Tim Link
Major Contributor
I've been thinking about XTC for many years. I've tried physical divider barriers, Polk Speakers, Carver Sonic Holography, and several DSP implementations. My general sense is that I like what it does for the most part. There's a big wow factor at first and then some contemplation on what it's actually doing wrong.
I propose that we don't want to widen then sound stage beyond what you would expect with a normal stereo listening triangle. I've argued otherwise, but I'm more in line now with the idea that we should, for the most part, hear the sound stage as it was intended to be heard in a standard speaker configuration. I don't always want a hard panned sound to go all the way 180 degrees to my left or right on every recording. But I always want good XTC for center panned sounds.
What I want to get after mostly is crosstalk that colors the sound and reduces clarity. These undesirable side effects mostly happen when sounds are panned center.
So I think a more ideal solution is to keep the stereo speakers where they normally are (like BACCH does) but apply selective crosstalk reduction. Selective crosstalk reduction is going to be fairly processor intensive I fear. Can modern computers do it with high precision in real time? I think maybe they can, with some amount of manageable latency. Maybe not good for video games.
The software will need to figure out which sounds are panned to where in the soundstage, and then make sure they perceptually stay there after crosstalk reduction by properly simulating the sound wave from that phantom source crossing the head at the correct angle. It will also have to figure out what to do with the not-perfectly-in-phase signals between the left and right channels. Are they timed closely enough to be heard as timing panned signals? If so then it needs to make sure both ears hear that sound as they would if it was crossing the head from the correct angle that the time delay normally images to. If not, then they could just be treated as hard panned left and right signals and left alone. Or maybe if they are exactly opposite phase the XTC could be used to maximize spaciousness without inadvertently moving sound sources in the sound stage.
It may be possible to get the speakers to generate the wave front across the head correctly with the DSP. They already produce a time delay with level panning as Blumlein recognized. So maybe converting all the timing panning to level panning would be enough. But if the HRTF is not correct at each ear, then the software would need to apply appropriate HRTF equalization to match the intended wave front direction.
Thoughts anyone? Is this crazy, or should I start working on the software? I think this could be applied to headphone listening as well.
What I'm not sure about is if all this processing could actually result in a net gain in perceived audio quality.
I propose that we don't want to widen then sound stage beyond what you would expect with a normal stereo listening triangle. I've argued otherwise, but I'm more in line now with the idea that we should, for the most part, hear the sound stage as it was intended to be heard in a standard speaker configuration. I don't always want a hard panned sound to go all the way 180 degrees to my left or right on every recording. But I always want good XTC for center panned sounds.
What I want to get after mostly is crosstalk that colors the sound and reduces clarity. These undesirable side effects mostly happen when sounds are panned center.
So I think a more ideal solution is to keep the stereo speakers where they normally are (like BACCH does) but apply selective crosstalk reduction. Selective crosstalk reduction is going to be fairly processor intensive I fear. Can modern computers do it with high precision in real time? I think maybe they can, with some amount of manageable latency. Maybe not good for video games.
The software will need to figure out which sounds are panned to where in the soundstage, and then make sure they perceptually stay there after crosstalk reduction by properly simulating the sound wave from that phantom source crossing the head at the correct angle. It will also have to figure out what to do with the not-perfectly-in-phase signals between the left and right channels. Are they timed closely enough to be heard as timing panned signals? If so then it needs to make sure both ears hear that sound as they would if it was crossing the head from the correct angle that the time delay normally images to. If not, then they could just be treated as hard panned left and right signals and left alone. Or maybe if they are exactly opposite phase the XTC could be used to maximize spaciousness without inadvertently moving sound sources in the sound stage.
It may be possible to get the speakers to generate the wave front across the head correctly with the DSP. They already produce a time delay with level panning as Blumlein recognized. So maybe converting all the timing panning to level panning would be enough. But if the HRTF is not correct at each ear, then the software would need to apply appropriate HRTF equalization to match the intended wave front direction.
Thoughts anyone? Is this crazy, or should I start working on the software? I think this could be applied to headphone listening as well.
What I'm not sure about is if all this processing could actually result in a net gain in perceived audio quality.
Last edited:

