• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Marantz CD6007 sounded bad - advice wanted for new cd player

Status
Not open for further replies.
May I interrupt the conversation just to remind everybody that Leon74 has sent back the Marantz CD6007 and the Marantz 70s integrated amplifier.

Thus, it is no longer possible to check anything to find the root cause of Leon74's subjective assessment.

Consequently, it seems pointless to me to proceed with further discussion.
 
Unlikely, considered measurements and me listening to it.

I have no reason to doubt my husband's trained hearing as a music teacher. And no, he is far from being an "audiophile". Neither am I.
Of course I can only talk about the Marantz amp and cd player we listened to. But as there was no obvious technical failure, I can only assume they all sound the same.
 
Nothing else changed, unless that particular night they sent me green instead of gray electricity or the other way around. Lunar phases and stellar constellations are beyond my control, too, obviously.
I'm afraid we are not going to find a credible explanation. I have no reason to believe the devices malfunctioned, nor the amp, nor the cd player.
Perception bias? I don't think so. The difference in sound with the old receiver and cd players was too big.

As for the statement that "all amplifiers sound the same " that people seem to propagate here, I am not sure if that is true. I heard a Luxman, a Sony and an Akai. The Luxman and Sony were soundwise very close, the Akai had a warmer, less neutral, (though not muddy) sound.
Perception bias? Maybe. Until now I have seen no big studies, just a test from the eighties with serious methodological flaws and indirect conclusions why all amps should sound the same. I am not saying that is not true, I am just saying there is no good evidence backing that claim (nor is there good evidence for claims stating the contrary).

As for all DAC's producing the same sound: No, that's just nonsense. I cannot distinguish between my old Philips and Akai player listening to them, but my husband's Sony cd player just sounds bad compared to the two other players, and though the Sony receiver's analog sound is good, the digital one isn't.
If DAC's sounded different dont you think someone would have conducted and documented a double blind test proving the differences? Fun Fact: They havent. Same with amps
 
If DAC's sounded different dont you think someone would have conducted and documented a double blind test proving the differences? Fun Fact: They havent. Same with amps
That's just presumption. As there are no such serious studies conducted, nothing can be said with certainty.
 
May I interrupt the conversation just to remind everybody that Leon74 has sent back the Marantz CD6007 and the Marantz 70s integrated amplifier.

Thus, it is no longer possible to check anything to find the root cause of Leon74's subjective assessment.

Consequently, it seems pointless to me to proceed with further discussion.
I guess you are quite right.
Maybe technically there was a little problem with the device, who knows? Not everything leads to a device not functioning at all or causes a crackling sound.
A year ago I bought a second Sony DAB radio. I heard a difference in sound. There seemed to be "less" pressure behind it. I thought I was imagining it but then I saw the light of the little screen was less bright, too. So probably that and the (in that case) very subtle difference in sound were caused by a technical problem.
 
General observation > Being a little less aggressive and abrasive will result in greater community engagement and a wider range of responses that might be beneficial to the poster. If you are new here try to understand the audience. This crowd is highly technical and many are professionals in their fields of Engineering. We are a Science based community and have little space or time for Subjectivity. Subjectivity is the antithesis to evidence based science. Please try to keep that in mind.
 
May I interrupt the conversation just to remind everybody that Leon74 has sent back the Marantz CD6007 and the Marantz 70s integrated amplifier.

Thus, it is no longer possible to check anything to find the root cause of Leon74's subjective assessment.

Consequently, it seems pointless to me to proceed with further discussion.
As said by @Scytales above. The purpose of this thread no longer applies as the product was returned. Closing the thread. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom