olieb
Major Contributor
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2023
- Messages
- 1,050
- Likes
- 1,935
It is neither.I’ve been following the Smyth Realiser since they launched the Kickstarter. It’s a concept that feels a lot like an advanced version of XTC plus DCH.
You can only copy the acoustics of the physical situation at hand. So, if you want XTC you need a divider or a Processor as it is not possible to manipulate the signal flow in the Realiser afterwards. If the microphones do record crosstalk, it will be in the 'PRIR'.
If you want a “domestic concert hall“ you would have to record the ‘PRIR‘ in one.
And as the characteristics of your head and ears are part of the situation (and you want that reproduced) you more or less have to do all this personally. And if the speakers at hand have flaws, this will become part of the ‘PRIR‘, too.
The BRIRs for these rooms are in the public domain, so yes they are available. However these are recorded with dummy heads and therefore one is listening with the “wrong ears“. And this does make a difference, for some more, for some less.From what I remember, they initially offered the two standard factory rooms (BBC and University of Surrey).
These rooms sound good, and together with the robust head tracking it is a nice experience.
The problem of the wrong head extends to all the available ‘PRIR‘, to overcome this, I would have to travel several hundred km and pay 1500$ to get a professional room measured with my head and it will become clear only afterwards how well this works out. How good are the speakers? It probably will not be bad, but is it worth 2000$?
As far as I know Smyth is struggling since the Kickstarter project as the price was not covering their costs at all. They probably don't have time and money to spent on extras for their legacy customers. As I understand it, their main market are professionals who want to work in their familiar acoustical environment on the go.If they can get impulse responses of great concert halls, they could even modify or personalise them further. Maybe I should email them with that suggestion.
Their problem is that everything the Realiser was able to do long before its time is now also possible in a DAW or just a laptop for little investment, and actually one can do a lot more now. My Kickstarter-Realiser is mostly gathering dust nowadays.
I still don't get what the impulse response of a great hall is supposed to do for the reproduction of sound recorded in a great hall.
In my view, all the reflections and ambience of the concert hall, where the music was recorded, is already in the recording.
It is just not strong enough; if it were, it would not sound good in most listening rooms, as the listening room adds its own reflections. Therefore the microphones are placed directly at or on the stage and the sound is mixed accordingly. Recording with a stereo pair in row 8 would create a reverberant mess in most listening rooms.
The effect of using concert hall reverb would be like placing the (two!) speakers playing Beethoven (recorded in hall A) in a concert hall B. This is not what a concert hall is for and though it might work with some content, this will probably not sound like Beethoven played in that (which?) hall. Of course you can tune down the ambience to fit with the situation, but then, why use a concert hall impulse response in the first place?
What is needed in my view are superb listening rooms that add/amplify the ambient sound. If you have one available, you can record that situation with the Realiser. However, a room cannot actually amplify sound, so some kind of upmixing is necessary. [The Realiser could record that upmixing too, but now it gets complicated, because you might want to have more or less upmix, and this a new acoustical situation and you have to record again.]
All this can be done in a virtual room binauralisation with much more flexibility.
Beethoven on the beach (almost) like in the great hall it was recorded in? No problem, just a bit weird ;-)