• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

How quiet has to be your room for open-back headphones?

Linlyn28

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2026
Messages
13
Likes
10
I have a fairly quiet room, but my PC fans can be quite loud, specially if I'm using it for playing games.

How "transparent" do they feel and do things like ambient noise (cars, rain, pets) affect the listening quality that drastically?

I would like to hear your experiences.
 
For critical listening during quiet passages, you'll hear other sounds. But your brain absolutely will not care. If it's part of your usual environment I think it will be completely masked by the sound.
 
… fans can be quite loud…

How "transparent" do they feel and do things like ambient noise (cars, rain, pets) affect the listening quality that drastically?
My region currently is in a heat wave so even late into the night I keep a portable room fan that definitely detracts from my open back headphone listening. I have to run that fan on the lowest setting and position it farther away.
 
It also depends on how much of your music you want people in the same room to hear!
 
If you can use loudspeakers, any kind of headphone will provide an extra layer of isolation. I sometimes think my Shure 1540 provide a bit too much isolation... never mind good NC IEMs.

Also... I'd look into quieter options for that computer, there are a ton of options out there. To me, any fan noise in unacceptable.
 
If you can use loudspeakers, any kind of headphone will provide an extra layer of isolation. I sometimes think my Shure 1540 provide a bit too much isolation... never mind good NC IEMs.

Also... I'd look into quieter options for that computer, there are a ton of options out there. To me, any fan noise in unacceptable.
I think I just have an overly aggressive fan profile, I will try to tweak it a bit since I will most likely use the open-backs for music and movies anyways.
 
I recently acquired my first open back HP, about 6 month ago, I use them exclusively inside my home. I cannot say that I have ever been disturbed by outside noise while using them (exclusively) to listen to music.
 
I bought my Dan Clark E3 in large part because of my fridge which periodically starts to do loud "ghost voices". This was often too distracting during quieter passages in music.

Of course an alternative option would have been to look for a quieter fridge. From what I read there's strong unit variation in this respect, so another model might not have been all that much better. Going that router would also have robbed me of a good reason to buy another headphone, so it was clear which way to go at the time.
 
I'd say, in general like 50-55dB SPL from your listening position is enough to start overwhelming minor details. In bass it's higher of course.
 
I bought my Dan Clark E3 in large part because of my fridge which periodically starts to do loud "ghost voices". This was often too distracting during quieter passages in music.

Of course an alternative option would have been to look for a quieter fridge. From what I read there's strong unit variation in this respect, so another model might not have been all that much better. Going that router would also have robbed me of a good reason to buy another headphone, so it was clear which way to go at the time.
I have the same problem with a noisy refrigerator.
When I listen to music or watch a movie, documentary, etc., I always use open-back planar headphones.
Here’s what I do: I always switch the refrigerator off completely.
That amounts to about 6 hours a day.
 
I have the same problem with a noisy refrigerator.
When I listen to music or watch a movie, documentary, etc., I always use open-back planar headphones.
Here’s what I do: I always switch the refrigerator off completely.
That amounts to about 6 hours a day.
Cold calculation, I like it
 
Although I build my PC server to be dead quiet, the rest of my house tends to be very noisy with a loud frig, etc.
Still I love my Senn HD 650 open-backs and don't find the extraneous noise to be a very large issue.
I always keep a pistol at me side in case someone should attempt to sneak up-in on me. ;)
Consider that fair caution, I don't waste ammo with warning shots. :p
 
I think it really depends on how sensitive you are to such things. For myself, I've become averse to obnoxious or loud background noise (noisy appliances, air ducts, for example). In those cases, even closed backs don't isolate well enough from those noises and they will be heard almost unabated.

Contrarily, a good pair (or even a decent pair) of ANC headphones will eliminate those types of background sounds, including PC fan noise. If you find yourself being too distracted by background sounds like this when listening to a pair of open headphones, then I would definitely consider looking into ANC headphones. They will change your life for the better when you have peace and quiet to listen to your tunes.
 
Contrarily, a good pair (or even a decent pair) of ANC headphones will eliminate those types of background sounds, including PC fan noise. If you find yourself being too distracted by background sounds like this when listening to a pair of open headphones, then I would definitely consider looking into ANC headphones. They will change your life for the better when you have peace and quiet to listen to your tunes.
So then you don't find the NC software effects the sound of the recording in any way? I do find that surprising result from a serious listener.
 
