• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Michi Prestige Q430 CD Player, and its $4,400 Fatal Flaw & Rotel's Bizarre Support

Do you read the driver’s manual front to back before buying a car?
If I were in that situation, and I could access the manual, yes I would, especially in this era when some of the car's features may be treated as a subscription item.
 
I tend to assume that if a function is not explicitly list in the spec, I'd probably not spend £50 until I'd done a bit of research. Like with a £200.000 car - until I know I'm going to fit into the thing, I'd not buy it.
 
My system is low budget. Player is LG. I do use REW/FF quite frequently when i buy audio cds of new music. (Recently it was Space Music). Very handy to evaluate songs. If i like the music of few portion in first two or three attempts, i listen the whole song. Then i keep the cd in my collection. I am surprised at this budget why they skipped such function. Infact at this price they should give more functions.
Regds.
 
Infact at this price they should give more functions.
At that price the target audience see functions as indicative of worse sound quality due to the 'noise' they think they add, and worse sound quality due to the budget being spent on functions and not on the sound. There's nothing rational about it but that's the High End.
 
I migth be so that drives aviable for CD players today also miss some basic functionality ? Who knows where they sourced the drive .

Manual? Ok for my car i would not check if the blinkers works for both ledt and rigth turns it sort of expected ;) same as ffwd and rrwd
This has absolutely nothing to do with the dedicated audio tray-loading drives available today; besides, there are only a handful of such drives left, and for the past 10 to 20 years, they have also been used in other players with more extensive feature sets.
Furthermore, a look inside the unit reveals that the control circuitry is located on the large board at the rear of the player and was developed entirely in-house by Rotel.

The audio drives used in this player—as well as in models like the Tascam CD-200, SMSL PL200(T), etc.—do not have integrated control systems.
They should not be confused with fully enclosed DVD or Blu-ray drives featuring integrated controllers, such as those found in other players. In those cases, developers are largely dependent on the drive's built-in functionality; modifying the firmware or control logic is only possible through the drive manufacturer and is very costly.
 
The owner's manual of the product in question here states quite clearly that there isn't a fast forwarding/rewind button:
It doesn't "state quite clearly" that at all. It tells you what it does, not what it doesn't do.
 
It doesn't "state quite clearly" that at all. It tells you what it does, not what it doesn't do.

That would make for *very* long owner's manuals, if everything that a product *doesn't* do were to be highlighted. Immensely impractical approach.

Owner's manuals always exclusively focus on what a product actually does, and how the owner can make it do that. That's that.
 
That would make for *very* long owner's manuals, if everything that a product *doesn't* do were to be highlighted. Immensely impractical approach.

Owner's manuals always exclusively focus on what a product actually does, and how the owner can make it do that. That's that.
It still doesn't "state quite clearly" that it doesn't have ff/rw.
 
This has absolutely nothing to do with the dedicated audio tray-loading drives available today; besides, there are only a handful of such drives left, and for the past 10 to 20 years, they have also been used in other players with more extensive feature sets.
Furthermore, a look inside the unit reveals that the control circuitry is located on the large board at the rear of the player and was developed entirely in-house by Rotel.

The audio drives used in this player—as well as in models like the Tascam CD-200, SMSL PL200(T), etc.—do not have integrated control systems.
They should not be confused with fully enclosed DVD or Blu-ray drives featuring integrated controllers, such as those found in other players. In those cases, developers are largely dependent on the drive's built-in functionality; modifying the firmware or control logic is only possible through the drive manufacturer and is very costly.

Aha , so it’s the same as my smls pl200t :)
 
It still doesn't "state quite clearly" that it doesn't have ff/rw.
Also, I don't think we can assume that just because it isn't in the manual, it doesn't exist in the product. Have you seen the manuals that come with home assistant electronics, for instance?
 
Thanks so much to everyone for your input. Apologies for being missing, but I've had an awful day and a half dealing with work and family matters (which obviously come first). I can't reply to every single post right now, but I'll catch up on everything you've written tomorrow.

Since I see there's still a bit of confusion on this point, I want to emphasize that getting a second remote wouldn't solve the issue. It is not a remote control problem, even though tech support fed me that absolute nonsense (which was completely ridiculous on every level) of telling me to just go buy another remote for a €4,000 piece of gear. The actual functionality to fast-forward or rewind within a track is missing; it simply hasn't been programmed in. And even though they acknowledge that the feature isn't there (and shoud be), they've told me they are not going to fix it. It's not just a matter of missing a button or two.

