• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

KEF versus Revel. Save me money ASR

Including value which system would you recommend?

  • Revel Ideal

    Votes: 6 27.3%

  • Revel Realistic

    Votes: 11 50.0%

  • KEF Ideal(reference)

    Votes: 1 4.5%

  • KEf Ideal(R11)

    Votes: 2 9.1%

  • KEF Realistic

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Total voters
    22
e: Ignore room volume I calculated bullshit.

Regarding speaker sizing.

There's a table here for recommended reference SPL levels https://www.atsc.org/wp-content/upl...tablishing-and-maintaining-audio-loudness.pdf (see Table 10.2 Reference Sound Pressure Level). There's also other standards that give slightly less SPL but more or less this is in the correct ballpark https://www.masteringthemix.com/blogs/learn/the-perfect-monitoring-levels-for-your-home-studio

Looking at your room, 21' * 28' * 38 is is 22344cuft (633m³) we should achieve 85dBC SPL at the listening position.

Looking at manufacturer spec sheets regarding sensitivity:

KEF R11 90dB
KEF R7 88dB
KEF R5 87dB

F226Be 90dB
F208 88.5dB
F206 87.6dB

We can see there's not much difference. Also note that multiple speakers will increase SPL obviously, you can assume +3dB for a stereo pair, with diminishing returns when adding more speakers.

In any case, taking listenting distance into account you could sit 20 feet (6m) away from any of these speakers and still reach 85dB with only 10W of amplifier power.

Unless you need insane volume I see no reason to spend the big bucks. Obviously then comes the question of crest factor and how much volume above the average you need.

Regardless of any standards or recommendations - do you know how loud you like listen at the moment? Do you have a calibrated SPL meter? If not get one, they are cheap.
 
Last edited:
To be honest, I would not choose either.

Instead:
3 pairs of Ascend ELX Tower (Raal) 5300 per pair
Ascend Sierra Horizontal v2 (Raal) 1750
Total 17650

ascendacoustics.com

ELX TOWER PAIR

Introducing our new ELX Tower! In development for over a decade, our ELX Towers represent the current State-Of-The-Art of loudspeaker design. Every performance category has been fully optimized – from shockingly deep bass extension and punch, to incredible spaciousness and ideal tonal balance...
ascendacoustics.com ascendacoustics.com
ascendacoustics.com

SIERRA HORIZON V2

Our Renowned Center Speaker! Combining the most advanced R&D lab equipment with sophisticated computer modeling, we have perfected a highly advanced crossover technology that we have been working on for over a decade. This new NFS optimized crossover better preserves dynamics and provides...
ascendacoustics.com ascendacoustics.com

And myself I would not use towers for surrounds and rears, but bookshelf speakers instead.
 
digitalfrost said:
Looking at your room, 21' * 28' * 38 is is 22344cuft (633m³) we should achieve 85dBC SPL at the listening position.
Click to expand...
Whichever number is used for ceiling height seems a bit high, huh? :)
I believe all dimensions given were wall lengths, with no mention of ceiling height.
My guess is the room has about 1/3 that 633m3 volume......
 
gnarly said:
My guess is the room has about 1/3 the volume......
Click to expand...

Even less, I’d guess.

Nevertheless, a volume of 633m³ could only be true with a ceiling height of around 37' (11 m) or so.
 
digitalfrost said:
Regarding speaker sizing.

There's a table here for recommended reference SPL levels https://www.atsc.org/wp-content/upl...tablishing-and-maintaining-audio-loudness.pdf (see Table 10.2 Reference Sound Pressure Level). There's also other standards that give slightly less SPL but more or less this is in the correct ballpark https://www.masteringthemix.com/blogs/learn/the-perfect-monitoring-levels-for-your-home-studio

Looking at your room, 21' * 28' * 38 is is 22344cuft (633m³) we should achieve 85dBC SPL at the listening position.

