• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Is the "audiophile measurement mafia" to blame for the hi-fi market being flooded with systems that lack audiophile dynamic range?

Neuro

Active Member
Joined
May 23, 2019
Messages
111
Likes
161
Location
Sweden
Actual reproduced dynamics is an underrated variable among audiophiles.
Among audiophiles knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception, there is a consensus that an audiophile-system should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion. Such peaks do not cause hearing damage, provided they are very short and do not significantly exceed the 120 dB level.
Older cinema sound systems were often capable of reaching 120 dB, except in the lowest bass frequencies.

The fact that the market is flooded with anemic, dynamically limited systems is likely due to an unholy alliance between the "audiophile measurement mafia"—who lack knowledge of the psychology of sound perception—and commercial hi-fi companies.
Large cinema horn speakers and tube amplifiers exhibited high levels of second-harmonic distortion. More "modern" transistor amplifiers and box-type speakers exhibited significantly lower second-harmonic distortion.

Second-harmonic distortion, as measured, is usually inaudible due to the psychology of masking by the fundamental tone.

Compared to large horn speakers, small box speakers were considerably easier to place in ordinary homes and were easier to sell.
Many old cinemas possessed a dynamic range that is lacking in many of today's standard audiophile systems.

It may be possible to measure audiophile loudspeaker dynamics using Spinorama techniques with short, gated impulses reaching approximately 120 dB.
The question remains: does "avalanche distortion" occur, or is the distortion spectrum inaudible due to masking or some other psychological variable?

Neuro
 
It may be possible to measure audiophile loudspeaker dynamics using Spinorama techniques with short, gated impulses reaching approximately 120 dB.
The question remains: does "avalanche distortion" occur, or is the distortion spectrum inaudible due to masking or some other psychological variable?
We don't use spinorama for dynamic capability. For that, look to the suite of distortion tests I run.

High sensitivity speakers of course exist that can get exceedingly loud. Getting one that is as clean as properly designed consumer speaker that does well in spiorama is hard. Closest I have heard is JBL M2.
 
The fact that the market is flooded with anemic, dynamically limited systems is likely due to an unholy alliance between the "audiophile measurement mafia"—who lack knowledge of the psychology of sound perception—and commercial hi-fi companies.
No, it's just a general trend that people do not want to have massive speakers in their interiors anymore.

This trend is way older than the "audiophile measurement mafia", BTW. Remember this crap:

1791789447172.png

That was 1987!

Back in the old days, speakers needed to be large and efficient because amps were not very powerful. Slowly, the market moved to smaller speakers and more powerful amps. Throw in some other trends, and you end up at today, with smaller, less dynamic speakers that can sound excellent for the audience they were made for. If anything, we got back some of the dynamics since those 1987 abominatios ;)
 
Lots of super expensive "audiophile" speakers who measure poorly have poor dynamic capabilities as well, so I don't think that is the case.
 
The fact that the market is flooded with anemic, dynamically limited systems is likely due to an unholy alliance between the "audiophile measurement mafia"—who lack knowledge of the psychology of sound perception—and commercial hi-fi companies.
Your premise fails to start with, as this is not a fact at all.

TBH, where do you get off saying things like "audiophile measurement mafia"... pfft.


JSmith
 
Among audiophiles knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception, there is a consensus that an audiophile-system should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion.
You forgot to put sarcastic quote marks around the word "knowledgable".

OTOH if you actually meant it, show us the rationale.
 
We don't use spinorama for dynamic capability. For that, look to the suite of distortion tests I run.

High sensitivity speakers of course exist that can get exceedingly loud. Getting one that is as clean as properly designed consumer speaker that does well in spiorama is hard. Closest I have heard is JBL M2.
I

The JBL M2 offers good dynamics in the upper frequencies. My Altec Lansing Voice of the Theatre speakers had good dynamics in the upper frequencies, at the cost of some distortion. Some Altec and JBL bass horns I owned delivered good dynamics in the upper bass range. My JBL L200 and L300 had no good bass dynamics. Upper frequencies were ok.
Are there any audiophile box speakers capable of delivering 120 dB across the entire frequency range without audible distortion?
The Spinorama measurement protocol ought to include distortion measurements at 120 dB.
Audio dynamics up to 120 dB represent an important—yet currently neglected—variable for achieving realistic sound reproduction with loudspeakers.
The question remains: does "avalanche distortion" occur.

Neuro
 
Last edited:
Are there any audiophile box speakers capable of delivering 120 dB across the entire frequency range?
There is no answer to that question because you have to specify at what distortion. And explain why you need 120 dBSPL at treble range.

Also, if you need loud bass, you are going to use subwoofers.

