• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Master Thread: Are Measurements Everything or Nothing?

But IMO the experience of live acoustic music is essential to knowing whether the sound you are getting is valid at all.
Each to their own, but IME your simply picking out your personal preferences for tonal quality. If it doesn't measure flat, acoustic or electric, it's not accurate no matter how much you like it. The human brain-ear isn't capable of surpassing or equaling modern measuring gear.
 
You seem to confuse “binary” with “digital”…
Yes, he does. Not disagreeing with you here, but what we call "digital" is commonly a quantized, sampled ANALOG of a time-continuous, level-continuous ANALOG of a sound source.

By any sensible reading of the ACTUAL MEANING OF THE WORD ANALOG, they are both analogs of an original signal of some sort.

There are some differences. Continuous time/level can never bee repaired, and each transmission, recording, etc, will always, absolutely, with no escape in the real world GET LESS ACCURATE. Quantized time/level on the other hand, by restoring the KNOWN times and levels, be restored, stored, etc, with no further loss beyond the initial capture, for which it is trivially shown that said capture is MORE ACCURATE THAN ANY 'analog' recording device. The only loss that can happen in "digital" is if the noise added makes the levels undecidable, which is MANY TIMES THE 'analog" noise. Furthermore, when "digital" systems fail, they don't just get noisy, they just choke altogether, which makes the errors very obvious.

Them's the facts. The "loss" in "digital" is bandwidth (that especially in the modern day is simply insubstantial) and noise floor (which is below the capture equipment used to get the original signal, is not a problem.

THAT'S THE FACT JACK
 
Last edited:
Regarding perception there are differences between individuals.

And the absolute sensitivity has long since been established. Hint, Helmholtz started on this a LONG TIME AGO. Fletcher, then Stevens, very solidly established a baseline. Modern physics establishes that the sensitivity of the ear is very nearly that of the air noise due to the molecular nature of air at the lower level, and also that the transmission ability of the tympani and 3 bones very clearly causes substantial bandlimiting. It is know that very young people can hear above 20khz if they have never worked or lived in a loud environment. The actual spectral content of actual music makes it clear that this is at most a tiny effect, and one or two rock concerts will end that problem permanently.
 
Name one speaker that has a flat, resistive impedance of 8 ohms. Just one. Or how about 1 amp that only performs properly into a flat, resistive 8 ohm impedance?
Straw man 101: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

Since nobody claims that, why bother to mention that? If an amp can only handle resistive loads, it's broken badly designed, etc. I could indeed name some, but it's actually hard with modern devices to make such a device.
 
Listening (often) to live, unamplified, acoustc music in many diffenent venues is a good way to learn what "neutral" sound is.
And such listening in any good acoustic space has many, many times the information that can ever, under any circumstances, be put into two 20-20k channels, no matter how perfect. Remember, you can move your head.
 
Each to their own, but IME your simply picking out your personal preferences for tonal quality. If it doesn't measure flat, acoustic or electric, it's not accurate no matter how much you like it. The human brain-ear isn't capable of surpassing or equaling modern measuring gear.

Very true, all of it. If you like sound that's been colored in some fashion, good for you, that's ok, it's your preference, and you have it, but like Sal says, DO NOT CLAIM ITS ACCURATE.
 
I would like to put Geoff Emerick, Alan Parsons, and All Schmitt, as well as tens of great sound engineers, or maybe a group of eminent conductors, in the limelight here
IME older Rock musicians and engineers are deefer than Beethoven.
I love Alan Parsons, for both his music and his engineering skills. But he was only 21 to 25 when he engineered for the Beatles and Pink Floyd at Abby Road. His later work on both his personal albums and others is very often criticized for being overly bright, I wonder why that could be ???? LOL
 
You don't think there is any incentive in rating things here?
The heck you talking about? Measurements are objective and are run the same way on every product. Exactly how would I game them in that context?

I test equipment from all manufactures and countless ones have gotten praise regardless of who they are. The only "incentive' that works is designing well-engineered products whose performance has been verified before I see them.
You're more gullable than I expected.
As if anyone would care what you expect or didn't expect....
 
Measurements are necessary to figure out what is wrong and what needs to be done to correct it, if it does not sound right. But IMO the experience of live acoustic music is essential to knowing whether the sound you are getting is valid at all.
I get the live music point for acoustic stuff, knowing what a real cello or flute sounds like is a decent sanity check. But even when the musicians played and sang live in the studio, the final version has been heavily processed in mixing and mastering, so there’s no live equivalent to compare it to. The only real “original” is what the engineer heard on their monitors, and those vary all over the place (Toole’s circle of confusion).

Other than some pathologically obvious difference, I don’t know how you’d trust what you’re hearing without measurements to back it up. I must admit, after well over 100 ABX tests trying to tell MP3 from lossless, I appreciate measurements a lot more than I used to.
 
Some recording companies (eg Telarc) use minimal miking and processing, and those are the recordings that I prefer.
Minimal is relative here: they still use 3-4 omnis. They do mic them quite a lot closer than typical (and definitely closer than audience members would be seated). It's a recording choice (as they all are! there is no "natural" or "pure" recording, mics aren't ears, etc.), and I'm not at all convinced by claims of greater verisimilitude (to what?).
 
Some recording companies (eg Telarc) use minimal miking and processing, and those are the recordings that I prefer.
They should just be using binaural microphones if you wanted to capture "what one hears", period.

Purpose of proper engineering is capturing what and how the artist wanted to be heard. I can understand liking the concept of "less processed=better" but honestly, most people who don't play music would be very perplexed how a guitar amp sounds without a microphone in the loop.

So many well-known music is a product of studio work. I used to believe that ECM produced very raw and had this strange "wait, what?" when I read that artificial plate reverb is one of common parts of their aesthetic.

Using omnis & catching natural room acoustics is similar to following a paleo-diet with dubious benefits of "rawer means better".

Close miking is very much artificial, since you don't usually stick your head into saxophone bell.
 
They should just be using binaural microphones if you wanted to capture "what one hears", period.

Purpose of proper engineering is capturing what and how the artist wanted to be heard. I can understand liking the concept of "less processed=better" but honestly, most people who don't play music would be very perplexed how a guitar amp sounds without a microphone in the loop.

So many well-known music is a product of studio work. I used to believe that ECM produced very raw and had this strange "wait, what?" when I read that artificial plate reverb is one of common parts of their aesthetic.

Using omnis & catching natural room acoustics is similar to following a paleo-diet with dubious benefits of "rawer means better".

Close miking is very much artificial, since you don't usually stick your head into saxophone bell.
There are very few paleo diet commercial recordings. There have been attempts to do classical with just two microphones. And 1960s folk music tried to sound like a musician I the room with you.

But the bottom line is the bottom line. Does it sell millions of copies.
 
There are very few paleo diet commercial recordings. There have been attempts to do classical with just two microphones. And 1960s folk music tried to sound like a musician I the room with you.

But the bottom line is the bottom line. Does it sell millions of copies.
Did they do binaurals though?

Just wondering since from XY, Mid/Side and others I would hardly doubt one can be considered more "real" than the rest. The result matters, not the technique.

The bottom line is that it doesn't really matter how you get a good, realistic recording. I believe there are also some "please no compression" purists here?
 
Some recording companies (eg Telarc) use minimal miking and processing, and those are the recordings that I prefer.
That was the folklore.
Didn't telarc avoid any tweaking of their recordings?
That was the folklore, to be sure, but scratch the surface and they were active experimentalists. I recall the early spaced-omni microphone phase, with very spacious delivery, ambiguous localizations - which was their objective for some recordings. But I just did a quick internet search and came up with these comments from some insiders:
“Jack Renner at Telarc used a 3 mike system with sometimes 2 more out in the auditorium for ambience. Bob Woods used 3 or sometimes 2 and again, sometimes 2 out in the hall. And yet on other recordings, particularly the jazz they used spot mikes. Sometimes when recording classical with individual singing, these individuals were also spot miked. On many of the Kunzel pieces which had sound effects, these effects were recorded separately by Mike Bishop and added in. It all just depended on the sound they were after.”

“Bobby Owsinski interviewed Michael Bishop - Episode #170 – Whiz Passes Psy, Gibson Buys Onkyo, And Engineer Michael Bishop | Bobby Owsinski's Inner Circle Podcast - recently. Mr. Bishop talked a fair bit about mic placement that was used while he was recording for Telarc. If I recall correctly he talked about 4 omni microphones spread out for "coverage" and possibly the use of some targeted mics. Much closer to The orchestra than you would expect.”

“Telarc recorded the Milwaukee Symphony performing Smetana's Ma Vlast back when we were recording them for Koss Classics. I recall part of the Telarc "sound" came from packing the musicians very tightly together, almost uncomfortably so.”

https://www.stereophile.com/content/jack-renner-telarc-direct-cleveland-page-2. This interview is an interesting perspective.

John Eargle, a noted recording engineer and much more, was a good friend of mine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_M._Eargle
He recorded for the Delos label, and was highly regarded for his classical recordings. He described the process in detail, which began with some overall orchestra miking combined with "tasteful" close miking to amplify weak instruments, and to provide clarity for solo artists. These close pickup signals were adjusted in timing and electronic ambiance to make their contributions fit the overall soundstage. He was especially proud that these manipulations were not detected, and that the result was interpreted as a credible replica of a live experience. John was a significant factor in encouraging me to write the first edition of these books.

As I said, the circle of confusion is difficult to avoid. It is almost certain that all decisions were made while listening to forward firing loudspeakers in a small room.
 
Name one speaker that has a flat, resistive impedance of 8 ohms. Just one. Or how about 1 amp that only performs properly into a flat, resistive 8 ohm impedance?

Most people don't choose speakers based on their impedance- they choose them based on frequency response and how they like their sound. They then buy amps that can provide the power they require to meet their volume preferences subject to their impedance- in other words, most people I know match the amp to the speakers, not the other way around. There are plenty of amps that can handle low impedance loads- why would anyone design an amp that can power a 1 ohm load if it wasn't a thing? Ask Krell, Purifi, Pass, etc. why their amps are stable into 1 ohm loads.

"Why would someone design a speaker that might sound "bad" on a "good" amp?" As mentioned, certain types of loudspeakers, just like certain amp topographies, have their fan bases and most people learn to combine those that are best suited for each other. To dismiss a loudspeaker as "bad" because it may have a low impedance regardless of how it might reproduce an audio signal is simply ignorant.

Some people actually pick speakers based upon impedance, or exclude speakers based upon impedance.
 
Some people actually pick speakers based upon impedance, or exclude speakers based upon impedance.
No doubt. I said most don't. Some people also pick speakers based on size, color, or what they read on web sites.
 
But IMO the experience of live acoustic music is essential to knowing whether the sound you are getting is valid at all.
With the exception of classical music, almost no recorded music is seeking to reproduce live acoustic music and listening to live music will tell you nothing at all about the accuracy or quality of a home system.

Listening (often) to live, unamplified, acoustc music in many diffenent venues is a good way to learn what "neutral" sound is.
Not really. A violin sounds dramatically different if it's being played in a church or a concert hall or a coffee shop or a small room. It also sounds very different depending on whether you're 18" from the instrument, and 18 feet from the instrument. Which of these is "neutral"?
 
[...] and listening to live music will tell you nothing at all about the accuracy or quality of a home system.
I agree with the rest, but this is IMO an overstretched argument. Instrument timbre is retained in most situations, apart from explicit effects processing.

While harmonics can be highlighted or missed in certain acoustic spaces, I'd not infer that live music tells you nothing. You learn the main spectral content of said instrument and how it generally sounds. Bad THD and wrapped FR doesn't modify the partials in the recording. Even moreso, incorrect FR affects all the instruments in the same way, so the relative harmonic partials structure is retained between instruments.
 
It seems to me our brains are incredibly good at extracting timber and creating mental models of the possible ways a thing can sound so it will be recognized in the future. It does this with ALL stimulus, so holding as many things in common as possible will allow it to process the differences. Other than that, I don't see that the source matters. Going to hear the acoustic instruments in many different venues will let your brain form models (that theoretical "neutral" we are talking about) of both the venues and the instruments. The more experiences you have the more your models are updated by other models your brain is making.

What this implies to me is that if you want to know what something "sounds like" listen to that thing in differing conditions. Your brain will make the model. For the past two years I have been seeing live, amplified, electronic music in about 5 different venues with differing reproduction strategies. Probably around 25-30 concerts. I have a pretty damn good model of how each of those venues sounds (since they are what is held in common). For bands that I have seen multiple times in different venues I have models for what an idealized version of that band sounds like.

Basically, I am agreeing that if you want "know what something sounds like" go listen to that thing in as many different situations as you can. Where I would differ from previous posts is that I don't think neutral has anything to do with it and "what it sounds like" is actually a mental model we are constructing which will likely match with other peoples models because our brains are similar.

I have also been wondering about the visual equivalent of timber. I'm pretty sure I don't see my wife as she is, but rather recognize her visual timber, the same way I don't hear my wife's voice so much as recognize it as belonging to WIFE'S VOICE TIMBER. I mean, she "sounds" the same to me as she did 35 years ago, unless I hear a recording of our younger selves.
 
Back
Top Bottom