Looking at manufacturer spec sheets regarding sensitivity:

KEF R11 90dB
KEF R7 88dB
KEF R5 87dB

F226Be 90dB
F208 88.5dB
F206 87.6dB

We can see there's not much difference. Also note that multiple speakers will increase SPL obviously, you can assume +3dB for a stereo pair, with diminishing returns when adding more speakers.

In any case, taking listenting distance into account you could sit 20 feet (6m) away from any of these speakers and still reach 85dB with only 10W of amplifier power.

Unless you need insane volume I see no reason to spend the big bucks. Obviously then comes the question of crest factor and how much volume above the average you need.

Regardless of any standards or recommendations - do you know how loud you like listen at the moment? Do you have a calibrated SPL meter? If not get one, they are cheap.
Click to expand...
Thank you that is really good information. I tend to listen louder with movies and Netflix etc. With music I find if I go that loud I loose some of the dynamics/detail. I think with your information I will be ok with either. As amper42 said maybe bid out both the KEF and Revel. As to room size it’s a 9 foot ceiling but the walls are all different lengths. Back wall is angled about 40 degrees.
 
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ said:
You are correct all 4 walls are different lengths
Click to expand...

The stated foot values seem to come from something like this:

1729093898978.png
 
amper42 said:
I replaced my Ascend Sierra Towers with RAAL Tweeters with the Revel F228Be. What a HUGE difference. Can't imagine ever wanting to go back. I need to sell my Sierra Towers so if any one wants them send me private mail.
Click to expand...
Is it the current NFS optimized v2 version? If so, what were the main differences (if not off topic)?
 
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ said:
Interesting the vote is overwhelmingly Revel Realistic but more discussion on the KEFs. I think this just means more people have KEFS ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Click to expand...

Revel speakers are not much know. If you pay attention on internet, KEF is doing and aggressive marketing sending its speakers to YouTubers or even Amir for reviewing. For its measurements, seems to be great speakers though I not liking its design. On the other side, Revel is Harman's premium speakers, have to spend time selling probably more profitable stuff like JBL Bluetooth earphone or portable speakers.
Just to prove my point, look for release dates for Revel products and compare them with KEF, Klipsch, Polk etc. But, from my perspective, my Performa bookshelf are my definitive speaker.
 
IMO the room is too large unless there is a point to it like multiple rows of seats, and even then better to re-think the whole concept. Also, the OP did not state his SPL expectations at MLP. We also don't know the size of the screen. If below 120", I usually urge people to consider flat panel options (really 115" TCL Max). Difficult to imagine that anything in this price range could come close to its performance, but yeah the size is limited. Using smaller screen and getting closer to it achieves a lot of the immersion factor and is also friendly to speaker choice as all of a sudden you are 2.5m or so away from the MLP.

Filling that room with SPL of 105dB for peaks per Dolby specs at 0dB reference volume and acceptable distortion is not really going to happen at 6m listening distance without some heavy duty professional speakers. So neither KEF or Revels would really do. On the sub side, that room can easily swallow 10 $2K subs unless they are near field, in which case perhaps just 8 or so could do.

Thinking about such large project requires also thinking about what is the ultimate goal and all components including subs and processor. Smaller room would be much easier to manage, plus you get extra storage if you divide it. Storage space is very valuable as well. You will have so many boxes to store after your are done with the project.
 
A significant question is whether the OP will benefit from using a concentric driver.

If the OP only is concerned about timbre while in the listening position, and the listening ear level is at or close to the tweeter height, then the Revel will perform great.

If the OP wants more consistent timbre over a broader vertical range, then the KEF probably is the better choice.
 
If your room allows, you can consider in-wall and in-ceiling speakers as well for surrounds/heights. Both KEF and Revel have good options there in a market where CI speakers often come up short on performance.
 
Oddball said:
IMO the room is too large unless there is a point to it like multiple rows of seats, and even then better to re-think the whole concept. Also, the OP did not state his SPL expectations at MLP. We also don't know the size of the screen. If below 120", I usually urge people to consider flat panel options (really 115" TCL Max). Difficult to imagine that anything in this price range could come close to its performance, but yeah the size is limited. Using smaller screen and getting closer to it achieves a lot of the immersion factor and is also friendly to speaker choice as all of a sudden you are 2.5m or so away from the MLP.

