• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Kali Audio IN-8v2 (Second Wave) 3-Way Studio Monitor Review

I’m curious what frequencies bring the guitar forward as in the video 1 at 46:23?

Could you provide a raw moving mic measurement avg (full-range periodic pink noise) and full IR sweep (0-24kHz) of your speakers?
 
Could you provide a raw moving mic measurement avg (full-range periodic pink noise) and full IR sweep (0-24kHz) of your speakers?
I'm not that advanced when comes to audio. The only time I have ever used a microphone was with Audacity that came with my Denon receiver.
Unfortunately, I cannot do any experiments for the next 3 months, I will give it a shot then.
Btw, I don't think my speakers sound differently from the ones tested in the videos, actually they sound the same.
 
Do experiment with boosting different parts of the spectrum by ear, maybe you'll find what you need.
It would be easiest to use an EQ that allow fluent adjustments (like using mouse to drag the filter gain and frequency around).

Measurements will also help.

A cheap way to do MMM is to use one of the Dayton microphones like iMM-6 or iMM-6C (using 3.5mm jack or USB-C respectively) to record audio with your smartphone and analyze it later in REW.

I was able to get such a measurement with the iMM-6 and my phone.

I use my IN-8V2s on desk against the wall, with about 1m listening distance and they sound good to me although I recall my previous Edifier MR4 had more treble which sometimes sounded "detailed" and "airy", but at anything above modest volumes the treble was fatiguing.

I've also tried them in a room, along the longer axis (far from side walls) and experience something similar.

Here is the comparison. I forgot to add the legend, sorry.
Red is IN-8V2 in room,
Green is IN-8V2 on desk, against the wall.
Blue is the Edifier MR4 + Presonus Sub8 subwoofer.
Measurements are smoothed to 1/12th octave for easier viewing.
I've measured both speakers playing at once for Kali, while MR4 was measured with only left speaker and the sub.
Also, MR4 was measured in a different place in the same room, hence such variation in bass performance (lack of energy in the 80-150 Hz range not seen on Kali)

Later I've added a high-shelf filter to the Kalis (+6 dB at 8 kHz) and the sense of "detail" and "air" improved, but it was a bit too much. +4 dB was fine, though.
With even a modest measurement setup, you should be able to find any areas to focus on and tweak around.

in-8-treble.png
 
I'm not that advanced when comes to audio. The only time I have ever used a microphone was with Audacity that came with my Denon receiver.
Unfortunately, I cannot do any experiments for the next 3 months, I will give it a shot then.
Btw, I don't think my speakers sound differently from the ones tested in the videos, actually they sound the same.

Without your actual room measurements, I would just muck around with the raw CEA2034 curves provided by Erin.

With your designed EQ filters in REW (room EQ wizard) select "Export filters impulse response as WAV" which is a convolution FIR file to be used/loaded/toggled on-and-off for a quick A/B listening test -- use whatever test tracks you want.

With REW, exporting 48kHz seems to work correctly as opposed to 96kHz (only two that I tested) probably because the generic EQ design parameters is set by default to 48kHz.

BTW, if you input the exact same values in the example below into something like rePhase, the filters won't match in the high frequencies. Instead, I would invert the generated curve in REW and re-design or "flatten" that one into a new filter set designed for rePhase.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20260603_074738.png
    Screenshot_20260603_074738.png
    55.8 KB · Views: 66
  • Filters-48k.zip
    Filters-48k.zip
    8.2 KB · Views: 32
  • Screenshot_20260603_081321.png
    Screenshot_20260603_081321.png
    251 KB · Views: 65
  • Screenshot_20260603_081256.png
    Screenshot_20260603_081256.png
    250.4 KB · Views: 66
  • KALI IN-8 v2 - SPINORAMA CURVES.mdat.zip
    KALI IN-8 v2 - SPINORAMA CURVES.mdat.zip
    2.2 MB · Views: 47
  • Screenshot_20260603_082254.png
    Screenshot_20260603_082254.png
    158.8 KB · Views: 76
Do experiment with boosting different parts of the spectrum by ear, maybe you'll find what you need.
It would be easiest to use an EQ that allow fluent adjustments (like using mouse to drag the filter gain and frequency around).

Measurements will also help.

A cheap way to do MMM is to use one of the Dayton microphones like iMM-6 or iMM-6C (using 3.5mm jack or USB-C respectively) to record audio with your smartphone and analyze it later in REW.

I was able to get such a measurement with the iMM-6 and my phone.

I use my IN-8V2s on desk against the wall, with about 1m listening distance and they sound good to me although I recall my previous Edifier MR4 had more treble which sometimes sounded "detailed" and "airy", but at anything above modest volumes the treble was fatiguing.

