• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

If Room Treatment is difficult, expensive and often ineffective, why are so many on reddit in love with it?

Sometimes people think that thousands of euros are needed to get good treatment, but the truth is that often a normal but well-furnished room—bookcases, sofas, rugs, curtains, shelves, etc.—provides a more than decent treatment.
Like many others, I have a home theater in my basement. It's a classic "man cave"-style basement, overfurnished with all sorts of 1980s-inspired gimmicks and a large sofa. Well, acoustically, it's truly excellent without any specific work.
Art solved the last bass issues, and now I'm completely satisfied.
 
I think the logic is that it’s a reaction to all the products that barely matter as you climb in quality. Room treatment has a profound impact on how a system will sound, but it’s also the “component” that is the least frequently installed.

So it makes sense to talk about if you want to feel “in the know”
 
I understand the aesthetic concerns when it comes to room treatments, but it's possible to effectively treat the room in a tasteful manner. I have people come over who complement the look of my living room and have no idea that the panels serve any other purpose than decorative.

On a practical level, room treatment had only a slight impact on my system's response in the room, what it changed was the warmth of the room. As you come from the hallway into the living area you get this sense of being blanketed, it's cozy. This translates to the sound in the room. It's the decay time, not the response that you're attending to.

ART is not a replacement for room-treatment, it compliments it. Room treatment isn't practical at the frequencies ART operates at, conversely, ART doesn't operate at the frequencies where treatment is most effective.
 
I understand the aesthetic concerns when it comes to room treatments, but it's possible to effectively treat the room in a tasteful manner. I have people come over who complement the look of my living room and have no idea that the panels serve any other purpose than decorative.

On a practical level, room treatment had only a slight impact on my system's response in the room, what it changed was the warmth of the room. As you come from the hallway into the living area you get this sense of being blanketed, it's cozy. This translates to the sound in the room. It's the decay time, not the response that you're attending to.

ART is not a replacement for room-treatment, it compliments it. Room treatment isn't practical at the frequencies ART operates at, conversely, ART doesn't operate at the frequencies where treatment is most effective.
Before Dirac and ART i used Helmholtz and quarter wave tubes down to ~30hz.
And to take down a mode with 6-9dB is doable.
Great thing with those solutions is that i also affects nulls a bit.

Anyway, ART and the way it works i am not really sure to much bass treatment is a good thing.
With "analogue" solution you more or less pin-points a small area whilst ART can cover a whole sofa or more.
I do not have any low frequency stuff left so i cant test :(
 
I don't understand the title. Room treatment is not difficult, and for the effect it's certainly not expensive compared to almost anything else. Finally it is very, very effective, and the effect on the sound is comparable to changing speakers - so magnitudes more effect than any other change (dacs, amps, cables).

The whole premise of this thread is completely wrong in my mind.
 
Without room treatment, the Genelec setup in my office would be a complete waste. Also the reduced reverberation also makes phone calls and video conferences much more pleasant. What particularly surprised me about the absorbers (given the "warnings" that one must select them carefully to avoid uneven room damping) are the RT60 measurements. These show that, from approximately 65 Hz upwards, the decay time now stays within a 200–300 ms range without any outliers (whereas there were previously peaks exceeding 1 second). And this is despite the fact that I simply installed as many absorbers as the available space allowed (10 cm deep on the front wall and sides, 40 cm triangular ones in the corners, and depths ranging from 15 to 40 cm on the rear wall). So, it is really not difficult at all. Of course, one might object that these measurements are not as reliable in small rooms. But even without measurements, it is great that the cabinet's rear-panel doors no longer act as passive radiators at higher volume levels. :)

The fact that DiracART is effective only between 20 and 150 Hz actually makes it the ideal complement to 15–20 cm thick absorbers. As a next step I will mount eight 60x60 cm panels on the front wall of my living room and have acoustic stretch ceilings installed.
 
Not sure how to get it to you more simply.

I understand what the sentence means of course, but I don't understand how that could have been the conclusion if you have taken some time to look into it.

It absolutely is for many many of us.

I certainly agree it's more difficult than purchasing a new DAC and replacing the old one, but not in the absolute sense. Care to elaborate on your standpoint on the subject beyond simply stating it as a fact to be challenged? Easier to discuss then. :)

This is not the consensus on this site, sorry.

I find that baffling.
 
I don't understand the title. Room treatment is not difficult, and for the effect it's certainly not expensive compared to almost anything else. Finally it is very, very effective, and the effect on the sound is comparable to changing speakers - so magnitudes more effect than any other change (dacs, amps, cables).

The whole premise of this thread is completely wrong in my mind.
Dito. Room acoustic treatment is the most important and most effective thing to do, after choosing a good set of speakers and optimising placement in the available space. Actually, in most cases treating the room will transform the listening experience much more than choosing the next "better" speaker series.

People don't like it because it costs money (though a lot less than what is generally spent on other equipment), it takes space (for bass traps: the more, the better!) and requires some effort to hide it or integrate it appealingly in a home environment. Plus it's less suited to show off.^^ Then most people believe what they believe and never get to verify the objective advantages by measurements.