Filling that room with SPL of 105dB for peaks per Dolby specs at 0dB reference volume and acceptable distortion is not really going to happen at 6m listening distance without some heavy duty professional speakers. So neither KEF or Revels would really do. On the sub side, that room can easily swallow 10 $2K subs unless they are near field, in which case perhaps just 8 or so could do.

Thinking about such large project requires also thinking about what is the ultimate goal and all components including subs and processor. Smaller room would be much easier to manage, plus you get extra storage if you divide it. Storage space is very valuable as well. You will have so many boxes to store after your are done with the project.
Click to expand...
For clarification

There will be two rows of seating. Probably 130” screen.

Oddball I’m surprised none those speakers would get to the recommended volume with appropriate amps. Though I suspect your technical knowledge outstrips my own. That’s why I read ASR. Right now I’m just looking for help with speakers.

Although it’s a good idea last thing I really need in my life is more storage. We had a previous home with tons of storage. Once word got out family(of course) and friends it was “could you just hold onto this for me for a little bit”.

As to terryforsythe’s question I’m mainly concerned about timbre in the listening position(s). I’m not as concerned about timbre when standing or walking around.
 
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ said:
For clarification

There will be two rows of seating. Probably 130” screen.

Oddball I’m surprised none those speakers would get to the recommended volume with appropriate amps. Though I suspect your technical knowledge outstrips my own. That’s why I read ASR. Right now I’m just looking for help with speakers.

Although it’s a good idea last thing I really need in my life is more storage. We had a previous home with tons of storage. Once word got out family(of course) and friends it was “could you just hold onto this for me for a little bit”.

As to terryforsythe’s question I’m mainly concerned about timbre in the listening position(s). I’m not as concerned about timbre when standing or walking around.
Click to expand...
You want to have a small club sized space, so that is how it works.

Make a room smaller and simplify your life. Unless you spend another $10k on various room treatments it’s going to ring like Christmas and even then will make EQ more difficult.

Not sure if you realized how many subs would you need for that space. I have 5 for 1/4 of your volume. And always on the verge of ordering more.
 
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ said:
Lastly anyone know any Rebel dealers near Atlanta they are hard to find online.
Click to expand...
amper42 said:
The F328Be and F228Be will fill this room with no problem. If you use half of a 200W Purifi amp you will need to wear ear protection while in the room. I have a 28' x 24' room with F328Be speakers in stereo and they reach my needed sound levels with less than 10W. I wouldn't be concerned about the Revels not filling this room. That's crazy talk. ;)
Click to expand...
Revels, KEFs, nor Perlistens S7t will not fill this room if they need to operate from 6m distance at 105dB. Not sure where the 6m came from just picked it up. Furthermore, watching 130" screen from 6m is also not going to provide immersion. That would be more of 200" screen from 6 m, but could involve additional cost in that size.

I understand that people have different views, so I will just fade away from this thread as already voiced my concerns that are supported with experience in similar XXXLLL projects. Last thing is that these are what are considered good Revel prices, but that is in UK. EU occasionally also has prices like these but not no on the whole lineup.

Search: 22 results found for "revel"

Established in 2008, Nintronics Audio is a specialist retailer and installer of High Fidelity Music and Home Cinema Systems.
nintronics.co.uk nintronics.co.uk

Wish the OP best of luck as this is exciting but clearly overstretched project.
 
If they're behind a screen have you considered something like JBL Cinema? Perhaps consult a company that does home theater.

JBL Cinema Speakers | Pro Audio Solutions

Buy JBL Cinema Speakers from Pro Audio Solutions. We offer great prices and quick shipping!
www.proaudiosolutions.com
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

¯
Matching Center Channel to Focal Scala Utopia EVOs
Replies
4
Views
830
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
¯
Back
Top Bottom