I've also tried them in a room, along the longer axis (far from side walls) and experience something similar.

Here is the comparison. I forgot to add the legend, sorry.
Red is IN-8V2 in room,
Green is IN-8V2 on desk, against the wall.
Blue is the Edifier MR4 + Presonus Sub8 subwoofer.
Measurements are smoothed to 1/12th octave for easier viewing.
I've measured both speakers playing at once for Kali, while MR4 was measured with only left speaker and the sub.
Also, MR4 was measured in a different place in the same room, hence such variation in bass performance (lack of energy in the 80-150 Hz range not seen on Kali)

Later I've added a high-shelf filter to the Kalis (+6 dB at 8 kHz) and the sense of "detail" and "air" improved, but it was a bit too much. +4 dB was fine, though.
With even a modest measurement setup, you should be able to find any areas to focus on and tweak around.

View attachment 536552

I will buy a iMM-6 microphone, they are cheap.
I don't have a wall behind the speakers, but my right speaker does have a wall about 1/2 meter to the side, the setup is not perfect.
When comes to in-8v2, the green on desk response looks fine, the red in room response has some holes in low frequencies, providing I'm reading it right.

When I was experimenting, i usually cut the higher frequencies.
Bringing them up just to see if the guitars would improve but that's just makes everything too bright.
All in all, i was never able to zero in on the right frequency. I usually use foobar and couple of equalizer within that.

The switches on the back of speakers have not helped, no mother what combination I used.
Thanks for help.
 
Without your actual room measurements, I would just muck around with the raw CEA2034 curves provided by Erin.

With your designed EQ filters in REW (room EQ wizard) select "Export filters impulse response as WAV" which is a convolution FIR file to be used/loaded/toggled on-and-off for a quick A/B listening test -- use whatever test tracks you want.

With REW, exporting 48kHz seems to work correctly as opposed to 96kHz (only two that I tested) probably because the generic EQ design parameters is set by default to 48kHz.

BTW, if you input the exact same values in the example below into something like rePhase, the filters won't match in the high frequencies. Instead, I would invert the generated curve in REW and re-design or "flatten" that one into a new filter set designed for rePhase.
I will try this as well. Thanks for the help.
Incidentally, can you hear the differences that I'm hearing in the videos?
 
I will try this as well. Thanks for the help.
Incidentally, can you hear the differences that I'm hearing in the videos?

Such "demos" esp. the first one lack rigor in their test setup methodology. Highly personal and subjective. I treat it as mostly entertainment content -- occasionally informative -- yet can be misleading as well. This is probably why no one else here at ASR has commented.

What I would do instead is learn how to read measurements and validate such measurements by taking some in my own room, and then thereafter understand how the hard objective data (speaker measurements and room acoustics) correlates with my own subjective hearing capabilities and preferences. Learn DSP EQ as well in order to shape what otherwise is less than "nice" or ideal sounding monitors to something more neutral sounding yet also leaning towards my own taste -- which can change depending on the type of played content and listening volume.

Assuming the IN-8 v2 is unsalvageable in your own room listening setup, then I would look for and demo other speakers now being more aware what it is in their objectively verifiable measurements that I clearly do not like or prefer.

Here's a start:


 
Last edited:
Such "demos" esp. the first one lack rigor in their test setup methodology. Highly personal and subjective. I treat it as mostly entertainment content -- occasionally informative -- yet can be misleading as well. This is probably why no one else here at ASR has commented.

What I would do instead is learn how to read measurements and validate such measurements by taking some in my own room, and then thereafter understand how the hard objective data (speaker measurements and room acoustics) correlates with my own subjective hearing capabilities and preferences. Learn DSP EQ as well in order to shape what otherwise is less than "nice" or ideal sounding monitors to something more neutral sounding yet also leaning towards my own taste -- which can change depending on the type of played content and listening volume.

Assuming the IN-8 v2 is unsalvageable in your own room listening setup, then I would look for and demo other speakers now being more aware what it is in their objectively verifiable measurements that I clearly do not like or prefer.

Here's a start:



I'm going to take a look at the videos later today.

I do have a pair of Paradigm Shift A2 powered speakers. These speakers are much smaller but guitars sound more powerful with more bite, very pleasant sound. However, my A2's are not as loud and clean sounding as IN-8v2. Kali's do have good clear detail.
 
I'm going to take a look at the videos later today.

I do have a pair of Paradigm Shift A2 powered speakers. These speakers are much smaller but guitars sound more powerful with more bite, very pleasant sound. However, my A2's are not as loud and clean sounding as IN-8v2. Kali's do have good clear detail.

