• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Master Thread: Are Measurements Everything or Nothing?

My ears are certainly not "silly" and not "oh so special"... yet another nice typical snarky insufferable snob audiophile dig, btw, a real turn off ... my audiologist confirms this quite clearly, and I am quite aware and readily admit... but they are my ears and have their own frequency response capabilities which have been altered by aging. My ears' capabilities are decidedly not linear and definitely benefit from some top-end EQ lift. I would argue that anybody over 35 on this "measurements" site who has not had their EARS measured by a competent audiologist, and I'm not talking about otc/Costco, is missing the most important component of all, in their measurements... anybody over 50, well it goes downhill further, primarily in high frequencies, and each person will be different and have his or her own "special" individual profile. If you haven't done it, and yet you concern yourself over speaker and other gear measurements, then I'd have to question both your priorities and your perceptions.

So, get your own special ears objectively measured... and know the truth about your own hearing.
I think you missed the point.
 
Does driver size play a role in perceived sound and if yes, can it be measured in some way?
Hifiman egg headphones for example have drivers larger than any ear. So in theory it would produce sound that also reaches your outer ear and eventually finds it's way inside instead of purely going into your ear canal from let's say, an average 40mm dynamic driver.
I am using an Edition X as my daily driver and I always felt like it sounded more "open" despite it's blunt tuning. Now that perception is very small and it could very well be placebo but I recently I can't seem to get it out of my head. No matter how much I tried to match it with EQ on other headphones that aren't the giant oval drivers, I never managed to get there.
HD600 was the worst example. I hate how closed in it sounds, and even if I EQ it to be brighter, it doesn't go away. And my only explanation would be it's tiny 38mm driver that is also damped to an extreme degree.

Anyway, would like to read some opinions on this topic. Maybe I am just losing my marbles at this point.
 
Does driver size play a role in perceived sound and if yes, can it be measured in some way?
Hifiman egg headphones for example have drivers larger than any ear. So in theory it would produce sound that also reaches your outer ear and eventually finds it's way inside instead of purely going into your ear canal from let's say, an average 40mm dynamic driver.
I am using an Edition X as my daily driver and I always felt like it sounded more "open" despite it's blunt tuning. Now that perception is very small and it could very well be placebo but I recently I can't seem to get it out of my head. No matter how much I tried to match it with EQ on other headphones that aren't the giant oval drivers, I never managed to get there.
HD600 was the worst example. I hate how closed in it sounds, and even if I EQ it to be brighter, it doesn't go away. And my only explanation would be it's tiny 38mm driver that is also damped to an extreme degree.

Anyway, would like to read some opinions on this topic. Maybe I am just losing my marbles at this point.
Quick answer from memory. I'm assuming we're talking about dynamic headphones with Mylar diaphragms. These usually carry some combination of microtextures, dimples, corrugations, ribs, and radial spokes, and the different shapes do different jobs. Corrugations at the surround act as a bellows: they set the suspension's compliance and keep the restoring force linear as the diaphragm travels, which is what limits distortion at high excursion. Ribs, spokes, and micro-textures work further in, stiffening the membrane and breaking up its resonant modes so it behaves as a piston over a wider band instead of flexing into its own shapes.

Diaphragm size trades against this. A larger diaphragm displaces more air per millimetre of travel, so it can reach a given bass level with less excursion — which usually means less distortion down low, provided the motor and suspension are up to the job. The cost is more moving mass and a larger surface to keep rigid, so breakup sets in lower and the geometry above has to work harder. A smaller diaphragm is easier to keep pistonic and tends to be cleaner through the midrange and treble, but it has to move further for the same bass output, which pushes it toward its excursion limits sooner.
 
Research by Harman International shows that a majority of listeners (roughly 64% to 74% depending on the study) prefer a specific non-flat target frequency response—commonly known as the Harman Curve—over flat or diffuse-field responses at normal listening levels.

Apparently, many folks prefer an "enhanced" reality, if that's the right word, or perhaps "altered" is a better word.
There's a difference between anechoic response and in room response. Anechoic there's very little attenuation, in your room there is. The same attenuation you get when you talk in that room, or make any sound. In other words, the smoothly downward tilting in-room FR is the 'natural' sound.
 