But sure, there are speakers with active bass towers and such.
 
Are we just talking about how loud speakers can go, or about dynamic range above some noise floor?
If the former, just buy a cinema system for your lounge. If the latter, bear mind a CD has theoretical 96dB limit, but I doubt you'll find many recordings that come close to that.

I'm pretty sure ears add their own distortion by the time you're up at 120dB.
 
I

The JBL M2 offers good dynamics in the upper frequencies. My Altec Lansing Voice of the Theatre speakers had good dynamics in the upper frequencies, at the cost of some distortion. Some Altec and JBL bass horns I owned delivered good dynamics in the upper bass range. My JBL L200 and L300 had no good bass dynamics. Upper frequencies were ok.
Are there any audiophile box speakers capable of delivering 120 dB across the entire frequency range?
The Spinorama measurement protocol ought to include distortion measurements at 120 dB.
Audio dynamics up to 120 dB represent an important—yet currently neglected—variable for achieving realistic sound reproduction with loudspeakers.
The question remains: does "avalanche distortion" occur.

Neuro

I'm working on a system that will reach your requirements down to 40hz (groundplane/outdoors within the CEA2010 distortion requirements, so likely to 20hz in-room), but that is with a 2x15" subwoofer for each channel. Which means not that many customers would be interested in a speaker large enough to reproduce this.

So it is understandable that relatively few manufacturers build to your requirements.
 
Among audiophiles knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception, there is a consensus that an audiophile-system should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion
Knowledgeable people publish evidence. Please share the peer-reviewed evidence supporting your claim.

Please also supply this evidence based on commercially available music recordings.

For the avoidance of doubt, I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, but your approach to stating requirements needs a more solid start.
 
So, about 95dB-100dB (C) average and recordings with high crest factor, close to 20dB or so.
Nothing exotic to it, apart from the fact that is very loud for average.

Such brief peaks can carry spikes of distortion and one would tell, it's nasty if the electronics can carry it and don't go to clipping before that.

I would pay much more attention at the distortion at 105dB or so though.
 
I'm not sure 120 dB is really needed for many.

I see a bigger problem that many think that a speaker with only constant directivity above for example 1000 Hz with fairly abrupt change below is a high quality speaker system. I also find that there's not enough understanding of how a speaker actually measures in the room, thus there's overly focus on spinorama besides the praise for speakers with a classical polar collaps.

But sure, size and woofer capability matters. A combination of smaller woofers, narrow cabinet, and a loss of direcitivty high in frequency has little to do with high-end audio IMO. Terminal distortion is another factor BTW which many speakers suffer from. And a passive speaker with no proper time alignement is really an outdated design.
 
Among audiophiles knowledgeable in the psychology of sound perception, there is a consensus that an audiophile-system should be able to handle brief peaks exceeding 120 dB without audible distortion. Such peaks do not cause hearing damage, provided they are very short and do not significantly exceed the 120 dB level.
Do you have a reference for that? I had hearing loss measured by an audiologist from the brief peaks of a taiko drum concert. Fortunately I recovered. No taiko drums for me now. When I recorded professionally, I used a calibrated sound level meter in the control room, low 90s were uncomfortable. I wear earplugs at pop concerts and use my NIOSH app. Just from the physics of reproduction it is hard to imagine a home system could pass 120dB SPL without distortion.
 
I've worked in studios where rock bands were recorded (before current regulations). The main monitors could exceed 120dB with low distortion. There were warning lights showing dB(a) and dB(c) levels. I can confirm that even momentary 120 dB levels are uncomfortable (not just to ears but kick drum beats causing chest compressions).
 
The best analysis of this audiophile phenomenon was given in the film "Ruthless People". When man's reproductive organ is big enough, he does not need 120 dB SPL.
If we're getting into d!ck jokes, can you support this line of thought with measurements ?
On second thoughts....
 
Expressions like mafia and inquisition mainly comes from people who does not want to discuss a topic, but just wants it to go away because it appears to reveal some unpleasant truths.

Speakers generally have at least the same capacity today as they had decades ago. There are small but very expensive speakers on the market today, and there were not many of that kind decades ago, but that is hardly due to measurements. It is probably just a result of a square meter in a major city generally going up 20-50 times while salaries has gone up like 3-8 times in the same period of time.

If we look at the 70's, there were some really big speakers with 15 or 18 inch woofers. But they were really few, and there are still a few on the market. But the ones available today generally can move a lot more air due to developments in speaker motor design.

So this strikes me as a silly argument that often surfaces when some self appointed expert is trying to fit excess harmonic distortion into the dynamic category, while it is really just the oposite.
 
Back
Top Bottom