I'll post a more detailed reply tomorrow when things settle down. Cheers, everyone.
 
Thanks so much to everyone for your input. Apologies for being missing, but I've had an awful day and a half dealing with work and family matters (which obviously come first). I can't reply to every single post right now, but I'll catch up on everything you've written tomorrow.

Since I see there's still a bit of confusion on this point, I want to emphasize that getting a second remote wouldn't solve the issue. It is not a remote control problem, even though tech support fed me that absolute nonsense (which was completely ridiculous on every level) of telling me to just go buy another remote for a €4,000 piece of gear. The actual functionality to fast-forward or rewind within a track is missing; it simply hasn't been programmed in. And even though they acknowledge that the feature isn't there (and shoud be), they've told me they are not going to fix it. It's not just a matter of missing a button or two.

I'll post a more detailed reply tomorrow when things settle down. Cheers, everyone.
It could very well be a deliberate design decision. I remember that with early CD players, skipping or scanning in the middle of a track was often discouraged. The thinking was that it could trigger error interpolation, causing a loss of true bit accuracy, introduce PLL jitter while the mechanism re-synchronized potentially making the audio measurably worse. I got into the habit of always starting a track from the beginning.

None of those concerns would really apply to modern CD players, of course. But a quick look into the subject suggests that the behavior may still have practical reasons: it could reduce mechanical wear, preserve the stability of large RAM buffers, and avoid the electrical noise and vibration that can be generated when the servo motors have to work aggressively to reposition the laser.

So even if there is no longer an audible or bit accuracy advantage, the behavior may simply be a legacy of or a sensible precaution based on the way the hardware is designed.
 
The actual functionality to fast-forward or rewind within a track is missing; it simply hasn't been programmed in. And even though they acknowledge that the feature isn't there (and shoud be), they've told me they are not going to fix it. It's not just a matter of missing a button or two.
That's really unforgivable in a high-end player like this; this is a basic function that most people would assume is already present. It sounds as though Rotel just forgot, amazingly enough, to include this function. Even if it isn't something that can be fixed on the design of their remote, it should be included in the unit (with a discrete IR code to program another universal remote should someone want to). Rotel should fix this, although it's not clear if it even can be fixed with a firmware update, either in the component itself or especially on the remote. Kudos to Tommassio for warning other potential buyers of the shortcoming of this player.

[Edit] BTW, I am a fan of Rotel. Although I don't own any of their equipment presently, I almost bought the Rotel Michi P5 S2; it's a great stereo preamp.
 
Last edited:
It still doesn't "state quite clearly" that it doesn't have ff/rw.
Matter of perception. Whats obvious to some is obscure to others.
But it's utterly silly to say it should list everything it does NOT do. Come on.
 
Also, I don't think we can assume that just because it isn't in the manual, it doesn't exist in the product. Have you seen the manuals that come with home assistant electronics, for instance?
Manuals are legally binding. Huge difference. If it's in the manual, it must work. If it's not, you didn't inform yourself enough. Over.
 
It could very well be a deliberate design decision. I remember that with early CD players, skipping or scanning in the middle of a track was often discouraged. The thinking was that it could trigger error interpolation, causing a loss of true bit accuracy, introduce PLL jitter while the mechanism re-synchronized potentially making the audio measurably worse. I got into the habit of always starting a track from the beginning.

None of those concerns would really apply to modern CD players, of course. But a quick look into the subject suggests that the behavior may still have practical reasons: it could reduce mechanical wear, preserve the stability of large RAM buffers, and avoid the electrical noise and vibration that can be generated when the servo motors have to work aggressively to reposition the laser.

So even if there is no longer an audible or bit accuracy advantage, the behavior may simply be a legacy of or a sensible precaution based on the way the hardware is designed.
Nah, really not. Marketing coming into the way of proper engineering, maybe.

Or ultimate laziness.
 
That would make for *very* long owner's manuals, if everything that a product *doesn't* do were to be highlighted. Immensely impractical approach.
My Fermi estimate is that the manuals would be infinitely long in that case.
Impractical indeed.
:)
 
At that price point, why not go for the matching Technics SL-G700M2?

I know, this is the mere 700 series instead of the 1000 series of your amp but it would even add SACD support.

technics-sl-g700-en-su-g700-zilver[1].jpg
 
I want to make it clear my objection here was never about the cost. It's about assuming a certain price point automatically buys you an extensive feature set. Especially in high end audio, we know that's seldom the case.

I don't even remember if my Accuphase DP-65v had ff/frw...
 
Back
Top Bottom