Research by Harman International shows that a majority of listeners (roughly 64% to 74% depending on the study) prefer a specific non-flat target frequency response—commonly known as the Harman Curve—over flat or diffuse-field responses at normal listening levels.

Apparently, many folks prefer an "enhanced" reality, if that's the right word, or perhaps "altered" is a better word.
[to CurtR] May be you want to read and understand what Dr Toole wrote in this post. You also mentioned "diffuse-field", are you talking headphone listening or loudspeaker listening here?
Yes, Curt is quoting the headphone study and misapplying it to loudspeakers.

He also doesn't understand the actual implication of the headphone study, and misuses it to draw inappropriate over-generalisations about what "many folks prefer".

In reality, regarding headphones, the individual variability in preferences lies in the bass. Outside of the bass frequencies, the research he is drawing on shows that people tend to be quite similar in their preferred response curve. In a nutshell, 100% of listeners prefer the Harman Curve to within 1 dB above 300 Hz, but below 300 Hz listeners split into 3 preference groups: 64% prefer the Curve within 2 dB, 21% prefer the Curve modified to -2 dB to -3 dB of bass, and 15% prefer the Curve modified to +3 dB to +6 dB of bass.

The underlined bit IMO is extremely important and gives a clue to how little human preference varies for sound quality in general. And even in the bass it’s the same curve, with tweaks to the level (not to the shape), and 100% of listeners fall into one of the 3 tweaks. IMO overall the message is one of remarkably high consistency in preferences: one only needs to ask a person if he or she is a bit averse to bass, or a bit crazy about bass, or neither, and you can pretty much hand him or her the target curve to look for in headphones. Wow. Even easier, just hand them the standard Harman Curve 100% of the time, and say there is a 1 in 3 chance they might want to apply a bass shelf of plus or minus a few dB to taste. Wow wow. No wonder Dr Toole describes us as stable and consistent measuring instruments.
 
I am firmly in the “measurements are everything” camp.

What I mean by that is that measurements confirming what audio capability exists in devices under consideration (DUCs?) dominate the early search and sort to find what I want.

So it’s a statement that measurements are an absolute prerequisite to make the table of DUCs worthy of further ‘inclusion’ (I hate that politicized word) in purchase decisions.

I might compromise other things, like features, physical size, appearance, cost, availability, country of origin or anything else, but I don’t want to compromise performance, which cannot be known outside of measurements.

And from that point of view…measurements really are the dominating ‘everything’ and all else are secondary considerations.
 
I might compromise other things, like features, physical size, appearance, cost, availability, country of origin or anything else, but I don’t want to compromise performance, which cannot be known outside of measurements.
How would you react to this scenario.

A loaner pair of affordable speakers are offered for an in home audition, there are no specifications or measurements available, but since there is no obligation or cost for the audition, you give them a listen and love the way the sound.

Would you consider purchasing them before also seeing measurements?
 
I assume that is a sarcastic remark... :)

While on the surface my proposed scenario may seem far fetched, but I have experienced this exact scenario half a dozen or more times.
No it genuinely isn't. I really wouldn't buy with only an audio audition.
 
How would you react to this scenario.

A loaner pair of affordable speakers are offered for an in home audition, there are no specifications or measurements available, but since there is no obligation or cost for the audition, you give them a listen and love the way the sound.

Would you consider purchasing them before also seeing measurements?
Measure them myself.
With a laptop and a cheap microphone. My time and the mic are likely less expensive than the speakers. I'm also not in need of more clutter, and as you can see by some of the tests I have posted I have plenty of speakers, so I would use the opportunity to make sure I will like the sound, with measurements, probably MMM. I would be even more careful if I didn't have plenty of speakers I like already or the speakers were expensive, perhaps a SPIN using a simple set of measurements, as I do.

FYI, the two best sounding speakers I own were purchased based on measurements only. One set are JBL M2 I built myself, I copied JBL's crossover settings, based on measurements. Instead of ported, I went sealed with Linkwitz transform for the bass, based on measurements. I used measurements to quantify the reduction in output I get with the sealed/transform. I tried a number of other things I thought would be interesting, including a 3-way and 2.5-way configurations, but rejected them based on what I heard and was able to verify, based on measurements. Everything I heard was verifiable in the measurements. They are in my room that I have measured so that I don't accidentally put them in a place where I get large bass peaks, otherwise I am likely to come away with the opinion that the bass is awesome. Or put them where I get a null, and come away with the impression that bass is super-tight. I also used measurements in the room to chase down rattles in the HVAC, and to setup the subwoofers.

