• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Multichannel Recordings of Classical ♫ Music only | Tell us about the ones you fell for !

Scytales

Senior Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 17, 2020
Messages
437
Likes
867
Location
France
Hi everybody !

Why opening a thread dedicated to multichannel classical recordings? Because we are on a forum where people care about objectivity and perfection. Let's not forget that stereophonic sound was designed and perfected in the 1930s almost from its birth to be on more than 2 channels of recording and reproduction, and that throughout the following decades, many people in the field of classical music recording have striven to record and release albums in multichannel because they were well aware that multichannel audio is the way to improve accuracy and fidelity to the live experience.

In this first post, I am happy to introduced you with an album you will most probably not be able to get because of its scarcity, but will hopefully lead you to discover two musicians you perhaps never heard of, but are worth knowing:
51fBYnTQJfL.jpg


Jean Cras (1879-1932) is a French naval officer who composed music inspired by his experience of the sea.

His piano works are not in the same league as Chopin's, Rachmaninov's, Debussy's and others of the same caliber. They are nonetheless very enjoyable. These musical works are distinguished not so much by their melodic or rhythmic quality. There are more of the kind of ambient music. These are protean musical pieces, sometimes delicate and sometimes passionate, like the moving surface of the ocean in the open sea.

Jean Dubé is a talented French pianist with a discreet career that deserves more attention. Equally at ease with the works of the great classical repertoire as with entertainment music, he understands what he plays and knows how to find ways to highlight its qualities to help it touch the listener.

The album illustrated above is a rare two discs set, one DTS CD with the full original 5 front-end channels recording with 5 omnidirectional microphones and one CD with a standard 2.0 stereo soundtrack (only the two "inner" microphones are used). I am for myself not able to enjoy this album in its full fledged 5 channels version for I still have only a 3 channels Hi-fi system. Nevertheless, to listen to this album in 3 channels make a better incarnation of the sheer size, power and sound envelope of a grand piano. The tactile presence of the instrument and its ability to fill an acoustic space in a three dimensional perspective are already much better than in only 2 channels stereo. Although the multichannel program is DTS coded (ie not lossless), when the pianist raise the dampers at the end of a piece, the resonances of the instrument continue for several seconds and then die away at a very low level. The perceptual coding therefore preserves enough finesse to not interfere to much with the musical restitution.

Your turn now !
 
Last edited:
1743077811376.png
1743077606060.png

1743077835307.png

These three of the roughly 200 multichannel SACDs stand out, not only for their sound, but their performances as well. The Bach is infectious (and can create an ear worm). The Dvorak offers some of the best orchestral sound I have heard, and the Handel is quite delightful.
 
I had to say I have to check the meaning of the word 'earworm' I suspected it was an idiosyncratic expression, because I didn't know it.

I have learnt the meaning for my relief ! :)
 
...Why opening a thread dedicated to multichannel classical recordings? Because we are on a forum where people care about objectivity and perfection...
You don't have to convince me. My ears tell me all I need to know about multi-channel classical (and other genre) recordings. Here is one that I find myself playing quite often on the setup (link provided):

71CqtxLjLuL._SL1205_[1].jpg

These compositions by Respighi are, of course, quite well known, and represent one of the most engaging examples of 20th-century Romantic music.. Highly recommended.

If you've got the setup to handle the scale of this recording, I've found that its fidelity far surpasses others of The Planets:

91IeRHCmUZL._SL1500_[1].jpg

No limiting (clipping) on this recording, and low levels of modulation distortion make this quite engaging and pleasant.

I've also found that any of Mari Kodama's Beethoven piano sonata recordings on multichannel SACD (there are several stretching back to the mid-2000s) by Pentatone Classics are excellent. I own six of these and play all of them quite often. I'm thinking about acquiring more of them. Some are available from private collections on Discogs, etc. Again, if your setup can handle the scale of these recordings, you will be experiencing these performances as if the pianist is in the room.

71nDEzINDxS._SL1429_[1].jpg


Chris
 
I don't have the knowledge to add anything here but I do want to link in member @Kal Rubinson who I'm sure can add much. He's about the most knowledgeable multich classical listener I'm aware of.
 
You don't have to convince me. My ears tell me all I need to know about multi-channel classical (and other genre) recordings. Here is one that I find myself playing quite often on the setup (link provided):

View attachment 439748

These compositions by Respighi are, of course, quite well known, and represent one of the most engaging examples of 20th-century Romantic music.. Highly recommended.

If you've got the setup to handle the scale of this recording, I've found that its fidelity far surpasses others of The Planets:

View attachment 439749

No limiting (clipping) on this recording, and low levels of modulation distortion make this quite engaging and pleasant.



Chris
Sounds interesting, The Planets is one of my favorites. I have this one on bluray and the visuals are very nice https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/The-Planets-an-HD-Odyssey-Blu-ray/70822/
 
Back
Top Bottom