• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

"Limp mode" for Beginners

Status
Not open for further replies.
But the Pioneer has an 850W power supply

It was literally tested and found to be able to push out over 100 watts each into 7 channels AT ONCE..

I don't think it pales compared to standalone amps power-wise..
sure, it probably cannot compete against the Topping B200 SINAD-wise and all.. but iirc, it beats the fancy HEGEL integrated amp at twice the cost.. or almost beats it.


regarding ART, if that is intensive load on processing, then yeah.. maybe the missing cooling on the processor could be a reason to omit the feature..
lack of power certainly isn't.
We don’t know the power supply ratings of many separate amps, let alone avrs, the 850 W is likely a vaguely or loosely defined power consumption spec.
 
Last edited:
I just have one question. How can pro audio amplifiers push thousandS of watts for a reasonable cost since the 1990s but these expensive AVRs give up the ghost much earlier?
pro audio amplifiers being PA?
or stuff like Behringer 2500?

they push out that much without any bling..

ahdiophiles don't want 2500 watts, they want 50 Watt class A furnace heat mode..
 
We don’t know the power supply ratings of many separate amps, let alone avrs, the 850 W is likely a vaguely or loosely defined power consumption spec.
I don't remember where I've seen the spec of the power supply, but it doesn't matter.
If it can draw 850 Watts, it very likely has 1000W in the power supply..

but the 7 x 100+ Watts was actually measured.

the 305 put out 7 x 70 Watts into 7 channels at once:
1793639585658.png



yes, the absolutely rip Yamaha to shreds for failing to deliver power.. that magazine is not bought

that said: it's into 6 Ohms.. nothing wrong with that. 7 x 70 Watts is still nearly 500 Watts of output into audio alone!
Most speakers don't have 8 Ohms impedance where they draw much power anyways..

they also measured 5 x 102 Watts at 4 ohm simultaneously.. the resolution is not great, but you can decipher the numbers on the diagram.
 
I don't remember where I've seen the spec of the power supply, but it doesn't matter.
If it can draw 850 Watts, it very likely has 1000W in the power supply..

but the 7 x 100+ Watts was actually measured.

the 305 put out 7 x 70 Watts into 7 channels at once:
View attachment 568954


yes, the absolutely rip Yamaha to shreds for failing to deliver power.. that magazine is not bought

that said: it's into 6 Ohms.. nothing wrong with that. 7 x 70 Watts is still nearly 500 Watts of output into audio alone!
Most speakers don't have 8 Ohms impedance where they draw much power anyways..

they also measured 5 x 102 Watts at 4 ohm simultaneously.. the resolution is not great, but you can decipher the numbers on the diagram.

I hear what you are saying, but in reality, it is not like that at all. For example, you can usually draw a lot more “power” than the official rating (based on established standards) of a power supply, whether it is a linear power supply or switching power supply. Which AVR you are referring to, I can look it up for you. If it is the 305, it will be nowhere near 850.
 
the Lx505 was rated at 850Watts
Again, if you are referring to power supply rating, then no way. Keep in mind it can output much more than the PS rating, on short term basis so don’t go by that for evidence.
 
I mean, they list 850W as the power consumption "operating", not a "max burst power delivery"...
 
I mean, they list 850W as the power consumption "operating", not a "max burst power delivery"...
Here's the back of your 505, where it says 850W. That's not going to be your output power. Class A/B are inefficient and heat is generated along w/the power.
In other words, you may draw 850W from your wall but you won't get 850W output unless you are claiming Class A/B amp can be 100% efficient.

1793645695657.png
 
I suspect that the old FTC standard (1974) would have (heh) short circuited the titular limp mode. It was specifically not directly applicable to multichannel domestic amplifiers or receivers, though. :rolleyes:
I just have one question. How can pro audio amplifiers push thousandS of watts for a reasonable cost since the 1990s but these expensive AVRs give up the ghost much earlier?
Kind of musing, but those pro amps are generally, and especially so in days of yore, just amplifiers, not sharing an overstuffed box with a bunch of energy consuming, heat producing junk... I mean features ;) all sharing one power supply and mains connection. It's a recipe for a nasty, brutish, and short product lifespan... or a very high price tag and a very large package, In terms of a multi- or oligochannel ;) all in one "solution", i.e., an "AVR".


Pro amps historically weren't designed for the utmost in distortion or S/N performance but they were meant to be robust, reliable, and tolerant of "pilot error" in terms of their treatment and the kind of loads to which they were subjected. :)
 
Here's the back of your 505, where it says 850W. That's not going to be your output power. Class A/B are inefficient and heat is generated along w/the power.
In other words, you may draw 850W from your wall but you won't get 850W output unless you are claiming Class A/B amp can be 100% efficient.

View attachment 568970

doesn't mean that it isn't an 850W power supply, does it?

yes, we can expect maybe 60% efficiency from a class A/B amp, but that's still around 500W of continuous power..

nobody would ever need that kind of power , ever..

and it was proven to be able to provide 700+ watts simultaneously into a surround system (measured the output at 7 channels at once with a 6 ohm load)

so.. it can provide enough power to blow your ears out..
and the power supply is actually much bigger than the one in the x3800H, iirc..

where are we going with this again?
 
doesn't mean that it isn't an 850W power supply, does it?

yes, we can expect maybe 60% efficiency from a class A/B amp, but that's still around 500W of continuous power..

nobody would ever need that kind of power , ever..

and it was proven to be able to provide 700+ watts simultaneously into a surround system (measured the output at 7 channels at once with a 6 ohm load)

so.. it can provide enough power to blow your ears out..
and the power supply is actually much bigger than the one in the x3800H, iirc..

where are we going with this again?
I was just trying to remove some of the confusion concerning the "850W" in your conversation with peng (nothing more).
 
Gents, first of all, let me be clear, those are "Power consumption", I put it in quote because it is so called, we don't know what the figure is based on and it looks obvious that manufacturers don't all follow the same basis, or standards (if any).

Take a look of the following examples of a few class AB amps including the Pioneer LX305:

Marantz Cinema 30, weight: 42.5 lbs, power consumption: 780 W
Denon AVR-A1H, weight: 70.6 lbs, power consumption: 1100 W
Yamaha RX-A8A, weight: 47.2 lbs, power consumption: 600 W
Pioneer VSX-LX305, weight: 28.7 lbs, power consumption: 850 W
Pioneer VSX-LX805, weight: 47.4 lbs, power consumption: 1095 W (North America), 1190 W (Europe, Australia).

With due respect to all, please don't take those figures too seriously on their own, though we can certainly use such info to compare the different models of the same brand such as the LX305 vs LX805, and conclude that the LX805's power supply and power output are significantly higher than that of the LX305, but we cannot say they are more powerful, or have larger power supply than the Yamaha RX-A8A just because the Yamaha rated its power consumption much lower.

The things we do know, in recent years, Yamaha provides two power consumption figures, the lower number is stated simply as power consumption, where as the much higher number is specified with the caveat "Maximum" (stated as for all channel driven and at 10% THD).

D+M, according to one of Gene's write up, he actually contacted Masimo about this:


I emailed our friends at Sound United to inquire about how they rate the back panel power consumption of their products and the answer was very revealing.

What does the back panel power consumption rating mean?​

  • Unless it says "max power" don't assume it's a max power rating with all channels driven.
  • ·According to Sound United, they follow IEC 62368-1 electrical safety standard for rating power, specifically Annex B for operating conditions and Annex E for test conditions.
  • Amplifier to be tested at 1/8th unclipped de-rated power @ 1kHz & rated load impedance.
  • Sound United follows IEC 62368-1, the electrical safety standard for audio, video and similar equipment for their AV receivers.
  • Follow operating condition under Annex B: Normal operating condition tests, abnormal operating condition tests and single fault condition tests, and the amplifier output conditions defined under Annex E: Test conditions for equipment containing audio amplifiers.
  • Measured input current/power under normal operating conditions shall NOT exceed the rated current/power by > 10%. Note: ACD testing is NOT considered a "normal operating" condition.