So then you don't find the NC software effects the sound of the recording in any way? I do find that surprising result from a serious listener.
Yes and no. The sound of the ANC unit should be generally indistinguishable from the frequency response of the headphone. One of my first listening sessions with a pair of Bose QC45s was the whole of Miles Davis's Kind of Blue and the tape hiss on that recording was louder than any hiss coming from the ANC being switched on. I think if you're used to that level of noise from a recording then the ANC shouldn't bother you.

Aside from that, I would say any other effects can be attributed to the frequency response of the 'phone. As Amir points out in his reviews, spaciousness can be adjusted with some high frequency tuning to eliminate some of the closed in feeling one might get from the ANC itself.

If anything, having good noise-cancelling should enhance serious listening by eliminating outside distractions and the noise floor itself. One can then listen to a recording and hear details better without interference. For a focus on critical listening, they should be considered hard to beat.

I do often think that listening on these types of headphones is not considered 'proper' or 'audiophile' and that doing so is disgracing the music in some way. But that's my own psychological problem, not a problem of the design of the 'phones themselves. The frequency response has no distinction of a right and wrong method to listen to a recording. If it's good then it's good.
 
Last edited:
So then you don't find the NC software effects the sound of the recording in any way? I do find that surprising result from a serious listener.
It does - NC always produces some slight static and pressure. That said, that's mandatory for its intended purpose. And it used to be bad and give me a headache. The balance has become so much better though. It used to be I could only use IEMs with the best foam ear tips to enjoy music on-the-go. Now it works with Bluetooth IEMs matched to good foam tips like the Soundcoe Liberty 4 Pro - good enough for what I need on the go, and extremely practical. I can be anywhere for a Teams meeting and people think I am in a quiet environment even when I sit next to NFL fans in an airport bar. :-)
 
If anything, having good noise-cancelling should enhance serious listening by eliminating outside distractions and the noise floor itself. One can then listen to a recording and hear details better without interference. For a focus on critical listening, they should be considered hard to beat.

I do often think that listening on these types of headphones is not considered 'proper' or 'audiophile' and that doing so is disgracing the music in some way. But that's my own psychological problem, not a problem of the design of the 'phones themselves. The frequency response has no distinction of a right and wrong method to listen to a recording. If it's good then it's good.
That's actually the (famous?) misconception of IEM-s that NC - for sure bombarding your ears with 104dB SPL will get you into trouble, but why would you do that if you push the environment into territory where it stops interfering. Much easier to then go for lower volumes.

Also I find it hard to cite any specific sources on this bit of - I think - common knowledge, but in many cases you're not supposed to listen to albums loud, since they're commonly mixed & mastered in calibrated volume, which will get reflected in the mix, because of hearing curves. One designs at what volume the other should be listening.

The part with ANC not being seen as the correct way... I can guarantee that many "budget audiophiles" would be stumped how much better QC35-II are than the boutique closed-back favourites, since ANC also buys you other DSP shenanigans, since it's basically a feedback-based automatic FR tuning system. Analog purists don't have facts on their side, basically.
 
It does - NC always produces some slight static and pressure. That said, that's mandatory for its intended purpose.
That's my feelings on the situation. I don't doubt that very good NC phones can work very well, I love the pair I have for rifle-pistol range use. They can subtract all the shot noise and other sounds at the range while still allowing me to carry on normal conversations with the folks around me. OTOH I believe expecting the software to be able to remove all the unwanted sounds while still leaving 20hz to 20khz music totally unaffected is a "bridge to far" expectation.
 
That's my feelings on the situation. I don't doubt that very good NC phones can work very well, I love the pair I have for rifle-pistol range use. They can subtract all the shot noise and other sounds at the range while still allowing me to carry on normal conversations with the folks around me. OTOH I believe expecting the software to be able to remove all the unwanted sounds while still leaving 20hz to 20khz music totally unaffected is a "bridge to far" expectation.
Remember that ANC isn't a pure-software solution, but a feedback circuit that doesn't "imagine/guess" the noise, but reacts to what is there in a very quick manner.
 
Back
Top Bottom