• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

"Limp mode" for Beginners

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's nothing you're describing that's contradicting what Amir is experiencing (especially the part about switching to a lower rail voltage). I think you're heavily objecting to the term "limp mode". In recent posts, I've renamed it "unintended 4 ohm mode", which is a better descriptor of what's happening and neutral. What makes it "unintended" is that the owner never flips the ohm switch to "4 ohms" from the default and the mode is live until the plug is pulled and the AVR is powered again. Do you refute this part of Amir's finding?

The smoking gun will be when the next gen Onkyos come out that are capable of Dirac ART. If one of these machines is submitted to Amir for testing and no "unintended 4 ohm mode" is found, isn't this proof enough that it never should have been on the non-ART capable machines in the first place? The other telling aspect will be how much more expensive the newer machines will be in order to be just as "robust" as the D&M competition. Time will tell...

No need to further bother dialolum: he's been a happy ART user w/his 4800 and I expect that others who have migrated to other ART-capable machines don't really have much to complain about.
This controversy is a result of ambiguous or inflated specs.

In real life, no home amp should ever deliver 50 watts or more at high frequencies. EDIT: continuous power.
 
Last edited:
There's nothing you're describing that's contradicting what Amir is experiencing (especially the part about switching to a lower rail voltage). I think you're heavily objecting to the term "limp mode". In recent posts, I've renamed it "unintended 4 ohm mode", which is a better descriptor of what's happening and neutral. What makes it "unintended" is that the owner never flips the ohm switch to "4 ohms" from the default and the mode is live until the plug is pulled and the AVR is powered again. Do you refute this part of Amir's finding?

The smoking gun will be when the next gen Onkyos come out that are capable of Dirac ART. If one of these machines is submitted to Amir for testing and no "unintended 4 ohm mode" is found, isn't this proof enough that it never should have been on the non-ART capable machines in the first place? The other telling aspect will be how much more expensive the newer machines will be in order to be just as "robust" as the D&M competition. Time will tell...
no, I don't refute that it does lock itself in the lower voltage (4 Ohm) mode when over-powered.

What I'm objecting is the fact that this keeps getting repeated over and over and over again.. people asking about lawsuits and refunds and whatnot..
Yet, nobody has ever observed this behaviour in normal use of these devices. Tens of thousands were sold, and not a single report exists.

This behaviour is like... "We have this car. It's a great car for commuting and it will reliably do 100 miles per hour on the highway every now and again."
And then a tester comes along and puts the car to the max, running it at 120 mph for 36 hours straight.. the car doesn't break down, but it limits the top speed to 60 mph because the internal system detects some sort of malfunction. (No normal human would ever go 36 hours in a straight line at beyond max speed)



All of us, actual owners of these devices, have witnessed the relay switching in normal use. When the AVR limits power because the system doesn't draw any power. (E.g. when I listen to music at around 65dB on my speakers with 2.8 Ohms min impedance), the AVR wil CLICK and switch to lower output voltage, reduce the power drawn from the wall.
When I turn up the volume to 85+ dB, the AVR CLICKs again, and turns the power up.

The power supply switches between "4 Ohm" mode and "open" mode, if you want to call it that. It conserves power when none is needed, and it releases power when there's a demand.

I'm ordering a power meter for the wall now, just to be able to make these measurements and show how the device behaves in a real life situation.

B&W actually openly advertised the 3 Ohms, but iirc measurements put it at 2.8 Ohms:
1793542855491.png
 
Am I wrong to think class D amps don’t do this, or need to?
 
I don't think they use Class D amps anymore, do they?!
At least, there's no mention of it anywhere I could find.

Any source I've read also said that the RZ50 has class A/B amplification.

(I previously had the LX57 - class D, but had to part with it because it simply couldn't do HDR 4k passthrough and my Tv doesn't have eARC for proper surround..)
 
I don't think they use Class D amps anymore, do they?!
At least, there's no mention of it anywhere I could find.

Any source I've read also said that the RZ50 has class A/B amplification.

(I previously had the LX57 - class D, but had to part with it because it simply couldn't do HDR 4k passthrough and my Tv doesn't have eARC for proper surround..)
I don’t have much interest in AVRS, so I don’t follow the products.

Apparently WIIM is paying attention and has displayed a prototype 5.1 preamp.

Decent class D amps start at about $150, but you could mix and match, depending on the individual speakers. Or use active speakers.
 
I don’t have much interest in AVRS, so I don’t follow the products.

Apparently WIIM is paying attention and has displayed a prototype 5.1 preamp.

Decent class D amps start at about $150, but you could mix and match, depending on the individual speakers. Or use active speakers.
I mean, one certainly could..

But why would I?
the Pioneer does exactly as advertised, has never made me any problems, and works like a charm.

If I get fortunate enough to build a small home theater one day, I'll look into proper Atmos/THX speakers, like the Magnat Cinema Ultra THX series speakers.
By that time, I'll probably upgrade again, Dirac ATR and all that.. But not because I hate my Pioneer..
 