That's just Masimo, that is applicable to D+M AVRs, but not necessarily other manufacturers.

And again, all these are just about "Power Consumption" figures stated on the back panel, we really do NOT know much about the Power supply ratings, very few, if any, has ever published the VA rating of their power supply transformers, but that (Power supply) rating is another can of worm discussion for any day, if ever lol...

My first response to @MbphotoX 's earlier post was about Power supply rating, not power output rating, not the power consumption rating, the three are obviously related but not quite rating at all.
 
I was just trying to remove some of the confusion concerning the "850W" in your conversation with peng (nothing more).
And you probably know that I find it difficult not to respond some of the forum info based on misconceptions or misinterpreted (all unintentional, that I understand, so no offence to anyone).
 
Gents, first of all, let me be clear, those are "Power consumption", I put it in quote because it is so called, we don't know what the figure is based on and it looks obvious that manufacturers don't all follow the same basis, or standards (if any).

Take a look of the following examples of a few class AB amps including the Pioneer LX305:

Marantz Cinema 30, weight: 42.5 lbs, power consumption: 780 W
Denon AVR-A1H, weight: 70.6 lbs, power consumption: 1100 W
Yamaha RX-A8A, weight: 47.2 lbs, power consumption: 600 W
Pioneer VSX-LX305, weight: 28.7 lbs, power consumption: 850 W
Pioneer VSX-LX805, weight: 47.4 lbs, power consumption: 1095 W (North America), 1190 W (Europe, Australia).

With due respect to all, please don't take those figures too seriously on their own, though we can certainly use such info to compare the different models of the same brand such as the LX305 vs LX805, and conclude that the LX805's power supply and power output are significantly higher than that of the LX305, but we cannot say they are more powerful, or have larger power supply than the Yamaha RX-A8A just because the Yamaha rated its power consumption much lower.

The things we do know, in recent years, Yamaha provides two power consumption figures, the lower number is stated simply as power consumption, where as the much higher number is specified with the caveat "Maximum" (stated as for all channel driven and at 10% THD).

D+M, according to one of Gene's write up, he actually contacted Masimo about this:


I emailed our friends at Sound United to inquire about how they rate the back panel power consumption of their products and the answer was very revealing.



That's just Masimo, that is applicable to D+M AVRs, but not necessarily other manufacturers.

And again, all these are just about "Power Consumption" figures stated on the back panel, we really do NOT know much about the Power supply ratings, very few, if any, has ever published the VA rating of their power supply transformers, but that (Power supply) rating is another can of worm discussion for any day, if ever lol...

My first response to @MbphotoX 's earlier post was about Power supply rating, not power output rating, not the power consumption rating, the three are obviously related but not quite rating at all.
Since the D&M blurb mentioned "Amplifier to be tested at 1/8th unclipped de-rated power @ 1kHz & rated load impedance.", does this mean it's on a conservative basis? You can nearly report anything after clipping and claim more power, can't you?
 
Since the D&M blurb mentioned "Amplifier to be tested at 1/8th unclipped de-rated power @ 1kHz & rated load impedance.", does this mean it's on a conservative basis? You can nearly report anything after clipping and claim more power, can't you?
Exactly, the important thing to understand is, as @popej mentioned a couple times earlier, for short time duration, amplifier output and power consumption can be higher, even much higher. Output devices, power transformers do have short time overload capabilities. Even the mini class D amplifiers such as Fosi, 3 e Audio, Aiyima amps that use SMPS (bricks) can claim 2X250 W when the 48 V 5 A brick's VA rating is only 48X5= 240 VA.

D+M claims 70% guarantee, so the X3800H can claim 105X5X.7 = 367.5 W, more into 4 ohms, at rated load the class AB amp efficiency is about 70%, so the power supply transformer would be at least 525 VA, or power consumption about 660 W.

