• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Invest in better measuring speakers or room equalisation ? When does one or the other make a bigger difference in your experience ?

At which price point does room equalisation (+ subs) make a bigger impact than upgrading speakers ?


  • Total voters
    49
Well, there is nothing out there comparable to ART really. Two biggest benefits are reduced decay and ability to fill in the dips in FQ response by having a different speaker play that particular segment. So it is not necessarily that 15dB dip can't be corrected any more, or the rest of the spectrum needs to be pulled much lower. This also adds additional clarity to the above 150hz range.

Take a look at the ART thread. Lots of people with multiple subs are quite happy and thought benefit was meaningful compared to Bass Control. In your case this means additional investment that is not insignificant, so best to research thoroughly. Also, ART does not support sub 20hz bass, but will pass it through without EQ. That transition might cause some dips or bumps, or for the lucky ones will go pretty smooth.

As far as blending mains and subs, ART does not work on crossover concept, so blending is really completely seamless in a good setup. This is how it looks in mine - measured 7 out of 9 bed channels and orange is average.

View attachment 501304
I had been tracking ART a while back but not lately. There were some teething issues in the beginning from what I remember and since my processor wouldn’t be supporting it, I pursued other ways to improve bass and overall sound.

ART looks pretty complex and very advanced. Pretty impressive stuff! I’m guessing that my best option would probably get something like the AV10 but a cheaper version when my XMC2 craps out.
 
I had been tracking ART a while back but not lately. There were some teething issues in the beginning from what I remember and since my processor wouldn’t be supporting it, I pursued other ways to improve bass and overall sound.

ART looks pretty complex and very advanced. Pretty impressive stuff! I’m guessing that my best option would probably get something like the AV10 but a cheaper version when my XMC2 craps out.
HTP-1 seems like a good choice, although I have never been brave enough to embrace it. It also has BEQ support which is great for movies if one is not paranoid like me.

As far as Marantz goes there is cheaper AV20 and to be released AV 30. Each drops 2 channels from AV 10 but looks you anyway don’t need them. These are rock solid and zero issues in daily operation.

Contrary to common wisdom, ART is pretty idiot proof (no pun intended - just a general statement). Initial auto run usually gets jaw’s dropping and then the tweaks can potentially get you 5-10% more. In your case it will just be the case of determining how far you want to stretch Salons. Probably not really low as Gothams can do far better job under 50hz and blending is really seamless so best to leave low end to SPL capable and low distortion speakers.

EDIT: Don't have Salons, but something like them (cheaper :facepalm: but still great). Can bang 105dB at 30hz, but distortion will go up significantly. 4 subs won't break a sweat at 105dB at 30hz and stay below 2-3% distortion. They are only at 50-60% of their gain, and then +12dB from ART gets them to 3/4 at max.
 
Last edited:
It was still expensive to me but I didn’t get the V2 version and I bought em used from a rich dude with a fancy home theater that was moving. This is where fortune favors the nag :). He had em at $6k each so I was just going to buy one - telling my wife this is an end game sub that’s beyond what I ever wanted (I was initially shopping for a 2nd F113). Then I told my wife that I’ll need to get a 2nd one down the line because you need 2 matching subs where she gave me this weird/disapproving look as in, I just “approved” you getting one and you are already talking about buying a 2nd one? She then thought for a second and said offer him $10k for both so I don’t have to listen to you talking about the 2nd sub ad nauseam and browsing online for days on end.

This is the culmination of years on nagging lol. So, while it was still expensive to me, it wasn’t the crazy current retail. $10k for the salon2 and $10k for the Gothams, $2k for the JL CR-1 = my poor man’s Sonus Faber Suprema lol.
Seems your wife is a keeper :) … my wife is also incredibly patient with this crazy hobby I have, including supporting some fairly large cash outlays over the years

You got a great deal on those Gothams, though these days you can spend much less and still obtain incredible LF output. Especially the offerings from GSG and JTR … still expensive, but compared to most of the silly HEA subs out there, they are a relative bargain. My next round of subs will likely be sealed GSGs using the 24” SI driver (https://shop.gsgad.com/collections/...tegrity-hs-24-24-high-excursion-carbon-driver)

