• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

miniDSP Tide16 - Holy Grail with 16 Channel Atmos/DTS:X, high SINAD

He said "Thanks." Also, last night, he said that it was quite remarkable and that his wife said, unprompted, that the sound was better than ever. (I am not kidding.)
The good old "Even my wife noticed the difference from the kitchen"

That is the ultimate benchmark of sonic nirvana.
 
The good old "Even my wife noticed the difference from the kitchen"

That is the ultimate benchmark of sonic nirvana.
ROTFL,, and the hits just keep on coming. :p
 
That is why it could go in a museum collection.
I hope it doesn't end up in the museum. LOL JK
Beauty is in the eye and all that. My Marantz AV20 looks just like I expected, a Classic Marantz Porthole design. ;)
 
You are right. I assume. And we all know what that means…
It's a known fact and confirmed by our resident Dirac rep both here and over at AVS. Granted the number of us who own at least one SW far outweighs those who don't but that's how the licensing works if you happen to be "SW-less".

"What are the requirements for using ART?

  • You need an ART-certified AVR or stereo receiver, a Dirac Live license with the ART add-on, the Dirac Live application on a Windows PC or Mac, and an omnidirectional measurement microphone. If using subwoofers, a Bass Control license is also required."
 
vs u
The good old "Even my wife noticed the difference from the kitchen"

That is the ultimate benchmark of sonic nirvana.
Yep, no wonder objectivists tend to emphasize the need for DBT, and for me even SBT can tell a lot.;)
 
It's a known fact and confirmed by our resident Dirac rep both here and over at AVS. Granted the number of us who own at least one SW far outweighs those who don't but that's how the licensing works if you happen to be "SW-less".

"What are the requirements for using ART?

  • You need an ART-certified AVR or stereo receiver, a Dirac Live license with the ART add-on, the Dirac Live application on a Windows PC or Mac, and an omnidirectional measurement microphone. If using subwoofers, a Bass Control license is also required."
What I meant was, you are correct that I made an assumption, and it would have been better if I had not made an assumption. I was not questioning the veracity of your statement.
 
You don’t need DLBC if you don’t own SWs (RC -> ART).
That is a bit of an extreme position that I didn't follow ???
Room sound modes start around below 300hz creating small to very large peaks and valleys in the frequency response.
Most any stand-alone speaker"s sound can be improved at the MLP from some sort of DRC in the bass.
DLBC and most other DRC also offer some form of crossover app to tweak good integration of subs but that's another issue altogether ?
 
That is a bit of an extreme position that I didn't follow ???
Room sound modes start around below 300hz creating small to very large peaks and valleys in the frequency response.
Most any stand-alone speaker"s sound can be improved at the MLP from some sort of DRC in the bass.
DLBC and most other DRC also offer some form of crossover app to tweak good integration of subs but that's another issue altogether ?
@EWL5 made that point because if you do Not have subs, you can, for example, upgrade an HTP-1 to ART for $299 without purchasing bass control, thus saving $250 (bundle price for bass control plus ART is $549.)
 
@EWL5 made that point because if you do Not have subs, you can, for example, upgrade an HTP-1 to ART for $299 without purchasing bass control, thus saving $250 (bundle price for bass control plus ART is $549.)
Someone w/large speakers all around and no sub could completely skip paying for DLBC going from DL RC to ART. Not sure how much clearer I can be on this point...
 
Someone w/large speakers all around and no sub could completely skip paying for DLBC going from DL RC to ART. Not sure how much clearer I can be on this point...

Out of curiosity, if you do this, what options do you have for how the LFE (the ".1" content) gets rendered?
 
Out of curiosity, if you do this, what options do you have for how the LFE (the ".1" content) gets rendered?
For most AVRs, I believe the LFE gets redirected to any speakers that are "Large".
 
For most AVRs, I believe the LFE gets redirected to any speakers that are "Large".
Ah yes, of course.

I understand that the LFE channel is supposed to be played 10dB louder than the normal channels. Does this mean that such a system must allow an additional 10dB for LFE putput? Therefore the normal channels can only play back at up to -10dB?

Or could headroom be even further constrained because the system must allow for the potential of full range content on LFE and the normal channel simultaneously?


Edit: Here is an excerpt of Google Gemini's answer to the above:
Google Gemini said:
When you configure an AVR with no subwoofer and force it to redirect the LFE (Low Frequency Effects) channel to "Large" main speakers, digital headroom becomes a massive constraint.

