Jimster480
Major Contributor
What a journey! I am glad that you figured out what was going on and are man enough to admit it. Takes a big person, honestly.UPDATE IN WHICH I EAT SOME TASTY CROW — well, I was basically full of sh*t. My second-to-last paragraph in my initial piece contains this: "The source audio was unbalanced consumer line-level stereo. I fed the M2 via TRS inputs (tip and sleeve only connected, ring floating)." The tip-off is "ring floating". I went round and round with MOTU tech support on whether TRS ring should float or not, with no guidance in any of their documentation on preferred connection of unbalanced source.
When I retested using Sound On Sound test files (https://www.soundonsound.com/techniques/sos-audio-test-files) and the input male TRS ring grounded, the frequency response and overall performance is completely different and entirely wonderful. Altogether a great piece of equipment! I apologize to anyone I confused or scared away from the MOTU M2.
Hats off to you