If you enjoy the speakers, that's what matters. I don't know anything about the Paradigm Shift A2, but Amir did review the Paradigm Monitor SE Atom:



Not exactly super "neutral" either with a bit of accentuated highs, but also perhaps not too bad IMO compared to some other speakers.
 
If you enjoy the speakers, that's what matters. I don't know anything about the Paradigm Shift A2, but Amir did review the Paradigm Monitor SE Atom:



Not exactly super "neutral" either with a bit of accentuated highs, but also perhaps not too bad IMO compared to some other speakers.
Shift A2 are powered and have DSP, frequency response from 55Hz to 20Khz at +/- 2DB, apparently there is an extension to 30Hz, but anything under 37 Hz is not there, if I remember correctly. However, the base was very good, tight and not bloated. They are more bright than Kali in-8. So, I used to equalize them down from 3k onward. The Shift A2 was about $600 for the pair, 13 years ago.
 
Five years on, are these still a good buy at 600eur? Has any competitors risen in the meantime?
 
Five years on, are these still a good buy at 600eur? Has any competitors risen in the meantime?
I don't personally know of any new products in this specific segment (I.e. active mid-sized, lower-mid-budget) since 5 years ago.

If you widen the net a bit, the Palmer Orbit 11 is certainly new and a competitor of sorts, although it is a more "mid-mid budget" option, not the same price point.

There's also the iLoud MTM which is more similar on price; I don't think that was around 5 years ago? But it's for a totally different use case than the IN8.

At €600, I think the IN8 is still gonna be a really solid option today.
 
If you widen the net a bit, the Palmer Orbit 11 is certainly new and a competitor of sorts, although it is a more "mid-mid budget" option, not the same price point.
Palmers are actually a fine point and had a review on ASR, but they're twice the price it seems.
 
I wish someone would bump in with an answer, since I am facing a very similar dilemma.

you get better directivity with the AsciLab F6b but a little less bass. If open to adding a small sub (or 2 as is my preference), the F6Bs might be the sweet spot. Amps are plentiful and there's no need to spend much; a topping Mini500 is probably my choice. We don't have measurements yet but their track record is superb and given it can run in mono you have an upgrade path if you ever need more power (simply buy another one)

The budget pick these days seems to be Ascend Acoustics CBM-170SE2. Also the JBL 308 mkIII should drop any day now, that's probably the closest direct competitor to the IN8v2 but I don't think pricing has been announced and no telling when we'll get independently derived performance data

An open box/B-stock Neumann KH120 II would be another good option, although I'm not a fan myself due having gone through multiple return cycles with their KH80s and bugs with MA1 and simply preferring the sound of other speakers slightly more
 
I think a subwoofer is always a useful addition. In theory, an active tri-amped system should be better than a single-amped one. As far as I recall, non-coaxial drivers in this price range tended to offer better on-axis response—though in-room response is ultimately what matters more. I’m not entirely sure at what distance a coaxial driver actually holds an advantage. For instance, Genelec’s SAM series also includes coaxial models designed for even greater listening distances; there’s likely a good reason for that.

I still really enjoy these speakers. In my country, the price for a pair has gone up from $700 to $1,100. If they were 600 euros, I’d buy them again without a second thought :)

Google AI states that a coaxial design makes sense for lengths up to 3 meters.
 
you get better directivity with the AsciLab F6b but a little less bass. If open to adding a small sub (or 2 as is my preference), the F6Bs might be the sweet spot. Amps are plentiful and there's no need to spend much; a topping Mini500 is probably my choice. We don't have measurements yet but their track record is superb and given it can run in mono you have an upgrade path if you ever need more power (simply buy another one)

The budget pick these days seems to be Ascend Acoustics CBM-170SE2. Also the JBL 308 mkIII should drop any day now, that's probably the closest direct competitor to the IN8v2 but I don't think pricing has been announced and no telling when we'll get independently derived performance data

An open box/B-stock Neumann KH120 II would be another good option, although I'm not a fan myself due having gone through multiple return cycles with their KH80s and bugs with MA1 and simply preferring the sound of other speakers slightly more
I believe I was eyeing the CMB-170SE2 last time I read, but none of other contenders seems to hold the same bass extension and neither CMB-170SE2 nor F6b are front-ported. IN-8 being coaxial strangely seems to drag me in.

I think a subwoofer is always a useful addition. In theory, an active tri-amped system should be better than a single-amped one. As far as I recall, non-coaxial drivers in this price range tended to offer better on-axis response—though in-room response is ultimately what matters more. I’m not entirely sure at what distance a coaxial driver actually holds an advantage. For instance, Genelec’s SAM series also includes coaxial models designed for even greater listening distances; there’s likely a good reason for that.