As to getting ART capability, tough to beat the HTP1 for the price, especially if you can grab a used unit (they are tough to come by!). Got my HTP1 for $2k used, mint condition, love it
 
Seems your wife is a keeper :) … my wife is also incredibly patient with this crazy hobby I have, including supporting some fairly large cash outlays over the years

You got a great deal on those Gothams, though these days you can spend much less and still obtain incredible LF output. Especially the offerings from GSG and JTR … still expensive, but compared to most of the silly HEA subs out there, they are a relative bargain. My next round of subs will likely be sealed GSGs using the 24” SI driver (https://shop.gsgad.com/collections/...tegrity-hs-24-24-high-excursion-carbon-driver)

As to getting ART capability, tough to beat the HTP1 for the price, especially if you can grab a used unit (they are tough to come by!). Got my HTP1 for $2k used, mint condition, love it
The only better arrangement on the wifey side is not to have to ask for approval at all. But still can't prevent ranting and endless complaining :facepalm:.

HTP-1 seems to be a champ now with ART. BTW did you go ART and if so what are your impressions?

Just to clarify, my multi-purpose room can't really take bass below 22hz as it starts to shake structures and does all kinds of havoc. So unfortunately I build my system at that level, but hopefully one day I will get to advance to monster level subs.
 
The only better arrangement on the wifey side is not to have to ask for approval at all. But still can't prevent ranting and endless complaining :facepalm:.

HTP-1 seems to be a champ now with ART. BTW did you go ART and if so what are your impressions?

Just to clarify, my multi-purpose room can't really take bass below 22hz as it starts to shake structures and does all kinds of havoc. So unfortunately I build my system at that level, but hopefully one day I will get to advance to monster level subs.
No ART yet, need my new speaker system first, expected to arrive by end January ;) … for now just trying to learn HTP1 basic operation. It’s a very powerful prepro, but learning curve a little steep. I actually haven’t installed latest firmware yet with ART as it is officially beta and waiting for others to work the bugs out (which thus far it has been remarkably stable from what I have read on AVS forum thread). @TimoJ and rest of the crew have done a great job with the early development!

And yeah, you genuinely need to be careful with the big subs, especially those with high output <~25Hz, as they absolutely can damage your structure!
 
Seems your wife is a keeper :) … my wife is also incredibly patient with this crazy hobby I have, including supporting some fairly large cash outlays over the years

You got a great deal on those Gothams, though these days you can spend much less and still obtain incredible LF output. Especially the offerings from GSG and JTR … still expensive, but compared to most of the silly HEA subs out there, they are a relative bargain. My next round of subs will likely be sealed GSGs using the 24” SI driver (https://shop.gsgad.com/collections/...tegrity-hs-24-24-high-excursion-carbon-driver)

As to getting ART capability, tough to beat the HTP1 for the price, especially if you can grab a used unit (they are tough to come by!). Got my HTP1 for $2k used, mint condition, love it
The only better arrangement on the wifey side is not to have to ask for approval at all. But still can't prevent ranting and endless complaining :facepalm:.

HTP-1 seems to be a champ now with ART. BTW did you go ART and if so what are your impressions?

Just to clarify, my multi-purpose room can't really take bass below 22hz as it starts to shake structures and does all kinds of havoc. So unfortunately I build my system at that level, but hopefully one day I will get to advance to monster level subs.
I definitely didn’t need these Gothams. A second F113 is all I needed but the sub had to look good since it’s in family room. No JTR type would pass the WAF. She actually likes how the salon2s and Gothams look so it helps getting better looking products when you want the bread winner to spend her mid-year bonus on my audio gear. The Gotham’s volume set to less than 1/4 which is why I think it’s a bit of a waste.

The HTP-1 was the ticket. I should have bought used it a couple of years ago when I had the chance but unfortunately I stuck with Emotiva and their promises they didn’t keep. Hopefully sooner than later I’ll get ART but even if I never get it, I’d be ok since everything sounds so good.
 
I definitely didn’t need these Gothams. A second F113 is all I needed but the sub had to look good since it’s in family room. No JTR type would pass the WAF. She actually likes how the salon2s and Gothams look so it helps getting better looking products when you want the bread winner to spend her mid-year bonus on my audio gear. The Gotham’s volume set to less than 1/4 which is why I think it’s a bit of a waste.

The HTP-1 was the ticket. I should have bought used it a couple of years ago when I had the chance but unfortunately I stuck with Emotiva and their promises they didn’t keep. Hopefully sooner than later I’ll get ART but even if I never get it, I’d be ok since everything sounds so good.
I dunno, I think the WAF on these GSG subs should be quite high :p

1767385224054.png
 
I dunno, I think the WAF on these GSG subs should be quite high :p

View attachment 501347
Can’t imagine any reasonable person would have any objections . Love Revels as well. A bit bigger screen if there are excess funds?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MKR
No ART yet, need my new speaker system first, expected to arrive by end January ;) … for now just trying to learn HTP1 basic operation. It’s a very powerful prepro, but learning curve a little steep. I actually haven’t installed latest firmware yet with ART as it is officially beta and waiting for others to work the bugs out (which thus far it has been remarkably stable from what I have read on AVS forum thread). @TimoJ and rest of the crew have done a great job with the early development!

And yeah, you genuinely need to be careful with the big subs, especially those with high output <~25Hz, as they absolutely can damage your structure!
Tell me about it :facepalm:

IMG_7280.jpeg
IMG_7279.jpeg
 
Can’t imagine any reasonable person would have any objections . Love Revels as well. A bit bigger screen if there are excess funds?
Agreed, that screen far too small for that system ;)
 
Whoa! That is from your subs? Beautiful view by the way
That's the main suspect, although did not catch it in the act. Like 2 days after I moved the sub to that corner, the glass was broken. And was at that point doing some exploring which did involve high SPL at low frequencies. Not using that corner any more :eek:.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MKR
I have always believed that the bulk of the money should go to the speakers.

You can put lipstick on a pig, but...
To me spending a lot of money on a pair of speaker that you then put in a room, like a living room, where you cannot optimize where the speaker go, for aesthetic or practicality reason, where you seat in relation to the speakers and the limitations of the room is putting lipstick on a pig and no DSP can overcome bad placement.
Expensive, preferably well designed, speakers belong to a dedicated room where they will have the opportunity to shine, if the dedicated room is problematic, after running out of options in placement, DSP can try to help.
 
To me spending a lot of money on a pair of speaker that you then put in a room, like a living room, where you cannot optimize where the speaker go, for aesthetic or practicality reason, where you seat in relation to the speakers and the limitations of the room is putting lipstick on a pig and no DSP can overcome bad placement.
Expensive, preferably well designed, speakers belong to a dedicated room where they will have the opportunity to shine, if the dedicated room is problematic, after running out of options in placement, DSP can try to help.
While I agree with your statement about placement, that does not alter the fact that a good quality pair of speakers is the first and most important step towards auditory bliss.
DSP will not overcome bad placement, but it will not overcome bad speakers either. Particularly when the volume is turned up...
 
To me spending a lot of money on a pair of speaker that you then put in a room, like a living room, where you cannot optimize where the speaker go, for aesthetic or practicality reason, where you seat in relation to the speakers and the limitations of the room is putting lipstick on a pig and no DSP can overcome bad placement.
Expensive, preferably well designed, speakers belong to a dedicated room where they will have the opportunity to shine, if the dedicated room is problematic, after running out of options in placement, DSP can try to help.
It seems that you are measuring things by your own budget and spending habits, which is useful for statistical reasons.

Some people have other perspective and might not have other means to spend their money than putting "lipstick on a pig" or buying a 3rd or 5th exotic car to their garage or another priceless piece of art that pigs would not understand at all?

BTW, why should pigs not wear lipstick? Anything wrong with the fashionable pigs?
 
Can I assume you have caulked all of the window panes in that room? :)
LOL … that is a photo from GSG website, not my system, just showing @Lsc example that their subs have good WAF. But indeed, with 2x of those beasts will definitely get some serious room pressurization !
 
LOL … that is a photo from GSG website, not my system, just showing @Lsc example that their subs have good WAF. But indeed, with 2x of those beasts will definitely get some serious room pressurization !
My mains have 12" woofers and I have 2 SVS SB3000 subs and I had to recaulk all of my window panes. You could hear the rattling once I hit 97dB.
My system is a baby compared to that one
 
Back
Top Bottom