B&W actually openly advertised the 3 Ohms, but iirc measurements put it at 2.8 Ohms:
View attachment 568692
I can't find an impedance curve for your 803 but if it's anything like the 803D, Sound and Vision found the min impedance of 3.65 Ω at 99 Hz. What crossover do you currently have your 505 at?

 
I can't find an impedance curve for your 803 but if it's anything like the 803D, Sound and Vision found the min impedance of 3.65 Ω at 99 Hz. What crossover do you currently have your 505 at?

the 803 D3 is 25 years newer than my N803..
They literally redesigned every single driver on that speaker.

Also, I don't have it crossed over, I run them full range with the subwoofer for support. The little 12" SVS (SB-12 NSD) doesn't really extend the deep bass, it just helps with room modes and serves as an LFE mostly.
This was at my old place, just some fun measurements, with the red line being Direct stereo with Sub (and apparently some MCACC or Dirac lifting the treble) and the blue being pure direct without sub (the bass extension was the same from my tube amp, I'm not imagining this) I then moved the sub to get that hole fixed, but I didn't measure it or didn't save the measurements.. either way, this was just a living room and you can see the age of the speakers and how the tweeter in those old B&Ws was very far from the hyper bright D3 or D4 series:
left AVR with sub red and direct blue.jpg
 
the 803 D3 is 25 years newer than my N803..
They literally redesigned every single driver on that speaker.

Also, I don't have it crossed over, I run them full range with the subwoofer for support. The little 12" SVS (SB-12 NSD) doesn't really extend the deep bass, it just helps with room modes and serves as an LFE mostly.
This was at my old place, just some fun measurements, with the red line being Direct stereo with Sub (and apparently some MCACC or Dirac lifting the treble) and the blue being pure direct without sub (the bass extension was the same from my tube amp, I'm not imagining this) I then moved the sub to get that hole fixed, but I didn't measure it or didn't save the measurements.. either way, this was just a living room and you can see the age of the speakers and how the tweeter in those old B&Ws was very far from the hyper bright D3 or D4 series:
View attachment 568720
That S&V article was posted in 2005. So your speakers are 1980 vintage? That's pretty old gear and due for a change methinks.
 
That S&V article was posted in 2005. So your speakers are 1980 vintage? That's pretty old gear and due for a change methinks.
B&W 803 D3 were released in 2015, and my Nautilus 803 are from 1997..
so, yeah, pretty vintage..

are we gonna beat that horse now that you got nothing left to rant on about the Pioneer?


edit: just realised that your post was about the 803D (not D3, third gen diamond)
sorry..
yeah, the D was the next gen after the nautilus.
However, the 803D utilised different bass drivers than the 803S (alu dome tweeter) and my Nautilus 803.. even the 803S (from the same generation as the 803D) used different bass drivers as my N803 (was otherwise basically identical, though)
 
The smoking gun will be when the next gen Onkyos come out that are capable of Dirac ART. If one of these machines is submitted to Amir for testing and no "unintended 4 ohm mode" is found, isn't this proof enough that it never should have been on the non-ART capable machines in the first place?
But the (non-art) RZ70 does not have this "mode".....doesn't it?
 
B&W 803 D3 were released in 2015, and my Nautilus 803 are from 1997..
so, yeah, pretty vintage..

are we gonna beat that horse now that you got nothing left to rant on about the Pioneer?


edit: just realised that your post was about the 803D (not D3, third gen diamond)
sorry..
yeah, the D was the next gen after the nautilus.
However, the 803D utilised different bass drivers than the 803S (alu dome tweeter) and my Nautilus 803.. even the 803S (from the same generation as the 803D) used different bass drivers as my N803 (was otherwise basically identical, though)
Yeah, I'm not looking to pick a fight. I actually do enjoy that we're not trading barbs these last couple of posts.

I had been a staunch supporter of the Pioneer Elite brand since 2006, owning the TSX-84, SC-25, and the LX-701 in succession. My 701 HDMI port started acting up with less than 5 years of ownership and that's when I switched over to Denon for the first time on my current 3800. I have no bad feelings for Pioneer and can understand why they're no longer part of the PAC group (now owned by Gentex). Having Onkyo, Integra, and Pioneer make clones of the same products w/o a ton of market differentiation makes no sense (Integra at least caters to custom installers).
 
Seems like there is a simple and universal solution. Use loudspeakers with higher nominal impedance and/or less sadistic impedance curves. Widespread shift in purchasing might shift the product offerings to easier to drive loudspeakers. :) If there is any real advantage to loudspeakers that resemble reactive short circuits, I remain naive. ;)
 
But the (non-art) RZ70 does not have this "mode".....doesn't it?
That's correct. The RZ70 doesn't suffer from "unintended 4 ohm mode" as it caters to the higher end customer that won't tolerate power sapping of any kind (not to mention it's Onkyo's current flagship AVR). My understanding is that the DSP used in all the current gen Onkyos is not capable of supporting ART (whether this is true or not is up to every RZ70 owner). Your follow-up question will be: then how can you blame the other Onkyos for that "mode" for the lack of ART-capability?

