• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Mechano23 Open-source DIY Speaker Review

Rate this speaker:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 5 1.1%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 54 11.8%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 398 87.1%

  • Total voters
    457
How would these compare to KEF Q1 Meta?

Q1 Meta​
Mechano23​
Sensitivity86dB85dB
Impedance4 ohms4 ohms
F365.1 Hz77.6 Hz
F647.6 Hz55.7 Hz

TEMP Comparison.png
 
Does anyone have a wiring diagram for wiring the passive radiators to the crossovers? Do you just wire them to the same location that you wire the woofers to the crossovers at?

Sorry if it's a dumb question. Wiring is obviously not my strong suit.

Thanks
 
Do you just wire them to the same location that you wire the woofers to the crossovers at?
It's even easier than that. A passive radiator has no wires (or coil), it reacts to the pressure in the cabinet.
EDIT: One could say it is a wireless device.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the answer. Just what I needed to know. Going to order the PR and weights. I guess I will drill holes in the weights until it drops down to 16ish grams
 
Thanks for the answer. Just what I needed to know. Going to order the PR and weights. I guess I will drill holes in the weights until it drops down to 16ish grams

I just used some washers and nuts to find a combo that added up to the weight I wanted.
 
I might try that. Thanks for the tip.
A passive radiator is basically equivalent to a port. It has mass and elasticity from the air behind it and the suspension. A port has mass and elasticity. By changing the weights you're changing the frequency it wants to resonate, just like changing the size or length of the port tube.

However whereas a port tube spits out turbulent gusts of air out of a small area, a passive radiator has a nice big diaphragm and a construction not unlike a high quality woofer, so they produce a lot less noise and can play louder without getting weird.

Anything else is a compromise.
 
20260225_104042.jpg
20260225_104118.jpg
20260124_121304.jpg


I know I'm late to this party but this speaker build project has been on my bucket list for awhile.

Cost was about $400.
Drivers (from Madisound) - $185
Crossover parts (from Solen) - $135 (includes $35 tariff)
Wood and veneer (free, left over from previous project)
Misc parts (bass port tube, bindings posts, glue, etc.) – (~$70)

Initial impression of sound is good. I'll need to live with them for a few weeks to get a feel for them.

Many thanks to XMechanik and Amir and all who commented and contributed. I read and used each and every post.
 
Good going with the build! Looks great! I always feel so proud after a build and every time I look it.
 
Hello everyone! I ordered the crossover parts from Parts Express for the standard circuit and the lower distortion add-on. I am planning on 3d printing the port or buying passive radiators from Madisound (I have not ordered the drivers yet). With the lower distortion from the additional circuit, is it worth it to get the passive radiators?

I am leaning towards the PRs because of concerns over chuffing. I am going to use these as my LR in my college dorm room movie setup to replace some Goodwill speakers, and plan to use these for a long time.

Additionally, would it matter if the PRs are on the back or side? I think the back would look better but side would be good if I need to put them nearly against a wall, like on a desk, for instance.

Any help is appreciated. I am very excited to build these speakers, and thanks XMechanik for your excellent design.
 
Hello everyone! I ordered the crossover parts from Parts Express for the standard circuit and the lower distortion add-on. I am planning on 3d printing the port or buying passive radiators from Madisound (I have not ordered the drivers yet). With the lower distortion from the additional circuit, is it worth it to get the passive radiators?

I am leaning towards the PRs because of concerns over chuffing. I am going to use these as my LR in my college dorm room movie setup to replace some Goodwill speakers, and plan to use these for a long time.

Additionally, would it matter if the PRs are on the back or side? I think the back would look better but side would be good if I need to put them nearly against a wall, like on a desk, for instance.

Any help is appreciated. I am very excited to build these speakers, and thanks XMechanik for your excellent design.
If you have the opportunity to create a curved slot port, give it a try. This allows for a turbulence-optimized design—see #9 in @Maartenovic 's thread:
Screenshot_2026-07-31_174029.291.jpg
 
Hello everyone! I ordered the crossover parts from Parts Express for the standard circuit and the lower distortion add-on. I am planning on 3d printing the port or buying passive radiators from Madisound (I have not ordered the drivers yet). With the lower distortion from the additional circuit, is it worth it to get the passive radiators?

I am leaning towards the PRs because of concerns over chuffing. I am going to use these as my LR in my college dorm room movie setup to replace some Goodwill speakers, and plan to use these for a long time.

Additionally, would it matter if the PRs are on the back or side? I think the back would look better but side would be good if I need to put them nearly against a wall, like on a desk, for instance.

Any help is appreciated. I am very excited to build these speakers, and thanks XMechanik for your excellent design.

While there have been some interesting projects in the diy space to optimize ports, I dont think they'll ever be as chuff free as a PR. I have mechano23 with the 5x8 sb pr, and it lets me get away with bass boosts that would most certainly drive a port to very audible chuffing.

Ive mostly moved away from ports. PR's sound better to me, the lack of upper resonances is a big benefit for me. Sometimes I play piano or mix music through my speakers. With piano and kick drums the upper resonances are really obvious and annoying.