Additionally, room-EQ cannot fix everything (it sometimes actually creates new problems), so even with room-EQ the first steps would be to at least tame early reflections.

What you hear always is a mix of direct sound and room interactions, where the latter rarely are beneficial to an accurate sound reproduction. Also the finest manufacturers like Genelec or Neumann encourage to treat the rooms, since acoustics don't change no matter how perfect speakers get and how powerful room-EQ becomes. But as with everything else, it also shouldn't be overdone (like too much damping).

[...]
This is not the consensus on this site, sorry.
Here you got some objective data, no need to believe. The difficult part as with all measurements is correct interpretation:









 
@829 Mostly agreed except bass traps. Personally I use acoustic treatments for the frequencies above 200hz or so, and EQ below. Effective treatment of the bass is unrealistic in most domestic spaces.
 
Velocity based treatment is relatively cheap and the effects are easily audible (making a distinction between audible and good). Few put in the effort to learn why pressure based absorbers are necessary and how many are needed to make a decent effect. Even fewer understand the application of diffusers.

Learning to hear unbalanced reflections and decay on the other hand is hard. Even learning to hear unbalanced direct sound is hard.

Just a gut reaction to the topic. Reddit is not a source for things audio outside of oracle1990.
 
I find that baffling.
I also find it baffling @Mort especially as studio based audio relies so heavily on room treatments to delivery better sound reproduction.

I understand that it’s not an easy area to become proficient in, and can be expensive (probably not as expensive as Sigbergs fine speakers though), but as others have said, I consider room treatment to be simple things like book cases, sofas, wall hangings/art, large plants, rugs, ceiling decorations.

I disagree that the ASR consensus is that room treatments are not effective. In fact I don’t know anyone in audio who believes that.

What a strange thread this is.
 
Says the audio dealers. I don't understand why you can't comprehend an alternative perspective. Shrug.
 
Says the audio dealers. I don't understand why you can't comprehend an alternative perspective. Shrug.

But you have yet to share said perspective.

And for the record I don't sell acoustic treatments. So I have no financial reason to recommend it, beyond the fact that customers who actually implement it will have better sound, and enjoy our speakers even more. :)
 
I disagree that the ASR consensus is that room treatments are not effective. In fact I don’t know anyone in audio who believes that.
Velocity-based absorbers are not effective for SBIR and modal problems. Pressure-based absorbers are, but they are expensive and a lot are necessary.

The relative effectiveness is such that velocity based absorbers are not even necessary in many rooms with normal furnishings and pressure absorbers are impractical. It's better to reallocate money to components allowing EQ and other solutions focused on improving the low frequency regions. For those who have dedicated rooms, studios or money, such tradeoffs are less meaningful.
 
I have a DIY panel behind my speakers that didn't cost much at all which helps dealing with the early back reflection down to around maybe 400Hz which helps clean up the sound quite nicely. Sure it requiered some cutting, sawing, drilling, screwing, and stapling, but I wouldn't say it was particularly difficult. Then I of course deal with some room modes in the bass using a DSP.
 
Says the audio dealers. I don't understand why you can't comprehend an alternative perspective. Shrug.
I don’t sell room treatment products.

What is the alternative perspective? To put your system in an empty room and run Dirac? Or are you saying that things in rooms that help them acoustically (furniture etc) are good, but dedicated specialist room treatment products are not good?
 
Velocity-based absorbers are not effective for SBIR and modal problems. Pressure-based absorbers are, but they are expensive and a lot are necessary.

No one has really claimed that so far in the thread?

The relative effectiveness is such that velocity based absorbers are not even necessary in many rooms with normal furnishings and pressure absorbers are impractical. It's better to reallocate money to components allowing EQ and other solutions focused on improving the low frequency regions. For those who have dedicated rooms, studios or money, such tradeoffs are less meaningful.

I don't understand the stance of "treatment isn't effective in the bass, so then we just ignore it alltogether". And why is it a choice between EQ and treatment? The best solution is clearly to have both. EQ for the lower frequencies and acoustic treatment for the rest.
 
@829 Mostly agreed except bass traps. Personally I use acoustic treatments for the frequencies above 200hz or so, and EQ below. Effective treatment of the bass is unrealistic in most domestic spaces.
Yes and no. Of course it always comes down to which possibilities one has and is willing to make use of. But when it comes to effectiveness of bass absorption even below 100 Hz, the important aspect is the area of absorption in a room - not only the (appropriate thickness and material of) bass traps in (as many) corners (as possible).


But I agree, a minimum should be early reflections and this can basically be done without huge sacrifices and by still maintaining a reasonable WAF. :)

DIY would also be very inexpensive...
 
The best solution
... is expensive and often impractical.

If you can't get the best, then priorities have to be established. Good speakers come first, then EQ-capable devices, then room treatment. For the average person I would never suggest buying treatment.
 
Back
Top Bottom