To prevent digital clipping (exceeding 0 dBFS), the AVR's DSP (Digital Signal Processor) must apply digital attenuation to the signals before summing them.

If the AVR simply allowed full-scale main signals (0 dBFS) and full-scale LFE signals (+10dB relative to mains) to mix without protection, the signal would instantly clip and distort horribly. To counteract this, most AVRs will automatically attenuate the main channels and the LFE channel internally when "No Subwoofer" is selected.

The Reality: The system doesn't necessarily lock your volume knob from going higher, but it lowers the internal digital ceiling. To achieve the same acoustic volume as a system with a subwoofer, you will have to turn the master volume knob significantly higher, pushing your physical amplifiers much closer to their limits.

When mixed together perfectly in-phase, the combined signal requires roughly 12 to 14dB of digital headroom reduction to guarantee zero digital clipping.


Would this then lead to a corresponding reduction in potential SINAD of 12-14dB?

Google Gemini said:
Yes, this digital attenuation can lead to a corresponding reduction in the system's effective SINAD (Signal-to-Noise and Distortion ratio), though where and how that degradation happens depends on how you compensate for the volume loss.

Here is the breakdown of how a 12–14 dB headroom reduction compromises your gain structure and degrades your real-world SINAD.

1. The Digital Domain: Quantization Noise

In the purely digital domain (inside the DSP), lowering the signal by 14 dB technically reduces the dynamic range.

Modern AVRs (24-bit or 32-bit processing): A 24-bit audio stream has a theoretical dynamic range of 144 dB. If the DSP attenuates the signal by 14 dB, the remaining dynamic range is still around 130 dB.

The Verdict: Because the digital noise floor (quantization noise) is so incredibly low, the reduction in digital SINAD is negligible. The digital bits themselves aren't the bottleneck.

2. The DAC Domain: The Fixed Noise Floor

The real trouble begins at the Digital-to-Analog Converter (DAC). Every DAC has a fixed analog noise floor (thermal noise, circuit design limitations).

If a DAC has a maximum output of 2V RMS and a SINAD of 100 dB at full scale (0 dBFS), it means its noise and distortion sit 100 dB below that 2V signal.

When the AVR's DSP permanently attenuates the incoming signal by 14 dB to prevent clipping during LFE peaks, the maximum signal level ever reaching that DAC drops significantly. * Your highest-amplitude musical peaks now exit the DAC at roughly -14 dBFS instead of 0 dBFS.

Because the DAC's analog noise floor remains completely stationary, your signal has moved 14 dB closer to the noise.

The Verdict: At the DAC stage, your effective Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) and SINAD drop by up to 12 to 14 dB.

3. The Amplifier Domain: The Double Whammy

To get back the acoustic volume you lost from that 14 dB digital cut, you have to turn up the AVR’s master volume knob. This introduces two major blows to amplifier SINAD:

A. Amplifying the Upstream Noise

If the master volume control is analog (positioned after the DAC), turning it up amplifies the now-higher-noise signal coming out of the DAC. If the master volume is digital (positioned before the DAC), you are simply turning up the digital signal back toward the clipping point, which defeats the purpose unless the AVR uses a sophisticated hybrid volume array. In most consumer AVRs, you are simply amplifying a compromised signal-to-noise ratio.

B. Increased Distortion (THD)

Your main channel amplifiers are now being forced to do heavy lifting. They aren't just playing vocals and guitars; they are simultaneously trying to reproduce a massive 30 Hz explosion from the LFE channel.

As an amplifier approaches its maximum voltage and current limits to drive those massive low-frequency waves, its Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) spikes dramatically.

Setting speakers to "Large" with "No Subwoofer" doesn't just put physical strain on your woofers; it forces a massive compromise in the gain structure of the AVR, ultimately dragging down the real-world SINAD of your entire system.
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, of course.

I understand that the LFE channel is supposed to be played 10dB louder than the normal channels. Does this mean that such a system must allow an additional 10dB for LFE putput? Therefore the normal channels can only play back at up to -10dB?

Or could headroom be even further constrained because the system must allow for the potential of full range content on LFE and the normal channel simultaneously?


Edit: Here is an excerpt of Google Gemini's answer to the above:
The LFE doesn’t work like that. Historically the LFE was recorded a level that was 10db lower than the other channels to provide an extra 10db of headroom before the recording itself clipped for transients.