I put my PR on the back because anything else looks visually wrong to me.

Its diy, just splurge for the pr. My mechano23 will be with me for as long as the cones keep moving and Im glad I went with a PR.
 
Hello everyone! I ordered the crossover parts from Parts Express for the standard circuit and the lower distortion add-on. I am planning on 3d printing the port or buying passive radiators from Madisound (I have not ordered the drivers yet). With the lower distortion from the additional circuit, is it worth it to get the passive radiators?

I am leaning towards the PRs because of concerns over chuffing. I am going to use these as my LR in my college dorm room movie setup to replace some Goodwill speakers, and plan to use these for a long time.

Additionally, would it matter if the PRs are on the back or side? I think the back would look better but side would be good if I need to put them nearly against a wall, like on a desk, for instance.

Any help is appreciated. I am very excited to build these speakers, and thanks XMechanik for your excellent design.
I feel that ports always contribute their resonances in the midrange, so after trying two passive rad vs port comparisons, I'm leaning towards passive radiators if such possibility exists.
 
Thanks everyone for your input. I was also planning on using them as monitors for my Numa X Piano GT and I think the PRs are the way to go if I want to make the piano sounds sound real, as @LiveTek
was saying. 80 bucks to remove the remaining flaws with the speakers doesn't sound like a bad deal to me, especially because I'm planning to use these long term.

Is the SB15SFCR-00 the best candidate for this? How do I attach the mass to it in a way that it won't accidentally disconnect? I have a few various washers and a grinder / files but I'm not sure what the most future-proof approach is.

I am also worried about leaving my driver's completely unprotected. I'm thinking of making some grills out of something like this (picture attached) and some accoustically transparent cloth... Just so if one of my roommates bumps into it, it doesn't collapse inward. I think the material is thin enough to minimize comb filtering and more structurally sound than a 3d printed alternative. The speakers will likely get some sun and I am a bit worried about 3d printed parts getting deformed in the heat and humidity.

If someone has a recommendation for accoustically -transparent cloth, I would really appreciate it. I am not fully sold on black grilles and might get a more vibrant color but do not know of a good supplier that is easy to order from and at a college kid budget.

Thanks!
1000027844.png
 
Thanks everyone for your input. I was also planning on using them as monitors for my Numa X Piano GT and I think the PRs are the way to go if I want to make the piano sounds sound real, as @LiveTek
was saying. 80 bucks to remove the remaining flaws with the speakers doesn't sound like a bad deal to me, especially because I'm planning to use these long term.

Is the SB15SFCR-00 the best candidate for this? How do I attach the mass to it in a way that it won't accidentally disconnect? I have a few various washers and a grinder / files but I'm not sure what the most future-proof approach is.

I am also worried about leaving my driver's completely unprotected. I'm thinking of making some grills out of something like this (picture attached) and some accoustically transparent cloth... Just so if one of my roommates bumps into it, it doesn't collapse inward. I think the material is thin enough to minimize comb filtering and more structurally sound than a 3d printed alternative. The speakers will likely get some sun and I am a bit worried about 3d printed parts getting deformed in the heat and humidity.

If someone has a recommendation for accoustically -transparent cloth, I would really appreciate it. I am not fully sold on black grilles and might get a more vibrant color but do not know of a good supplier that is easy to order from and at a college kid budget.

Thanks!
View attachment 548634
Get oval race track from SB if possible. You always want larger surface of passive rad than woofer to keep distortions low. BUT, try modeling the freq extension in Vituix. I have no idea if Mechanik measured the T/S, I think he did (usually they differ from what manufacturers publish in their data, also check https://www.audioexcite.com/?page_id=4018
The NRXC T/S can be used since it uses the same suspension, voice coil, just different cone). You will have input data into Enclosure module and save it. Then choose the passive rad and input the radiator data. See which rad works best for the volume of your enclosure. You can add mass to the rad, 6mm metric thread common in cars, motorcycles to fasten the additional washer(s). Good luck
 
would rounding the front edges improve any measured characteristic

Recent YouTube tests, for a 3 way project video, showed little difference in the FR curve between rounded and not rounded edges on tweeter and mid frequencies.

Perhaps a larger rounded edge might make more of a difference.
 
Hi !
I think I've started this project 18 months ago... and decided to finish it this week.

Wood part is finished, crossover has to be soldered.

And I have a soldering question.

I've glued every parts on the crossover.
But as I was cutting the wires behind the PCB, I've realised that I've cut all the metallic (greyà part of one of the inductors.
The only wire I can solder now is the copper part.

Can I solder the copper ending ?
I've used a pair of cissors to scratch the potential enamel, quickly burnt it with a match, but it stays with its copper color.


Many thanks
 

Attachments

  • 20261112_204931.jpg
    20261112_204931.jpg
    159.4 KB · Views: 12
  • 20261112_204922.jpg
    20261112_204922.jpg
    308.6 KB · Views: 13
Back
Top Bottom