• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Introducing the Phono Cartridge Measurement Library

I have a couple of customers with Hana's, and the variations are quite recognizable. Especially the Blue. Some are just great - others, not quite worth the money.
I always mention the risk involved, when someone says: I'm getting a Hana. Hope they can figure out their quality control.

Personally, I'm going to try a Le Son, am curious...

Cheers
Measure it! Please?
 
Measure it! Please?
I am as curious as anybody, I just never have the time. Certainly with clients, even harder. But - if I manage to get a Le Son, I will make the effort, certainly worth it. I don't even know anybody who has one, yet.
 
Micro-Acoustics Stratus S2

I just bought this cartridge on eBay as NOS for $499.99. Big disappointment, it is totally an el-cheapo cartridge, with a sub-par aluminum cantilever and a generic elliptical stylus. There were better models back then, with beryllium cantilever and "micro-point" diamond, apparently this isn't one of them. I was very interested in evaluating the supposed advantages of the Electret transducer, in this instance there are none. Linearity is terrible, distortion and separation are OK.

EDIT: This cartridge is load insensitive, it has no magnets and no coils, the output impedance is purely resistive. An internal passive output equalizer stage makes it RIAA compliant. The non-standard load below is what I use for my AT, I tried other loads, the output stays the same.
I've been thinking that the poor HF perf might be related to suspension aging. I have ordered some "Liqui Moly Power Steering Oil Leak Stop" and I'll try and see if it helps.
Micro-Acoustics S2 - 1.35g_90pf - 33kOhm_STR 100.png
 
Last edited:
I got a sense that the new generation of cartridges from AT and others do not achieve the same test record tracking as before, Maybe, if OP agree @USER , posters could add info about tracking ability in the notes , if they have tested tracking too.
 
Last edited:
I got a sense that the new generation of cartridges from AT and others do not achieve the same test record tracking as before, Maybe, if OP agree @USER , posters could add info about tracking ability in the notes , if they have tested tracking too.

Heck yeah, I fully support this kind of supplemental information. I'll make a note of it as a welcome test. If you guys have recommendations for test records I can add that information as well.
 
Technics EPC 205 II L, Goldnote PH10, Technics SL 1300mk2View attachment 567499

Have you played around with the script settings or with the file cut-off points? Something about that kind of bump between 20-1k always makes me think something is off. Maybe it's the cartridge that is off.
 
Heck yeah, I fully support this kind of supplemental information. I'll make a note of it as a welcome test. If you guys have recommendations for test records I can add that information as well.
The current Ortofon test record 315 hz is very available, and a good reference, while my app allow use of CBS, Ortofon and Clearaudio records.Clearaudio is 333hz and therefore Harder to track than Ortofon.
I suggest to use the Normalized tab plot( it compensates for Level and radius). It shows onset of mistracking more clearly
1789677524251-png.1222740
 
I’d recommend validating the test first.
Done by ear+ oscilloscope. When the distortion lifts abruptly, like from 90 ok to 100 not ok above, the wav file sinus shape becomes corrupted/cut, and a buzz is audible. So the shape with abrupt rise coincide well with what I hear. what else would you suggest as control?

Hearing mistracking is very easy, a steady rising distortion I makes it harder to visualize the onset of mistracking- that is where the normalization helps.
Welcome feedback on what others hear/see..

PS. I could add detailed pages from my PC script..here is a mistracking case 100 um

1787387689672-png.1217206


1793381265824.png




100um AT VM540 no mistracking

1793381642274.png

1793381619170.png
 
Last edited:
I understand how it works, and I understand that the tool appears to work. My perspective comes from scar tissue - several decades running development organizations at scale, and my own work. Even something as simple as the FR script takes at least 10x the effort to run all the test and validation scenarios, with most of the revisions due to having to correct AI mistakes.

What you have may well be correct. I don't know. That's all.
 
Yes, I see that. It often takes 25+ iterations with Claude to get scripts right,, and still bugs may appear. But this one is a quite simple distortion measurement, and seem to correlate well with what I hear.
 
I have been doing a trackability analysis across all my cartridges. I have been using the TTI tracks from the Shure obstacle course record V.
I choose that because it is a more complex signal with lots of intermodulation opportunities.
I have been testing with a variety of VTAs and tracking forces.
The good news is that my new AT VM750xSH out traces (marginally) even the Shure V15 V-MR, and has lower distortion overall.
I’ll share a complete analysis and results later today.
Fun fact: VTA has very little effect on either tracking, linearity and distortion
 
I have been doing a trackability analysis across all my cartridges. I have been using the TTI tracks from the Shure obstacle course record V.
I choose that because it is a more complex signal with lots of intermodulation opportunities.
I have been testing with a variety of VTAs and tracking forces.
The good news is that my new AT VM750xSH out traces (marginally) even the Shure V15 V-MR, and has lower distortion overall.
I’ll share a complete analysis and results later today.
Fun fact: VTA has very little effect on either tracking, linearity and distortion
VTA has little effect on tracking and linearity, but vertical 2nd HD is affected. I've tested in the range of 30°-22°. Tracking LF and HF is also affected by different things; compliance vs damping.
 