Quoting what MbphotoX who quoted Audiovision.de:

Into 5 ohm, it would be 113X5 = 565 W, so the draw from the wall outlet would be around 750 to 800 W, or more, yet again the power consumption spec of the X3800H, according to the owner's manual is 660 W so you can't go by that.

If Denon were to use Yamaha's dual power consumption spec, they might have their "Maximum" as high as 800 W or higher. Remember Yamaha's spec for the flagship RX-A8A is 600 W, but Maximum is 1,160 W. It is real mess, resulting in people speculating all kinds of numbers. Best to ignore such specs, and rely more on bench test measurements. That's why we need Amir.

1793658199348.png
 
Aside from Dlalolum, who never even could confirm that he actually encountered limp mode, there has never been anyone who spoke up to report about it. No user has ever encountered this limp mode in the real world.
Not a single AVR Review measuring these devices and testing them in proper home theatre setups has ever mentioned the AVR going into "limp" mode..
Yep never actually encountered Limp mode - even driving my 1.6ohm speakers - and not sounding great doing it (sounded great as a preamp, with my external power amps driving the same speakers)
Someone (was it dlalolum?) had a power measuring device connected to the power socket and measured the power draw by the AVR.
They noticed that the AVR would CLICK (the relays switches to the lower voltage rail when only little power is used, and it will switch back when you turn up the volume.. the user clearly showed this behaviour with his measurements. He also showed us how the Hdmi boards just "existing" were drawing insane amounts of power.. the speakers playing music didn't even affect the reading.. it was all smooth and flat.)
Nope, not me...

Based on my experiences, Limp mode was never a real life issue - but the (DRX3.4) AVR was "unhappy" driving my speakers, and I wonder whether, like many amps, it gets unstable (which in measurements often shows up as substantially rising distortion) into low impedance loads... - so not a deficit of current/power, but instability into low impedance loads.
 
But the (non-art) RZ70 does not have this "mode".....doesn't it?
I have a feeling that all the Onkyo extended family AVR's have it - but the bar for when it is triggered is far higher for a heavy duty device like the RZ70 - and therefore far less likely to get triggered on a lab bench...
 
Yep never actually encountered Limp mode - even driving my 1.6ohm speakers - and not sounding great doing it (sounded great as a preamp, with my external power amps driving the same speakers)

Nope, not me...

Based on my experiences, Limp mode was never a real life issue - but the (DRX3.4) AVR was "unhappy" driving my speakers, and I wonder whether, like many amps, it gets unstable (which in measurements often shows up as substantially rising distortion) into low impedance loads... - so not a deficit of current/power, but instability into low impedance loads.
You are literally describing "limp mode". Your system was limping along and you didn't realize it was on a lower voltage rail. If you were to finally separate "limp mode" from straight AVR protection that shuts off the device, then we would be on the same page. As it is now, you keep saying it never went into "protect" and the web UI never reports it. Again, you are describing what makes this mode so egregious and why so many of us are offended by it. Any sort of "stealth protection" w/o the owner's knowledge is objectionable by most of the world's standards!
 
I have a feeling that all the Onkyo extended family AVR's have it - but the bar for when it is triggered is far higher for a heavy duty device like the RZ70 - and therefore far less likely to get triggered on a lab bench...
We'll see in the gen Onkyos if this modes still exists.

Feel free to bookmark my post #34 to see how well it ages.
 
I wonder if one day, some very smart person would invent, and eventually someone would manufacture a affordable (say under $200) device that allows quick blind AB between amps and speakers. My bet is, it may get invented/designed and made available as prototype for the few, but would never be manufactured as it would put many expensive gear out of business. Many, including me, will continue to spend big bucks on devices that don't sound better, but look, touch, feel, better and even sound better when used imagination helped by the look, touch, feel, but many will not.

Point is, without that, EWL5 and dlaloum will not likely be able to convince each other, not even half way, on this real world limp mode feature that Onkyo, Pioneer entry AVRs offer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom