• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Is the "audiophile measurement mafia" to blame for the hi-fi market being flooded with systems that lack audiophile dynamic range?

I

The JBL M2 offers good dynamics in the upper frequencies. My Altec Lansing Voice of the Theatre speakers had good dynamics in the upper frequencies, at the cost of some distortion. Some Altec and JBL bass horns I owned delivered good dynamics in the upper bass range. My JBL L200 and L300 had no good bass dynamics. Upper frequencies were ok.
Are there any audiophile box speakers capable of delivering 120 dB across the entire frequency range without audible distortion?

You said should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion.
(I'm guessing this is based on Fielder's work on dynamic range in live settings? Or what?)
But, um, how brief is brief, here?

The Spinorama measurement protocol ought to include distortion measurements at 120 dB.
Audio dynamics up to 120 dB
So we're no longer talking about exceeding 120db......

represent an important—yet currently neglected—variable for achieving realistic sound reproduction with loudspeakers.

Do they, though? Are levels near or at 120dB in home audio common enough to be important? And how much of that comes from loud bass/percussive instruments ? Which nowadays are typically handled not by the sort of floorstanders you cite, but by subwwoofers.
 
I usually haul my phone dB meter out in concerts if they seem to be loud and also look at the frequency graph. I know it won't be super accurate but dynamic readings by eye aren't ;)

The highest dynamic range concerts are classical orchestra with plenty of brass and big competition brass bands. I see peaks up to 105 to 110 dB very occasionally with quiet bits around 35dB. No sane music company would release a recording with that much dynamic range since 99.9% of people couldn't reproduce it.

There is never any high level at high frequencies on my favourite music nor that much below 50Hz most of the time.
I do have 2 pairs of very efficient speakers which can get to 120dB in that frequency range but never listen that loud at home, even though I know I can. Both pairs are H-U-G-E.

I do have a subwoofer and one recording which disappoints if it is off - simply because once heard forever missed - but just that one recording out of around 7000.
 
I suffered hearing loss from rifle-fire in Basic Training -

"Unprotected gunfire can cause permanent hearing damage. NIOSH recommends that peak impulse exposure not exceed 140 dB and recommends wearing both properly inserted earplugs and well-seated earmuffs whenever firing."

I suggest that long-term exposure to 120 dB is highly inadvisable!
 
An unamplified trumpet can reach sound levels exceeding 120 dB
Ah, yes. Who among us has not enjoyed the sound of a fortississimo trumpet played straight into our ears from 50cm?

So where are you finding the recordings with the necessary dynamic range to meet both this requirement and the 120dB peaks at so-far-undefined distortion levels?
Certainly not from any mainstream label. Commercial recordings having long-term crest factors above 30dB are exceedingly rare. The vast majority of classical/symphonic music I've measured is in the range of 20-29dB; popular genres rarely exceed 15dB.
 
Audiophile and high sound pressure levels don't belong in the same sentence. Most audiophiles I know despise very high sound pressure levels. High quality sound comes from finding the sweet spot in a room. Acoustical overload of a room is a real thing. Every room and every system has a sound pressure level that is ideal for sound quality. Audiophiles find that sweet spot and live there. I don't call those that worship at the alter of high sound pressure levels audiophiles, I call them "head bangers". The dynamic range of the recorded music doesn't change with volume. Lower sound levels provide more dynamic headroom not less. Home theater is a different animal and home theater enthusiasts are not generally considered by my peers to be audiophiles. Home theater is a completely different related endeavor that has it's own audio related requirements that are quite different from audiophile music reproduction. Have a nice day everyone.
 
I suffered hearing loss from rifle-fire in Basic Training -

"Unprotected gunfire can cause permanent hearing damage. NIOSH recommends that peak impulse exposure not exceed 140 dB and recommends wearing both properly inserted earplugs and well-seated earmuffs whenever firing."

I suggest that long-term exposure to 120 dB is highly inadvisable!
The day after my eardrum was perforated in training, everyone was issued earplugs.
 
Ah, yes. Who among us has not enjoyed the sound of a fortississimo trumpet played straight into our ears from 50cm?


Certainly not from any mainstream label. Commercial recordings having long-term crest factors above 30dB are exceedingly rare. The vast majority of classical/symphonic music I've measured is in the range of 20-29dB; popular genres rarely exceed 15dB.
the most frequent occurring level (mode) across the orchestra is in the 63–69 dB range for listeners, and 56–70 dB for musicians.
Overall concert hall levels for the audience typically range from 95 to 110 dB during fortissimo passages, with some heavy repertoire (e.g., Shostakovich, Mahler) reaching 115–116 dB.
 
The fact that the market is flooded with anemic, dynamically limited systems is likely due to an unholy alliance between the "audiophile measurement mafia"—who lack knowledge of the psychology of sound perception—and commercial hi-fi companies.
No, you said the real reason a little later:
Compared to large horn speakers, small box speakers were considerably easier to place in ordinary homes and were easier to sell.

Do you think there's some secret technology that allows 2nd hd but also 120dB at small size? What a silly post.

No, you're right, if not for the measurement mafia everyone would have at least two refrigerator sized speakers costing at least $3K each in their apartments. We got together to invent the nefarious scheme of affordable systems. Hahaha! Take that, knowledgeable people!
 
Audiophile and high sound pressure levels don't belong in the same sentence. Most audiophiles I know despise very high sound pressure levels. High quality sound comes from finding the sweet spot in a room. Acoustical overload of a room is a real thing. Every room and every system has a sound pressure level that is ideal for sound quality. Audiophiles find that sweet spot and live there. I don't call those that worship at the alter of high sound pressure levels audiophiles, I call them "head bangers". The dynamic range of the recorded music doesn't change with volume. Lower sound levels provide more dynamic headroom not less. Home theater is a different animal and home theater enthusiasts are not generally considered by my peers to be audiophiles. Home theater is a completely different related endeavor that has it's own audio related requirements that are quite different from audiophile music reproduction. Have a nice day everyone.

This is inaccurate at best.

You don't have to play that loud for many speakers to struggle or fall apart completely, and playing reasonably loud is arguably a more realistic (and thus high fidelity) experience than playing soft. With regards to acoustical overload of a room, while perhaps somewhat of a thing, most of the time when people blame this, it's their speakers that fall apart, not the room. I can play 100+dB (average) just fine in a small 20m^2 room without acoustical overload.

Your claim that dynamic range doesn't change with volume and that lower sound levels provide more dynamic headroom is also wrong. If you play at low volume, the dynamic range disappear in the noise floor of the room. So as long as your speakers can keep up, you get more dynamic headroom by turning it up, not down.
 
An unamplified trumpet can reach sound levels exceeding 120 dB.
An amplified rock concert easily exceeds 120 dB.

As a medical doctor, I am well aware of the dangers of high sound levels. The average level at the listening position over an extended period should not exceed 85 dB. Above this level, the muscles of the middle ear begin to attenuate the sound; in other words, non-linear distortion is introduced. The muscles in the middle ear are relatively slow to react. Sudden odd musical instrument transients and transient sounds like gunshots occur too quickly for these muscles to respond. Consequently, the hair cells of the inner ear are left unprotected and can suffer permanent damage.
TrumpetE (165 Hz) / D³ (1175 Hz)15 kHz / 15 kHz106 dB0.5 m from bell piece: normal; forte: 108 dB; extreme forte: 128 dB

In the physically objective, measurable dimension, it is important to demonstrate how a loudspeaker compresses and produces distortion at levels up to 120 dB.

In the neuropsychological dimension, the perception of objectively measured distortion decreases as the sound level rises—possibly due to masking or some other variable that does not immediately come to mind.

The focus on high levels of objectively measured second-harmonic distortion in horn speakers was a mistake.
From a neuropsychological perspective, this distortion is generally inaudible in horn speakers. In contrast, compression and peak distortion are audible in box speakers when compared to horn speakers.

Neuro
Interesting. It's always good to have subject matter experts on ASR. I think this will be a valuable discussion for ASR and thanks for broaching the topic.

1 Could you explain how the middle ear muscle actions produce harmonic distortion. There must be some academic papers somwhere. I'm also curious if and when the hair cells in the cochlea produce harmonic distortion.

You are correct that many instruments are loud. In a concert hall by the time the sound is reflected by the orchestra shell and bounces around the hall, listening levels are in the 80s dB SPL or below. Pop shows can be mixed loud and compressed. They are also limited to prevent damaging the speakers. That is the job of outboard gear like the DBX Driverack or plugins to modern digital house mix consoles.

Many house mix engineers have hearing loss, so they turn it up or over emphasize the high frequencies.

In classical and jazz there has been a trend in close microphone placement on individual instruments. I study microphone specs. They are usually rated with a maximum SPL at .5 or 1% distortion. Typically those numbers for modern condenser microphones are 110-130 dB SPL. A good resource is the DPA microphone university. With a microphone you are dealing with the capsule limits and the impedance buffer limits. Then of course, you have all the gain staging in the recording process.

You do see microphones clipped to the bell of trumpets. Even back in 1985, I saw Miles Davis in our concert hall. He has a bell microphone and a radio pack so he could wanter the stage and even get in front of the on-stage speaker stacks to generate feedback. I had a front row seat. I thought about taking some pictures, but probably seeing a camera he would have walked off the stage and ended the concert. There are videos of his bell microphone setup and that band.

2 I'm still puzzled why you believe the speakers and electronics have to reach 120 dB SPL for transients at the listening position.

You may have an interest in ASR discussions of the loudness wars.
 
ASR catnip

Among audiophiles knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception, there is a consensus that an audiophile-system should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion.
Other people have noted that this is not sourced, but it also exhibits 'No True Scotsman' fallacy. If you don't believe your system needs to handle 120dB peaks, well then, clearly you're not knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception.
 
How many postings and/or 'likes' are required to qualify as a 'made man' of Audio Science Review, aka La Cosa Nostra of measured audio performance ? ;)
"Never take sides against the family again" :)
 
"An amplified rock concert easily exceeds 120 dB."

Err, not where I live and not for many years.
Not at the Rammstein gig I was at a couple of years ago, and not at our local venue. I go regularly and I am friends with the sound engineer there, and hang by his desk sometimes, and can't help noticing his big and expensive looking dB meter. Perhaps you go to lots of rock concerts where it's loud and I'm sure you have measurements to back up your claim.
 
If we should look at dynamic capability say up to 105 dB at LP, would not compression be the measurement?
 
This is inaccurate at best.

You don't have to play that loud for many speakers to struggle or fall apart completely, and playing reasonably loud is arguably a more realistic (and thus high fidelity) experience than playing soft. With regards to acoustical overload of a room, while perhaps somewhat of a thing, most of the time when people blame this, it's their speakers that fall apart, not the room. I can play 100+dB (average) just fine in a small 20m^2 room without acoustical overload.

Your claim that dynamic range doesn't change with volume and that lower sound levels provide more dynamic headroom is also wrong. If you play at low volume, the dynamic range disappear in the noise floor of the room. So as long as your speakers can keep up, you get more dynamic headroom by turning it up, not down.
That's your argument? That if you play the music low enough the dynamic range will disappear into the noise floor? That makes no sense at all. If you play low enough you won't hear anything at all. No one is suggesting listening at 40db. A reasonable listening level of say 80 or 85db does not cause the dynamic range to disappear into the noise floor.

There is no science that I know of that demonstrates that higher volumes increase "dynamic headroom". This is false. The dynamic range of music is determined by the recording. The difference between the softest passages and the loudest; not the difference between absolute silence and the loudest passage. Turning up the music just makes it louder. It does not change the dynamic range of the recording.

Audiophiles don't find objection with "reasonable" listening levels only the unreasonable. 110-120db is considered unreasonable by most music loving audiophiles because it does not provide the cleanest most pure listening experiences that they enjoy.

PS "Dynamic headroom" is determined by the difference between the average listening level and the maximum sound pressure abilities of the reproduction system not it's absolute volume. Your confusing the terms "dynamic range" and "dynamic headroom". Two different things.
 
Last edited:
I think we entered the zone of "It's all posturing (TM)" and can't resist engaging. Including me!
 
How many postings and/or 'likes' are required to qualify as a 'made man' of Audio Science Review, aka La Cosa Nostra of measured audio performance ? ;)
EDIT: wrong reply. I meant @Power Pop 23:
How many postings and/or 'likes' are required to qualify as a 'made man' of Audio Science Review, aka La Cosa Nostra of measured audio performance ? ;)

You have to go to a subjectivist audio forum and "whack" a prominent member...with data of course!
 
Last edited:
The noise floor in a good listening room is about 40 dBa. For recorded music to disappear, you would have to play it so the peaks are below 70. Even lower for non-classical. Realistic peaks would be around 100.

But there’s a catch. As you get older or acquire hearing loss, you may be inclined to play louder. But that just invites more loss.
 
Back
Top Bottom