My bank locks the account after 3 unsuccessful attempts.
Why would I need some extreme overkill password?
I've been fine with a 5 digit alphanumeric nonsense password since 2007.
Really, instead of pestering people with more and more complex password shenanigans, give logins a time penalty after 2 wrong attemtps, starting at 30s and doubling after that. Lock accounts after 10-20 attempts. This eliminates brute-force attacks.
Use 2FA in order to prevent DB leaks from being effective.
Tough I'll be honest: 2FA for a Forum like ASR seems WAY overkill. After all, ASR has no personal data from me.
Worst case: Senpai banhammer's my account and I need to create a new one. Sure beats the hassle of reaching for my smartphone every time I log in.