• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Master Thread: Are Measurements Everything or Nothing?

If you can't measure it, how did you built it? Even when I am cooking something and I do a taste test, I can say it's need a little bit of salt or spice.

When someone like Paul McGowan designs an amp, what does he say during a listening test? It needs more mundolf capacitors?
 
When someone like Paul McGowan designs an amp, what does he say during a listening test? It needs more mundolf capacitors?
Would not surprise me in the least.
 
How about measuring a photo image if it measures perfect if it more engaging and appealing then one that doesn't ? Is perfectly measured photo lens better then a character type lens with some flaws ?
Visual art invites and even demands subjectivism. That is the intent. Music reproduction demands some accuracy to truly represent the artists’ intent. In my opinion, I can’t speak for all musicians, but many seem to care about the quality of their recordings.

Is a mechanical watch less appealing because it keeps time less accurate then a digital one ?
I wish that people here that bought components totally based on measurements would list what they own.
People buy mechanical watches for many different reasons, Some for status. Some because they celebrate superb craftsmanship. Timing accuracy is pretty much completely irrelevant. I personally enjoy setting and correcting the time on my mechanical watches when necessary. I’ll never put a watch that’s not mechanical on my wrist. And being a minute early or late has never harmed anyone, and any decent mechanical watch keeps that level of accuracy over a week.

Of course you’re completely free to express your own creativity and artistic choice by listening to music through any system of your choice. The problem only arises when people claim their way should be everybody else’s and elevate their personal preference to pseudo science. And note I’d think the same of anyone that thinks a DAC with a 120dB SINAD is “much better” than one with 115.

I could not care less less if someone enjoys listening to their music on a 1920’s gramophone. But if they argue I am ignorant for striving for a tad more accuracy, I’ll laugh in their face.
 
Last edited:
How about measuring a photo image if it measures perfect if it more engaging and appealing then one that doesn't ? Is perfectly measured photo lens better then a character type lens with some flaws ?
Visual art invites and even demands subjectivism. That is the intent. Music reproduction demands some accuracy to truly represent the artists’ intent. In my opinion, I can’t speak for all musicians, but many seem to care about the quality of their recordings.
I think @mpw's analogy was a bit off the mark.
A better analogy between visual art and the recording and playback of music would be the act of photographing visual art for art books or posters. If you use a distorting lens your reproduction will not be faithful just as our using an inaccurate speaker or colored tube amp will not recreate the music as intended.
 
…
A better analogy between visual art and the recording and playback of music would be the act of photographing visual art for art books or posters. If you use a distorting lens your reproduction will not be faithful …
That is a great way to put it!

Which does not mean some people will never claim the Mona Lisa looks better in black and white photography, of course… :-)
 
I think @mpw's analogy was a bit off the mark.
A better analogy between visual art and the recording and playback of music would be the act of photographing visual art for art books or posters. If you use a distorting lens your reproduction will not be faithful just as our using an inaccurate speaker or colored tube amp will not recreate the music as intended.
I am not saying distorted lens but lens that have character rather then a precise clinical look.
 
Actually, the musicians create the music, the engineer records it, and manufacturing reproduces it. But nevertheless, I think you misunderstood my point. My point had to do with unwanted "effects" that the engineer deals with and accepts, not intentional effects.
What the recording engineers do is very much a part of the artistic process. Also IME both engineers and artists are very much concerned that the end user hears it as close to 'as they intended' as possible. If you don't believe me go and hang around some studios.
 
Aesthetics are the only thing that measurements are not available for. :cool:
And even that is just because it'd be difficult and expensive.

Definitely possible today. Just hire experts accordingly, with the right equipment. fMRI, psychologists, brain experts. You'll be able to gather a lot of data about people's reactions to various aesthetic stimuli.

Typical example of: just because it isn't done doesn't mean it's impossible. You definitely can measure aesthetics!:D
 
who said anything about "based on nothing" ?
Feel free to give me some good examples of people questioning, here at ASR, established science and engineering of audio where they have some valid evidence to support their questioning.


Other than (as a couple of examples of what is posted here on a daily basis) "I can hear a difference in devices so there must be something missing in the measurements." Or - "Look this youtuber says the science is wrong" followed by the posting of an evidence free youtube video.
 
Last edited:
When musicians and producers create music they do it in way that sounds good to their ears instead of having scientists in the studio measuring the sound to determine when the music is perfect.
You are mixing two things up.

Musicians and producers create music that sounds good to them, bcause the music is the art, It is what we enjoy, that stirs our emotions etc etc. That is not somethign that in a lot of ways needs (or can have) measuremnts - because it is pretty much a subjective process - within the scientific unerstanding of how music "works".

With some exceptions - I am not an expert in studio work, but I'd guess there is a lot about studio work that involves measurements - look at all the bouncing vu meters and spectrum analysers. See also Auto tune. There is also a lot of measurement involved in setting up the studio equipment in the first place before even one song is recorded or mixed.


But measurements as we primarily discuss them here are used for reproduction equipment. Simply to demonstrate that it delivers the carefully crafted music to your ears without being changed at all - or as close as possible to unchanged. So that the work done by musicians and producers is not ruined by poorly performing gear.




How about measuring a photo image if it measures perfect if it more engaging and appealing then one that doesn't ?
Again you are mixing up the measurement of the art itself, rather than the measurement of the equipment that reproduces the art. There is a fair bit of measurement done on computers and printers (eg colour calibration) - or in the past, photographic film and papers - intended to ensure visual art is reproduced more faithfully.
 
Last edited:
Again you are mixing up the measurement of the art itself, rather than the measurement of the equipment that reproduces the art. There is a fair bit of measurement done on computers and printers (eg colour calibration) - or in the past, photographic film and papers - intended to ensure visual art is reproduced more faithfully.
I am pointing out the experience of the end user, the perceptual experience. How would you measure Monet's paintbrushes? You wouldn't. You would experience the result. Measurements, unless you are trying to measure the neural network response to the experience, become rather irrelevant to the experience. I suppose you could dig down into measuring the chemical composition of the paints and such, and explain from there the end users' experiences, and then explain the end users' experience as delusional if it doesn't match your expectations of how the end user "should" see it if only the end users could simply be objective and have "perfect" eyes, lighting, viewing angle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mpw
We cover this again and again, in order; the composition, musician/voice, interplay, venue, recording technique/mastering, results in 90% of value staying at 90% with accurate playback (can be verified with measured playback equipment) of a superlative experience, can get back down to 75% with poor measuring devices and 60% on an AM transistor radio. No recording or playback will yield the 100% value of a beloved live musical experience.
 
You would experience the result.
Of course. And you would want to experience the result as close as possible to how the artist created it. If viewing the original, you would want optimal presentation/display/lighting to see the brushwork (if that is what floats your boat).

Measurements, unless you are trying to measure the neural network response to the experience, become rather irrelevant to the experience.
Again, of course - who has ever claimed we should measure the artwork? That seems to be a straw man you are constructing there. Or you are somehow suggesting yourself that we should. Either way whatever point you are trying to make is lost on me.

To continue

If viewing a reproduction - ideally the reproduction would look identical to the original. You might to go some lengths to get a reproduction which achieves this.


Same applies to music. Ideally, gear should not alter in any audible way, what the artist created. We find out how well the gear achieves this ... by measuring the gear ... not the art.
 
Last edited:
Would you love your photos if the printer always made them very slightly blurry? Maybe, but ASR member devotees, probably not.
 
Measurements, unless you are trying to measure the neural network response to the experience, become rather irrelevant to the experience
I bet you measure the salt added to your food. Is that irrelevant to your experience? Your logic is flawed.
 
We cover this again and again, in order; the composition, musician/voice, interplay, venue, recording technique/mastering, results in 90% of value staying at 90% with accurate playback (can be verified with measured playback equipment) of a superlative experience, can get back down to 75% with poor measuring devices and 60% on an AM transistor radio. No recording or playback will yield the 100% value of a beloved live musical experience.

Could you clear up for me how you were using the term “ value” here?

If you’re using it in some purely quantitative way, a measurement for instance of the level of accuracy, then I think what you’re saying could make sense.

But it does seem to me like you were using the term value here in terms of the subjective nature - what would be “ valuable” in terms of our experiencing the music.

In that case, I would disagree with your scale.
For instance, depending on the record I find myself valuing the musical experience on a less accurate vinyl playback than digital playback. And I have found myself to often value the experience of listening to music using less accurate tube amps versus my more accurate solid state amplifiers.
 
Back
Top Bottom