I'm also happy to see measurements on old speakers I have owned. I finally understand why my Vandersteen IIc sounded the way they did, based on Erin's measurements. Same for LS3/5A and NS-10 speakers that were so popular back in the day on our store's used shelves, I now understand the sound and use conditions for these, and the dramatic unit to unit variability of the LS3/5A. And some of the very odd opinions I

So yeah, the measured sound is what the speaker produces. And despite my opinion that I am a good listener, with some measurements to back that up, I am not Spock. So I measure.

I'm not being sarcastic. Measuring is such a simple thing. I notice this forum is drifting away from fundamentals of sound and the realities of human perception, a reverting to the misdirection and confusion that we had back in the day.
 
FYI, the two best sounding speakers I own were purchased based on measurements only.
Same. I purchased Philharmonic Audio and Genelec based on measurement reviews. They are both endgame.
 
How would you react to this scenario.

A loaner pair of affordable speakers are offered for an in home audition, there are no specifications or measurements available, but since there is no obligation or cost for the audition, you give them a listen and love the way the sound.

Would you consider purchasing them before also seeing measurements?
No.
 
How would you react to this scenario.

A loaner pair of affordable speakers are offered for an in home audition, there are no specifications or measurements available, but since there is no obligation or cost for the audition, you give them a listen and love the way the sound.

Would you consider purchasing them before also seeing measurements?
Nope
 
Well, at least you guys are consistent... if not closed minded.

I am a believer in measurements and have been making MLS and other high resolution measurents since 2006. That said, If I love the sound... say with a pair of JBL DD67000 which do not measure well, then the hell with the measurements. Ultimately in a home environment, a loudspeaker is supposed to be for playing back music and to be listened to by the human ear.

Nothing wrong with enjoying beautiful measurements, but they should not be the destination.
 
I assume that is a sarcastic remark... :)

While on the surface my proposed scenario may seem far fetched, but I have experienced this exact scenario half a dozen or more times.
I experience it regularly - with the same set of speakers. Sometimes they sound sublime. Other times not. Sometimes (It's only happened once or twice) I can't listen to them and I have to turn the music off and find something else to do.

It is not the speakers - nor anything else in the system - that is changing.
 
I experience it regularly - with the same set of speakers. Sometimes they sound sublime. Other times not. Sometimes (It's only happened once or twice) I can't listen to them and I have to turn the music off and find something else to do.

It is not the speakers - nor anything else in the system - that is changing.
Absolutely, human auditory perception is certainly inconsistent... but it is what we have.
 
Absolutely, human auditory perception is certainly inconsistent... but it is what we have.
Which is precisely why "just listening" without measurements to back up your perception is flawed. It could be that the day you audition those speakers for which there are no measurements just happens to be the circumstances that generate "sublime" perceptions.

Which, because the speakers are (may be) bad - may never happen again.
 
How would you react to this scenario.

A loaner pair of affordable speakers are offered for an in home audition, there are no specifications or measurements available, but since there is no obligation or cost for the audition, you give them a listen and love the way the sound.

Would you consider purchasing them before also seeing measurements?
If the price was low enough I would consider purchasing them, but only after a lot of listening. Not just a day.
This is because some songs may sound good, and others not so good, and I would need a wide variety to evaluate. Also, preferences can change based on state of mind, and I might not hear what I want to hear at the time.

Measurements, on the other hand, are constant and will not vary day to day or with material. That's why I feel it's important to have both.

That said, I would sooner own a pair that measured okay but sounded great than a pair that measured great but sounded just okay.
 
Which is precisely why "just listening" without measurements to back up your perception is flawed. It could be that the day you audition those speakers for which there are no measurements just happens to be the circumstances that generate "sublime" perceptions.
Agreed with your premise to a point. I would never consider a single audition as a valid judgment of a speaker... and I would never consider an audition in an unfamiliar space as particularly valuable, however I disagree that our flawed hearing apparatus should be completely discounted and only measurements relied upon. I have heard really well measuring speakers that I would never want to own and other really well measuring speakers that I love.
 
Back
Top Bottom