For example let’s say we have an explosion that might be present in the unprocessed L+R signal at 90db but would be at 80db in the unprocessed LFE channel. The processor adds 10db of gain to the LFE to bring the output signal level back to 90db.

If we say the recording medium can cope with a full scale signal of 100db then that means on output we can have a transient of 100db in the L+R but 110db in the LFE. Obviously that means the quietest signal possible in the LFE is 10db higher than in the L+R but since LFE is mostly used for loud effects this is a good trade off.

This is done when before any bass management is applied.

It is assumed that the speaker system can cope with transients far in excess of those which can be represented on the recording medium.
 
The LFE doesn’t work like that. Historically the LFE was recorded a level that was 10db lower than the other channels to provide an extra 10db of headroom before the recording itself clipped for transients.

For example let’s say we have an explosion that might be present in the unprocessed L+R signal at 90db but would be at 80db in the unprocessed LFE channel. The processor adds 10db of gain to the LFE to bring the output signal level back to 90db.

If we say the recording medium can cope with a full scale signal of 100db then that means on output we can have a transient of 100db in the L+R but 110db in the LFE. Obviously that means the quietest signal possible in the LFE is 10db higher than in the L+R but since LFE is mostly used for loud effects this is a good trade off.

This is done when before any bass management is applied.

It is assumed that the speaker system can cope with transients far in excess of those which can be represented on the recording medium.

Please re-read. I was specifically talking about the case where the AVR is configured with no subwoofers and where the LFE content has to be added to the normal channels.

I.e. What happens if the source contains full range bass content simultaneously on LFE and L&R, but there are no subs to hand the LFE off to. There is no bass management, in the sense that there is no crossover of main content to the subs (because there aren't any).


For example let’s say we have an explosion that might be present in the unprocessed L+R signal at 90db but would be at 80db in the unprocessed LFE channel. The processor adds 10db of gain to the LFE to bring the output signal level back to 90db.
^ This part is correct for a system with subs, where bass content that is initially in the main channel gets bass managed to the LFE via the sub crossover. But it doesn't explain what happens if there is already full scale LFE content present in that channel.


The following is just me trying to make logical sense of this...

If you have subs you also have the option of subwoofer modes: LFE or LFE+Mains

In LFE Mode, all speakers Large:

Main and LFE channels can both play at full digital scale simultaneously. No pre-dac attenuation is needed. (LFE channel doesn't need to handle any bass managed content).

In LFE Mode, with Small speakers:
Bass management has to add content from main channels to LFE channel. Therefore pre-dac attenuation is needed.

In LFE+Main:

Regardless of Small or Large speaker setting, below sub crossover content from all channels is added to LFE. Therefore pre-dac attenuation is needed. (If speakers are set to large and can play full range then bass is duplicated on mains and LFE).

No Subs:
LFE content must be added to mains. Therefore pre-dac attenuation is needed.
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, of course.

I understand that the LFE channel is supposed to be played 10dB louder than the normal channels. Does this mean that such a system must allow an additional 10dB for LFE putput? Therefore the normal channels can only play back at up to -10dB?

Or could headroom be even further constrained because the system must allow for the potential of full range content on LFE and the normal channel simultaneously?


Edit: Here is an excerpt of Google Gemini's answer to the above:



Would this then lead to a corresponding reduction in potential SINAD of 12-14dB?
If you are using Dirac ART, and you have configured your filters correctly (i.e. following Dirac's instructions), all of this will be taken care of (sorry Gemini). If you are not using ART (or contemplating same), and you are not using the Tide 16 (or contemplating same), then you are definitely posting to the wrong thread.
 
Please re-read. I was specifically talking about the case where the AVR is configured with no subwoofers and where the LFE content has to be added to the normal channels.

I.e. What happens if the source contains full range bass content simultaneously on LFE and L&R, but there are no subs to hand the LFE off to. There is no bass management, in the sense that there is no crossover of main content to the subs (because there aren't any).
It makes no difference to the processing of the LFE channel. In a home setting the 10db offset is nothing to do with if you have subwoofers or not or any other speaker configuration and nothing to do with bass management including the LFE signal being sent to the L+R in the absence of a sub.

It is to do with the amount of headroom available on the input side between the nominal signal level and the maximum possible signal level.
 
Back
Top Bottom