• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Listening to music in multichannel mode

I have to confess that I really like listening to music in multichannel mode better than in stereo
And why not?
In my sound surround/home theatre system, I often listen to music in multi channel mode, the stereo in that system is not optimum, so both ways are compromised. My home theatre is very good at playing a decent experience for more than one listener, it is optimized to play/decode multichannel movie soundtrack.
When I want to listen to music, as in just listening to music, not background music when really doing something else, if listening to a stereo recording, which is 99% of the music I listen to, I do it on my stereo system, in my dedicated music system, from my unique listening seat. A properly set stereo system, will let you hear all of the music and present a very convincing sound stage, if it was recorded properly to start with.
So for me listening to music that was recorded and produced to be listened to in stereo using digital processing to re distribute it on 7.1 channels does not seem like a great idea.
In reprocessing a stereo recording to a multichannel, however sofisticated the process is, we are getting very far from the concept that digital flies are so much better because they are closer to the original master.
That said everyone should enjoy the music in their home the way they see fit, mono, stereo, multichannel.
 
Last edited:
Some of my favorite surround music recordings













In addition I have over 200 multichannel recordings of classical music in multichannel!
 
Last edited:
Some of my favorite surround music recordings













In addition I have over 200 multichannel recordings of classical music in multichannel!

Turns out my Sony BRD player is also a SACD player. I had no idea. I just ordered the Dire Straits 5.1 SACD hybrid disc you linked to try it out. I have had the original since its initial release and have always loved it. I am sure the CD program will be heavily squished and loud compared to the original, but perhaps I will be surprised.

I am not sure my setup will be optimal for this, as my surrounds are all Polk 65-RT in-walls. They are great as noisemakers for movies. I shall see how they perform for multichannel music.
 
I will admit I have a bootleg digital copy of the Avalon SACD because I'm too cheap to pay market rate for the out of print disc. It's not like Brian Ferry is getting any of that money anyway and I already own a copy of the stereo CD. That seems like a prime candidate for an Atmos remix for distribution on Apple. At least then there would be a few pennies flowing back to the artists.
 
I have to confess that I really like listening to music in multichannel mode better than in stereo. I use a Denon x3700h with audyssey32xt, and I like the multichannel sound of music in my 5.2 set up more than Stereo, Direct, or Pure Direct. It's like being in a sonic envelope, very layered and enveloping. I've taken the surround volume levels down from the recommended surround levels that Audessey came up with (was too high, they have to be low enough so that the Front speakers are the stars of the show).

Anyone else like listening to music in Multichannel mode?
Yes, I do all my music play back in multichannel.
I do not use sub woofers since I have Big Main Speakers.
If you're not using Quality Speakers in the center position
you're missing out on yer music.
I use a Marantz for my surround speakers and my mains.
I like big sound so I use 2 speakers for the center.
I do not have the space to use a "center channel speaker".
If I did have the space for a "center speaker" I would not
use a center channel speaker because I do not like the way they sound.
Playback in 5 channels is not "Plug & Play".
It takes work to get it correct.
I don't use room correction, I tune my system by ear.
Having a Marantz or Denon gives you better options
for playback than using Audessey.
 
The best results i've had thus far was with a prepro+Auromatic upmixer on my 5.2.4 system . More recently, i discovered the Shiit Syn upmixer and I am running it in 5.2/4.2. In 4.2 the surrounds serve primarily as "enhancers' for the mains. The Shiit Syn is incredible value at 400 dollars. Once you realize the glory of it, it is impossible to go back to any music in stereo.
 
I used to be a real snob on this.....until I figured out that with the correct setup, and room correction....multichannel is a more realistic listening experience for me. YMMV.
I absolutely love multichannel music! Stereo is fine with my AirPods
 
I used to be a real snob on this.....until I figured out that with the correct setup, and room correction....multichannel is a more realistic listening experience for me. YMMV.
I also used to be a snob about using EQ with headphones.....until I figured out that it can make certain phones sound a ton better.
 
Funny enough - Dolby Atmos mixes are much better quality than 2Ch mixes in most of the cases. Dynamic range usually 13-15dB area.

Also material, that is good per se (usually classical music) is better in MCH. Ambiance, size of the venue. dynamics.
 
Been a serious audiophile for 50 years. I used to be a snob about multichannel......until I finally had a well matched set of speakers with Dirac room correction. Just sounds so much better to me than when I run in stereo. Wider soundstage with remarkable imaging and instrument placement. Can't believe I didn't do this years ago.
 
I have to confess that I really like listening to music in multichannel mode better than in stereo.
Older post so, but
I'm not sure what you mean by "multichannel mode"?
I'll normally upsample 2ch sources to one of the included codec in my Denon X4700H.
I find the current Dolby Surround with center wide enabled to most often be the best but still try all of them with a new piece of music.
You never know when Auro 3D, or much less often DTS-X, may find a sweet spot.

I used to be a snob about multichannel......until I finally had a well matched set of speakers with Dirac room correction. Just sounds so much better to me than when I run in stereo. Wider soundstage with remarkable imaging and instrument placement. Can't believe I didn't do this years ago.
Good post! I've been doing multich since the mid 70s and found that when the equipment is right, there's nothing better.
We suffered from poor sources "vinyl & CD4" and wonky matrix codings liked SQ and QS that never allowed Quad to take off with audiophiles back then.
But the last 3 or more decades has brought us high resolution discrete digital sources that has allowed multich to really shine.

Apple Music Atmos tracks have the bass and/or subwoofer channel mixed WAY too hot.
Sounds like you have some sort of equipment or setup issue.
I hear nothing like that from Apples Atmos files. ???
 
MCH is the way to go! Real world is MCH although we have only two ears. I have been pleasantly surprised by my 9.1.4. Ensure that height channels are at less than 60 degrees from the MLP. My Integra AVR also has Auro 3D and it gives you control on how much material is distributed to other channels. One thing I don't like about Auro is the massive bass boost. 2 CH is limited in its abilities to actually create a truly immersive experience given the lack of channels and comb filtering etc.
 
One thing I don't like about Auro is the massive bass boost.
As in listening to a 2ch source upsampled by Auro 3D?
Or listening to a Auro 3D encoded recording?
 
As in listening to a 2ch source upsampled by Auro 3D?
Or listening to a Auro 3D encoded recording?
Up sampled content. I don't have any native Auro.. does anyone have any ?
 
Niche within a niche topic.

My setup si 9.x.7, combined dts:x/atmos layout with centre height, focused on Music (MCH&Stereo)

In most of the cases, especially with classical recordings, I do prefer DTS HD MA vs Atmos mix, sounds more “correct”, as if Atmos was just afterthought and whole focus was on 5.1. version. Latest example being this recording? Anybody with same/different experience? (for the record, I liked Dts vs Dolby also before Atmos won format wars)


When there is Atmos native mix, I guess it is “as artist intended” @Kal Rubinson - maybe your insight, with hour vast experience in MCH?
 
Last edited:
Up sampled content. I don't have any native Auro.. does anyone have any ?
There are labels (e.g., 2L.no, trptk.com and spiritofturtle.com) that sell Auro-3D files embedded in FLAC as part of their downloadable music productions in various formats. The recorded from above acoustic reflections are mixed into 5.1, 7.1 or even 9.1 PCM streams. An Auro-3D capable device will decode the original 3D information. If there is no suitable decoder, then the original surround PCM recording will be rendered.
AURO-3D downloads.jpg
 
MCH is the way to go! Real world is MCH although we have only two ears.

I have never understood what it is people want to point out when they bring up that we “only have two ears”, what exactly does that have to do with the number of channels/loudspeakers reproducing the sound? :)
 
I have never understood what it is people want to point out when they bring up that we “only have two ears”, what exactly does that have to do with the number of channels/loudspeakers reproducing the sound? :)
Stereo pair (ears or even eyes) is a minimum required for accurate sound direction and depth sensing. Our brain uses delays between the left and right neuronal signals emanating from ears to determine direction. Also, our height perception is pretty bad, only upto about 45 degrees. If objects are above 45 degrees then we can't precisely locate them. May be if we had another ear over our heads we might have had better height perception?

PS:

In the case of eyes we're constantly doing a feature matching from both the field of views and triangulating the matched features to obtain depth. If someone put you in an extremely white or black room..your depth perception will start acting up because there are no features for you to triangulate.
 
If someone is looking for ATMOS mixes, ChannaD (Techno Dad on YT) does re-mixes in the ATMOS renderer. They're available for free download.
 
Back
Top Bottom