right inner diameter

and then a bead of sealant used to jury rig a press fit
 
> IIRC as it was designed for 3D printing

sorry, what does "it" refer to there?
The knob cylinder and case top from the smartknob - see https://github.com/scottbez1/smartknob/tree/master/cad. You could use a 3D printed plastic part for the details on the cylinder inner, glued inside a turned metal part to give the appearance, feel and weight, and probably mill the case top if you wanted machined parts instead of printed.
 
That will be great for me when I know what auto-variable loudness contour device I've chosen for doing volume level control, if compatible with smartknob project.

Especially if there is a finished product I can just buy.

I actually don't want a screen or RGB bling, but it seems those would not be required to operate it once configured.

Meantime, I'll likely try the JDS unit, and if that works, no integration DIY required, Just Works™
 
I’m using a Philips Hue Dial as a remote for my miniDSP Flex. It has no screen, but the batteries last for years. I have a few at home, so one is always close to me.
For 2 years I used it with a Broadlink IR hub.
Recently, thanks to Claude, I managed to use BLE to control the Flex. So far I’m very happy with the results.
The Philips Dial has 4 buttons (with double and long clicks), so you can program them as presets or sources or even lights like me.
The catch is that you need Home Assistant (a free smart home system) and an ESP32 module with BLE.
I’ve published the code on GitHub.

hue_dial.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom