Look, I am not in any hurry to jump on the MQA bandwagon myself. It is just not in my plans. Nor, do I need to convert anyone else to my viewpoint or anyone else's. Nor, do I endorse it or claim to have all the answers. I have even listened to it under reasonably, though not perfectly, controlled conditions. Frankly, it is not exciting enough for me in terms of sonic bliss creation. So, I will just remain on the sidelines, thanks.
I am just trying to remain somewhat objective. I think in order to do that, one needs to look at at understand the original premises, research papers and other documents supporting the idea, as well as counter arguments from credible sources. Those are not likely to be found directly in online forums, though their may be links to the more pertinent stuff - the news rather than the fake news. There is also plenty of marketing hype favoring it, much of it encouraging justified skepticism. Online postings by amateurs is often just speculation, at best, if it has not descended to far worse mob rule, as internet postings often do, even here.
So, if you have a burning desire to dig into it, avoid the tribal Internet chatter and go deeper yourself while trying to keep an open mind. I have tried to do this myself. If I were to align myself with any one point of view, right now I would say Amir comes closest to my own.