I still really enjoy these speakers. In my country, the price for a pair has gone up from $700 to $1,100. If they were 600 euros, I’d buy them again without a second thought :)

Google AI states that a coaxial design makes sense for lengths up to 3 meters.
Whether coaxials hold any advantage over the distance is one thing, but aren't they easier to get a proper phantom center in due to wider directivity? Can't really hide the fact that wide stereo imaging and forward placement is the only thing I'm missing with headphones, which coaxials promise.

I wonder where this "AI fellow" read those "up to 3 meters" claims.
 
Whether coaxials hold any advantage over the distance is one thing, but aren't they easier to get a proper phantom center in due to wider directivity?
Yes, I was writing about phantom sound sources. I’m not sure about the impact of the directivity pattern, but since the acoustic centers of the drivers are aligned, this should result in a more cohesive sound. Furthermore, the interference pattern at the crossover point should be improved—especially if the drivers are in phase—though one might expect this to be visible in the directivity plots of systems using conventional drivers (which, in this case, it isn't). I’m not sure how relevant this article is: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11267622/. According to it, "The best localization performance in terms of elevation is of the order of 4–5 degrees." For instance, someone mentioned the Neumann KH120 II earlier; the distance between its drivers is—by my estimation—(130+25)/2 + 35 = 112.5 mm, which corresponds to a distance of approximately 1.61 meters for a 4-degree angle.
 
Coaxials don't have wider directivity. It really depends on design of speaker. As a generalization many non-coaxials have a wider horizontal dispersion causing greater envelopment/soundstage. The 170SE2 has better horizontal directivity than most coaxials. However, vertical directivity is where coaxials shine.

At distance sound decays based on physics. Coaxial speakers don't change that. In the pro world speakers are rated for distances based on two criteria. One is SPL. If you are listening further away and want to reach a louder volume, you need a speaker that is capable. Most smaller speakers can't play loud as you listen further away. Two is the sound from all the woofers, midranges and tweeters combined. If you sit at a desk and the speakers are on the desk half a meter away, will you hear the combined sound of all the drivers or are the drivers closer to you more dominant? Most bookshelf type speakers would be labeled nearfield in the pro world, most towers would be midfield speakers. If you want lower bass or louder SPL where a larger speaker is needed a coaxial has advantages here. Something like an 8361 could be used at a closer seating distance than a similarly price Neuman 420.

The Kali LP8 and JBL 308 are very similar. In our shootout between those 2, they were basically a tie. Technically the LP8 won by a very narrow margin. The 308 goes on sale quite a bit and I would get it over the LP8 if I saved some money. The IN8 is definitely a step up over either of them. No contest.
 
Coaxials don't have wider directivity. It really depends on design of speaker. As a generalization many non-coaxials have a wider horizontal dispersion causing greater envelopment/soundstage. The 170SE2 has better horizontal directivity than most coaxials. However, vertical directivity is where coaxials shine.

At distance sound decays based on physics. Coaxial speakers don't change that. In the pro world speakers are rated for distances based on two criteria. One is SPL. If you are listening further away and want to reach a louder volume, you need a speaker that is capable. Most smaller speakers can't play loud as you listen further away. Two is the sound from all the woofers, midranges and tweeters combined. If you sit at a desk and the speakers are on the desk half a meter away, will you hear the combined sound of all the drivers or are the drivers closer to you more dominant? Most bookshelf type speakers would be labeled nearfield in the pro world, most towers would be midfield speakers. If you want lower bass or louder SPL where a larger speaker is needed a coaxial has advantages here. Something like an 8361 could be used at a closer seating distance than a similarly price Neuman 420.

The Kali LP8 and JBL 308 are very similar. In our shootout between those 2, they were basically a tie. Technically the LP8 won by a very narrow margin. The 308 goes on sale quite a bit and I would get it over the LP8 if I saved some money. The IN8 is definitely a step up over either of them. No contest.
And the vertical directivity is what I would like to achieve, since the intention is IN8v2 for mixed use in a roughly 4x4 [m] room standing alongside TV close to the wall - ~3m midfield listening from a sofa + bass guitar monitoring at below-reference SPLs to not annoy the neighbours and preferably with SPLs that won't energize the room modes, since it's a rented flat (yes, I know bass will be a crapshoot with no adaptation).

I guess that specific case highly suggests front-ported coaxials, due to what you mentioned about better vertical directivity, to have more leeway with sitting position.
 
Back
Top Bottom