Here's my thinking (I may say "Onkyo" but it also applies to the relevant PAC clone as well):

Current gen Onkyo RZ30/RZ50- not ART capable and has "unintended 4 ohm mode"

1) Next gen Onkyo RZ31/RZ51 - ART capable and doesn't have "unintended 4 ohm mode" - I was right to say all reserve power is needed for ART, especially at the lower speaker ohms.

or

2) Next gen Onkyo RZ31/RZ51 - ART capable and does have "unintended 4 ohm mode" - then I will eat crow and the mode doesn't impact ART at all.

If #1 is true (and I have no reason to doubt this given the robust nature of current D&M designs starting w/the 3800), then the question you should ask yourself is why would Onkyo get rid of the mode since it typically leads to higher reliability and less hardware investment like HDMI heatsinks? As I said before, only time will tell.
 
Seems like there is a simple and universal solution. Use loudspeakers with higher nominal impedance and/or less sadistic impedance curves. Widespread shift in purchasing might shift the product offerings to easier to drive loudspeakers. :) If there is any real advantage to loudspeakers that resemble reactive short circuits, I remain naive. ;)
I don't think that will ever be a reality. If there was such a pressure on speaker manufacturers to produce speakers closer to 8 ohm nominal, then there'd be a "speaker standard". The audio industry is already as transparent as mud as it is. I guess we should feel "lucky" that the FTC even gave us the amplifier reporting standard of power into 2 channels at 8 ohms, 20Hz-20kHz. I'd ask for a 4 ohm number as well but that would upset quite a bit of OEMs. ;)
 
I don't think that will ever be a reality. If there was such a pressure on speaker manufacturers to produce speakers closer to 8 ohm nominal, then there'd be a "speaker standard". The audio industry is already as transparent as mud as it is. I guess we should feel "lucky" that the FTC even gave us the amplifier reporting standard of power into 2 channels at 8 ohms, 20Hz-20kHz. I'd ask for a 4 ohm number as well but that would upset quite a bit of OEMs. ;)
I am of the opinion (like some others on ASR), that "one cannot have too much power" and "one doesn't realize how often their amps are clipping..", and "one doesn't realize how little power they actually need/use in their real world applications.." are are true to a point and under some conditions. Similarly, people often get overly concern about low impedance dips, and/or high phase angles, stability issues etc.

The fact is, most mid range AVRs including the likes of RZ30, and the Pioneer versions could do very well in many homes without activating protection mode, or even limp mode. People just need to be ware of those limits and if they have reasons to be concerned such as needing/using outputs close enough (say for example, to over 25% of the rated outputs) to use an online calculator to estimate their chance of triggering such modes, including the limp mode. A quick extreme example, if someone never listen at volume above -20 (like me) on their AVR, then there is nothing to be concern about, assuming the trim settings are less than a few dB. If it exceeds -10, then definitely should investigate on potential risk and solutions.
 
I am of the opinion (like some others on ASR), that "one cannot have too much power" and "one doesn't realize how often their amps are clipping..", and "one doesn't realize how little power they actually need/use in their real world applications.." are are true to a point and under some conditions. Similarly, people often get overly concern about low impedance dips, and/or high phase angles, stability issues etc.

The fact is, most mid range AVRs including the likes of RZ30, and the Pioneer versions could do very well in many homes without activating protection mode, or even limp mode. People just need to be ware of those limits and if they have reasons to be concerned such as needing/using outputs close enough (say for example, to over 25% of the rated outputs) to use an online calculator to estimate their chance of triggering such modes, including the limp mode. A quick extreme example, if someone never listen at volume above -20 (like me) on their AVR, then there is nothing to be concern about, assuming the trim settings are less than a few dB. If it exceeds -10, then definitely should investigate on potential risk and solutions.
Agreed. I think most of us understand that the amp in any given AVR will usually pale in comparison to a dedicated amp (for the same money). That's why any reduction in power is so egregious for an AVR, especially when the mode allows the AVR to operate w/o letting the owner know it's on a different voltage rail.
 
But the Pioneer has an 850W power supply

It was literally tested and found to be able to push out over 100 watts each into 7 channels AT ONCE..

I don't think it pales compared to standalone amps power-wise..
sure, it probably cannot compete against the Topping B200 SINAD-wise and all.. but iirc, it beats the fancy HEGEL integrated amp at twice the cost.. or almost beats it.


regarding ART, if that is intensive load on processing, then yeah.. maybe the missing cooling on the processor could be a reason to omit the feature..
lack of power certainly isn't.
 
It was literally tested and found to be able to push out over 100 watts each into 7 channels AT ONCE...
If memory serves, that was rated into 6 ohms. I'd like to see the 8 ohm number as that is more commonly reported. No one has ever said the 505 doesn't have a decent power supply. It's the software and the heat control that is really driving the bus.

I think we're generally agreeing in most points. In where we disagree is how it impacts sound quality. If Onkyo ends up removing the mode for the next gen, I'll see that as a sign of "yeah, it can make a difference (especially for ART)".
 
I just have one question. How can pro audio amplifiers push thousandS of watts for a reasonable cost since the 1990s but these expensive AVRs give up the ghost much earlier?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom