• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Master Thread: Are Measurements Everything or Nothing?

IMO this is extremely outdated at least in the world of rock and pop music. Virtually every artist under 40 started out making bedroom recordings and has hands-on experience recording and mixing their own music, even if they're now at a level where they (or their label) can pay someone else to do it. Most contemporary artists are involved in the mixing and mastering process and engage with intent in these areas.

My experience with classical musicians is they're typically totally ignorant of how to make a recording, though, so it may well hold up in that world.
^ This. It also applies to many musicians over 40, btw. Times are changing and people's general understanding of matters they are interested in is much better today, mostly thanks to accessible and affordable resources, now including AI.
 
I work mostly in the adjacent progressive rock and metal scene and it's similar. People have their shit together, are professional, and put on great shows. Modern live rock concerts sound 1000x better than they used to as well thanks to a combination of people using amp modelers going straight into the soundboard instead of stacks of amps on stage, and sound guys running room correction.
Where do you stand on amp modelers? So many guitar purists are holdouts. They seem like a touring godsend to me.
 
^ This. It also applies to many musicians over 40, btw. Times are changing and people's general understanding of matters they are interested in is much better today, mostly thanks to accessible and affordable resources, now including AI.
Yes, and they have quickly learnt how to create DR3-4 recordings.
 
^ This. It also applies to many musicians over 40, btw. Times are changing and people's general understanding of matters they are interested in is much better today, mostly thanks to accessible and affordable resources, now including AI.
Classical recording has the impossible task of capturing live unamplified instruments.

I’d like to ask the forum a question I don’t know the answer to.

Can anyone produce a recording of a male speaking voice that sounds like a person in the room?

I have heard this is in a binaural recording played back over headphones, but never over speakers.

I sent a number of years being lectured on singing technique by a guy whe recorded with Robert Shaw. What I took away is that a trained singing voice is quite different from a speaking voice.

Our brains are wired to discern the identity of people by their voice, we hear things that we simply ignore in other sound sources.
 
Last edited:
Where do you stand on amp modelers? So many guitar purists are holdouts. They seem like a touring godsend to me.
I love them. I use a Headrush Core, the other guitarist in my band uses a Neural DSP Quad Cortex. Fifteen-twenty years ago when they were first coming on the scene they were definitely a step back, but the good modelers by NeuralDSP, ToneX, Headrush, etc. being made over the past few years - I don't think anyone could tell the difference on record, and live, they sound better than the real thing for the reasons I mentioned before. There's no fighting between stage sound and room sound, sound guys has direct control over levels and ability to room correct, which really makes the sound in the venue better.

Bands go on tour now with just a little UHaul trailer for their drums instead of a whole second bus for all their stacks of amps - it's fantastic. Setup is a lot faster too. It also, and this is a much bigger matter than it might seem, makes it a hell of a lot easier to fit a 5-6 person band on a relatively small bar stage. Giving musicians the ability to move around a bit on stage without being wedged between a Marshall stack and a giant bass amp makes the whole performance better.
 
Modelers are fantastic, especially with NAM2 models now being extremely cheap to adopt.

Apart from what @SuicideSquid mentioned, they solve a common guitarists problem "how do I get a screaming Marshall sound in this small venue". Now (I imagine) you just run load a cranked Marshall profile at comfortable monitoring levels, EQ to taste (acc. to equal-hearing curves), use your favourite mic IRs to that you known well and used on the records and you're off to the races (perhaps with an FRFR with lots of clean headroom) with completely no problems whatsoever... But I am not gigging, maybe the mojo just isn't there?
 
Last edited:
Where do you stand on amp modelers? So many guitar purists are holdouts. They seem like a touring godsend to me.
I don't use modelers but a very small analog "pedal" amp and a small 1x12 cab for touring. The days of hauling around my Marshall tops an 4x12 cabs are over.
 
Some recording companies (eg Telarc) use minimal miking and processing, and those are the recordings that I prefer.
I remember Chesky Records used to claim their mic and recording techniques were supposed to provide the most realistic "live" sound.

David Chesky is still at it. I've listened to some of the new recordings, which sound good, but I'm not sure I buy their Mega-Dimensional Sound™ hype. Haven't tried listening through headphones, though.
 
I'm reluctant to play without a stage amp unless I can have my own in-ear monitoring with full control over it.
Guthrie Govan switched to an effects/modeler (Fractal, I think?) a few years ago. He seems to like it for touring but did say he likes having an amp blasting behind him. His clean sounds are still great, IMO.
 
The science I accept is Floyd Toole's own interpretation of his own data
Here is Floyd Toole's own interpretation of his own data, in a comment which he said is his "final word" on the subject. I completely agree with this statement by Floyd Toole:
Sighted evaluations introduce the possibility that opinions will be biased by non-auditory factors. The extent of the bias depends on the nature and importance of the non-auditory factors to the individual listeners.
https://www.audiosciencereview.com/...r-audio-luminaries.62951/page-74#post-2489322
 
I ran an interesting measurement and tweaks of WiiM PEQ and my sub LPF / Phase in my audio setup and dedicated home office and listening room. I was already very happy with sound, even before tweaks, to start with - in terms of sound balance, available headroom, ultimate transparency, linearity and virtually unlimited power and current delivery capacity ... but these additionally improved the overall enjoyment of my music listening sessions

My main hi-fi audio chain

1. Mac Mini - Roon server core
2. WiiM Plus Pro streamer - Roon endpoint
3. Benchmark DAC3 B - DAC, in fully open voltage mode
4. Benchmark LA4 - preamplifier
5. Buckeye 1ET9040BA - Purifi Eigentakt, class D mono blocks (in LOW GAIN mode)
6. Neat Acoustics Motive 1 - 2.5 way floor standing speakers, 86 db sensitivity
7. SVS SB-1000 Pro - subwoofer, 30cm in front of the main speakers, firing into the room, its back panel is 50-60cm away from the wall

Connectivity
1. WiiM Plus Pro to Benchmark DAC3 B - Toslink optical
2. LA4 to SVS SB-1000 Pro subwoofer is RCA
3. All other - XLR connections

Room
In this case the room measures approximately:
• Width: 3 metres
• Length: 6 to 7 metres
• Height: 2.5 to 3 metres

My Current Setup
WiiM PEQ
PK Filter 1 at 32Hz, Gain -9db, Q=5
PK Filter 2 at 57Hz, Gain -1db, Q=4
PK Fliter 3 at 130Hz, Gain -1db, Q=5

SVS SB-1000 Pro sub
Volume at -10 db
LPF at 40 Hz
Phase at 0 deg

In Room REW RTA Measurement With Real Music Played Through This Audio System, 10K+ samples

1793755978572.png


The REW RTA graph above with 10,000+ averages maps out the room's exact physical geometry signatures, with Benchmark LA4 volume set to -30dB. It seems to be highlighting what acoustic engineers call geometric boundary nulls (destructive phase cancellations)

These dips are caused by sound bouncing off the walls, floor, and ceiling, then colliding at the listenning seat, somewhat out of phase—meaning they may not be able to be fixed with further EQ tweaks.

The good news is that my system seems to be handling them relatively nicely:

1. The 32–35 Hz Null (Sub-Bass Cancel)
  • What it is: This is a longitudinal room mode cancellation. As the deep sub-bass from the SVS sub travels the length of the room and bounces off the back wall, it meets the incoming wave exactly 180 degrees out of phase at the listening position.
  • Why it's a blessing in disguise: Because the room naturally wants to ring aggressively at 32Hz, this localized null actually helps prevent the sub-bass from turning into an endless, muddy drone. By locking the filter back at -9.0 dB, setup seems to be preventing the adjacent 25Hz peak from inflating, keeping the sub-bass fast and incredibly well-behaved and properly tamed.
2. The 75–80 Hz Null (The Floor Bounce / Front Wall Cancel)
  • What it is: This sharp canyon is a classic boundary cancellation. It is caused by the mid-bass waves bouncing off the hardwood floor and reflecting off the wall directly behind the Neat floorstanders?
  • Why ears don't care: Human hearing is remarkably insensitive to narrow, razor-sharp drop-offs. Because the frequencies directly to the left (60–70Hz slam) and right (90–120Hz punch) are perfectly flat and phase-aligned, the brain completely "fills in the blank," ensuring kick drums and bass guitars retain all their physical impact
3. The 180–220 Hz Null (The Desktop / Side-Wall Cancel)
  • What it is: This wider, shallower valley lives right at the transition from upper bass into the lower midrange. This is almost always caused by a closer, secondary reflection—such as potentially sound bouncing off a nearby side wall, the surface of a coffee table, or the front chassis edges of the audio gear rack.
  • Why it is perfectly fine: the floor of this dip stays up near 40–42 dB, making it much shallower than the deeper low-end nulls. Because it is a soft, wide dip rather than a sharp spike, it acts as a natural separator between the heavy punch of the rhythm section and the clarity of vocals. It actually keeps the lower midrange from sounding thick, chesty, or boxy.

The Ultimate Takeaway
Every single listening room in the world has similar nulls, depending on its own dimensions — even multi-million dollar professional studios. The mark of a world-class system isn't having an absolutely straight line on a graph; it is actually about ability to tame and control the destructive peaks (like the 32Hz mode above) while keeping the overall frequency envelope as flat and as uniform as possible from 40Hz all the way to 20kHz. The long-term average is sitting beautifully at 65.3 dB C / 61.4 dB A.

I am very happy listener indeed and now I have some kind of a 'scientific proof' ha ha ;)
 
Last edited:
There's plenty of documented evidence that it's not folklore, and there's one man's claim that it is. I welcome any evidence to substantiate that claim.
Sounds like Toole’s right, at least Gemini agrees with him, so I asked for references:

1793759883677.png
 
Here is Floyd Toole's own interpretation of his own data, in a comment which he said is his "final word" on the subject. I completely agree with this statement by Floyd Toole:

https://www.audiosciencereview.com/...r-audio-luminaries.62951/page-74#post-2489322
Great. It backs up everything I have been saying, as the actual statement he wrote immediately after "let my final word be", was:-
The factors influencing opinions formed in all listening tests involve acoustical and non-acoustical factors. Controlling the auditory factors is difficult. Comparisons require equal loudness, rapid changes, and positional substitutions if room effects are to be normalized. When this is done in double-blind fashion there are decades of results showing usefully reliable opinions from hundreds of listeners of all backgrounds.
The experts have spoken and in agreement with one another, not with you:-

- The critical factor is that the listening tests must be blind or double-blind - sighted tests cannot be trusted. - Floyd Toole Link

- If you want to obtain an accurate and reliable measure of how the audio product truly sounds, the listening test must be done blind. - Sean Olive https://seanolive.blogspot.com/2009/04/

From the perspective of sound quality, I would trust my interpretation of a “spinorama” presentation of anechoic measurements more than my subjective judgment in a typical consumer listening circumstance. - Floyd Toole Link

I have done many blind tests, way too many, sometimes it seems, but it's the only way to accurately establish an audible difference, even of differences described as "large" or "obvious". - James D Johnson Link

What humans are really good at is incorporating all senses. Even when they don't want to be, or are trying not to be. - James D Johnson Link

Let me finish with Dr Toole’s own published words when discussing the results of the test that you have presented without context: “Again, it seems that the listeners had their minds made up by what they saw and were not in a mood to change, even if the sound required it. The effect is not subtle.

"Summarizing, it is clear that knowing the identities of the loudspeakers under test can change subjective ratings.

  • They can change the ratings to correspond to presumed capabilities of the product, based on price, size, or reputation.
  • So strong is that attachment of “perceived” sound quality to the identity of the product that in sighted tests, listeners substantially ignored easily audible problems associated with loudspeaker location in the room and interactions with different programs.
"These findings mean that if one wishes to obtain candid opinions about how a loudspeaker sounds, the tests must be done blind.” (his emphasis)

And my corrections, to your misunderstanding of the data in his book, stand.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like Toole’s right, at least Gemini agrees with him, so I asked for references:

View attachment 569270
First, Gemini is not reliable. Second, you posted a quote supporting Telarc's "pioneering mainstream purist and minimalist techniques" which contradicts Toole's claim, so I'm not sure why you declared him "right". If those supposed sources (LLMs make up sources entirely sometimes, and other times misrepresent what's in them) can be reviewed by a forum member, that would actually be useful.
 
Lets talk when you actually know what your talking about. One of the most often mentioned testing at ASR is the SUBJECTIVE speaker research done by Dr Toole where people used ONLY there ears, not like you guys, to find preferences. Offer some blind test results to prove you can even hear a difference and you might have a point but I doubt that will happen because your afraid you cant hear shit and that would prove it.
lol, ok... right...
 
I think you’ve nailed the fundamental problem with subjectivists. They believe human perception trumps technology.

Find me a microbiologist that refuses to use a microscope or an astronomer without a telescope. We can meet up at a hifi showroom.
Human perception is human experience, by definition. Technology is subservient, which is counter to prevailing asr attitude
 
Back
Top Bottom