VTA has little effect on tracking and linearity, but vertical 2nd HD is affected. I've tested in the range of 30°-22°. Tracking LF and HF is also affected by different things; compliance vs damping.
Yes, there is some effect, but it is little, much less than I would have anticipated, especially with the big fuss the industry makes about it. Azimuth is way more critical and more difficult to get right reproducibly with headshell tonearms.
 
Yes, there is some effect, but it is little, much less than I would have anticipated, especially with the big fuss the industry makes about it. Azimuth is way more critical.
Agree there is a lot of myths.
 
Trackability (Shure TTI bands): 5 cartridges, several VTF/VTA settings

As promised, the trackability results. Disclosure (per forum AI policy): the analysis script was written with Anthropic's Claude (Opus 5.5) in an iterative session where I supplied the recordings and checked the results. Recordings and setup are mine. Script available on request.

Setup
Technics SL-1300G, miniDSP ADept, 192 kHz / 24-bit captures.
Loads: AT at 90 pF / 33 kΩ, all others at 140 pF / 50 kΩ.
VTF measured with a gauge. "VTA" is the Technics arm-height scale in mm.

Test signal and why
Shure TTI bands (TTR-117, 45 rpm): 200 Hz + 2.1 kHz + 17 kHz played together at six levels (+2, +2, +1, +1, +1 dB steps).
The math model: while the stylus stays in contact with groove, its tip can’t exactly follow the shape the cutter made. That tracing error grows with how sharply the groove bends, so the IM percentage rises in step with the cut level, 1 dB per dB:
IM ≈ √2 · π · r · U₁ · f₂ / v² (r = tip radius, U₁ = low-tone cut velocity, f₂ = higher tone, v = groove speed)
Mistracking breaks this model: once the stylus loses contact, IM rises much faster, and that upward kink is what the test detects.
Each tone loads a different part of the cartridge: 200 Hz tests compliance, 2.1 kHz damping, and 17 kHz tip mass. Playing them together puts the high frequencies on top of large low-frequency excursions, as music does, and mistracking shows up as easy-to-measure intermodulation. The bands are lateral, so a channel that fails on its own points to skating or anti-skate.
There might be more demanding tests, but this was devised by Shure to show off their supreme tracking ability. It is probably good enough for most practical purpose.

Method
- IM-LF = the 2.1 kHz ±200 / ±400 Hz sidebands relative to the 2.1 kHz tone.
- IM-HF = the 17 kHz ±2.1 kHz sidebands relative to the 17 kHz tone.
- Mistracking: with the stylus in contact, the IM percentage rises about 1 dB for each dB of level (the dotted line in the plot). Mistracking shows as a steeper rise. I flag excess growth above about 1 dB over levels 4–6.

Results
28b2a76d-2225-471d-9d33-8971ec668cd4.png

Best VTA per cartridge. Left: worst channel. Right: mean of the two channels. The Pickering is with the brush down.

Spread across all the VTAs I tested (level 6):
Code:
Cart                 VTF (g)  VTA tested  IM-LF %     IM-HF %      Mistrack (dB)
AT VM750xSH          2.0      0 - 2.0     1.73-1.83   40.9-41.4     0.4 - 0.6
Shure V15 V-MR       1.0      0 - 2.0     1.82-1.89   46.8-47.0     0.3 - 0.4
Pickering XSV-3000   2.0      2.0 - 4.0   1.57-1.68   47.1-49.6    -0.1 - 0.7
Stanton 881S         1.0      2.0 - 4.0   1.50-1.54   60.2-62.9    ~0
Dynavector 10x3      1.8      1.5 - 3.0   3.42-3.76   61.8-64.0     4.0 - 4.8
Dynavector 10x3      2.0      2.5         2.52        58.4          2.0
Cartridges have different heights, each cartridge VTA range is adjusted to that.

Findings
1. Every cartridge except the Dynavector tracks all six levels cleanly.
2. The AT VM750xSH has the lowest IM-HF (41% vs 47% for the V15) and matches the V15 on IM-LF.
3. The Dynavector mistracks on the right channel only, at levels 5–6. Its left channel stays at about 0.9% IM-LF. Going from 1.8 g to 2.0 g helped but didn't cure it, so this is anti-skate.
4. VTA makes no difference beyond the session-to-session scatter. @Thomas_A, two caveats: my range is only about 1° of SRA (0–4 mm on a ~230 mm arm), and these bands are lateral, so vertical modulation isn't tested.

Limitations
Shure TTI record 45 rpm is a little easier on groove curvature than 33 rpm LP inner grooves. Levels top out at L6, so a pass doesn't show the remaining margin.
 

Attachments

  • 28b2a76d-2225-471d-9d33-8971ec668cd4.png
    28b2a76d-2225-471d-9d33-8971ec668cd4.png
    211.7 KB · Views: 34
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom