• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Lily Audio Genesis One Headphone Review

Rate this headphone:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 152 84.9%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 19 10.6%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 5 2.8%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 3 1.7%

  • Total voters
    179
Yes, the new one should be a lot easier to drive (easier, not easy).
I think I'll get one in for testing the next few weeks, then we'll know more.
Interesting.
The surround size is normally included in the diaphragm's nominal diameter, so that's fine. Otherwise a traditional 40mm headphone driver would only be about 17-20 mm.
It gets more tricky if we're talking about effective diameter of course, but even then we have to partially count the surround as well.
I think you mean the voice coil diameter with that 17-20mm ?
Yes, the effective diameter is 55mm for the G1 (and about 34-36 for 40mm drivers)
Manufacturers often even seem to count the outer diameter of the whole assembly.
Just because manufacturers do this does not make it right. :)
 
I think you mean the voice coil diameter with that 17-20mm ?
Yes, the effective diameter is 55mm for the G1 (and about 34-36 for 40mm drivers)
Well, it's not quite that simple.

First off, the "nominal diameter" (e.g. "40mm driver") refers to the outside dimensions - this is the relevant dimension for the mechanical engineer designing the rest of the headphone.
"40mm driver" means "leave space for a disc that's 40 mm in diameter"

The nominal diameter tells you a little bit about how much diaphragm area there will be, but it is not the only thing that matters, it depends on the diaphragm's design as well as on the inner diameter of the frame/basket.

For a conventional headphone driver, which is manufactured from a single material that is pressed into shape, the "surround" portion (which is the part that folds/bends during use) stretches from the inner diameter of the frame to the voice coil. This means that only the part of the diaphragm that's inside the voice coil's circle moves like a piston - because the surround is fixed at the edge, so not all of its area moves pistonically
The displacement profile along the radius is typically such that on the edge the displacement is zero and towards the voice coil it reaches its maximum, where it then stays constant to the centerpoint
A good approximation for the linear system is to take the midway point between the inner and outer radius of the surround and describe the loudspeaker as a piston with a radius that's exactly that: the halfway point between the inner and outer radius of the surround.

For cone drivers the same core idea works well - the only real difference being that the surround is typically smaller and the actual pistonic area is larger (due to the stiff cone). So you can fit a higher acoustically effective area (Sd) into the same nominal diameter.

Yes, the effective diameter is 55mm for the G1 (and about 34-36 for 40mm drivers)
Effective diameter is a bit more than 55 mm.
If nominal diameter is 75 mm, consisting of a 55m true piston and a 10mm surround, then the effective diameter is 55+10 = 65mm.
Not all of the surround contributes to the sound pressure, but that doesn't mean that it contributes nothing either.
Manufacturers often even seem to count the outer diameter of the whole assembly.
Yes, manufacturers specify the outer diameter (nominal diameter), because that is what matters on whether or not you can fit the speaker into your earcup.
The acoustically effective diameter is not usually given directly, instead the acoustically effective area (Sd) is specified, because the area is what matters for acoustics, not the diameter.
Of course you can calculate the effective diameter from the effective area: deff=2*sqrt(Sd/π)
 
Effective diameter is a bit more than 55 mm.
Indeed... a (little) bit more in this particular case.

Agreed on what you say (of course) on driver construction, dimensions, effective diameter and its 'sliding slope'.
BUT in this particular case (the very supple roll-edge for the rigid 'disc') I reckon the effective diameter is closer to 57mm effective than 75mm and only for the lower frequencies at that.

What I meant with "... the marketing material still states that the membrane is 75mm diameter but in reality the membrane is 55mm in diameter..."
is this:
Schermafdruk van 2026-09-27 08-46-50.png


and for the upcoming 'pure':
Schermafdruk van 2026-09-27 08-55-24.png


There isn't a 75mm honeycomb diaphragm ... there is a 55 mm honeycomb diaphragm (+ 20mm very soft roll-edge).
That was my point and sure ... perhaps I should have written 'honeycomb diaphragm' instead of 'membrane'.

I welcome the 10dB increased sensitivity and hope it doesn't 'cost' anything in say.. higher capacitance or max SPL (lower allowed max. pp voltage).

It seems they were able to get the same sensitivity as Pioneer did with the SE300 and SE700, but with a lot of bass.

Looking forward to your findings of the 'pure' and hope you post a link to them at ASR too when the info is released for publication.
 
Last edited:
Indeed... a (little) bit more in this particular case.
Don't underestimate the difference here!
A diameter of 55 mm yields about 24 cm2 of area.
A diameter of 65 mm yields about 33 cm3 of area.
That's a difference of 40%.
In terms of sound pressure level that's an additional 3 dB. Quite significant

BUT in this particular case (the very supple roll-edge for the rigid 'disc') I reckon the effective diameter is closer to 57mm effective than 75mm and only for the lower frequencies at that.
What makes you say that? Excursion levels are not high enough for the surround to behave in a significant nonlinear manner, so the linear approximation (half of the width) will hold just fine.
The nonlinearity in this system is limited not by the surround but by the piezo-coefficients

And sure, all of this is only true for frequencies below the first breakup frequency. That's true for any diaphragm or membrane. At breakup modes the effective surface area is reduced as individual components of the area are decoupling. That's what limits high frequency extension in a loudspeaker - but high-frequency extension is not a problem this headphone has.

What I meant with "... the marketing material still states that the membrane is 75mm diameter but in reality the membrane is 55mm in diameter..."
is this:
View attachment 561194

and for the upcoming 'pure':
View attachment 561196

There isn't a 75mm honeycomb diaphragm ... there is a 55 mm honeycomb diaphragm (+ 20mm very soft roll-edge).
That was my point and sure ... perhaps I should have written 'honeycomb diaphragm' instead of 'membrane'.
I see your point! But that's industry convention - Diaphragm size doesn't describe the acoustically effective area, it describes the mechanical dimensions. (Acoustically effective area is given as "Sd", not as "size")
It's a 75 mm diaphragm because that's the outer diameter, and parts of the diaphragm are made from the honeycomb material.
 
I get your points.

A 55 mm honeycomb with a large thin rubber surround measuring 75mm in outer diameter in total, even if almost half the surface area has extremely different acoustic and mechanical properties can safely be called a '75mm honeycomb driver' because some of it is made out of stiff honeycomb material and has that diameter.

The nonlinearity in this system is limited not by the surround but by the piezo-coefficients
Sure largely it is, and quite measurable (but not as audible as many think)..., and also the modal behavior of the 55mm honeycomb disc as it is only driven from (part of) the center where it is affixed to the flexing element.
And not forgetting maybe some small contribution by almost half the surface area does not move in the same way as the edge of the honey comb disc does.
 
Back
Top Bottom