• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Most Beautiful Songs - 1960 - 1979

The first Reprise album by Gordon Lightfoot - originally "Sit Down Young Stranger", retitled "If You Could Read My Mind" when that track proved to be a hit - has some of the best arrangements of any of his albums. This track - "Approaching Lavender" - has a Randy Newman arrangement:


Speaking of Randy Newman, here's "Louisiana 1927":

 
Claus Ogerman (1930-2016) had a long a distinguished career as an arranger for multiple ensembles and record companies. In the 1970s he turned his attention to composing. This excerpt - "Air Antique" - comes from the "Gate of Dreams" album, 1979:

 
Joni's own recording of it is pretty sublime as well.
There's a great and very early (1966) live on TV version (that looks like a kinescope, but probably just a lowish-quality videotape) that's pretty amazing as well.


Sort of on the same subject, The Circle Game always generates some tear duct activity for me. Almost hard to believe that she wrote it for Neil Young as he reached adulthood!! :eek:
shivers
 
Bob Dylan's demo tape has its own kind of stark beauty. But Joan Baez' version of "Farewell Angelina" is prettier:

 
Cool.
I've been thinking, in full disclosure, about a couple of Dylan-penned odes for this thread ;)
 
Pentangle, live at the Royal Festival Hall, 1968 - Watch the Stars:

 
So I will offer two arguably* beautiful Dylan songs:

It's All Over Now, Baby Blue
This is a cover that I quite like, so I am sharing this.


Desolation Row Probably my favorite Dylan song after Tangled Up in Blue (which is kinda beautiful, too -- come to think of it)

bonus/runner up: Joanie singing Forever Young
 
Noel (Paul) Stookey's Wedding Song, written for Peter Yarrow's marriage to Mary Beth McCarthy (Eugene McCarthy's daughter) is beautiful.
1741210833665.png

 
Beauty in the eye / ear of the beholder and all, but the old Stan Rogers tunes still resonate with me.


Hard to believe it has been so many years since the fatal AC incident where he lost his life.
This put me to mind of Eric Andersen's Thirsty Boots. Very much of its time.
 
Stephen Stills... buddy of Peter Tork and Monkee wanna-be way back when... good ol' Stephen Stills has written or co-written a number of fine songs, many of which were beautiful in their own way (e.g., 4+20, Southern Cross).

I'd like to call out two beautiful songs -- that he recorded with two different bands -- which always seemed to me to be of a piece. The better known (probably) of the two, Suite Judy Blue Eyes was famously written for his sometime muse and partner Judy Collins.


I've always suspected that his earlier song Bluebird, recorded by Buffalo Springfield, was also about her -- or someone an awful lot like her.


Oh, and speaking of Ms Collins. Starting as a folkie in the early '60s, she seemed to incur a fair amount of ire over the years as kind of a low-rent Joan Baez, and she's derided for appropriating some other fine songwriters' songs in ways that (perhaps???) weren't entirely ethical (e.g., Leonard Cohen's Suzanne and maybe also Joni's Both Sides Now -- or so I have read). EDIT See posts below, I stand corrected :)
She did cover Ian Tyson's Someday Soon to good effect.


She also was responsible for a pretty darned nice cover of a beautiful John Lennon song (In My Life).



1741213546338.png
 
Last edited:
So I will offer two arguably* beautiful Dylan songs:

It's All Over Now, Baby Blue
This is a cover that I quite like, so I am sharing this.


Desolation Row Probably my favorite Dylan song after Tangled Up in Blue (which is kinda beautiful, too -- come to think of it)

bonus/runner up: Joanie singing Forever Young
"Jackass" a track from Beck's "Odelay", samples Them's cover of "It's All Over Now Baby Blue."
 
one more: Dylan plus Judy Collins -- I really like this one; used to sing it to my then infant daughter as a lullaby. Not sure she liked it, but I liked singing it to her. :)

 
Stephen Stills... buddy of Peter Tork and Monkee wanna-be way back when... good ol' Stephen Stills has written or co-written a number of fine songs, many of which were beautiful in their own way (e.g., 4+20, Southern Cross).

I'd like to call out two beautiful songs -- that he recorded with two different bands -- which always seemed to me to be of a piece. The better known (probably) of the two, Suite Judy Blue Eyes was famously written for his sometime muse and partner Judy Collins.


I've always suspected that his earlier song Bluebird, recorded by Buffalo Springfield, was also about her -- or someone an awful lot like her.


Oh, and speaking of Ms Collins. Starting as a folkie in the early '60s, she seemed to incur a fair amount of ire over the years as kind of a low-rent Joan Baez, and she's derided for appropriating some other fine songwriters' songs in ways that (perhaps???) weren't entirely ethical (e.g., Leonard Cohen's Suzanne and maybe also Joni's Both Sides Now -- or so I have read)... She did cover Ian Tyson's Someday Soon to good effect.


She also was responsible for a pretty darned nice cover of a beautiful John Lennon song (In My Life).



View attachment 433572
Judy Collins is first and foremost a song interpreter, so I don't question the ethics of her singing songs written by other people. She was one of the first to recognize the Genius of Randy Newman (I Think It's Gonna Rain Today"):


Speaking of Randy Newman, here's "Marie" from "Good Old Boys":

 
Judy Collins is first and foremost a song interpreter, so I don't question the ethics of her singing songs written by other people. She was one of the first to recognize the Genius of Randy Newman (I Think It's Gonna Rain Today"):


Speaking of Randy Newman, here's "Marie" from "Good Old Boys":

She is indeed, and a priori, of course, there's nothing wrong with that.
Ahem. Spurred by your post, I just quickly fact-checked my own memories of reading of some skullduggery around both Suzanne & Both Sides Now and I cannot find any support for my recollections, so I shall recant them! Will edit the earlier post to (mostly) de-snark it.

I like Judy Collins quite a bit, in fact. :)
 
Back
Top Bottom