• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Is the entire audio industry a fraud?

thecheapseats

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Feb 22, 2023
Messages
727
Likes
776
Location
Los Angeles refugee
He has a PhD but word vomits, how did he defend his dissertation? I call bullshit on that. Both my parents have PhD's and their english is incredible (Physics and Neuroscience) and English isn't their first language.

Okay, Mr. PhD, what was your PhD thesis in?
better asked is, "who was your Doctoral advisor?"... in physics that lineage (going back generations) is comprehensively memorialized and as detailed and revered as race horse parentage... don't ask me how I know this...
 
Last edited:

Galliardist

Major Contributor
Joined
Jun 26, 2021
Messages
2,558
Likes
3,273
Location
Sydney. NSW, Australia
Here's a pretty honest one, but it's still exploiting people in a very unethical way. They just state how ethernet cables work, and let the viewer assume they're saying things that are relevant to sound quality, since it's billed as being for audiophiles. Of course, it does nothing at all for sound quality, but hey, don't let that stop you from spending >$200/m on a cable that ought to cost $4.
I have somewhere around here a Cat 3 cable that drops upwards of 20% of packets sent through it. I plugged it into an Oppo 105 playing from an SMB drive and with the TIdal app. It worked perfectly. The idea that you need a high category of Ethernet cable for audio isn't actually true, so it's not that honest.
 

thecheapseats

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Joined
Feb 22, 2023
Messages
727
Likes
776
Location
Los Angeles refugee
Oh, man, but I really want to ask!
errata info that means nothing ->> teaching lineages in several disciplines have been documented and published going back centuries, it seems... I speculated it was merely a revenue generating cottage industry for publishers not long after the printing press was invented - however some people revere this arcane knowledge... always seemed silly to me (my profession included) until my goofy son pointed out the historicity of his professorial lineage... it was rather impressive, so maybe now - I sorta' get it... oddly, I raised him to be a world class musician early-on - but it didn't take...
 

digicidal

Major Contributor
Joined
Jul 6, 2019
Messages
1,981
Likes
4,838
Location
Sin City, NV
I don't want to rain on your parade but some some things truly are easier heard than measured. I have a PhD in physics but don't have a lot of test equipment laying around unless I bring an Oscope from work and years ago when I made these observations I was not a scientist then. I had a Thorens TD290 turntable (until the circuit board failed) and I replaced the chrome (?) plated RCA plugs with thick, majestic looking gold plated OFHC ones from Esoteric Audio USA in the 1990s when they were making very good speaker wire and interconnects - I have dozens of their wire products still. (OFHC oxygen free high conductivity or electrolytic grade copper with nitrogen cell foam - oxygen is "corrosive"). Immediately the treble was brighter! The phonograph cartridge was the Stanton 681 EEE Calibration Standard. I still have it in a box with two other styli. It was indeed an AUDIBLE difference! Why? Gold is a much better electrical conductor than chromium (and aluminum) even though it is poorer than copper and especially silver. I used silver solder to make the connections, cutting off the old plugs, stripping the wires, and soldering on the new plugs. I even wore rubber gloves when I did that to avoid contamination by skin oils! (It is a relief to me that new turntables are not hard wired. They simply have RCA jacks now and I can use the cables I still have.) I also have a Marantz 6200 turntable that I will soon do some work on - I got a capacitor kit specifically for the 6200 from a company on eBay, and also got from a specialty audio company in Florida silver plated phonograph cables to replace, noch einmal (German: once again) those darned chrome plated RCA plugs. I have had the Marantz since before the Thorens and have history with it too. The headshell that came with it is 13.5 grams and I noticed the Shure M95ED nude diamond needle was getting narrower. I bought a new stylus but decided I needed to do more than that as the chrome plated S shaped arm was too massive. I bought two 6 gram Supex headshells from a local stereo store and decided I would not use the lead sheets enclosed with them. I removed the chrome plated brass counterweight and found a local gunsmith with a drill press. He drilled two holes in the back but I had to come back and have him drill two more. I mounted the Shure in the bare Supex shells, rebalanced the arm, set the tracking force, and shure enough (Ha ha!) Linda Ronstadt's "sinus condition" was GONE! It was an AUDIBLE improvement. I heard it - I did not imagine that I heard it. Why? Lower effective moving mass allowed the stylus to track the groove more precisely. Please note that I heard the new stylus before and after the drill press work so that was NOT the issue! (Currently I am using a U-turn Orbit Custom with a Grado Prestige Series Black 3, Soundcraftsmen stereo separates: A100 amplifier with MOSFET power transistors and toroidal transformer, P100 preamp, T100 AM/FM tuner, Klipsch KSF 8.5 tower speakers, Herbies Way Excellent II turntable mat, and the 8MZ stylus replacement whenever I want to use it. My ears are imperfect now but the sound from all this USA made equipment is fantastic. Singly they may be imperfect - except for my old but mint condition Soundcraftsmen gear! - but together it is a perfect synergy. "Time" from "The Dark Side of the Moon" is out of this world.) Now is there fraud? Yes and much of it is at the "mid fi" level. I need to motivate myself to write a letter of complaint to the FTC. Japanese makers of Audio video receivers (made in Malaysia) will say things like "60 watts per channel with all [5] speakers driven" AND power consumption is like only 200 watts. Obviously that is a massive violation of the principle of conservation of energy. You simply cannot get out more (300 watts) than the 200 you put in! Probably they mean "peak power" not average power but it is still FRAUDULENT! I will say one more thing - those speakers you see on the covers of "The Absolute Sound" and "Stereophile" are frequently like works of art and people with $$$ will want them. What kind of car do you drive? If you had all the $$$ you wanted you might want to buy a Corvette, a Viper, a Ferrari, or a Lamborghini. Now they are all cars and will take you from point A to point B - right? The same is probably true of those power amps and speakers that cost as much as a Corvette. Now if I had all the $$$ I wanted I would still buy an American car, a Tuatara! I'm just saying that there is a class of people who want to enjoy "the finer things in life". Now I am not a member of that club but at the same time I do NOT resent them. One last thing (really!) all this writing has brought to mind: R. D. Laing in "The Pollitics of Experience" said something like "your experience of you experiencing me is not the same as my experience of me experiencing you. We demand to experience the evidence but experience is the only evidence." That last sentence is very important, even here.
I seriously thought ChatGPT was better than this... I guess I was misled. ;)
 

mhardy6647

Grand Contributor
Joined
Dec 12, 2019
Messages
11,217
Likes
24,183
very well documented - he proclaimed, "linux is better than windows"...
Indeed.
I've seen the photograph.

7fuq1c.jpg
 

atmasphere

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Technical Expert
Audio Company
Joined
May 26, 2021
Messages
504
Likes
779
If I can’t live forever, let me live until Linux works on the desktop.
I've been using Linux on my desktop for the last 23 years and I'm no Linux guru. I run a Debian/Ubuntu package, 64 bits. Seems to work fine. When I first made the change, internet browsing speed increased by a factor of 5 running on the same machine. Its not like that old joke about Windows, MacOS and Linux as airlines anymore.
 
Joined
Mar 24, 2023
Messages
9
Likes
0
He has a PhD but word vomits, how did he defend his dissertation? I call bullshit on that. Both my parents have PhD's and their english is incredible (Physics and Neuroscience) and English isn't their first language.

Okay, Mr. PhD, what was your PhD thesis in?
Uh, your reading comprehension is not too good. Look at the first line: physics!
 
Top Bottom